Easily one of the best spots to find a gift! I could spend hours here. The staff is incredibly knowledgeable and always helpful with any questions. If you love silver jewelry, this place is a candy store, but you'll also find fun games, unique cards, glassware, candles, books, Indy swag, and more. There is also a location in Carmel. And, they just celebrated 25 years (amazing!), so if you haven't checked it out yet, it's definitely worth a visit! read more

See all

Looooooove SITC! Fantastic business run by good people with an incredibly fun retail selection. White elephant, sentimental, unique, Indy-based gifts at your fingertips. Incredible jewelry (some made by awesome local artists). All items range in cost, which makes it easy to find what you want. This store is a staple for the city and a must visit. read more

Silver In the City - Storefront around the holidays - Jewelry Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This is an absolute MUST visit when in town. So many cute, clever and fun items. Great spot for gifts and unique knick knacks. We walked out with more than what we should but that's ok because it was totally worth it. Staff is also very nice! We loved everything. read more

One of the first things I saw as I stepped into Silver in the City: a coffee mug with Rose Nylund from The Golden Girls giving me the middle finger. Which was a coincidence, because I actually stopped in to find a new ring for one of my fingers! It was like Betty White knew, somehow. Silver in the City has a lot of jewelry, which is not on their website. I know this because I checked. You have to visit in person to see their collection. They have jewelry in all price points, too -- from around $15 all the way up to $100+. My little ring, which I love, was less than $20. I also looked at some lovely necklaces, bracelets and earrings. This is a great place to get inexpensive but fun jewelry. This is a great place to find Indiana-related gifts, too. You'll find local chocolates and food, wine glasses etched with Indianapolis streets, state park t-shirts, Monon Trail posters, Mass Ave stickers and lots more. There are kitchen goods, wacky socks, toys and gifts for kids, plant-specific things, pottery, handbags, and hundreds and hundreds of other fun things that I didn't know existed but suddenly had the urge to purchase right that minute. There are so many tchotchkes and trinkets, at a variety of price points. The people who work at the store are exceedingly helpful. Well-behaved dogs are also welcome -- I saw at least two beautiful doggies while I was there, who got lots of attention, of course. read more

Truly one of my favorite shops in the city and one I don't frequent because I know my wallet won't be happy (but my heart will be!) It is my go-to shop for souvenirs to bring friends when I travel but also to find special gifts for myself as well. There's a certain warmth and welcoming to the items in this store and the employees that make you want to stay, slow down, and browse each item. From jewelry, to puzzles, banners and Indy posters, there's much to see here. Thank you Silver in the City for being such a welcoming shop with heartfelt gifts for all! read more

I know....another gift store review. I just can't help myself. This is one of the great ones. It checks off all of the boxes: Cool, fun, unusual items - check! Friendly helpful staff - check! Good vibes - check! They also have a really gorgeous selection of jewelry. read more

It's always a joy to walk into Silver In the City! The amount of things they have for sale is jaw dropping! From candles and jewelry to plants and stickers and so much more! There is always new things to look out for and the staff is always bubbly and helpful. It's always a good day when I get the chance to stop in! read more

Excellent assortment of silver jewelry as well as other products. Friendly, helpful sales associates. Very reasonable prices.

I had a wonderful experience shopping at Silver In The City!! -- They have a wonderful, carefully selected selection of merchandise and their staff is incredibly pleasant and helpful! And they went above and beyond in correcting one of my orders. A true pleasure! read more

100% always wonderful. Helpful staff and readily available without pushing sales, if you just want to browse. My biggest complaint is that I get lost in the store and buy more than I should. Please stop being so cute! An actual gem on Mass Ave. read more

