We recently took a little two day vacation to the hill country, just to get out of the house. We found ourselves in Llano at about 2pm and were hungry. We decided to stop at Inman's and see how it stacked up against the BBQ places in our town. To sum it up, I was impressed.
Despite the fact that it was well after the lunch rush, and there were only a couple of other people in the dining room, the staff was more than attentive and friendly. In my opinion, you can judge the skill of a pit-master on his/her brisket and ribs, so that's what I ordered. The brisket was more of a competition style brisket. It was tender, but didn't fall apart when I picked it up. It still has some substance to it, which is the way it should be. A lot of people think that brisket should fall apart when you look at it, but in reality, that means it's overcooked. The rub seemed pretty plain, and I'd be surprised if you told me it contained more than 3 ingredients other than salt and pepper. I really like this. IMO, too many people try to disguise mediocre food by coating it with a layer of rub that is jam packed with sugar and other spices, to the point where that's all you taste. I tasted brisket, with a little bit of saltiness and a hint of pepper, without being overwhelmed with 100s of flavors.
I do have to admit that the ribs were a bit overcooked for me. They shared the same simple flavors as the brisket, but were VERY tender. I can overlook this though, because I know that most consumers out there think that all good BBQ should fall off the bone, so that's what most places try to serve. I also understand that it's next to impossible to cook ribs to perfection, then hold them at that state for an unknown number of hours until they get served. I suspect that if we'd been there right at noon, the ribs probably would have had a consistency more to my liking. The flavor was very good, nonetheless.
Now, on to the BBQ sauce. Their sauce is like none I've ever had at a restaurant before. It is VERY tomato-y (yeah, I know that's not a real word). It leaves a heavy, lingering tomato aftertaste, even after you swallow. The only way I could describe it would be that it is similar to the taste of Manwich sauce. Being a bit of a BBQ sauce snob, I always make it a point to try the sauce by itself, before running the risk of messing up good BBQ with sauce. I had my doubts. I honestly didn't like the aftertaste of the sauce when I tried it plain, but decided to give it a chance and put it on a piece of the brisket. As much as I hate to admit it, I was wrong about the sauce. There is something magical that happens when the strong tomato taste of the sauce blends with the flavors of the brisket. It was good. Really good. It would not be my choice of a "do everything" kind of BBQ sauce, but when combined with the flavors of the meat and rub at Inman's, it works.
As for the sides, I thought the potato salad was pretty good. I'm a fan of creamy, mayo based potato salads instead of mustard based, so I was pleased. Sure, I've had better, but I've also had worse. Much worse. The pinto beans were less than remarkable. I don't know if it's the fact that we were late and they'd probably been sitting on the warmer for a couple of hours, or if it's the fact that they're just pinto beans, but I wouldn't bother with them. There was no real flavor to speak of, and their consistency was kind of mushy. If this was an email to Inman's I'd suggest that they chop up some burnt ends and throw them in the mix, along with a few thinly sliced jalapenos, but that's not what this is all about. I'd probably pass on the beans altogether if I went back.
The staff was more than friendly. They greeted us when we walked in, made sure we didn't have any questions, and made small talk with me while I was waiting on my wife to change our daughter before we left. All in all, it was a very enjoyable experience, and I wouldn't hesitate to drop by there again if I was in Llano and wanted some BBQ. read more