If you're paying nearly $20 for a medium iced coffee and an iced matcha latte, you'd expect the…read moredrinks to be good at the very least. Unfortunately, the matcha was a big disappointment. It isn't freshly whisked or made to order, they have it premixed and sitting in a container ready to pour. You can definitely taste the difference. It didn't taste fresh and, strangely enough, kind of tasted like Play-Doh. The place itself is really nice, and the staff was friendly, so there are definitely positives here. But at these prices, the quality of the drinks needs to match. With so many good coffee shops in town, they really need to step up the drink quality if they want to stay competitive.

Visit Date: May 3, 2026…read more All I want to do is go to the cafes listed in my LI cafe passport book for Christmas but my friends keep picking different coffee shops that are not in my book which is slightly annoying to me lol I made a plan to meet my friend Shani and she wanted to check this place out. I got a regular coffee with half and half because I also got the crepe and wanted to not have sugar on top of sugar if I drank a sweet drink and had a sweet dessert. I ended up choosing a crepe, they had no dessert with peanut butter in it which would have been my first choice. The crepe was okay. I ate half of it and my boyfriend ate the other half when I saw him after coffee. I found this place to be just okay, I gave it 4 stars because it was good but it didn't wow me and I think they made it too trendy looking and too hyped up. The service was also very good the man who helped me answered my questions patiently. So I liked this place but wasn't really wowed by it.

On my way out of a recent street festival in Syosset, I happened to pass by The Groovy Cookie's…read morebooth, where these gargantuan lumps of dough, buried in almost obscene mounds of chocolate chips, were screaming my name. Most of the time, when I drop a lot of money on a "boutique" cookie, I end up sorely disappointed in its over-sweet or way-too-crunchy character. I had just had a spicy Indian lunch and needed something to counteract the curry, so I thought I'd take a chance on a Groovy Cookie. The supersized Chocolate Chip looked a little overwhelming, so I opted for the package of normal-sized ones. I was a little concerned that these wouldn't be as soft and gooey as the large one, but as soon as I popped one out of the package, I was proved wrong. This thing felt like it was straight out of the oven. "Uh oh," I thought. "There's got be a catch. This must be one of those chemical experiment confections that tastes nothing like a real cookie." But after the first bite, my theory was shot and my cookie snobbiness was instantly humbled. "This..." I remember thinking, "is THE BEST chocolate chip cookie I have ever tasted." To make sure I wasn't overreacting, I found a friend to give one to and she responded the same way. I quickly folded up the package and stuffed it into my pocket, afraid someone else I know might see me and ask for one. I tried to make it all the way home so I could let my wife taste one, but by the time I got there, I had devoured the entire bag. Everybody has different taste in cookies. I don't like the crazy-sweet ones they sell in that big bread restaurant at all. I like semi-sweet and really soft. These tasted like (and had the consistency of) raw cookie dough, so much so that I had to double-check as to whether I was supposed to take them home and bake them! Your taste will be different, but without getting too overdramatic, as a total cookie snob who usually HATES the cookies that others will travel miles and miles for, I've got to say that these are well worth a try. Fortunately (for me, not the company), these aren't readily available at the local convenience store, otherwise I'd be downing a pack a day. The literature from the company doesn't make it very clear, but I THINK you can order these online. Also, the company's lit doesn't really stick with a recognizable theme or logo throughout, so you have to be careful to make sure you're getting the real thing. Have fun, and I hope you enjoy your Groovy Cookie as much as I enjoyed mine.

a great new long island small business! the groovy cookie is…read morethe perfect place to get some delish, huge, and fun cookies and cookie dough! the cookies are so tasty and they have such interesting flavors. the owner is super nice and explained super thoroughly everything that i got and got me super excited to try everything! they even offer local pickup and nationwide delivery! highly recommend if you loveee cookies!

Great food great service and also great desserts and are reasonably priced. Also it doesn't matter…read morehow big or small your party is. Everyone will be happy

This was my first time at the Bay Shore location. We used to go to the Nesconset location fairly…read moreoften, but it's probably been a year or so since we've been to one. Unfortunately, this visit reminded me of some of the reasons we don't come here as much anymore. The prices have definitely gone up quite a bit over the last few years. We had a party of six, and about half of the meals were kids meals, so I was pretty shocked when we got the bill. What makes it harder to swallow is that the portions also seem smaller than they used to be. The food was delicious, as it usually is, but the value just isn't what I remember. The fried mozzarella was a good example. I remember getting six to eight pieces that were easy to share. Now you get three larger pieces. They tasted great, but with six people at the table we had to cut them up just so everyone could have some. My Cuban sandwich also seemed noticeably smaller than I remember. The service was probably the most disappointing part. The restaurant wasn't particularly busy, and we had reservations, but we still ended up waiting and eventually had to remind someone that we were there. As soon as we did, we were seated, so it seemed like they may have just forgotten about us. Our waiter also seemed pretty disconnected. He wrote down our drink order but still forgot several of the drinks, and we had to remind him more than once. The bathroom wasn't much better. It smelled pretty bad and there were no napkins available. There was also a large amount of napkins piled in the garbage, so it looked like it could have used some attention, especially during the dinner rush. A regular maintenance check during busy periods would probably go a long way. I will say that the food itself was very good. Everything we ordered tasted great, and honestly, that's probably the main reason I didn't leave feeling completely disappointed. Overall, it wasn't a horrible experience, but it definitely wasn't the experience I remember having here years ago. Prices are higher, portions seem smaller, and the service and cleanliness left a lot to be desired. There's a reason we haven't been coming as often, and unfortunately this visit reinforced that. I still enjoy the food, but at these prices, I expect a little more.