I've had Silver in the City bookmarked on my maps since the last time I was in Indy several years ago as a spot I wanted to check out. I wasn't able to check it out when I was here last, so when I was back in Indy this time a few months ago and saw I was walking by it on the map and had it bookmarked, I decided to pop in and see what it was all about. ...and now I'm kicking myself for not having come here sooner!!!!!! This place is SO CUTE! It is bursting at the seams with adorable, beautiful, whimsical GOODIES! There is something for everyone here and this is the perfect shop to shop at if you're looking to add some character into your home and life and DEFINITELY a perfect shop to shop at if you're looking for unique gifts for your loved ones! I love it here so much and I am a big frequenter of cute and unique gift shops in general, so over the years I have come to notice a lot of the same products from shop to shop of these types. Yet, Silver in the City still managed to surprise me in so many delightful ways by carrying SO MUCH - honestly the vast majority of the shop - that I had never seen before! It was so delightful to explore and discover so many unique items. I had a great time here and frankly it was probably a good thing that I was time constrained so could only shop here for 5-10 minutes before I had to go because otherwise I definitely would've bought way more and spent an obscene amount here!! Love everything about Silver in the City - AMAZING job on sourcing just the coolest goodies from all over to this wonderful store and on the lovely customer service too! I can't wait to come back here - INTENTIONALLY this time - the next time I'm in Indy to properly peruse the selection here and see what new goodies this gorgeous shop has in store! read more

If you love silver you definitely have to check out this store. It has a very large selection of silver.

Great trinkets and gifts at reasonable prices. Love this store! Got lots of gifts for my secret pal and others for Christmas!

Silver in the City is one of the best places in the city to browse and/or shop for gifts (for others and for yourself!). They have a lot of locally made products or products by independent artists and designers outside of Indiana, as well as cutesy things that are a bit standard for eclectic gift shops. The staff are always friendly here and I felt good about the covid precautions - everyone wears a mask, hand sanitizer, and you gift bag your own items (I like this because it get to choose bags/tissue paper color). read more

See all

Wonderful shop. Everything sterling silver. Got my daughter in laws the cutest earrings.

LOVE LOVE LIVE going to silver and the city. You can bet that if I'm downtown, especially near mass ave, I am begging my husband or friends to go in with me!! COVID: they have made some changes and have shields, sanitizer, and distancing in place. PRODUCTS: you can find anything from expensive jewelry, to cheap pins, to tshirts, and gag gifts at this store which makes it my favorite. I always find the best social justice items here and have bought several pieces of jewelry as well. Products include fair trade and sustainable items which is also a plus. If you're looking for a cool and unique gift for a friend or family member (or yourself) I definitely recommend going in! STAFF: employees are so friendly and welcoming and more than willing to help you with whatever questions or comments you have about the place. They are accommodating with returns and ensure that you have the best experience possible! read more

Silver In the City - Jewelry Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This is a staple shop on mass and is the perfect place for gifts or just wandering to discover what you didn't know you needed! Anything from sentimental, statements, gag gifts, or home decor, this place has it all! Check it out next time you're in the area! read more

Silver In the City - Jewelry Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Silver in the City is my go-to for gifts for every occasion - they have everything from sarcastic socks to locally made goods - tasty snacks. The staff is always super friendly and welcoming. They're also great at helping pick out gifts. You can preorder online and have your gifts delivered in just a couple days or pickup at the store. They're doing an excellent job at maintaining covid procedures and I feel super safe. Can't wait to check it out again. read more

See all

We had stopped at this shop earlier in the weekend and noted that they sold a lot of "gift shop/tourist" items. Many of the products seemed like they were made by either independent designers or small businesses. It had anywhere from jewelry to stickers to gag gifts and books. We stopped by on our last day to see if we could grab some items. I ended up buying some dad joke socks. The employees were very welcoming and helpful. I recommend checking this place out! read more

I was introduced to Silver in the City during a virtual conference this week. The non-profit is located in Indianapolis and the owner shared insights about her company, work in the community and leadership. It was very inspiring and it's the type of business culture I'd like to support. A necklace with the non-profit's slogan has been designed and a portion of sales will be donated to them. read more

Silver In the City - Virtual conference for IWL and the owner shared her insights - Jewelry Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

This is my ABSOLUTE favorite store in Indianapolis. Not only are the staff here always so kind, but they're knowledgable and try to answer any and all questions thoughtfully. They also remember which items I've purchased before and will show me new things that are similar (ie. DIY mini building kits) Do NOT miss out on this wonderful local store. I swear there is magic in there. read more

