Jersey Girl

This is my second winter here in Bellevue and I always will come by to visit Oak St! You can taste…read morethe freshest of ingredients in Vicky's bahn mi and her veggie lasagna just warms my heart. Also, don't forget to take away a bakers dozen worth of cookies! She has a variety of sweeties from sugar cookies to PB topped with a chocolate kiss, petit fours to old fashioned chocolate chips, and gluten free options too! My favorite so far are the S'mores!! If you're lucky, you might meet ol' Uncle Donnie, an old friend of Vicky's from Santa Cruz. If you buy him a gluten free cookie, he'll tell tell you all about the hippie days. (:

Vicky and her daughter Kate are so nice and always available for a chat, even if you are just…read morewalking by. (Not pictured) the sandwich special--the reuben was one of the best reubens I've ever had in my life. Also the mixed fruit shortcake. So fresh and delicious

For the holidays

Don't forget to bring cash!

See all

Yummy Chicken Salad Sandwich on Sourdough! Tangy mustard, plenty of veggies. Delish!

Big Belly Deli

4.3(62 reviews)

0.1 mi

We love these folks. Food quality is very good , service is…read morewarm and fun. A true go to in Hailey

This place was hopping on an off day in off season, so I cannot imagine what kind of wait you would…read moreendure in peak season. The gals behind the counter were nice but clearly running around like chickens. The website is down (and has been for a while, and still is as I post this review 10 days later), which is always a drag because I like to preview the menu and cross reference with Yelp photos. When I mentioned it, they were a little snotty, so I dropped it. I ordered two sandwiches, the hot roast beef and the ham and apple. Instead, I received the meatball sandwich in place of the roast beef. Honestly, I was fine with it, but the lady doubled down and insisted I had ordered the meatball one. Spoiler alert, I did not. The ham and apple had barely a whisper of apple, so the meatball ended up being the winner of the two. The real stars here though are the cookies. Yes, they are overpriced, but they are delicious. The peanut butter based ones are the champions in my book.

Cookies!! Get one in your belly

Cookies one half eaten

See all

Dining room

E Street Deli

4.9(99 reviews)

70.2 mi

If you haven't been to E Street Deli here is your sign! The food, service, and atmosphere was…read moreperfect on this rainy day. The roasted poblano soup and the jalapeño cornbread were out of this world.

I stopped in this town as a side trip off the interstate... this place was AMAZING .. had a Spicy…read morePeach Steak sandwich that was Incredible !! Prices are VERY REASONABLE... especially compared to everywhere else.. Definitely a future stop again when passing through Idaho...

Great food and ambiance! With beautiful city park right across the street.

#5 is very tasty!

See all

Johnny G's Sub Shack

4.7(88 reviews)

11.5 mi

Great sandwiches and great people. Stopped in here for lunch and had nice chats with staff,…read moreeveryone was super friendly. Thanks JG's!

The BEST sandwich shop in the West, possibly in all of North America! There's something for…read moreeveryone and the vibe is lit. Only wish I could go there more often... try the chicken parm or the steak dip!

Chicken Caesar

See all

Outdoor seating

Village Market

4.0(22 reviews)

11.4 mi

Super awesome staff. They accepted a return on a product that I didn't expect them to do (it was…read morestill in the package, but I had no receipt). I like that they have the free small fruit for the kids while I shop. More reasonably priced but not as big as Atkinson. Less crowded, they have a ton of produce and better deals on spindrift (kids fav).

Tried to order a sandwich at the deli counter. The guy working pointed at a prepackaged sandwich in…read morethe fridge and said "are you sure you don't want this?" I politely said thank you and walked out. Guess they don't like out of towners.

See all

Gross

Albertsons

2.2(20 reviews)

0.7 mi

Overall the staff are friendly and many have been there for many years. Meats have a decent variety…read morebut watch dairy expiration dates. Do NOT buy ice cream here. When restocking, they park the frozen products in the isle until stocked and they may stay there for hours. Every Breyer ice cream I have purchased in the past 5 years had melted before refreezing, losing 10 to 20 percent and becoming hard as a rock.

Almost everything I have purchased here is expired...cheese, milk, frozen meals, canned goods,…read moreproduce....the list goes on. I have handed expired goods to the store works and have seen them place the items back on the shelf. What a dump.

