Sharing a local business story... a family dinner meal from Jersey Mike's Lighthouse Dr location. Once home and into the meal it was discovered a sandwich was incorrect. The sandwich was tossed out and left at that. No phone call or the like. The next day I went by the store and spoke with John, the manager. This approach was more reasonable than jumping on social media and complaining about the sandwich. John listened and the order was made whole. This exchange or sharing of info is how and why members of the Barnegat and Manahawkin communities shop local and support our local businesses. Manager John, thank you again for your time, understanding and your solution. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - A story to be told... - Fast Food Near Me - Barnegat, New Jersey

Great subs at this location. They don't skimp on the meats and cheese! Workers are super efficient and very nice. Place looked clean too. Easy 5 stars read more

Usually good. However I wish I knew the cheesesteak would have the sandwich peppers in it instead of green peppers. The pickling juice on these sandwich peppers was so strong it ruined the flavor of the entire sandwich. Huge chunks of pickled peppers in my cheese steak was not appetizing. read more

Great fresh hoagies and service is skies with a smile and quick. The Barnegat one has easy parking and seems to be the best at phone in orders ... just my experience ! read more

Bought lunch for my guys, ordered four different large subs. The boy making the sandwich was very nice. Service was great. He made the sandwiches in less than 10 minutes! A lot of ingredients the subs were very good. Not the cheapest as each sub was around $17 each. Great place for a quick lunch And the restaurant was nice and clean and quiet. read more

It's Jersey Mike's! Great subs great selection of food and other items. Don't forget to save room for the chocolate chip cookie. Place is always clean, well kept, great fast friendly service especially with using the app. No issues there! Earn those shore points get your free sub! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Barnegat, New Jersey

Service is outstanding, you're notified via their app when online orders are ready for pickup. (Usually under15 minutes). Staff is awesome, store inside is clean , product well displayed. Subs are made right in front of you , nothing to hide! Using the app gets you free subs after a few visits. Highly recommend Jersey Mike's. read more

So I've been to this location twice this week. The bread is extremely fresh with a nice crisp outside and soft inside. I ordered the tuna with lettuce and onion, my son the Portobello and cheese, my daughter the #42,and my husband the tuna with everything. The location is extremely clean and friendly I just have a big issue when they don't fill a sandwich and you take a bite and it's just bread. The first time I went they put one onion on my sandwich. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Hubby got me a tuna and lettuce for lunch. So full!! - Fast Food Near Me - Barnegat, New Jersey

See all

I have ordered several of these pricey sandwiches and from several places. When this location first opened they tried harder to please. I had points accumulate which is a plus. It rewarded me a free sandwich, I ordered the #17, steak and cheese and it was an epic fail. The meat was so skimpy it looked like pieces were chewed and grainy, and just scattered in the bread. There was not an ample piece of steakum in sight. The bread was mushy cause I asked for light mayo, was it the extra 1.96 I paid and not full price? This was disappointing and I couldn't eat that sandwich at all. I couldn't give it away, no one wanted it. Sadly disappointed, that is the sandwich I usually buy! Is a reward sandwich really a reward? read more

This location is fantastic. I stopped in on my drive home from the shore and they are the FRIENDLIEST staff I've ever seen at any deli ever. They were also SUPER fast. After we ordered, there was a big rush of customers that came in (including one guy picking up a large catering order) and they helped everyone at lightning speed. Bravo. read more

Place is the absolute best around. Crew is always hustling to get orders out. JM makes the best subs around hands down

All was great. Friendly and prompt service. Food delicious as always. Clean and quick delivery as well.

The subs have less & less meat and cheese etc. ingredients than ever before added in the subs. They're getting cheaper and cheaper with adding stuff. Wouldn't recommend them anymore. At least the one on Lighthouse in Barnegat. Sad. read more

So far so good! New store in the area so I decided to grab lunch for the family. The app made everything super easy. I put in what we wanted and they gave a pickup time. I arrived a few minutes after the time and the bag was waiting for me. The girl greeted me and gave me my order and I was off. Easy peasy. The sandwiches were perfect for the order and tasted great. I got my usual #9, it was awesome, the bacon was crispy, the meat was delicious and basically it was fantastic. The family loved theirs as well. For a fairly new spot, everything was great. No problems, the app worked fine and the store was immaculate. Wonderful experience, will return. read more

The bread here is consistently hard. On the most recent sandwich I've order, the bread was rock hard, couldn't even eat it. On occasion the bread will be soft but rarely. Please fix this issue. read more

very disappointed in this place. ordered a big sub for $18.98 and there was very little meat in the sub. not much of anything else either. way overpriced---should have been $12.99 at best. never going to another Jersey Mikes. read more

Truly some of the nicest staff I've ever met. Had a very nice conversation with a girl that worked there-made me feel like I was a friend and not just some customer. the food is great and the overall vibe is amazing!! read more

So happy to have a JM in my town. Went opening day for a fee half sub and it rocked. Lots of meat, toppings and LOVE. Can't wait to go back. They have some really nice tables outside to relax and eat. Not the greatest view of the main road but I'll get over it. read more

Updated review: Since last year, there have been many turnovers in the staff. Lately, the staff has been quick and kind. Recent orders have been made correctly and are ready by the promised pick up time. read more

After Downloading The APP, The Having To Uninstalling The APP Seven Separate Times (7X), Calling The Store Three (3) Separate (3X), Being Told By Management That I NEEDED To Visit The Jersey Mike's Sub Website, To Ultimately Having To Drive To The Location Was NOT A Pleasant Experience At ALL. Although This Was The Locations First Week Opened, The Staff Was Friendly But They Were NOT Prepared For A SUNDAY NIGHT Visit. The Cheesesteak Meat Was Tough, And In Large Clumps, And The Vegetables (Peppers, Onions, & Mushrooms) Were HUGE Pieces NOT Bite Sized Nor Like ANY "Philly Cheesesteak" That I Ever Enjoyed! ! ! BOTH Subs We Had Ordered Were FULL Sized With Double Meat And Cheese. . . The Turkey And Cheese Was Also Less Than Desirable! ! ! The BEST Part Of My Wasted Money Were The Choclate Chip Cookies, And Fudge Brownies! ! ! Corporate Subs Are Obviously NOT For Me, The ONLY Thing That Would Have Made This As Bad As Subway Would Of Had Jarrod Personally Make The Food! ! ! Save Your Money. . . This Was My First And Last Time Giving Jersey Mike's ANY Of My Hard Earned Money! ! ! "If" I Could Give NEGATIVE STARS I Would! ! ! I Suggest Walking/Driving Across The Street To Wawa And/Or Another Local Family Owned Sub Shops Like Rancaniellos Pizzeria Where Either Location Serves A Far Superior Sandwich's For A Better Price & Value! ! ! Respectfully, Eternally, #SOSJohnD read more

My chicken cheese steak was not good and the next time I tried an Italian and again was not impressed. My husband wasn't impressed with his subs either. Don't think I'll be going back. read more

The Jersey Mike's location in Barnegat is amazing. There employees are the most friendly, kind, customer service friendly people. They always greet you with a hello and a smile. Keep up the good work. read more

Great Service and staff! Always friendly. Place is always clean ! Close to home ! Compared to others I have no complaints

Food is as good as any Jersey Mikes. What makes this place different is how nice the employees are. They go above and beyond to make you smile there. It makes me want to go there more often just because of how good of an experience it is. read more

This place sucks. Every time ive been in here there has been some type of issue. Even if there is a short line expect to wait, the subs are ok - standard Jersey Mikes - but save yourself the aggravation and go someplace else. read more