Food was reheated like Chucky cheese pizza. It looked like they had it stuck in a fridge for a couple of days and put that thing in the oven as if it was fresh. Thanks but no thanks. If I could get a refund I so would. read more

Wow, Infinitos Pizza has lost its touch, Took my family there today around 4:30ish, pizzas were sitting in the bake lights so long it looked like jerky all dried up and nasty. When asked if they could make some new ones, staff acted like it was a chore to do. I remember when fresh pizzas were ready they would holler out what just came up. Today silence, Had to go up and check for ourselves. All I can say is don't waste your time and money at Infinitos anymore, you'll be disappointed . read more

Food is great, wide variety of pizza! Lady at front desk is very nice and knew we didnt know what we were doing so she asked us is we needed help. Great people, Great food, Great place. read more

Younger staff was working so the food was not being replaced as it should of been. We had to request things a few times and being a Saturday night at dinner time we shouldn't of had to wait. The staff was busy talking and playing on their phones and not paying attention to the food nor the requests that were put in. I shouldn't have to request something 2-3 times before they finally decide to make it. read more

We enjoy coming here every couple of weeks for some good and inexpensive pizza. There are a couple of wait staff that make this place amazing, including Steve who always makes our time here a pleasure. read more

We visited tonight with 6 kids about and hour before closing. The staff was very nice and accommodating making sure the kids had whatever pizzas they wanted available. We closed the place down and they were great. read more

Literally the dirtiest most disgusting infinitos we've ever been to. There were no pizzas ready besides 1 which didn't have a spatula so there was no way to even get it without using your hands. They didn't even bother making more pizzas until then either, so everyone was left waiting for more to be made. All the "clean" plates had stains, pizza sauce, and crumbs all over them. We will never be back. read more

pretty mediocre food. it's good for a buffet and a fast meal to feed lots of people, but overall, it's nothing special.

We are regulars here and it's decent and a good value. But tonight was not great. For the third time in five visits, the rewards system was down. When I expressed displeasure at that, the employee at the register became snippy, threw the receipt at me and walked off. I wasn't blaming her for the technical difficulties, but that was way out of line. read more

We have really enjoyed this place in the past when we have visited the Hanover area. Our experience this time was mixed. Prices have gone up from "Hey, this is cheap!" to "It's not too bad, I guess." Currently, the pizza buffet is $6.99 while the drink station is $2.49. Figure $10.00 for lunch. This is pretty good for all you can eat. Then again, for a family of four, it will be $40.00, and you could do better for a pizza dinner. There were maybe a dozen pizzas to choose from, 3 or 4 of them vegetarian. They were enjoyable, but none would be considered outstanding. New pizzas came out regularly and they were willing to take requests. The pasta bar was basic, but the kids liked it. Our main concern was cleanliness. A number of tables were piled with dirty plates and cups, with the few employees getting to them sometime in the future. Floors were both sticky and slippery in places. The clean plate pile had some unclean dishes. The person that appeared to be the manager was friendly, but had terrible food handling protocol. She wore gloves -- but NEVER took the gloves off or changed them. She took money at the register, cleared dirty cooking items, opened all sorts of drawers, formed the pizza dough, sprinkled the cheese on, handled more cash register money, went back to placing pepperoni, answered the phone, etc. This was a major turn-off. A younger high-school kid, on the other hand, seemed very good at getting a new pair of gloves when handling food. Unfortunately, we were "grossed out" enough to question coming here again. read more

This place is pretty hit or miss. Sometimes, the staff is really friendly and attentive. The pizza is fresh and there are lots of options. Other times, you have stacks and stacks of plates on your table, the buffet is nearly empty, the salad bar looks like it's seen far better days, and no one is really concerned about customer service or keeping the place clean. Nothing terribly special about the pizza and the "signature" cinnamon buns are pretty gross. I personally love the salad bar when it's fresh. There are plenty of goodies to choose from and I'd rather fill up on that. Pasta isn't bad. Again, nothing spectacular, but decent. read more

All you can eat cheap pizzas. They had a lot of different pizza choices to choose from. A decent salad bar and good drink choices. For the price I thought was pretty good. For 3 adults with drinks it was only $28 and some change. The cinnamon rolls were the best! I would go back again just for them. The staff were friendly and helpful. The only downside the place needs a good cleaning. The floors were wet, sticky and slippery. The bathroom also needed to be cleaned. If I was in the area I would try it again. read more

This place is ok. Food is good. Choices r nice. Can be packed and very noisy though. Good for people with kids.

