Ordering cookies and ice cream at 10 pm is bound to get a higher rating from me. The bar is low here - just warm up the chocolate chip cookie or brownie, keep the vanilla ice cream cold and not overly sweet, and I'm a bullseye for your product market fit. I can't speak for other locations but I like the service at this smith st location where the temperament is adjusted down. I don't need a cheerful face at 10 pm getting a glucose spike I know I shouldn't. I don't need an upsell either to deluxe over the top options. The folks working here know the deal - grab that spatula and get me those warm cookies in a box so I can enjoy my midnight snack. read more

Everything was delicious. Warm. Sweet. Fully understood the late-night assignment. The kind of dessert run that feels a little irresponsible while you are doing it and completely correct once the first bite lands. No complaints from this box. Just sugar doing what sugar came to do. The real shoutout goes to the night staff. Absolute gems. Friendly. Quick. Still kind even at hours when most people are running on fumes and bad decisions. They kept the energy up and made the whole stop feel easy, which honestly is half the magic with a late-night cookie place. Good staff can make a cookie taste even better, and this team definitely did. The vibe is pure after-hours survival mode in the best way. A little chaotic. A little sleepy. A little sugar-fueled. But exactly where you want to be when your self-control clocked out two hours ago. it's giving... Euphoria energy with cookies and better customer service. read more

The cookies/sweets at insomnia are a hit or miss. We tried the s'mores, cinammon bun classic, and the chocolate chunk brookie. The sweetest of the bunch was the chocolate chunk brookie. It was more cookie than brownie - it was hard but also extremely sweet. If you're not trying to lose your sweet tooth, avoid the brookie. The s'mores were good - super sweet still but manageable because of its gooey chocolate inside. The best was also the smallest cookie - the cinnamon bun classic - this was the right amount of sweetness and not nauseating to eat. Would come back to try their peanut butter cookie because they were out during my time of visit. Highly recommend the cinammon bun classic. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

There's a 20 cookies for $20 deal right now so I figured why not! I placed my order online for pick up and got there earlier than my pick up time. Luckily the store was empty when I got there and they started packing up my box. The store filled up soon after. The counter area for this location is pretty spacious in comparison to others and very clean and bright. Their anniversary deal is until Oct 31! read more

See all

I was craving for a good chocolate chip cookie & this place popped up nearby. I got chocolate chip cookie to try & it came right out of the oven. It was warm gooey and chocolately. The cookie was good but not amazing. I still think one of the best chocolate chip cookie is from Levain Bakery! The guy server was friendly and nice. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

My go to spot for cookies EVERY TIME. There's a special going on now until December 4th for a free cookie once you show the app in store only . I do my rounds (grocery shopping and laundry) every Saturday in the neighborhood and couldn't resist this special treat. Upon arrival as always I'm greeted by a friendly cashier, and the smell of fresh baked cookies. It's always spotless clean as well. It was not crowded and you get your cookies always fresh and always in a timely . The spot is small, but you definitely will not be in there for long periods of time as they move very fast . I picked up their famous s'mores cookie today. It's full of chocolatey goodness and marshmallows, served warm and oh so yummy. If ever your in the area and have a sweet tooth you should definitely stop in. They also have other locations in the tri state area. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Yummy s'mores cookie - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Very kind and friendly staff, even though I know they probably had to deal with a lot of nonsense on Halloween night. They gave me a free classic cookie since I was in a costume. I also bought one of the limited edition Reese's pieces cookies. Delicious cookies as always. Please bring a location to Queens! read more

I've seen Insomnia Cookies in multiple locations. I wanted to try and see how special this place was. We picked a variety pack and it was not so impressive. Compared to other competitor companies, I didn't notice anything special. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Deluxe 6-Pack - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

A mixed experience to be sure. The white chocolate macadamia and double chocolate chuck are excellent, moist and gooey. However Oatmeal raisin was dry and the Snickerdoodle tastes like uncooked cookie dough. I'm sure their late hours add to its popularity. Mia's Bakery is right up the street and their cookies are bigger and better read more

As the last day before I start my clean eating I figured I'd go out with a bang by having some Insomnia Cookies. I absolutely love the warm soft cookies served here. My favs are the Sugar and the Classic with M&Ms. These cookies are enough to satisfy any sweet tooth or craving. Just as the name implies, they are open till late. Perfect for late night munchies. I like how you are able to choose between purchasing individuals or boxes of assorted flavors of your own choosing. I will say that starting tomorrow I will miss these cookies. read more

