I'll give Holt's 2 stars because there are both the good's and the bad's. Aren't there always?
First the good's. Great location in relation to the ATV trails, the Trading Post at Taylor Reservoir and the Marina as well as Cottonwood Pass. Cabins are rustic and meant for temporary lodging only while hitting the trails. Great views of the mountains and easy to get in and out.
Now the bad's and I will be very honest knowing the place is a bit old. First, the floors are very dangerous. Our unit was covered with an old wall to wall carpet which was fine but the wooden flooring underneath was sagging and rotten in places to the point where I felt my foot was going to go straight through the floor. A piece of plywood covered one hole directly in front of the refrigerator, which prevented the refrigerator door from opening more than halfway. Second, there was only a single electrical outlet in the unit near the kitchen sink. Would definitely be nicer to have at least two. Third, there was a single overhead light in the "living room" which is fine, but it was an exposed bulb, which drenched the room in a very harsh light. Would be nice to have a simple shade of some sort to cut down the glare. Fourth, the oven did not work. I could get the unit to light but first had to remove the bottom plate covering the burner and light it manually. Worked fine for a few minutes, but the flame slowly died to nearly nothing to where it couldn't be used at all. I was told by my neighbor that the unit was supposed to get a new oven a week earlier...but never did. Very frustrating! Fifth, the heater never worked at all and there was no thermostat to control it. I actually had to keep one of the stove burners lit all night long to heat the place. Sixth, the window sills were filthy and covered with dead bugs.
Although the price is reasonable, what's not is the expectation to pay a good price with the existing problems. Although I could live with some of the issues what I could not accept is dangerous flooring and non-functioning heater or oven. What bugs me the most is that the owners must have known about these problems before we made our reservations and checked in. Borderline fraud in my opinion.
In summary, the bad's outweighed the good's considering there are other lodging options nearby. The place needs some serious TLC but my guess it would take a near complete rebuild of my unit to bring it back up to acceptable standards. Maybe other units were in better shape but if they are like mine, then I would not stay here again. I was told by the clerk in the Trading Post that the place was for sale which explains why the units (mine at least) was not being maintained. read more