Excellent. Vanilla chocolate chip is very creamy with a good amount of chocolate chips.read more

This location seems to be a little older than the one on Main Street in Bay Shore, but one thing it…read moredefinitely has going for it is the variety of flavors. There is also a convenient parking lot, which makes stopping by much easier. The pricing seems to be about the same and is a little high in my opinion, but since the ice cream is homemade, you can truly taste the quality. Another thing I enjoyed about this location is that they have seating inside, so you can relax and enjoy your treats. There was a long line when I arrived, but it moved smoothly. The worker was friendly and patient, allowing me to sample a few flavors before making my selection. I ended up sticking with our favorites, Brownie Nut Fudge and Banana Oreo, but next time I'll definitely have to try one of the new flavors I sampled. Definitely recommend! If you're going to treat yourself to ice cream, it might as well be creamy, delicious and made with care.

My husband says I'll put the owner's kids through college because I live here…read more But who wouldn't? Manhattan Sweets is beautiful, and you're always greeted so warmly, and everything you get there is a hit. It's my go-to for a box of mixed cookies when I'm having guests or when I am going somewhere as a guest. Their rainbow cookie cupcake is super-special and they'll accommodate pretty much any custom order conveniently. The brownies are great, the baguettes are phenomenal - you can't miss with this bakery.

I've seen a lot about this place and wanted to give them a try. They are not your conventional…read morebakery but have many different and interesting items sure to please almost anyone. There is street parking and multiple municipal lots within walking distance. The shop is long with many cases and displays of baked goods. Everything is labeled clearly and the packaging they use to wrap your purchases is very visually pleasing. Better looking wrapping if you are looking to bring something to someone's house. They have gluten free options and quite a few items you don't typically see other places. The employees working were friendly and knowledgeable. They were also extremely patient with the more indecisive customers. Overall I would recommend this bake shop for a fun change to your typical bakery.

Love love love this donut place!! They have so many delicious flavors. You'll definitely walk out…read morewith more than one. Great service as well!

This was my first time trying these donuts! They were recommended to me by my aunt. I got a box of…read moresix and they didn't disappoint. All of the flavors were nice and moist on the inside and the toppings were delicious. By the time I got there at 1pm, most donuts were sold out (popular spot) but they had a good selection to work with! My favorite was the glazed donut. It was so soft and pillowy. It melted in my mouth! I would definitely want to come back and grab a different dozen of donuts. The staff was super friendly and the place is just super cute and cozy! I would definitely come back to try more and would recommend for others to try.

I really like this place. I always get a coffee boba when in the area. They have almond and soy…read moremilk options and they always make my coffee just right. If you visit the mall, stop here before you leave.

This is not like yaasss tea but similar. The have cheesecake tea and other fun teas to try. It is a…read morefun tea, and coffee place to try different teas and coffees with many flavors. If you're a bubble tea fan definitely it's a must try. The service is great I call the people who makes the type of drinks artist. It's amazing to watch! It's a small spot take out spot in the mall but the ambiance is cute, clean and small.

Finally got to stop by this local ice cream shop. It was nice not having to track down the truck…read morethis time. The store itself is simple, with no seating inside. There's a small merchandise area where they sell hoodies, T-shirts, and even a toy ice cream truck. I noticed they had a large selection of ice cream and really appreciated the assortment of cones available. The prices were a little higher than I expected, but the customer service was good. They also offer a BOGO sundae special on Tuesdays, which I definitely plan to take advantage of in the future. For such a nostalgic company, though, I do wish they had some seating so people could sit, talk, and enjoy their ice cream with family and friends. Overall, it's a fun stop for a sweet treat, but adding a small seating area would really make the experience feel more complete.

Here's the Scoop! We all remember the Siftee ice cream truck…read morecoming down our block or at the park. Well now you can go to the store. It's located on Carlton Avenue in Islip. Oh boy the choices are delicious and so, so good. I ordered a waffle bowl with soft serve vanilla, nuts, black cherries and whipped cream topping. Yum, yum, yum!!! So happy I don't have to wait until summer to listen for the truck. Definitely check them out. Fast service and reasonable prices.

My new favorite cafe! It's All you could want. Strong WiFi. Great playlist. Delish pastries and…read moreyummy drinks. Added bonus games, AND outdoor seating to switch up the vibe. Yeaaa you can't miss coming here. The staff here are super friendly and honestly one of the things I appreciated most is that they leave you alone! I didn't feel pressured to give up my seat, or buy more. I was heads down on a project and when I looked up hours later the barista was simply there smiling which made me want to get something else lol I also came for there open mic night and wow packed house! Great live music . What a gem

I was looking for a local coffee shop while in town and found my way to My Town's Cafe. Upon…read moreentering, I was immediately greeted by the cashier and other staff. The shop itself was nicely laid out with places for customers to relax and/or work while enjoying their beverage (and possibly dessert). There were ample tables and seating choices for customers to choose from depending on their needs. My Town's Cafe had a lot of beverages and pastries to offer. I was a little overwhelmed, but was just as happy to see variety. The drink menus that I immediately saw were mainly the specials and baristas' recommendations. I didn't see a regular menu without all of the fancy drinks until after I had paid as they were laminated and lying along the counter. I was a little bummed because there weren't any prices written for the speciality drink items and I really didn't NEED to have a fancy drink that cost almost $7. With that said, I tried one of their Spring Specials, the Biscoff Bliss Latte. It was a little sweet, but the hints of Biscoff, Nutella, and cookie butter were prominent. I also ordered a piece of bread pudding upon recommendation from the staff. It had the potential to be really good, but it definitely tasted as if it had been in their cooler for several days. I usually love visiting local coffee spots, but My Town's Cafe missed the mark for me. Perhaps I came in on an off day for them.