This delicious Pizzaria is OPEN FOR BUSINESS. Perfect " stop by" for an exceptional taste of Italy. You may wonder where the grandmother is adding secret ingredients. A "MUST TRY" SUPPORT LOCAL read more

See all

I got the cheese pizza, and it was really fresh. I liked it a lot. The people are super nice, service is quick, and the location's on the west side of Manhattan in Midtown, so it's very nice. It's open almost right now. It's like a small space with maybe five people here, but you don't feel crowded because this place usually isn't in walking distance, so you get undivided attention when you're served in person. My slice came to $3.50, which was pretty good for how big it was--like, it was a pretty good NY slice, and the flavor was really pronounced. I really liked the cheese, and the sauce was good too. read more

Highline Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

If you're hungry and you want some pizza, this is a good option. I really liked my cheese slice and it had a good flavor. I think it's best to eat it there. Once it gets cold it's not as good. read more

Highline Pizzeria - Inside - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Got the chicken bacon slice and the flavor and crust were on point. Little more bacon leaning than chicken but the crust was so crunchy and perfect. I thought that this slice was going to have a white sauce but I don't think it had a sauce at all because it was pretty dry. read more

Highline Pizzeria - Chicken Bacon Slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Crunchy crust. Light on sauce. Newly reopened with a full menu and cold drinks. Right off the High Line. 4 stools to stay and eat. read more

See all

If you're hungry and it's late, this will not disappoint. Got the pepperoni slice, broccoli and chicken slice, and a spinach artichoke roll. The crust was perfectly crisp and flavored well. They were delicious! The staff were friendly and the place was clean. read more

Highline Pizzeria - Spinach artichoke Roll - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

While staff is nice and welcoming, the pizzas carries a serious emotional baggage. Nothing radiates more exhaustion than these pizzas :/ Bummer. read more

I did not try the pizza here but the Garlic knots were mini but tasty! The staff working here were nice and friendly. This pizza shop is very small but when you walk in the smell of pizza just is soo good! If you are in the area I would stop in for a slice! read more

See all

We came here after seeing Sleep No More and needed some food and needed it fast! We ordered pepperoni, cheese and meat lovers. I enjoyed the pepperoni pizza! The sauce wasn't sweet, which I liked. Pepperonis were those normal sized ones but still good. I needed the salt after the work out at Sleep No More. There's some front seating to enjoy the pizza. read more

Highline Pizzeria - Pizzas - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This place is amazing and as of May 12, 2025, this place is very much open. I don't think yelp has updated this site yet, but it is open thank God for people who live in the area because their pizza is heavenly read more

Tried this place over the weekend, it was one of the best slices I have ever had in NYC... a must go to if you are visiting NYC!! The staff was so pleasant as well!! read more

Pretty good pizza, especially for this part of town where pizza parlors are scarce. About $5 on average per slice. Cheese is on par with Joe's, I think. But the chicken parm was pretty damn good. Love the crispy crust from the 're-bake'. And they have some seats out front (none inside). read more

See all

Solid pizza choice near the high line! We tried a selection: white pizza, pepperoni roll, grandma pizza, and plain. Not the most amazing pizza in my entire life, but everything was very solid. Staff was very friendly and food came up quickly. There were a handful of seats and a small counter outside where we ate. If you're in the area, not a bad stop if you're craving some pizza! read more

I needed a snack one day when I was in the area and grabbed a slice here at Highline. The place is super tiny and cramped, so don't expect to sit down and enjoy a relaxing time. I'd strictly expect to get your slices to go at this pizza joint. I did enjoy seeing painted art along the edges of the walls calling back to the nearby Highline. I ordered a slice with mushrooms on it. Service was good. The guys behind the counter took my order quickly and they had the slice in the oven in moments. I paid, grabbed my slice and headed out. The slice was good. A solid B-, but nothing extraordinary. I wouldn't go out of my way to go there but if I was in the area I wouldn't mind grabbing a slice here either. read more

the nicest staff ever! so good and great service! would come back again over and over

