Burgers were perfectly cooked, pink as ordered. Waitress was beyond amazing! Bar drinks were…read moreawesome! Most diverse menu I have seen in 25 years. Not the same ol same ol thank god! Thanks for thinking outside the box! Can't wait to go back! A+

Gave this a try with family not too long ago. Convenient parking, easy entry and a clean appearance…read moremake for a nice introduction. A full bar, solidly poured drinks and accommodating servers allow you to settle in. A menu with enough choices to satisfy everyone. Our group mostly ordered the smoked chicken wing special. Large, well prepared wings were appreciated by everyone in our party. I added an order of twice baked potato skins. Not only were they fantastic, they were huge. My side became a shareable for the table. We finished up with some dessert drinks. They were great and put the exclamation point on our visit. Definitely consider this place when you are hungry and in the area!

Cassie did a great job!! Icy cold beverages and cheese curds where amazing!!! Boneless wings and…read morebuffalo chicken wrap..... highly recommend!!

Very nice bar. Our waitress, Paige, was really nice. Quality good. There were 4 guys and 2 of them…read morehad the hamburgers and they were good. The poppers and fried pickles were great! Nice people

We have been coming to this place for 20 years and it has gone through a few owners in that time…read more Some have been good some not so much, but it's always been a popular spot right on the water with a great atmosphere, decent drinks, and varying quality of food. Visited for dinner 3x this year and the new owners seem to have focused on the food being better. Gone twice for Friday night fish fry and the quality of the fish has been a pleasant surprise. I distinctly remember last year coming in later in the evening for a fish fry and getting a baked potato that was a dried out relic. Ordered one this year and it was fresh and hot. Little things like that make a big difference. Fish seems to be hand breaded and they also offered a broiled option which comes with delicious garlic butter to dip it in. You can get soup and salad bar and the soup is always good although the salad bar can be a bit picked over if you come in later like we tend to... My dad has ordered the drunken captain chicken twice and raves about it. Even the picky eaters in our family are content going there. We had the same waitress on a couple trips and she is so friendly and attentive you never have an empty drink. I would say my only complaint is the old fashioned. They are so small you take a couple sips and it's empty. Bigger Glasses! Overall it seems like they are intent on moving this place in the right direction. It used to be the top spot in town and hopefully it is again! Lots of things to do...pool tables, video games, and they always seem to have music, trivia, karaoke or something going on. We haven't hung out in the tiki bar yet this year I'll leave that for the next review...

So, iv been to this bar once and there was nothing special about it, thats not all , service seemed…read moreto take awhile and they couldn't care about you. Iv been doing some recent reading into this business and found out that they treat their staff very very badly, especially this most recent case with someone who had diabetes. Dont go here!! Dont support this business who treats employees like trash! Gilligans inside is just a dump to be in as wel. The food, more worth it to go to McDonald's.

Very good service; fish sandwich was dry ( overcooked?); shrimp tacos were good but could have used…read moremore pico or side of sauce. Prices moderately high. Nice atmosphere. (Definitely better than FireAway...which doesn't take much, given how bad they are!)

What a disappointment. Food is terrible and prices are rediculous. One star and that is for the…read moreview only.

Good sandwiches. I order thru door dash quite often and the order is usually accurate. I like the…read moretuna although portions on sandwiches are getting pretty skimpy. Friendly and good service.

Terrible service I watched a Laday come in and freak out because here online order was an hour…read more and 10 minutes late

This was my first fish fry and I have thought about it countless times since. I may be biased…read morebecause it's the only fish fry I've ever been to or experienced but I'm already thinking about coming back. We did have to wait about an hour. But we got delicious cocktails while we waited. A lot of other families who were waiting were smart and brought games with them. It was so worth the wait. Every single food item was delicious. The staff was friendly. The atmosphere was electric and so community oriented. Like I said, I can't wait to go back!

