If you're a BBQ chicken pizza or Philly cheesesteak kind of person, you CAN NOT go wrong here. If it is hot, it's for YOU! Holy smokes. Best I've had in this area. I will keep ordering for delivery read more

Cream of crab No crabmeat Salty, too much old bay and they left whole bay leaves in my cup. Greek salad was mostly just lettuce Avoid read more

Affordable delicious pizza! What more could you ask for?! They're quick and a great value

Always amazing food!! Great service and Top is great to deal with when we needed a large # of pizzas for a pool event!

Based on my first experience I have to start this carry out spot with 4 stars. Hilltop is in the location where Spyro's used to be. The employees there are extremely friendly and offered suggestions on their menu. They allow you to order your wings with 2 flavors. I ordered half Lemon Pepper and half Old Bay wing. I also ordered a sign of mango habanero. As you can see by my pIcture, the wings are a nice golden brown and they are seasoned very well. The mango habanero was sweet and spicy! It was a great mixture of the two.. It is not always easy to find a cart out spot with good flavored wings. My first visit here was a good experience! read more

See all

Stumbled upon this place and what a gem! Wings were great! They have so many flavors/sauces to pick from. I also ordered cheese bread sticks, mozzarella sticks, garlic bread with cheese and old bay fries. Everything was well seasoned! read more

See all

The salads are delicious and very large. The subs and soup are very good. This is a go to place for us when we want something good and quick. read more

We placed a delivery order at 4:30 p.m. on 10/4/25. Their online order process is very specific, where you can check things that you want to add on your sub, even though they state they come with certain things. I ordered a chicken filet with just cheese; none of the other boxes were checked (I've done this many times). There were six items in the order, and it arrived at 5:20 p.m. The chicken filet had lettuce, tomato, mayo and onions, even though these boxes were not checked. I called, and the person who answered argued with me that those things come on the sandwich. I told her that none of the boxes were checked. Long story short, they said they would send another sandwich and that it would arrive quickly. The replacement arrived at 6:40. This was my daughter's birthday dinner (her request), and it was her sandwich that was wrong. We've ordered from Hilltop on a weekly basis for the last couple of years, but this has completely turned us off to them, and they will no longer get our business. read more

My family and I have been frequent, loyal customers of this shop for quite some time now. The last time we ordered, it was extremely late and cold. I reach out and they gave a small monetary reimbursement that I did not feel was enough at that time, but trying to give them the benefit of the doubt. We placed another order tonight and the same result; late and cold. Again, reached out and given $5 refund. This was completely unacceptable for the quality being provided. I am assuming they have began stacking orders and have completely forgotten customer service. This issue should have been remedied the first time. We will no longer be customers. read more

I love their pizza period, I go past at least 4 other pizza spots to get to them. They also have this cheese cake that is amazing! Prices are good also, comparable to other spots. read more

I specifically showed the guy, Cheesesteak, Fried onions, green peppers, american cheese, mayo. Got a dry cheesesteak. no nothing. no pepps, no chesses, no onions, no mayo. waited 20 mins while he made it. this was at 10 am, nobody else there. Nope, you got 1 chance to get it right, wont be back. read more

The pizza was awesome and we're from Chicago. We also had the Italian sun and the roast beef sub. I highly recommend all of their food! Can't wait to order from them again! read more

Good food, made as requested and on time delivery! Nothing was wrong with my order and I made an order late, right before they closed.

I have to say that I was a bit disappointed with this meal choice. Looks can be deceiving! Backstory: I had the biggest taste for a fish sandwich and contemplated going from McDonald's to a random far out sub shop for one. That's when I remembered Hilltop was near my home. My family raved about their sandwiches in the past, so I thought I'd try them out. Here's the spin, though: I wanted a fish sub with fried shrimp included. I didn't know if they could even do this & I was worried about how much they would've up-charged me if I asked. So, I called and ordered a half fish sub and a jumbo shrimp box (came with French fries). It took about 20 minutes or so before my order was ready. The restaurant definitely takes all measures to ensure the safety of patrons. The cashier was very nice, which is always a plus. My order came to $21 and change, $25 and change, including tip. I headed home and immediately prepared to eat. The sub container was hassle free and nestled the sandwich perfectly. The fish sub looked very good. The shredded lettuce was fresh and perfect, the fish itself looked good. I opened the shrimp box, and I believe it came with 8 butterfly shrimp. The shrimp were of the frozen variety. Nothing to write home about. The flavor was definitely lacking, but I overlooked that part because I knew I was going to put the shrimp in my sandwich. I placed the shrimp between the bread for what looked like an epic fried seafood sub sandwich creation. But then...I tried the fries. They were pretty awful. I usually eat all my food because I simply like food and I don't like to waste, but they were bad. Salt, pepper, and ketchup could not save them. They were not fresh at all. They tasted like they fried stale fries that had been sitting all day. They were hard, yet spongy. Warm, yet kinda cold. In the pictures included, you can see that I barely ate them. The sandwich itself was pretty filling. While it had a good taste, I got full pretty fast and realized I could done without the boxed/frozen shrimps. I would definitely go back for the fish sandwich by itself. All in all, I'd give everything a solid 6 1/2. read more

See all

Huge menu makes for never-ending options. This is great for when everyone in the family wants something different. It'd be nearly impossible to try everything... but I'm trying my hardest And everything I've tried e far has been excellent. Large portions, fresh ingredients, cooked perfectly. The only problem is long wait times at peak hours. read more

Nice staff. Real local feel and seemed busy with pizza orders. My food was ready on time. However the fries smelled funny - maybe the oil hadn't been changed recently? Perhaps stick to pizza to get the best experience here. read more

