Had a half mushroom/ half plain pie delivered to Manafirkin Brewery! Delivered nice and hot! This was during boozy bingo and they found us inside the crowded room. The mushroom appeared and tasted so fresh and I'm sorry i didn't get the other side with sausage The crust was a meal by itself. I'm actually planning my next meal from them as I'm eating this on lol They also remembered the plates and forks .(And the craft beers at Manafirkin Brewery are all so good too) read more

Review is based on a to go Sausage & Pepperoni pie which was hot with a crunchy crust and a delicious sauce, split between three hungry adults which gave it a total of six thumbs up and I'm lucky I took a picture before it was devoured. It was hot and ready when it was picked up. Nothing more to add except I will be back soon. read more

Fusaro Pizza - Perfect South Jersey pie. - Italian Near Me - Manahawkin, New Jersey

See all

Sometimes mid week you just need to order a thin grandma vodka pizza with some calamari to get you through the rest of the week. The best part is that it was still hot and fresh when it was delivered. Delivery service is always on time and whether you order online or over the phone it's super easy, but online offers coupons you can apply to your order. My family and I love their pizza, but this is definitely our favorite. read more

See all

I ordered pies and wings and everything arrived well and delicious. Outstanding staff and delivery. Top notch would gladly order from them again read more

Dear Fusaros, you made me the best ever chicken francaise dinners on New Year's Eve. You also added a couple of gifts that were so appreciated. You have the best tasting wine. The most delicious food and amazing staff. read more

Their pizza and wraps are delicious. The service is very good, staff are especially kind and make you feel welcome.

Been here 3 times so far and I love it. The bread on their specialty slices ....sooooo delish!

Get the Lucy slice! Delicious hot honey sopressado (sp?) Friendly staff - quick service and decent pricing.

On a recent trip we stopped at Fusaro; excellent service, pizza and friendly staff. We had the pleasure of meeting the owner, Andy and he was very helpful on describing the many pizza choices that he offers at Fusaro's!! read more

See all

They seem to be nice people but there pizza sucks.Cardboard and a little cheese.Not the first time I have had pizza here but im sad to say the last. read more

As a year round local, you tend to find good spots, and give leeway for a bad day. That goodwill has come to a slow death. As Covid dwindled down, so did the serving size and quality of the food. I was like, "Hey, its been a while, lets get takeout from Fusaro!" Next time I say that, someone slap me. They say pictures are woth a thousand words. Aside from the little bit of dry Chicken on the sandwich, the rolls are smaller and a bit stale. Yup you read that right. More cheese than chicken. As far as the onion rings, you can safely say that the fryer oil was old, and generosity is not a trait of Fusaro Pizza. Yeah, Im mad, as well as sad. The Fusaro Chicken sandwich special was a a crow favorite. We would take friends over there almost every weekend. Fusaro is now Pewsaro. read more

3 times I ordered box pizza from them and the pie was bigger then the box , so they folded it to fit the box . Now there is four slices that are stuck together which we cannot eat. never have I ever seen this . I confronted the owner and her never offer any solution. they lost a ten year customer . real great bussiness owner. read more

Great wings & pizza! I am not a Sicilian style pizza lover but my husband loved theirs. We didn't go inside the pizzeria so I can't let you know how the restaurant is but we were able to have our order in a quick time on a Friday night. So service was good. read more

Don't order the baked ziti... AKA penne with a scoop of ricotta on top... pizzas crust was hard as a rock as well

The pizza was tasteles and soggy. I cannot bslieve that a succinct critique is invalid And Yelp! Has a character minimum.

Ordered a plain pie with extra sauce and crispy. It was terrible there was hardly any sauce on it at all, never mind the extra I wanted. The sauce had no taste and there was hardly any cheese on it. To be honest is was terrible. Waste of $$. read more

Consistently delicious and extremely friendly girls at the cash register continue to return however last visit had too much cheese My fault for not asking light on the cheese read more

My kids love their classic cheese pizza . Classic taste consistent as well ! Tried the mozz stix! We love them and the cheesesteaks are great too! read more

I discovered a new favorite slice! They ran out of regular grandma's pizza so I grabbed the last piece of vodka grandma's.It was shockingly not heavy and full of flavor the crust was perfectly cooked and not to doughy. I will definitely be ordering this again.My husband had the margarite pizza very thin crust and good, he said grandma's was better. read more

See all

1st time ordering from Fusaros. Food looked great from ads on Hulu. Ordered Lucy special which was burnt/black in corners and dry. Couldn't eat it. The Grandma pie was just okay but the garlic knots were good. Sorry Fusaros of Spring Lake Heights. I did send them direct email thinking they'd appreciate customer feedback but never got response. read more

See all

This is our local spot for pizza, wings, cheesesteaks, and burgers. Whenever we order out, we get Fusaro's. For years, we've been consistently happy with the food we've gotten and the service we've received. It's a great thing to be able to support a local business AND get food we love. Delivery is always quick, the food is always hot, and it's brought with a smile and a great attitude. If you want pizza tonight, get it from these folks...you'll be happy. read more

Best pizza in town. I've had pizza and every pizzeria in Manahawkin and Barneget. Some are really good but this place is definitely the best pizza in town. read more

sarah and erin are the best!! we love them and the vodka sauce grandma pies xxxx amazing customer service and food

This is the best place for Pizza & Pasta. Awesome staff and they deserve all the love. Coming back soon.