See all

Atkinsons' Market

3.3(39 reviews)

11.6 mi

•$$$

WARNING! ATKINSON'S SELLS EXPIRED BEVERAGES AND ROTTEN PRODUCE! - CONSISTENTLY, IT IS A REAL…read morePROBLEM! ATKINSONS SELLS EXPIRED MILK, FRUIT, AND BEVERAGES TO THE COMMUNITY AND APPARENTLY DOES NOT CARE! It's disgusting and unhealthy. Three times I've brought home Atkinson's milk, fruit juice, and cherries, only to find that the expiration dates had already passed and the fruit was soft and spoiling. Their produce really sucks. It makes people lose money and time and threatens family health. Someone is going to get seriously ill from this store. Greedy store owners who aren't concerned about customers sell expired food and rotting produce. SPECIFICALLY IN HAILEY. Entirely true. Switch to Albertsons.

Fell into SV during Billionaire summer camp and decided to have a simple sandwich lunch. Went back…read moreto the deli and ordered 2 sandwiches from Carmen, who went to work on our orders. While we waited, we noticed the clientele and the hardworking folks staffing the store. Most everyone working at the store was friendly and anxious to be of assistance. The store is jammed with a lot of goods and not a large footprint which can make navigating the store challenging with a cart and a lack of spatial awareness for yourself and others. We feasted on our sandwiches at one of the tables at the front by the coffee stand. It was delicious and fun to watch the people checking out and play old money/new money.

Get them fresh for the log cabin

Fun wine section

See all

The Smokey Bone BBQ

4.3(106 reviews)

67.1 mi

I was excited to try this place as it was highly rated. I ordered my sandwich that had pulled pork…read moreand brisket on it. The portions were very generous and the brisket was dripping with juices when it was being carved. I ordered a side of Mac and cheese. It looked so good on my tray. Unfortunately my Mac and cheese was overcooked and had gummy noodles and a soupy texture despite being made with real cheese and being seasoned well. The brisket was as good as it looked but the dry and woody pulled pork ruined an otherwise perfect sandwich. The service was lackluster. I felt like I was bothering the staff. Make smaller batches of food so they don't overcook and train your staff to engage people. You are in a food hall, your competitors share a dining room with you.

Brisket sandwich was great, lots of meat! Split the sandwich and was full (not sure why people are…read morecomplaining about not enough meat!). Get it with spicy bbq sauce, which is not really spicy, but has a nice kick.

Burnt ends sandwich

See all

A & A Market

4.2(12 reviews)

51.3 mi

I have ordered food for events several times and it is always delicious. Recently I ordered their…read morecrispy and juicy fried chicken for 20 and it was fresh and ready on time. A day later we fed our hungry group A&A roast beef which everyone raved about. It came in an electric roasting pan to keep warm until we were ready to eat. We also got baked potatoes which had its own roasting pan--every potato was a good size and blemish free. We rounded out the meal with salad, rolls, and brownies. The staff packed everything and loaded it in my car making easy work of feeding a crowd. This has always been my experience when ordering catering from the A&A. If you aren't feeding a crowd, their hot takeaway food is so tasty. Plus, the staff is friendly and helpful. Five star service every time!!!

The people that either own run or work for this market are theives and do not do their jobs. I went…read moreto arco idaho for a visit with a friend. I went shopping and decided I didn't want something from the fridge. And just set it out so I can finish my shopping. Also expecting the worker to clean their store and walk around to make sure this dont happen and the lose money. I went in a week late and she ran that same item that I didn't not try to get this time and charged me for it for the rest of my groceries. And I never got the item this week or the week before. This is totally illegal. It is also against the Idaho Consumer Act. Store are supposed to take those losses. So now they gona get money for it through their company and off the customer. Don't put anything in the wrong place in this store. What disgusting business practice. No one should shop here. Go the hour away to Idaho Falls rather. When I called to talk to them about this issue she threatened cops on my for theft thow I never walked outta the store with the item. I also have arterial pulmonary hypertension and breathing is a real scary struggle. I couldn't breath was getting scared and going into a panic attack hence why I didn't walk it all the way back to where I got it. I need to finish getting a couple other thing and get home before I passed out in their store. I will be putting this review on every platform I can find. A AND A MARKET IN ARCO IDAHO STEAL FROM CUSTIMERS. THE MANAGER HUNG UP ON ME THE SECOND TIME I CALLED TO SPEAK WITH THEM ABOUT THIS ISSUE. I GUESS I WILL HAVE TO GO BACK TO CALIFORNIA AND ASK MY ATTORNEY TO HANDLE THIS AS HES LICENSED IN ALL STATES. THIS COMPANY ALSO HAS SURVEILANCE OF ME LEAVING THE ITEM. WHICH WILL BE BETTER FOR ME. CUZ IT SHOWS THEY ARE TO LAZY TO WALK AROUND THEIR STORE TO MAKE SURE EVERYTHING IS WHERE ITS SUPPOSED TO BE. ESPECIALLY IF THEY WATCHED IT HAPPEN ON SURVEILLANCE.