Tried this place after people raced about it on a Facebook group. Everything was delicious! My wife and I got a large bacon pizza, cheesesteak sub and fries to split. Cheesesteak was good, wasn't the best ever but also far from the worst. The pizza and fries were AMAZING! We already plan to order from here again! read more

Hilltop Pizza & Subs - Cheesesteak Sub - Pizza Near Me - Nottingham, Maryland

See all

Wow! The chicken wrap and lamb gyro is the best!!! We will definitely order in this place again! Lots of food selections! Do you offer catering??? read more

I'd like to leave a better review but we ordered from here through the Slice App and put in some special instructions which were ignored. The food was good but don't expect to get it the way you ask. read more

Hilltop and Pauly's Pizza used to have the best food in the Perry Hall/White Marsh area. It has always been hard to find good pizza, chesse steaks and especially wings in this area. Hilltop used to have good wings. i ordered 10 buffalo wings and 10 old bay wings tonight (12/23/23) however and they were literally the smallest, worst wings ive ever had. i dont knoq if they changed owners or just started trying to save pennies but ive never been more dissappointed. i actuallt had to order more wings from Pauly's. guess im down to one place now i can order from in this area read more

Second time I've ordered from the recently, Italian cold cut and quesadilla were great. read more

Hilltop Pizza & Subs - Chicken Quesadilla - Pizza Near Me - Nottingham, Maryland

See all

The website for online ordering is not accurate. The item does say boneless wings but they put a picture of bone-in wings so I was confused. There also was not an option for normal wings so I figured they just made a typo, and I was ordering bone-in. When I went in to talk to them about this, the man at the register seemed disinterested and seemed like he didn't even know what he was talking about. I was very disappointed to open my bag and see that I payed almost $10 for Tyson chicken nuggets with bbq sauce just squirted on top, they weren't even tossed in the sauce. The cheese fries were okay at best, and the Buffalo boneless wings weren't that good. Between the false advertisement and the poor customer service I would not recommend this place at all. read more

Hilltop Pizza & Subs - Bbq wings - Pizza Near Me - Nottingham, Maryland

You know if your a business owner you need to follow up with customers. I got a delivery and the food was hard and cold. Guy said I would get a refund but never followed up with it. I will not ever order from Hilltop again. Bad Business practices. read more

This pizza shops pizza is nothing to write home about, but their subs...my god, their subs are great. My favorites are the cheese steak and the shrimp salad sub. Their motz sticks and fried mushroom are also decent - better than usual greasy sub shops. read more

So happy we decided to try a new place tonight. Got the 2 sub special with fries and sodas for $18.99. The cheesesteak subs were so good and neither of us could finish all our fries. I also picked up a cheese pizza for the kids, my daughter said it was the best pizza crust she's ever had. Staff was very nice!! Online ordering made it easy. I'll be using Hilltop as our regular place from now on! read more

I was curious to see just how awesome the pizza would be given all the rave reviews...and I have to admit that I was not a fan. The pizza was average at best. But, the cream of crab soup was stellar! I'll give it another chance and try a sub next time... read more

This is a solid neighborhood pizza and sub shop. However, it doesn't rise to the 4 or 5 star level in any way. I've eaten here three or four times over the last five months. The cheesesteak sub is pretty good. For Italian cold cut subs, keep driving a few blocks. I ordered a fish sandwich and it is a swing and a miss. Frozen fish patty on a store bought kaiser roll is not worth the effort. They need to get some fresh cod or haddock to beer batter and fry, then they'll have something. The should also consider baking the rolls, store bought rolls are not worth a darn. Also, lettuce shouldn't be shredded to the consistency of confetti. There is potential here at Hilltop, they just need to add a pinch of passion. read more

Didn't know this place existed until searching for delivery during this pandemic a week or so ago. Thought I'd give them a try. So glad I did! Ordered a small meatlover's pizza minus bacon plus onion. A little extra sauce (I know...picky!). They made it exactly right and it was delicious! Great sauce, plentiful toppings. I hope they stay consistant, they will be my new fav in the area! Also, delivery person was wearing a mask and gloves...cudos! read more

Hill top was recommended to me by a friend and I finally gave it a shot tonight. I waited a little longer than I would have liked but the food was absolutely amazing! I had a cheesesteak sub and it was more than filling. The wings where fresh and probably the best I've every had. Will be back if I'm in the area. read more

The absolute best carry out and delivery place in Perry Hall. The food is amazing, the portions are enough for dinner and left overs, and the prices are outstanding. So happy we found Hilltop. read more

Best spot. Had really good pizza and wings. I'd definitely return. The wings were great too

Always great service!! I love Hilltop Perry hall. I always place my order over the phone and I've never had any issues. After you pay, they ask you to sit back in your car and they will bring the food out to you. Highly recommended read more

They killed it. They showed up faster then I thought they would. Clean, delicious and efficient

I ordered the garden salad and the chicken cheesesteak. The cheesesteak was quite large and excellent. The sub roll is crispy on the outside but soft on the inside and it was packed with meat. Salads are usually just blah but this was a large portion size and the croutons were great! I will definitely be ordering from here again soon. Great food!! read more

Look like this place needed a review so I decided to review the is place. So the website looks super clean.

I ordered from here and was very dissatisfied. My order consisted of two fish sub combo and they were just one piece of fish broken in half to make a sub. The French fries was the best thing from my order and that's why I gave it two stars. I also ordered HOMEMADE ICED TEA but was given a bottle instead. This was my first time and definitely my last time from ordering fro this place read more

Just moved here and have been trying to find a good pizza place. Hilltop is the best! Pizza was so cheesy and so good!

Just didn't care too much for anything but the fries were ok. I do like that everything with the place was clean.