Ordered a white pizza and it had a strange smell to it. My son wouldn't touch it and I threw the whole thing out. Ordered a cheesesteak with mushrooms and the mushrooms tasted bad and the steak was disgusting. Only ordered it because it got such rave reviews, but huge mistake. Threw out more than 1/2 of that too. Only good thing in my $48 order was the cheese fries. 1st and last time I will ever order from this place. read more

Ok, aside from Tacos and my travels around the country eating them, there is no other food that I have eaten more than Pizza. Now the truth is, good pizza does not exist out side of New Jersey and New York and yes I have had pizza in about 30 states and the reason I try outside of NJ is obvious. I check the yearly pizza reviews and go to the top ones in The NJ/NY metro area some times up to 3 stops in a day. Now the deal with this pizza, large slices, right amount of cheese and sauce, Flavor was good, crust was thin and crispy. The problem was the amount of oil and this required napkins to prevent an Exxon Valdez disaster. Now I like Olive oil, but was that the case here, don't know so therefore worrisome. Not much more to say here... read more

Get the grandma pie. It's sooooo yummy! Loved eating outside! .....................................................................

Ever time I order from here it's been PERFECT!!! Even the company I work for orders from here allllll the time!!!!! I love the bubbles on pizza crust which they won't pop if you ask them not too. The soups are amazing! And so are the entries which they will make to order for you if they can. Just check out my latest spread!!! Chicken Sal Timbocca. I get extra spinach, prosciutto, and mootz on mine!!! Super yummy mixing it in with the pasta and a really delicious brown wine sauce! Pasta Fasul Soup (the red kind for those that know what I mean) Mmm toast up the fresh baked bread, butter it up and dip!!! WOW They give your a 'serious' serving too! HUGE is more like it! So, If you're looking for a great Italian place with fresh hot food, reasonably priced for the quality, and picky like me, try them out! I don't think you'll be disappointed! Cheers Trish read more

Fusaro Pizza - Italian Near Me - Manahawkin, New Jersey

See all

We've been loyal Fusaro's customers for nearly a decade. Up until recently they've provided quality food, often times prepared to order. However, the last three deliveries were not up to par. More often than not the food was not made as requested and delivered warm, not hot and/or underdone. Heating the food wasn't a big issue, it's just amateurish. The last delivery, though, was awful. Our typical order (pizza, mussels, and wings) was so overdone that the mussels disintegrated and the wings were burnt leaving only the pizza edible. This isn't a story of being disgruntled, just extremely disappointed. I sent private messages via FB Messenger to avoid public embarrassment, but they have gone unaddressed and unanswered. It's clear that Fusaro cares only about the customer's money and not the customer's satisfaction. Fusaro routinely removes negative comments from their posts on social media to give the impression that all is good and no one is dissatisfied. You can do better, Fusaro, much better! read more

Food was good but put meat in my wrap after ordering it without, called back and the lady on the phone was really nice so they sent another one but that one also contained meat. I was extremely disappointed as I was excited to eat my meal but ran out of time due to them missing it up. Went back the other week and it happened AGAIN. Make sure you are specific about your order and double check it. read more

This place has always been hit or miss but lately all miss. I don't know if it's supply chain excuses but for the extra charges it should be balanced. 17 bucks for wings and they didn't include sauce! Pizza came burned. Pasta Fagioli was just dish water broth. Sides we paid for were not included or chintzy. This is the last straw and we will be moving on to order from somewhere else. read more

Down in the area to visit family, we got these guys delivered to the house. Delivery got here in perfect timing. Got the Fusaro grilled chicken wrap it was pretty good , definitely not the best but up there. Would like to try one of their pizza's next time read more

Fusaro Pizza - Fusaro Grilled Chicken Wrap - Italian Near Me - Manahawkin, New Jersey

I will make this review quick and to the point. Pizza is okay. Not the best but definitely not as bad as some of the one star reviews describe it. Place is fairly clean. Employees could be nicer but nothing terrible stands out. 3 stars out of 5 seems like a nice fit for a place like this. read more

Best pizza around! They are always so accommodating as well so all my kids are happy on pizza night to each have the toppings they want. Great staff! We always have the friendliest delivery drivers. read more

Great vodka pizza! Love the variety the menu offers. It's great for take out and hearty portions.

This was the worst pizza I've ever had in my life. Family and friends know me as someone who loves pizza and I can usually deal with a mediocre pizza, but this. This was disgusting I actually spit it out and that's a first. I'd rather eat a frozen pizza than gag this down. The sausage was gummy and bouncy and the flavor was like smelling a dumpster as you walk by. Garlic knots were as hard as a rock while the pizza was soggy. No amount of trying to throw garlic powder or anything towards this pizza could make it palatable. I wis I could get a refund. read more

So far best pizza I've found around. Vodka sauce pizza is really good. Attentive service and yummy pizza. Ate twice this week there.

Got take out once, don't waste your money. Everything was too salty and slimy I couldn't even eat it

Order from them all the time. The price increase on shrimp is insane. For what they charge, you can go to shoprite and get a pound. I do not mimd paying more for cooked food but something that cost 58 is now 85 for two orders it's robbery. 4.50 for 2 litter soda is high also. read more

Been ordering from here for too long to remember. Food is always amazing and the people who work there even more so. Highly recommend. Some of my go to's: Hot & Spicy Shrimp, Grandma Pizza, and anything with grilled chicken (salad, sandwich, wrap, etc) read more