I want to thank the staff and new owners of Windser Jewelery for their quality of work on a special…read morepiece of jeweler that honors a true love story of a man and a woman married 67 years enabling the wife to have a cherished taken of their loved turned into something that she can wear as a reminder that their love will be forever. Thank you. What a blessing that new owners brought Windsor Jewelry back to Indianapolis.

Day is a great person greeting you as you walk in. And Ken did a fantastic job restoring an old…read morewatch I inherited. I will come back without a doubt.

I wanted a specific David Yurman ring and was communicating with their Digital Marketing Manager,…read moreJoshua. He was very helpful and responsive to all my questions. I finally decided to purchase it and it arrived in a timely manner and I am very pleased. I highly recommend Reis-Nichols if you see something on their website that you like if, like me, you cannot go in person to their stores.

My wife and I have been going exclusively to Reis-Nichols since we got married six years ago, and…read morewe wouldn't go anywhere else. From the very first time we walked in and met our jeweler Kathleen (who we still work with today because she's truly the best) we knew we were in great hands. They always take amazing care of us. Whether you come in knowing exactly what you want or, like us, not knowing much at all, the team treats you with the respect and attention you deserve. They're patient, knowledgeable, and genuinely want to help you find the best fit and value. If you're looking for a place you can trust and keep coming back to for years, this is it. Expect to find your forever jewelry home too!

I took a certified gemstone in and asked if they could make a bezel for my jewelry and they said…read morethey could do that. I also showed them the design I would like for the pendant holder and they designed it just as my photo showed. Everyone here was great and this is a really cute store: There are designer illustrations of the different types of diamonds throughout the store with old hollywood legend wall crystal artwork and beautiful crystal lighting. My necklace I had designed was my something blue in my wedding!

Ladies, tell your man what you want and then send him to Petite G. Better yet, tell your man what…read moreyou want and tell the helpful sales staff at Petite G. I am so thankful to Heather who helped my husband pick out my "every day necklace." This jewelry store is tiny, but it is always busy. The staff are super helpful and approachable. The decor inside has just the right amount of sparkle.

Lois is great! She was willing to work on my weird project - a custom watch band for a vintage…read morewatch that is not a Rolex or something else expensive. She has old school classic jewelry repair know how that is nearly impossible to find these days. I take all my repairs here now.

Highly recommend Barrington Jewels if you are looking to customize a piece for yourself. The staff…read moreis friendly and able to make recommendations on how to best make the item work. I took in a pair of ear cuffs from Hearts on Fire. They were individual cuffs that could be easily taken on/off (they didn't have an ear post). I loved them but I'd almost lost them at least twice when wearing them so I was looking for a way to turn them into a more permanent ear decoration. Barrington helped me get the two cuffs sauntered together and added a post so I'd be able to wear them without fear of losing them! I loved the finished product. The price was reasonable as well! Very happy with my experience! Thank you Barrington!

Easily one of the best spots to find a gift! I could spend hours here. The staff is incredibly…read moreknowledgeable and always helpful with any questions. If you love silver jewelry, this place is a candy store, but you'll also find fun games, unique cards, glassware, candles, books, Indy swag, and more. There is also a location in Carmel. And, they just celebrated 25 years (amazing!), so if you haven't checked it out yet, it's definitely worth a visit!

Looooooove SITC! Fantastic business run by good people with an incredibly fun retail selection…read more White elephant, sentimental, unique, Indy-based gifts at your fingertips. Incredible jewelry (some made by awesome local artists). All items range in cost, which makes it easy to find what you want. This store is a staple for the city and a must visit.

I happened to stumble on this amazing "jewel" of a place when I needed a ring resized. The…read moreproprietor, Charlie Walker, was amazingly knowledgeable and kind. The interior is vintage 1920s, and much of the equipment Charlie uses is original. Charlie's inventory of jewelry is also very interesting, particularly the pearly. Highly recommended for all your jewelry needs.

Great service. Friendly staff. Helpful Professional. Great…read moreselection. Repairs are done swiftly and with care I highly recommend recommend this store for your jewelry needs and repairs

Felt pressured here. Shorter heavy-set guy was a little pushy and seemed not to want to be bothered…read moreby me looking and asking questions

They are very nice people. However, I do regret selling my jewelry to them. I should have sold it…read moreto my local store here in Brownsburg. I don't think I was given a fair price and I know I went through with it and I said yes to him, but soon as I drove away, it occurred to me that I wasn't given a fair price for a diamond sapphire ring. Diamond sapphire ring was offered at weight. And I should've had the stones taken out live and learn I guess. This ring I bought from them I later sold to a local jewelry store. I didn't like it as much as I thought I did. I wish they could've taken it back. I wish I could've returned it to them. For what I bought.

Disappointed with their watch repair services. Brought two watches in for battery replacement and…read moreboth of them now get condensation under the glass face.

Just left the store. Excellent customer service and a special thanks to Stu. I purchased my wife's…read morewedding band from this location a few years ago and have had no issues at all. Today, I came in for a separate occasion and everyone that helped me was very friendly and efficient. Highly recommend!

Just stopped in here to look at wedding bands and had a very poor experience. My partner and I have…read morebeen together for a very long time, but haven't legally tied the knot. We bought my engagement ring here in 2022 and have contemplated where to get our wedding bands from. When I stopped in here last Saturday to have my engagement ring cleaned, a staff member told me they were having out of town designers fly in this weekend for a big sale and to come back and have drinks and hors d'oeuvres. We both work Monday-Friday and were already busy on Saturday, so I asked if they would be open on Sunday for the event. She said they would be open 12-5. We decided we would get brunch in Castleton and then pop over to look at weddings bands today. The older woman who is always at the front door greeted us and we went to peruse the wedding bands at the back of the store. Not one other employee greeted us, asked if we wanted to look at anything, if we needed help with anything, etc. There was no additional stock or outside designers there today like I was told last week, so I guess they only came in for Friday/Saturday. Which is frustrating since I expressed that we would only be able to come in on Sunday and she didn't mention anything about them not being here today. We looked through all of the wedding bands we have already seen before and had to keep stepping around staff members who were blocking display cases while having personal conversations (not anything to do with jewelry). At one point, several men started yelling and jumping up and down because they had the Colts playing on the TV. Super weird vibes for a jewelry store. The last straw was when a woman who was sitting inside of the wedding bands area, but again never even greeted us, asked another staff member if he wanted something and he came over and sat his soda down on the display case we were actively looking at and then leaned back on it and started blocking it. We promptly decided to leave since we weren't being acknowledged. We previously had a very bad experience with a customer service staff member when we came in to have an antique tanzanite ring resized and appraised that had been gifted to me by my great-grandmother. After today, we are just going to only come here for maintenance/warranty needs on my engagement ring and look elsewhere for wedding bands.