I am so sad to write this review. This used to be my favorite meal of the year. We've been going…read morefor over 20 years and we were happy to wait 2 hours, but last night we learned how a new owner can take a rare gem and run it to the ground. 1.We were seated and ordered drinks & fish. They said they were out of broiled fish. My daughter ordered spaghetti and then they came back and said they were out. We jokingly Asked who do we have to fight for the last spaghetti and the owner turned around and said me and I'm not making anymore. I couldn't believe his rudeness. A simple I'm So Sorry we are out would have been acceptable. 2.Our drinks never came then the fish basket came without our drinks or the cole slaw or fry bread that is always served as an appetizer. 3. We asked a 2nd time for drinks and the alcohol arrived but not the other drinks. I saw the waitress just standing talking to other employees so I went to the bar and got our own drinks 4. Baked potatoes never came. 5. The fish used to be big and flaky and so delicious. This time it was small, overcooked and 1 per person. We asked for more and they brought some bite sized pieces back with more chicken because they ran out BUT then we saw them deliver fish to a table of employees. 6. Our bill came with the spaghetti still on it 7. The waitress never checked on us and the owner scowled at us everytime he walked by. 8. Last straw, we were leaving and my daughter used the restroom to find no toilet paper and then no soap!!! We are heartbroken! She We will never be back nor recommend it like we have for 20 years.

We have been coming here for 25 years and they continue to improve year after year. The service and…read morefood are top notch. The ultimate Wisconsin supper club! Try the chicken dinner that was recently put back on the menu. You won't be disappointed.

We had an excellent 1st dinner about a month ago. Called ahead to ask to about eating on the deck…read morewith a dog. All seem great, the hostess even came out with water for all...then we sat while other got served. No acknowledgment, so we left after 30 minutes...too bad great food and ambiance

Our meal was delicious! Our service was friendly and attentive. I would go back again!…read more Not pictured: We had the French onion soup (highly recommend!), the minestrone soup, and the cheese curds.

Solid, old school supper club. So much food for a fair price. Service was great. Food was good.read more

Kincaid's has a nice salad bar for the area (two soups, rolls, cold pasta salads, lettuce and…read moretoppings for salad, along with cold dressings and hot bacon dressing). The only thing odd was that the clam chowder was spicy - - I had my husband taste it in case my taste buds were tricking me, but he thought maybe they put tabasco in it?? The chicken alfredo is something we would not order again. The queen cut of prime rib was much larger than we anticipated and it was well-seasoned and tender. It's also really nice that they serve prime rib nightly, instead of other places that only offer it on Saturday nights. Our waitress was good through us getting our food and then disappeared; it took forever for us to get our bill and a to-go box so we could hit the road and move on with our night.

We got there during the dinner rush and waited to be seated at a table at the bar. The bartender…read morewas lovely and wonderful, after waiting about fifteen minutes we were escorted to a table. Our waitress (who ended up being the owner) sat us and we told her we'd like some water. After waiting another twenty minutes the rest of our party arrived and sat down. After waiting about ten minute we all went to the bar to see if we could coast get water. I saw our waitress and asked the bartender to direct her to our table. She came shortly after and took our order. We all ordered and another person in our party asked for water. My boyfriend then asked for extra tarter and lemon which never came with his food, my friend never got her water. We wouldn't have gotten drinks if we would t have gone to the bar ourselves to get them. Our food arrives and my prime was completely rare I sent it back and when it returned it looked microwaved and was 1000% well done. Zero pink in it all all. While my friends ate their food I ate my salad bar and auggies waiting for our waitress (who is the owner!!!!) but she was nowhere to be found. She finally came back and my firmed asked for her bill and I told her to please take my prime off of the bill because I hadn't taken a single bite of my microwaved overdone food. She said okay and walked away. After waiting another ten minutes my friends went yo the bar to look for a to go box for his food at the bar instead of waiting even longer for her. When she finally came back she refused to take the prime off, I offered to pay for the salad bar and potatoes I ate. She still refused and told us she was the owner and we didn't know what we were talking about and that we should just stay home insisted of coming back. GLADLY. If I could give zero stars I would.

I put in and order over 2 hours ago for a certain time, and when I got there, they still didn't…read morehave it ready. And it's been over half an hour, and it still isn't ready worst possible place ever to eat & they never have enough staff.

Very good cheeseburger was very fresh. Service was ok. The staff were all carrying phones in their…read morehands. Not good for cleanliness. No rules about phones while working?