Coffee was good! I got the honey cinnamon latte iced! It was fast & the atmosphere was inviting read more

Jack's Stir Brew Coffee - Coffee Roasteries Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

See all

Jack's offers fast service, but the quality is missing! I ordered their seasonal Strawberry Matcha Latte. The matcha itself was mid, but the biggest issue was the artificial strawberry syrup. It made the drink overly clumpy and overall not enjoyable. For almost $11, I expected better! read more

Jack's Stir Brew Coffee - Strawberry Iced Matcha and Iced Coffee - Coffee Roasteries Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

One of the best spots for a cappuccino or latte in the Hampton that I've found. No frills spot with a couple of tables outside. Not friendly service at all, but the coffee comes out quick. read more

The coffee was fine but a bit bitter and pricey. Also was not a great service experience both times we went.

To say I dream about this coffee every day would be an understatement. Their iced Happy Jack is simply the most perfectly blended, palate pleasing, just the right amount of ice drink. I would drive back to the Hamptons just to have this. The employees aren't the most friendly but I will say they crush that line super quickly which is what's most important read more

Jack's Stir Brew Coffee - Iced Happy Jack - Coffee Roasteries Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

Best coffee in Sag Harbor - standing room only unless you can perch on a window seat, but worth it.

We got a perfectly decent cappucino here. Maybe the best we had in the Hamptons.

It was a cold afternoon (38 degrees) and Sag harbor was somewhat deserted. I was told that the coffee here was good ; Well like other reviews mentioned , it was expensive for what they offer. I had a medium cappuccino with an extra shot of espresso. It was somewhat bland and I missed the aroma of a good coffee ($6.50). The hot chocolate with almond milk wasn't great either. Let's move on . read more

I used to drive from Southampton to Amagansett to get the honey cinnamon latte from the store when they first opened. Jack happened to be there and was very friendly and very nice as was the staff. So, today I walked into THIS store. I'm sure they had a rough day as did we all working in Sag Village today. But I barely put my foot in the door and I got greeted by someone screaming at me that they were closed and they closed at 3. No need to yell buddy. I'll drive to Starbucks before I'll go here again. read more

This coffee shop was somewhat of a letdown. I came this morning to get a few coffees for my family and the lattes were pretty bland and the flavor was overall plain. I prefer lattes where you can really appreciate the flavor of the espresso, but this was more nondescript. Not that it was bad by any means, it just isn't worth getting again when there are so many superb options. I also did not like that they used small ice chips because 1) small pieces of ice melt faster than larger pieces, and it waters down your coffee more quickly, and 2) they do not give straws and so the little pieces of ice easily flow through the spout as you're trying to drink the coffee. The cashier was also really off-putting, which made the experience not great. All in all, there are much better coffee shops in this area that I will go to in the future instead of Jack's. read more

We were visiting for the day from Manhattan where I live. I had my Mom with me who has very strong taste in coffee. The local ladies at the florists recommended it -had that not been the case the two negative reviews below may have put us off. -We were not disappointed. Best cappuccino we have had in a long while. Yeah its not cheap but its comparable with high end coffee anywhere. Lovely friendly service too!! read more

Best coffee in the Hamptons (though that is a low bar), but coffee here is always solid and unlike their mean sister in Amagansett the service here is civil and efficient. The Teddy Boy is our particular decadent favorite. I only wish it stayed open later in the afternoon. read more

Grace is the best! She always serves her customers coffee with a smile. She makes coming to jacks worth it every time!

My favorite spot in the Hamptons to get great coffee with friendly, happy service! The coffee is always so tasty. The staff are always kind, inviting, and moving quickly. The place to get coffee in sag harbor or Amagansett! read more

We visited this coffee shop everyday on our vacation in Sag Harbor. The baristas were friendly and Grace made great recommendations on both coffee drinks and other shop items! (Ginger Shot anyone?!) read more

Are you kidding me??? The absolute worst cup of coffee for $3.50 that you could ever imagine!!! No taste, all watered down and absolutely no strength. It's such a shame that this place doesn't obviously care to make people happy which would be so easy. I don't like Keurig coffee but I would much rather have Keurig dark roast anything than this places jacked up ripoff prices. Also, a tiny apple cider donut was $3.50 what a disgrace!! read more

Great coffee and espresso. Fantastic friendly service. And a beautiful dark-haired barista that served us on Sunday morning 7/31. Super recommended. read more

This coffee shop has become my new go to. I came in one morning and the women at the register suggested I have a "Honey Cinnamon" coffee. The second I tasted it, all of the flavors exploded into my mouth, the coffee was not to strong and the taste matched the aroma. In my opinion its a real gem I found,. read more

The best coffee in Sag Harbor!! Better than the coffee is Grace! She welcomes her patrons with a warm smile and a delicious cup of coffee!

Wow, I can't even believe I have to be downloading this app just to put this out there. These people had the guts to charge me $14.00 for 4 shots over ice (which is more than twice as expensive as their iced americano which has 3 shots). Needless to say there is absolutely no chance I will ever spend a dollar here again. As a local who has consistently tried to support businesses such as Jacks I am appalled. read more

I visit Jack's every time I'm in Sag Harbor and make sure to go when Grace is working. She is incredibly kind to customers, whether regulars or guests like myself, is thoughtful and knowledgeable about her work and store products, and is a valuable asset to the Sag Harbor Jack's location. Plus she makes some mean latte art and the world's best chai with oat milk! read more

Let me preface this review by mentioning we were at a wedding the night before until 2 am, hungover and in desperate need of coffee for our ride home. Voila... we happened to be near Jack's Stir Brew Coffee so my wife and I parked across the street in the police station lot and walked over to the cafe. Ordered one iced coffee and one small regular coffee... and the price was $8.50. Let me repeat that, freaking $8.50 for two coffees that were average tasting, mild and a waste of money! Would have been far better off going to, dare I say, 7 Eleven! Really not sure if this is the going rate for coffee in Sag Harbor but if we are paying $8.50 the coffee better be excellent which was not the case. read more

Not bad. Jack's stir brew is a small, quaint coffee shop good for pit stops. Not really a sit down place. I had a small plain coffee, it was good, not too strong but not too weak. I could see myself coming back. read more

$3 for small coffee?! Overpriced, even almost by Hampton's standards, unless they jacked up their prices now that Sag Town Coffee isn't operating due to the fire. I'm just not sure what the fuss is about. Coffee is good, not outstanding, service austere, while prices are very high. read more