This place used to be good. Good, fresh pizzas made to order quickly. The staff used to be extremely friendly and outgoing. Today's visit there are many empty plates sitting on empty tables. They were out of Pizza frequently. The woman's restroom had a broken water facet, the soap dispenser and paper towel dispenser are not working. read more

Infinitos - Hanover - tables and chairs in a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

I was just there (May 9th at 2:30pm)...did not eat. MANAGER rudely refused to accept my phone text coupon. He said because it was fowarded when I know for a FACT the 3 couples in front of me used the exact same coupon! I got the texts before but just changed phone numbers. Sad because the special was for Mother's day MOMS...and I have 3 kids (2 were with me then). I will not return. Don't run specials you refuse to honor. No mention of forwards not allowed. read more

Shocked to see the low review we use to go to infinitos in harrisburg, this location in hanover blows them away! Cinnamon rolls are soft not hard like Harrisburg's same with bread sticks which are awesome! But they should have little dishes for the sauce. read more

Pizza tastes good, but they recently raised their prices again for the buffet?! It was more reasonable before. It would have been cheaper to go somewhere else with way more selection. Their choices are diverse but can be super hit or miss. For example, the Tuscan taco can be really spicy or barely flavored. Some days the broccoli on their broccoli-alfredo tastes freezer burnt. The salad bar can be awesome and fresh or kinda wilty. The pasta bar sauces sometimes get weird and clumpy on top. Their cinnamon buns are great. Their bread sticks can be overly buttery. Their cleaning standards could be better too. Chipping paint on the counter where food is, dusty air vents, and I saw a serving spatula on the floor for a good half hour under the buffet during a visit once. The employees are always super friendly and our plates are always cleared quickly when we get up to grab more food. (Sometimes tables that are recently vacated will sit a little longer before being cleared though) I also love that they will immediately cook up any pizza on their menu if you ask and put it out on the buffet. Verdict: not too bad but could be better. read more

Excellent, hot, fresh pizza! I wish I had room to try more! Friendly service too - if I still lived in Hanover I'd be a regular (a fat regular!)! read more

Manager is super friendly. Pizza was very fresh and tasted great. All employees were friendly and eager to help. Would highly recommend.

I eat here on lunch break regularly and food is always good, they keep it fresh and staff is very polite and friendly. Recently, on Labor Day, our business decided to treat the staff with food. Having used Infinito's in the past, I called last minute, hoping they could take a large order with no notice. Within the hour, Danielle and her staff had 22 pizzas ready for pick up, and another 12 shortly after. All while prepping for regular lunch business and serving a large group inside. Great experience, will use them again, and a thank you to Danielle and her team! read more

I took my family into this Infinito's today and should have left when they told me they only had water. This was not a big deal, the problem was that there was roughly 3 slices of pizza being served, not counting dessert pizzas. There was no pasta and the salad bar was brown. The staff spent their time on their cell phones, unconcerned with the lack of food to serve their costumers. We sat and waited for 10 minutes before another pizza was served (which everyone jumped on). One couple who walked in stood at the counter and waited 5 minutes before anyone noticed them, they were smart and left after being told about there only being water. We over heard them tell people absolutely not to drink the iced tea because something was wrong with it. We will never return to this Infinito's again. We made the wrong choice, should have picked the Subway next door. read more

This place must have changed management (and recipes) recently. I hadn't been to this one in a while but went recently for a nephews party and the staff was friendly and the pizza was really tasty for the price. Pretty good salad bar too. Pleasantly surprised! read more

I swear the employees are higher than me.. I love the breadsticks and rosè pizza, but sadly they mess up my order almost every time. Needs better employees, like jesus christ read more

Danielle answered the phone and asked if I could hold on. Being considerate, I said yes. SIX minutes later I hung up. I've been trying to call back and the line is busy! I guess six pizzas isn't a big enough order to be considerate. if they need more counter help, they need to hire more people. Sorry but I have people to feed and lunch hours to respect. too bad Infinitos doesn't do the same. read more