BEWARE: NH Dept. of Health is investigating this location. Numerous people including my family had their Christmas holidays ruined due to norovirus or food poisoning from food bought on 12/23 and 12/24. Many folks in town reporting and talking about the violent vomiting and intestinal issues lingering for a week. BEWARE! 1/13/26 UPDATE: Although you can see they reached out to me and want me to contact them, there is nothing that can really be done at this point. Not looking for money or a year of free subs. The unfortunate thing is they have taken no responsibility for the issue. In fact their store manager did an interview and stated they received a clean review and although some employees were sick it was not during times when they were working. This denial of responsibility is ridiculous. They should have publicly apologized and said they would do better to make sure this never happened again. Big missed opportunity. I am sure this location will be closed soon. You may want to stay away from their Epping and Seabrook locations also as this is the same franchisee. https://iwaspoisoned.com/outbreak/norovirus-outbreak-linked-to-jersey-mike-s-subs-in-exeter#scroll read more

The 2 people working were friendly and the girl making cold subs was attentive. I had to tell her she used the wrong roll, I requested the rosemary roll. There wasn't much for toppings on 1/2 of my regular size sub, the shredded lettuce appeared a bit "rusty" , and I was concerned how long it had been sitting out, uncovered, the tomatoes too. Even more frustrating is that my rosemary sub roll was really hard, not at all fresh. Which I didn't find out until we got home to eat. My husband was satisfied with his cheese steak sub and said his roll was soft and fresh. We would have stayed to eat there, but the tables were all dirty, even though there were no other customers there when we went in, just the 2 employees. I feel that over $30.00 for 2 subs was too much for the quality. We've had much better quality at 2 other Jersey Mike's sub shops in New Hampshire. read more

Dirty tables, slow service, and mediocre subs. There is too much bread and not enough meat. The process of ordering is weird. read more

FAST, CONSISTENT, and the like MOVES This store is well staffed and they get your order right the first time! BRAVO on the superior service and knowing workers, like me, have limited time to get lunch. You are a great store read more

So, having been quite excited to see my favorite sub chain move to town, I really hope that the extreme skimpiness I experienced here was just newly-opened growing pains and lack of training, and not by design. Just two weeks back, I was standing in Jersey Mike's in South Portland, and marveling at the size of the club being built. There was so much bacon on it, for example, that I might have removed half and saved it for a later meal - and the rest of the portions were similarly generous. This gels exactly with my memory of this chain in other states as well, and why, along with the quality of ingredients, I was looking forward to the opening of this location. I ordered the supreme club here, regular size (medium). The turkey was almost adequate in portion, the roast beef far less so, and I got two strips of bacon. Two. What you see in the pic was half the bacon and half the onion on my entire sub. Three times, as it was being prepared, I asked for as much vegetables as they were allowed to stack on (as I could see by the meat already placed on the sub which way the wind was blowing). My sub had four undersized tomato slices, for example, and when I asked for more, the kid took off the slices (threw them back in the tomato bin) and replaced them with four slightly larger slices. Even at Subway, (the lowest form of sub on Earth), if you ask for extra veg, they will gladly stack it. Sure, they put out a lesser product, but it's also a much cheaper price tag. If I'm going to get two medium subs and pay over $20, with average tip, I would really hope that the product looked half as large as the pictures on the menu proclaim, and on par with other JM's locations. The taste was solid, but this just left me disappointed, and most likely headed to On the Vine, right down the road, for a better value and product. The woman taking my order was super nice, but that's where the good vibes ended. I might try back, in a few months, to see if training has improved or if it's just this location's policy to cheap out on ingredients. Will update if/when that happens. Edit: Also, you might note that there is a reply to this review. I sent them the requested email 10 days ago, and have yet to hear back. Will also update on the customer service experience. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - This is "stacked" with vegetables (not shown, skimpy tomatoes and lettuce). Challenge: find a another sub, anywhere, with less bacon & veg. - Fast Food Near Me - Exeter, New Hampshire

Okay. We're talking about grinders, so let's be honest. Jersey Mike's is delicious, and it's really nice to have a new place to go. But what I loved was the easy online ordering process...and the option of having my tuna grinder in a takeout bowl (they call it a tub...and I refuse. A tub?!?!). Clean store, lots of happy people already there at noon, and tons of bustle. Thank you to the staff who wrote the happy birthday message on my son's grinder wrapping! Good luck, Exeter Jersey Mike's!! read more

I really like Jersey Mike's subs. The quality is there and the taste is delicious. So far I have not been disappointed and the service is so fast. Yummy all the way! read more

Absolutely love Jersey Mikes! I've never been to any other location, so I can't compare, but the portion sizes are pretty big and prices are super reasonable. Even the mini sub is pretty filling for a smaller meal. My favorite is the #8 Club Sub--the ratio of meat to tomatoes/lettuce is great, bread is never dry, lettuce and onions taste fresh, and the herby red vinegar/olive oil vinaigrette (Sam's way all the way!) tossed on the lettuce perfectly cuts through the creaminess of the mayo and provolone. Can't speak much to the ambiance or cleanliness of the location, because I've only pick-up or delivery, but service is quick and always consistent. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - #8 Club Sub - Fast Food Near Me - Exeter, New Hampshire