A&A Market

Cold Deli Items

See all

Cheese selection

Main Street Custom Cutting & Grill

5.0(8 reviews)

55.8 mi

The food was very good and tasty! Service was fast and friendly. The restaurant was clean and well…read moremaintained. I had no idea this place existed but would highly recommend for a quick lunch. I know I'll be back.

The best! I am from out of town and always will eat here when passing through! All te way from TN…read moreto ID!!! My favorite spot!!

Love the new look!

Mushroom Swiss burger

See all

Reuben with 2 types of cheese

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Dan L.

0

4

2

5 years ago

This place is amazing! Get the "Jersey Girl"! One of the greatest inventions known to man. I've tried a few other menu items, and all amazing too. Amazing customer service and restaurant vibe! Our go to spot on our way into Ketchum. Great coffee as well! read more

G S.

1

167

3

4 years ago

Very good sandwiches. Good service. We had the roast beef and the bacado. Both were very good. We will be back.

Frederic R.

Elite 22

56

196

34

9 years ago

Great fresh sandwich and the soup (tomato that day) was just as fresh as it can be.

Mary R.

126

17

65

9 years ago

Love Jersey Girl - great, fresh food! The grilled turkey on a pannini is awesome!

T C.

0

7

0

11 years ago

Food is amazing

Jersey Girl - delis - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Hailey, Idaho Things to Do near Jersey Girl

BEST of Hailey, Idaho Sandwiches near Jersey Girl

BEST of Hailey, Idaho Coffee near Jersey Girl

BEST of Hailey, Idaho Lunch near Jersey Girl

BEST of Hailey, Idaho Pizza near Jersey Girl

BEST of Hailey, Idaho Breakfast near Jersey Girl

BEST of Hailey, Idaho Thrift Stores near Jersey Girl

Best of Hailey

Things to do in Hailey

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Jersey Girl also viewed

Big Belly Deli

4.3

(62 reviews)

We love these folks. Food quality is very good , service is…read morewarm and fun. A true go to in Hailey

This place was hopping on an off day in off season, so I cannot imagine what kind of wait you would…read moreendure in peak season. The gals behind the counter were nice but clearly running around like chickens. The website is down (and has been for a while, and still is as I post this review 10 days later), which is always a drag because I like to preview the menu and cross reference with Yelp photos. When I mentioned it, they were a little snotty, so I dropped it. I ordered two sandwiches, the hot roast beef and the ham and apple. Instead, I received the meatball sandwich in place of the roast beef. Honestly, I was fine with it, but the lady doubled down and insisted I had ordered the meatball one. Spoiler alert, I did not. The ham and apple had barely a whisper of apple, so the meatball ended up being the winner of the two. The real stars here though are the cookies. Yes, they are overpriced, but they are delicious. The peanut butter based ones are the champions in my book.

Shorty's Diner

4.0

(89 reviews)

We were in town fir a softball tournament and went walking down Main Street looking for good food!…read moreMany others had recommended Shorty's so we decided yo give it a try! My husband ordered breakfast and I ordered lunch. They have all day breakfast which my husband loved! I had a Rueben and asked for it in sourdough and they brought it out in are still so that was disappointing considering my husband then had his food get cold as he waited for me to get mine to eat. The ambience was old school, very quiet and country town feeling. Our server was running all over the place so maybe they were short handed I don't know. My husband finished his meal off with the cinnamon roll, his fav! It was ok, a little on the dryer side and needed more frosting lol But all in all this place was fun to try.