Love shopping here! Great spot to buy gifts for others or for yourself:-) Employees are always friendly & helpful. One of my frequent stops on the weekends!! read more

Silver in the City has been one of my favorite shops downtown for years. I used to visit with my sister when I'd drive in to see her. Now that I live here, a Sunday stroll through Silver in the City is a leisurely way to spend the day. I adore all of the thoughtful and cute gift items. For the more fiesty and irreverent folks, there are gifts for you, too. And the actual silver jewelry portion is always fun to peruse. There are great finds in every nook and cranny of this place and I love it! Best time to visit for me is definitely around Christmas. They get so many beautiful holiday items in stock and even if I'm just window shopping, they make me happy. Don't pass up Silver in the City next time you're on Mass Ave! It's well worth a visit. read more

Silver In the City - Jewelry Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

What a great little shop in Indianapolis. I visited silver in the city while waiting for a table at a local eatery. We were greeted by the friendly staff as soon as we walked through the door. It is a great gift shop with lots of merchandise to choose from. I do appreciate seeing kids books on diversity and acceptance. What a wonderful and safe vibe you all have created! Thank you for existing in this world. read more

DIVE IN with your magical self. This store is a charm, literally. It is the epitome of gift giving or the answer to your whimsical needs. The best experience is being completely unaware of cute location until you're walking by and decide to stop by. This store is set up nice with little niches to tickle your fancy.. (the little witch isle is my personal favorite). I picked up some books that I am waiting to delve into. It has jewelry, collectibles, mugs, clothing items, decor and so much more. The staff is amazing. We were greeted, given space to roam and checked on casually for any questions. They have a super thoughtful and super cute gift wrapping station with tissue paper and adorable gift bags!! I love this little detail. There's also a reward system so don't forget to sign up to receive points and discounts. Support local small business this holiday season! read more

See all

If Target and Urban Outfitters had a baby, this would be it. I have to be careful coming in here because my wallet is bound to take a hit. From kitchen items, to jewelry, to funny stickers, this place has the perfect gift for someone in your life. I recently picked up a pair of cat earrings and a Pawnee Goddesses (Parks and Rec) pint glass as Christmas gifts for my friends. The workers were also super helpful! I asked if they could hold on to some things while I finished shopping, and they put everything behind the counter for when I was ready to check out. They even have a gift packing station! I'm so happy Indy has such a hip small business I can shop at! read more

Stopped by for a quick look around. My friend was looking for a gift for themselves. I love this shop for it's filled with local businesses. It's all artsy products that are related to Indiana, politics, cute pop culture references, or just a brush of fresh air. Anyone is bound to find an item they want to take home. read more

Silver In the City - Jewelry Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Indy is lucky to have this place. Silver in the city is my go-to for buying friends and family unique gifts. Love supporting local artists and all the stuff they Ave is pretty awesome. read more

Customer service was great. Also the store is so cute and small but have a lot of merchandise. I just came to buy the Pride flag ‍ and I did find it since I had already called and they have saved one for me. Which is pretty amazing that they did that. Moreover they have a ton of Pride merchandise and of course other things but I was amazed on how much stuff they had. Furthermore I didn't get to see the whole store since I only came for the flag but I'll sure be coming back. read more

Very cool shop with all kinds of quirky stuff. The store can get a little tight if there are a ton of people in here. They've got jewelry, books, succulents, and all sorts of random knock knacks. It's cute! They greet you at the door and when you leave. Such nice people! read more

See all

Again, like so many places these days, how have I not made a point of getting to Silver in the City until now? It's a fun local gift shop, and when I say local, I mean that with a capital "L". I'm happy that I'm literally across the street every day, and I can find the most offbeat, unique gifts for people in my life. (Or just treats for me!) This place is a great way to be introduced to locally made items, Indiana-themed items, and just cool/different/crunchy stuff! I don't think I can come here without picking something up. I really love the bags from PUP made from old RCA dome materials and Super Bowl banners! I didn't even know that stuff was still floating around! While you're hanging out nomming your way through Mass Ave., definitely stop at Silver in the City and get lost in all the fun! read more