Excellent food and even though there wasn't a place to sit inside, they had a place outside and it was fabulous! My cheese pizza was definitely worth the walk from Penn Station and we will be going back! read more

Highline Pizzeria - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

While attending Scentxplore on West 28th Street where we weren't allowed to bring anything to eat and drink I had spotted this pizzeria. I came here as I was famished. Unfortunately the pizzas didn't look appealing as the crusts looked leaden. I opted for the empanadas. A mistake as the chicken one was dry and so was the ham and cheese. I threw half away. $8+change. Waste of money. On top of this they couldn't give me a cup of water that the majority of pizzerias willingly give with a smile. This pizzeria is small with a counter where two people were sitting. I stood opposite the area where the pizzas were being made as it was drizzling and eating in the rain is not a pleasure. I will not be returning. read more

See all

Gluten free pizza not good :( Disappointed with the crust. The sauce and cheese were delish. read more

We stopped by here before going to the show Sleep No More, and funnily enough the pizzeria had a mask from the show on their walls. I'm guessing this is a popular spot for folks going to the show! We ordered two slices: one slice of Chicken Cutlet and Broccoli Pizza, and one slice of Pepperoni Sausage Pizza which were both super meaty and satisfying!! The heating of pizza was super quick, and the crust gives you that satisfying crunch. Seating is fairly limited but was a great spot to grab a quick meal on the go. We also bought a bottle of water which was quite decent at $1 / bottle considering prices at other places. read more

Highline Pizzeria - Chicken Cutlet and Broccoli Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

do not eat or order food from here apparently they like to give old expired food to paying customers

DO NOT SLEEP on highline pizzeria! I totally expected this to be "mid" and after ordering a grandma slice I was ready to get a highline pizzeria logo tattooed on my forearm. A small line at 1 am on a Saturday but with it, the crust is amazing, the sauce incredible, AND they have hot sauce, honey, and ranch close by. Definitely coming back! Great stop after a show at the The McKittrick Hotel. read more

Highline Pizzeria - Grandma slice yummmmm - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Pizza used to be good here. Must be new owners the pizza is not even edible. Crust was rock hard. $1 slice spots serve better pizza. You have been warned read more

Highline Pizzeria services hot delicious pizza, Staff is busy, yet friendly. The Highline is my favorite place in NYC, Pizzeria is a great high-light! read more

This was my second time having pizza on this week trip right after the boat then the edge this was a perfect slice had the buffalo and white pizza 10/10 100/100 1000/1000 read more

Highline Pizzeria - Outside - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The best of the best in NYC. Don't walk run. I've been to many pizza places in NY, this one is delish. Scott is back. He's the best.

Mean little takeout operation. Top tier plain slice, not too elaborate l, good sauce and cheese. All the chicken options from Buffalo to parm hit. Had a good chicken parm sando from here too. Discovered this spot one night stumbling towards my car now it's a regular lunch spot. Classic NYC slice spot for real. read more

Amazing pizza! Must stop. Try their granma pizza. Super yum. Fast pizza!!! Exactly what you want if visiting New York!! read more

Highline Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Food was good. People working were not. So incredibly rude- there's 100 pizza places. Why go to one with rude staff? read more

Stopped in today while I made a quick trip into the city. Fantastic pizza!!! Done to perfection!!