I mean how can you not give Shorty's 5 stars?! We've been many times but just writing a review now…read more Staff is always so friendly and waits usually aren't too bad. Vibes are great in downtown Hailey. Anything on their menu is great so you can't go wrong with what you order!

Lucy's Breakfast

4.6

(37 reviews)

*this yelp will take you to an old address- this is 2 doors down from YoiMi sushi and hibachi…read more(which is outstanding as well). 745 Main Street, Gannett ID Wooooowwww so good. The options were great. The service even better. Quality and quantity of food was superb. We ordered and within 10 minutes we had our freshly cooked food out. Tips- order the Cafe de Olla coffee. You will thank me later. Today's order: Chilaquiles 10/10 (beans and rice outstanding) NY steak plate 8/10 (don't think it was a NY steak but the steak cut was good) Waffle 6/10 (a little dry)

Excellent food! Excellent and friendly service. Extremely clean. Reasonable prices. Regular or…read moreMexican coffee is free Monday through Friday with breakfast. We've had breakfast there two days in a row and are considering a third as I type this. There is no question that we will be back if when we're in the area again.

Dark Sky Deli & Dogs

5.0

(4 reviews)

Awesome food in the middle of town! The only place to get food late night. Everything is high…read morequality ingredients and delicious. Haven't ordered anything that wasn't amazing!

The sandwiches are tasty and delicious. The bread is tasty and light. Love the arugula and the…read moresauce. Meat portions are perfect. Service is always excellent. The vibe is local and friendly. Love this new spot.

Café Della

4.8

(60 reviews)

OK, this is definitely one of my new favorite places here in Haley. Whether it's for breakfast or…read morelunch or just to grab a quick health and item, this is the place to go. They're fast Freche and tasty. If you eat inside the café, you can eat indoors or outdoors. The coffee is delightful and I can't wait to come back.

Incredible food - healthy quality ingredients, amazing flavors …read more I love their menu and the market at the front of the store!!

Wrangler Drive-In

4.3

(56 reviews)

Stopped in Fairfield at the Wrangler and I'm not mad about it! There's a small sitting area inside…read moreand tables and chairs out front. We placed our order and the shakes came out first. We ordered chocolate, which was indeed very chocolatey, and raspberry, every bite had real raspberries in it. These shakes were the star thick and delicious, we fought over the last bites! We also ordered some burgers, chicken strips, finger steaks, fried curds, and hand dipped onion rings. It was typical Drive-In food, that being said, there was also no leftover:)

Busy little place with a lot of locals and a few travelers passing by on their way to somewhere…read more Best option on this desolate stretch of highway. Has a nice wood burning fireplace in the dining room for the cold days. Helpful and pleasant young lady taking our order at the counter. Asked for suggestions and they happened to be out of their famous curly fries on this day. Chicken strips were just ok. Seemed to be the frozen type with no real chunks of chicken. Regular fries were the same, nothing special frozen type. Family liked the burgers and the sweet potato fries were really good. Shakes are thick and made with real ice cream.

Elkhorn Clubhouse Grill

4.3

(6 reviews)

It's a spectacular spot to have lunch indoors or outdoors either after a golf round or just go and…read morehave lunch. The menu is terrific and also they always have a daily special. The bar is awesome and offers whatever cocktails you want. The staff are kind friendly and just great. Go and enjoy the views and the tasty plates!

Monday night $5 burger is where its at in the summer. Great patio seating available. Come early!read more

Trail Creek Cantina

5.0

(2 reviews)

New spot just opened last week. Menu has interesting selections from salads. Appetizers. Sandos…read more Fried chicken. Kids eats. And sweets. They have sodas. Beer and wine. Service was quite pleasant and the seating is indoor and outdoor. Enjoy.

Great food, fantastic staff. The salads and sandwiches are incredible and the chips are homemade…read more Eat lunch with an incredible view of Baldy. This place rocks!

La Cabanita Mex

5.0

(1 review)

We stopped in for a quick snack on the way to Sun Valley…read more The complimentary chips, salsa, and beans served on arrival are excellent! We had chicken tortilla soup. Food was served quickly and is delicious!

Bigwood Grill

3.5

(28 reviews)