My custom made jewelry from 27 years ago, which was soon after this shop opened , still looks flawless today. They provided excellent service to maintain it and enlarge it when the ring didn't fit as well as it used to. I have the utmost confidence and respect for this jeweler and would be hard pressed to go anywhere else. read more

Wonderful experience buying my wife's Christmas gift. Mike and his team made finding the perfect present effortless -- so many options and excellent diamond advice. Always a pleasure visiting Masters Jewelers. read more

I've used Master Jewelers for several repairs over the years. They are always professional, reasonably priced, and timely. A few months ago I had the need to liquidate a fair amount of jewelry from a family member who passed away. Mike was just fantastic to work with. He spent several hours to help me determine what was real and what was costume, as well as tell me which pieces were worth keeping. After disbursing some of the pieces to grandkids Mike purchased the rest for a very fair price for the gold and silver. I would not hesitate to use them again or recommend them to anyone who needs jewelry services. read more

I took my gold chain here to he repaired. I was met with extremely nice and welcoming staff members. I was told my chain was going to be soldered in spots. I was a little concerned because I typically use Moyer jeweler but Chose Master on a referral from a friend, but assumed they knew what they were doing. But ...never again I paid $130.... It came back with Silver spots where it was soldered in 5 different places. My wife was very upset with me and demanded I take it back. I didn't say anything my bad, on me to employee because I was frankly embarrassed. I have worn it for less then a week, and now there are shards or parts of my chain coming apart where they soldered it. I need a completely new chain now. My $600 dollar chain down the drain, because of my stupid decision. Please I would like to save anyone else the time and money. DO NOT use them for Jewelery repair. read more

Master Jewelers - Watches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I dropped off my watch for repair and was given a written estimate of $50-$60. I was told I would get a call in a couple days with the exact cost and the date the repair would be completed. A week passed and no follow up, so I called and was told that the repair hadn't been done yet and an exact cost couldn't be determined. I affirmed my desire to know the exact cost before approving the repair. However, the next week I was called and told that the watch was ready to be picked up and the cost was $82. No apology was given. This strikes me as dishonest. I will not go back or recommend them to anyone. read more

I took in some fairly ugly jewelry that my grandmother had given to me. It really wasn't my style and had been tucked away for a couple of decades. Master Jewelers was able to give me options and ideas to consider to reset it and make it my own. The prices were fair and the service was amazing. They were also able to source a perfect match to a solitaire diamond I had and create a beautiful set of earrings. Now I wear my heirloom pieces everyday and am thankful that I can have a reminder of my grandmother with me and not in a drawer! read more

Master Jewelers - Reset sapphires and diamonds. - Watches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Could not ask for a more honest, kind and professional business. They fixed my 29 year old wedding ring back to new. So beautiful! Thank you all! read more

I took my antique diamond ad sapphire ring to have it repaired. The ring that was returned to me looks worse than when I took it in for repair. Thay have ruined it. It was a ring belonging to my great-aunt that now looks nothing like the ring I brought in for repair. On top of that they tried to charge me twice the amount they originally quoted me. I am very, very upset. What should have remained a family heirloom is now a piece of junk. None of the store employees seemed to have a problem with that. They acted like they were doing me a favor by discounting the price they were trying to charge me, which was more than twice the cost quoted when I took it in. Whoever owns this store needs to be held responsible for the damage to my ring. It is now UGLY instead of being a family heirloom. read more

I wanted a one of a kind necklace made to my specifications. Everyone was welcoming and then took the time to listen, recomend and then create a spectacular necklace. Very reasonable. Master Jewelers is now my go to jewelry store. read more

I'm Proud to write an outstanding review for MASTER JEWELERS: needed a minor jewelry repair; MASTER JEWELERS's quote was $85 below/less than another jewelry store; repair was ready for pick up four hours later on same day; previous jewelry store was taking 5 weeks to complete repair; Sales Associate-Ms. Arlene Robinson was a "jewel" to work with; and, I plan to do more business with MASTER JEWELERS. read more

Love love LOVE the customer service and attention to details at Master Jewelers! We've used them for 20+ yrs to design wedding rings, for repairs to all our jewelry, purchased gifts here and we always walk away happy. The integrity the owner has and instills in every employee he hires shines thru every.single.visit! Thanks Michael and staff for being THE best anywhere hands down!!! read more

Dan provided me with wonderful and friendly service! I was looking for a custom engagement ring, and he was able to have some sapphires shipped in for me to look at and know exactly what the ring would look like before buying. read more

One of the things I am thankful this year is my new anniversary ring. Tom and I came to masters one month ago to buy a replacement for my old damaged ring. They helped us find a new one, bought the old one for three times it's original price, and when Mike found out our anniversary was the next day, he stayed late so Tom could come back that evening and pick it up! What a gift to us the masters experience was! Thank you! read more

Fantastic experience with Master Jewelers! Particularly, Christine is amazing! They patiently worked with me to recreate my old wedding ring set and it turned out better than before! Great personal experience, attention the detail and affordable prices. read more

Master Jewelers - Watches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The owner is very involved and personal. Always available to consult with. Great selection of fine jewelry.