Scott is BACK Baby!!! I love his pizza, Pure NYC Pizza Pie! nothing better. Scott's personality makes grabbing a coke and a slice a real Pleasure. Love it read more

The workers there are super friendly and it was open by the time me and my friend left the club so it was perfect for a late night snack. The pizza was okay but nothing special, pretty standard read more

Highline Pizzeria - Chicken Cutlet Parmesan Pie - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Quick, tasty, easy to buy, nice staff, added my favorite extra sauce, fresh cheese, light crust, and just enough but not too much bread on bottom with that chewy and light texture dough. It was an excellent and fast 5 minute dinner for a great deal at $3.27 and you can use credit card for that amount. Thank you Highline Pizzeria for making my life easier. And making really good NY style pizza that only some NYC pizza places do well. read more

Highline Pizzeria - The storefront - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Small little hole-in-the-wall walk-in pizza shop near the Hudson Yards. This establishment is meant to get your pizza and take it with you. They offer several different flavors. I got the chicken bacon ranch. It was really good! We got three slices to try. All of which I would recommend. They were really nice. There are a few small chairs along a tiny bar style table outside the restaurant. We ended up taking it down the road a bit and found a place to sit and enjoy them. read more

Great atmosphere and even better pizza! Loved every bite--definitely coming back soon.

Ordered a pepperoni pizza and it was great. The crust was awesome. Definitely authentic NY pizza.

The cheese Sicilian cheese pizza square was a huge, greasy cube with a massive layer of. cheese. I will say this was convenient after a trip to high line. There is some seating outside. read more

Small so there is very little space to eat inside. There were 5 of us so we had to eat outside in the cold. They have a few seats outside, which helps. The pizza was much better than I expected. Five of us ordered 5 different types of pizza and all 5 of us gave the pizza a thumbs up. Five thumbs up! Just don't count on eating inside or being comfortable if you do. read more

Highline Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Just close the doors. tried this place 3 times in a 1 month span and today was the last straw. Although the flies were free i did not appreciate having them fly out at me when i opened the box.after they were able to chow down on my slices for the 2 block walk. The Good: its 2 blocks from my office The Bad: this is NYC and your pizza tastes terrible. The Sicilian is a bunch of puffed up dough with a dab of sauce and fake hard cheese on top. the regular slice is undercooked dough that separates from everything else. That's still not the worst of it. You're an old style pizza place. if you advertise a slice for $3.50 i should be able to walk in there and put down $3.50 and walk out with a slice. Not the case. They actually nickel and dime you and charge you tax. also, while they were waiting for the flies to get comfortable on my slices i had a chance to look around and my god that place is filthy, everything is dirty, the employees even had dirty uniforms right after opening. the air filter above the oven tells the whole story. but now at least there are 2 less flies there. should be ashamed of yourselves read more

Yelpers don't be fooled by the "4 stars" you see on this joint. I came here yesterday for the first time to try Highline Pizza and it was a huge disappointment to say the least. My husband ordered 2 slices of the BBQ chicken and I ordered the only pizza that looked like it was the freshest (the grandma). As soon as I opened the box to check out the 3 slices I could clearly see that it just didn't look right. I don't know what the heck these guys are doing or not doing with the pizzas, but this pizza was not made that day. I decided to tasted the Grandma slice anyway and it wasn't that bad compared to the other 2 slices my husband ordered. We both one-hundred percent agreed that this pizza couldn't possibly be fresh and was probably one of the worst pizzas we've ever had. Seriously this is not an exaggeration. For my husband to say that he wouldn't bother eating these slices right after we paid $14 bucks is totally unheard of. We ended up tossing out 2 of the slices of the BBQ pizza and shared the 1 slice of grandma. After this pizza fiasco we ended up walking to another pizza joint that's totally legit when it comes to the freshness of their pizza. Coming to Highline Pizza was a complete waste of time and money and I won't be doing that again. read more

Highline Pizzeria - Ended up throwing away 2 of the 3 slices I got because it tasted really really bad. There is no freaking way this is fresh pizza! - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Solid 4! Great hole in the wall and ready for pick up slices of pizza it is right below the high line so we bought ourselves a slice of pepperoni and sausage pizza and headed up to the highline. We found a bench to sit on, ate our delicious pizza and people watched. It was a great experience. Back to the pizza, the pizza crust was crispy yet soft, the pizza had a good amount of grease and toppings and it was quite big in size for $4.50. Yumm after writing this review it makes me want another slice hahah read more

Highline Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York