See all

Bought chocolate walnut coconut cookie, and received a red velvet and strawberry chocolate cookies for free. The former is 4.50 each. Yep you read that right! 4.50 for a cookie and it is not Levain Bakery.. Maaaan go to the grocery store buy your own cookie dough and add some walnuts to it. It's ridiculous in these streets. read more

See all

This place has warm cookies. And they deliver. And they're open late. (These are good things.) They also have excellent marketing. I know this because my wife came home and said, "Did you see what opened up on Smith? A place that has warm cookies. And they deliver them! Late at night!" I thought, "That's awesome. But how do you know all this?"* And then later saw the window of Insomnia Cookies, which reads, "WARM COOKIES DELIVERED. OPEN LATE." Excellent marketing. Also, probably the best thing that could open up nearby, especially if you want to get super fat. But also super happy. I'm neither super fat, nor super happy,** but I could be both now that Insomnia Cookies is here. I would also like to report that the cookies are pretty tasty, in addition to being warm, and delivered late.*** I've only had the chocolate chunk and the oatmeal raisin thus far (I'm a classic kind of guy), but I'm never sad to get them. Warm. Delivered. Late. ________________ *My wife is not one to do research on local businesses. That's my role in our marriage. **I actually am pretty happy, but cookies make you happier. It's science. ***For me, late is like 8 pm. I have two children now, and if I'm awake at 3 am (when they close on the weekends) it's because I went to sleep, and was awakened by a problem that has to do with my children. That could potentially be improved with warm cookies. read more

We came here for dessert after eating around the corner and was so happy we did. We both got a cookie and ice cream. I got the dream weaver flavor which is interesting mlt purple but it is chocolate-y. The employee was generous and gave us huge scoops of ice cream. read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This spot is the best! Rodley was great, the cookies are always good. The service is 10/10! Just a cute spot to hangout with your friends and have a cookie. read more

Warm cookies? Yes please! Great price too! There are so many choices, all great. I think the mint chip is my favorite. There is something great about gooey chocolate chips and mint chips. They also have mini cookies which I will definately get next time! read more

Insomnia Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I love how they offer vegan and gluten-free options without compromising on taste. The Cookie'wiches and brownies are dangerously good too! Overall, Insomnia Cookies is a must-try if you love fresh-baked desserts and late-night convenience. read more

love this location! Alawsys great energy from the workers there! I love the chocolate peanut butter deluxe cookies!!!

Very bad service. We stopped in and the worker walked up front eating a cookie. I asked him for a 6 pack and he ignored me and started to fulfull an online order, no hello or can I help you. We left without ordering. Obviously do not appreciate walk in customers. Really need to do better. read more

It is dangerous having this place in my neighborhood. Even though it's fairly decent walk for me, I still manage to find myself stopping here to grab a cookie whenever I'm in the area. Which has amounted to a good 5 or 6 times in the past month, but who's counting? They have a variety to choose from, but the chocolate chip cookie is still my favorite. Warm, gooey, chocolatey (but not too sweet) goodness. There's one guy who works there who's awesome, and the rest of the workers range from friendly to barely tolerating me. But as long as I get my cookies, I'm good. read more

excellent customer service, cookies always made to perfection, and the store is always clean .

Ordered - after two hours without delivery grubhub cancelled the order Two hours to not deliver 6 cookies 10 blocks away I thought this was their whole thing read more

These cookies are delicious and very addictive . Cookies are always fresh and warm, like they literally just came out the oven. read more

Ordered on Uber eats. Said would be delivered by 745 pm and at 849 pm still undelivered. Delivery guy said it was fault of insomnia who can't process orders and double up on orders. Won't order here again. read more

If I could give zero stars I would. They accepted my online order and when I went to pick it up they weren't even open. read more

I came here to see what the hype was all about and honestly I didn't think they would be all that but I was hopeful. They're pricey I will say that but It turns out that I really did enjoy the cookie! I can only speak for the s'mores cookie. It was served warm and had a nice crisp (I don't like soft cookies) but over all it was pretty good. read more

I admit I'm a foodie...Just putting that out there as a disclaimer. I really enjoy Insomnia cookies. My wife introduced me to them when we were in NC. Love their oatmeal raisin and macadamia nut cookies. These are my personal favorites. read more