My family has been purchasing from this jeweler for 30+ years. I drive from Lexington, Kentucky for the welcoming atmosphere, excellent customer service and Mike's expertise! We have always been thrilled with all pieces from here. Highly recommend to all!! read more

If you are looking for outstanding quality for the price with a very personal touch- definitely go to Master Jewelers. This business is a proud sponsor of the Indiana Pacers and and the Indianapolis Colts. Mike Neylon and his staff will take excellent care of you. All repairs are done on site, including a window of which you can see them working and crafting jewelery. I have purchased many items from this store, and plan to keep going back and purchasing more. read more

Master Jewelers - This is the Fabulous Showroom! - Watches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Master Jewelers recently custom designed and made beautiful rings made out of family heirlooms. Christine did an amazing job giving us suggestions and patiently working with us to design perfect rings. They met and exceeded our expectation. From sales to design to working with their craftsman. You won't be disappointed. They are extremely fair in price and beautiful. I rarely give five stars but would give 6 if it possible. read more

Looked on yelp for jewelry repair and came across Master Jewelers. Took my ring in and was impressed with the service, I decided to try them out. Needless to say I wish I did it sooner! I love my ring but most importantly it was finished right in time for me to go out of town to celebrate my husband's birthday. I think my ring looking brand new was a better gift than what he actually got lol. Will definitely recommend and use their services in the future! read more

Master Jewelers - Watches Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I have always heard good things about this place and they really lived up to their name. I took two rings in - one a David Yuman - to be sized. The craftsmanship was amazing and the work was completed will ahead of schedule. I will be back! read more

Great place! Ask for Don My stone was a bit loose and he fixed it in a few seconds with no charge! Thx Don

So happy to have found Master Jewelers! It has been a journey. My husband did a wonderful job picking out my wedding set in his small hometown mom and pop estate jewelry store however this jeweler didn't know anything about jewelry repair...little did we know.... After we were married I wanted to have the two bands soldered together so we took the rings back to the estate jeweler to have this service done. After several months of wear the rings came apart. This happened twice, and as this service from the estate jeweler was outsourced, I would wait 4 weeks at a time to get my rings returned. The third time we took it to a different jeweler in Indianapolis, same thing happened. The forth time after seeking recommendations we found Master Jewelers. Thank heavens! At Master Jewelers, thanks to their knowledgeable staff, I discovered my rings were from the 1920's and I probably would have never soldered the rings together in the first place if I would have known they were vintage pieces. I also discovered the previous jewelers were using white gold instead of platinum (my ring is platinum) to repair the shank of my ring. Master Jewelers had to go in, remove all of the white gold and rebuild the shank with platinum. They did an excellent job with the repair and my ring was finished within the week. It has been 6 six years and I haven't had any issues with my band. I have also taken my ring to them to fix damaged prongs and replace a small pave diamond. My ring always comes back looking beautiful. They really do an exceptional job, their pricing is very reasonable, and they can get repairs done quickly. Their staff are also super friendly, very knowledgeable, and helpful. Other notes: They source Fair Trade diamonds for their jewelry. The have a team of craftsman & gemologists on staff that are certified master bench jewelers. This means you can feel confident they know what they are doing. They won't outsource your repair. My one regret is that I didn't take my ring to them first as it would have saved me a lot of trouble and money. So, if you are in the market for an engagement ring, jewelry, a custom designed piece, or repairs I would highly recommend checking them out. read more

I take my watches here whenever I need repairs or adjustments. They do a great job at a reasonable price very quickly.

I am really disappointed at the service I received here. I have had to have a watch redone now 3 times due to their extremely poor and incompetent work. I have never experienced such a complete lack of understanding of watches and jewelry. This jeweler was recommended to me by a friend and I will not be going back - ever. Take your business somewhere else. read more

The utmost in professional service; quality jewelry and personal touch. Mike and his staff are the best!