Like so many other reviews for this location, my special requests were absolutely ignored. I ordered a number 13 original Italian with banana peppers hot pepper relish and pickles to be added. None of them showed up on the sub that I eat when I got home. This was a disappointment as the sub itself was OK but would've been much better had my special requests been honored and applied. This was a $20 giant Italian. They have my special requests ignored is simply poor performance and poor management of this particular location. I will try them again, but only when I have time to wait in line and watch them make my sandwich. This removes all of the convenience of the app, but it may at least I'm sure I'll get a sandwich that I actually ordered. Also, I ordered it Mike's way... There was no oil, no vinegar. Just a really sloppy way to make a sandwich that cost $20. I'm really not that impressed. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Order description - Fast Food Near Me - Exeter, New Hampshire

BESTT SUB EVER i wish I could do 5000 stars but i can only put 5 stars best service I've ever seen! Also a guy that was taking the order was the nicest person ever!!!!!! read more

Fresh and delicious but pricey. We have been to the Exeter and seabrook locations Both are clean. The people who work in both places do a great job. read more

I really enjoy Jersey Mikes, I've never had a bad experience, and always been satisfied with my food. However, I decided to try ordering on DoorDash since it was convenient at the moment for me, what a mistake. I ordered the #65 and paid extra for more portabella mushrooms. I usually get this sub when I go there so I was really annoyed when I opened my sub to see there was literally 1 mushroom on the whole sub! I definitely will never order them in DoorDash ever again. Such a shame read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Exeter, New Hampshire

Food is good. They can't be ready for a pick up time to save their lives. Usually running at least 10 minutes behind.

While out doing some shopping and taking a ride yesterday, my wife asked if I was hungry and wanted to stop and get a sandwich. I agreed it was a good idea and she brought up the Many great comments she's heard from coworkers at the hospital she works at about this sub shop. To our delight, the comments were correct and the sandwiches were very good. The rolls were fresh and the amount of quality cold cuts in the sandwiches was as expected, fresh and plenty. We'll be making this a regular place to eat when looking for sub sandwiches. We paid about $0.75 more for each sandwich at MOE's than we paid at Jersey Mikes. The small price difference is well worth it considering that Moe's actually puts meat in their sandwiches where Jersey Mikes sold very skimpy sandwiches at a premium price. read more

Philly cheese steak was mostly bread and cheese, not much steak, peppers and onions. May go back and try one of their regular subs which looked to be more substantial. read more

Looking for a decent hot steak and cheese? This is a good as it gets and I had a really good steak sandwich. Bread was a little flakey and light and thus made a mess of me, but the flavor was spot on. The young woman assisting me was pleasant and quite fast in preparing my meal, but it would have been less awkward if she asked if how I wanted it (add lettuce, mayo etc). I will return as the place was clean, friendly, and offers a good steak sandwich/sub/grinder/poboy....what ever you want to call it. read more

Great sandwich but boy are they slow. Don't be in a hurry at lunch if you go here. There are lots of people working but not a well oiled machine yet. read more

Jersey Mike's is the best! High quality and quantity of meats, and they have the best fresh-baked bread. They even have gluten-free bread. It was super busy when I went but that's probably because they just opened a couple weeks ago and the word is out. I have the app on my phone and ordering ahead is definitely the way to go. So glad to finally have one nearby! read more

Delicious sub! First time at a Mike's (not available in our immediate area) Will definitely seek out when traveling read more

Cant say a lot about a Subshop but We got subs to go from Jersey Mikes in Safety Harbor Fl. They where excellent, beats out by a mile Subway. Very fresh rolls all contents of the Sub quite fresh and tasty. Will definitely return read more

Exeter NH area Portsmouth ave Terrible subs no meat. Purchased a giant size steak and cheese $17.... All bread shredded steak very little meat!!!! Rip off never again. read more

Jersey Mike's subs are so good! Great quality meats and delicious bread. The staff here is very attentive!

This place (and chain) really has it all together:Consistently great food, prompt service, convenient pick-up. Phone in orders are reliable and efficient. No one does it better-- or close. read more

Yesterday I bought an Italian and was asked if I wanted it Mike's Way. I said yes...it was my first time at this Sub Shop. For me, the excess of everything, especially the lettuce and the oil and vinegar spoiled what could have been a good sandwich. It ended up being a sandwich with extra soggy bread and not what I expected when ordering an Italian. Would guess that the excess is the result of poor training, or someone trying too hard. Anyway, there are better Italian sandwiches at other shops. I'll try this new business again, but will not order that sandwich again. read more

Unbelievable unreliable staff at Exeter NH location workers read back your order and still can't get it right !!! 4 Times they messed up a simple order even when asked to read order back.... Total lack of work ethic!!!! spoke with a so called manager Alex... Twice One time was given a free sub just this past time was asked to be reimbursed... Get help that actually take pride in their work read more

Literally the BEST BLT I have ever had and I've ordered from just about everywhere in town. Now I'll never go to another place but to Jersey Mike's! read more

We love Jersey Mikes especially cheese steaks and Italian. So happy when they opened one close to us. We use to travel to South Portland Maine to get our fix. read more

I had never had a Jersey Mike's Sub until this location opened. I've been in 4 times now and every time it's consistently good. Fresh and tasty. I keep getting the Italian, but next time I'm going to try their hot subs. My office is right around the corner and this is a solid addition to our lunch options in this end of town. read more

Love this place and so glad they came to the area! Very delicious food and consistent every time,Thank you!

Awesome subs! Pleasantly surprised to see they slice the deli meat when you order. Everything tastes fresh an delicious. Well run, efficient operation. Excited to see the Jersey Mike's addition to Exeter. read more