See all

It's not just a jewelry store! They have so many fun, unique, quirky things. Check it out, whether it's a gift for a friend or something fun for yourself. This has become one of my favorite shops and another great shop on Massachusetts Ave. The staff are friendly. The only thing to beware of are the narrow walkways, especially in the winter when everyone has a coat on. Just be careful not to knock into things and you'll be fine. read more

Silver In the City - Some fun and unique items: RBG pin, nerdy iron on patches, Mr. Rogers mints. - Jewelry Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Love this place! I've found multiple gifts that my friends have liked from this shop! They have curated items that millenials would love - air plants, succulents, Bob Ross themed mugs, fun books/journals, birthday cards, cocktail kits, Indianapolis/IN merch, jewelry, stickers, pins, patches, etc. Reminds me of a slightly more affordable Urban Outfitters home/beauty/apartment section. If you're stuck with finding a perfect gift, try silver in the city! read more

This is such a cute little shop! This is a perfect place to get a cute little present for yourself or a friend. They have a large jewelry section consisting of necklaces, rings, earrings and bracelets. They're gorgeous and usually locally made. They have fun stickers and pins to help flare up any outfit or accessory. The wide variety of gifts range from plants and pot holders to books and journals. They do have quite a few alcohol related items which are fun to look at! This is a smaller store so if there's anymore than 10 people it does feel a little crammed. I did purchase a pair of sunglasses from here and they broke after a few times wearing them, so be very careful! read more

Silver In the City - Jewelry Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Fart lip gloss. Mini terrariums with gold dinosaurs inside. Socks covered in bacon strips. Cookbooks for couples. Stationary with the coolest designs in all the land. Yep, just a glimpse of what you'll find at Silver in the City on Mass Ave. Set aside a half hour to explore the ever-changing inventory. I often leave with a smile on my face or some sort of creative juices flowing. Fun fact: Yelp's data team pulled the top 50 rated gift shops in the country and Silver in the City was 10th! Not my shop but I'm beaming with pride. read more

See all

Really cute stuff for yourself and for gifts to loved ones!! You'll adore it. I was looking around for quite a while before making my final decision. So many cool, useful things for great prices! read more

Silver In the City - Entrance to the shop. Massachusetts Ave. - Jewelry Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Silver in the City is an adorable shop full of fun gift type items. I'd equate it to an Urban Outfitters minus the clothes but with a huge addition of a jewelry section. As far as the gifts go, you'll find everything that's 'in' right now from mustache items galore, bacon items abound and tiny outfits for squirrels. They have a bunch of special Indiana items, quirky cards, fun books, strange cat items and many drinking accessories. This is a fantastic shop to find a unique gift for someone, plus they have a pretty space with items on sale. This kind of shop is dangerous for me because I love awkward little cute items.I narrowly escaped with my wallet intact. read more

Silver In the City - You drive me Swayze! - Jewelry Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

If you haven't been here yet - go! There are so many cute, original and fun items for everyone! You could spend a good amount of time looking at everything. I just about found something for everyone on my Christmas list and they had a good quantity of items on stock. The jewelry is way too cute ... it was very hard to make my decisions! All staff was very friendly and eager to assist. I love a lot of the Hoosier pride items in stock too! This is my new go-to for gifts for family and friends! read more

Stopped in here just to look around, ended up buying things of course. The kiddo wanted the bacon flavored candy canes. They always have new and fun things. They did not disappoint. If you have small kids, viewer discretion lol, the F word is on a few things. Jewelry, nicknacks, notebooks, coffee mugs, and many unique gifts. Cute little shop. read more

Silver In the City - Bacon flavored candy canes - Jewelry Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

This place was by far the busiest of the three gift shops on Mass Ave that my wife and I explored. With a name like Silver in the City, she expected it to be more of a jewelry store. When she passed by that section of the store, no one asked if they could help. There was a lot of stuff, a wide variety actually, but the place felt cramped and crowded with a line stretching back from the pay counter like you would see at a department store with kids waiting to see Santa. Either not enough help or enough registers...not sure, but I found the experience difficult to maneuver and actually look at the goods. Maybe I will have better luck on a weekday when the crowds aren't so large. Review #1834 read more

See all