Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Hidden Cave Cidery

    4.9 (16 reviews)
    Closed Closed
    Updated 2 months ago

    Hidden Cave Cidery Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Hidden Cave Cidery

    Recommended Reviews - Hidden Cave Cidery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Bar area
    Sara E.

    This hidden little gem is worth a visit. They offer unique ciders and a few snacks. It's located in the industrial area of Middleton but when you walk in you feel transformed to a cozy and relaxing setting. My friend and I each ordered a flight so that we could try them all. The ciders offer crisp and refreshing flavors and the staff are super friendly. We also tried the chocolate made by a local Madisonian and the cheeseboard looked delicious.

    A flight with some classics and some specials. The framboise was my fave
    Steph B.

    What a lovely spot! The ciders are delicious and unique, the staff super kind and helpful and the cheese board is also really good and filling. Definitely recommend! And pro tip, try any new blends they have! It's definitely off the beaten path but worth the find!

    Entrance
    Allison G.

    Hidden Cave Cidery certainly is hidden! It's located in a strip mall in Middleton across from the ice rink. It has its own parking lot so it's fairly easy to find parking. They just opened back in June so they are still in the process of renovating and decorating. When you walk in, it seems like the business is not open but as you keep walking through the building you'll see the tap room located in the back. The tap room has all sorts of cider decor and has the doorway to a nice patio. I can't wait to see what the place looks like when it's complete! My husband and I ordered a Cider flight, a glass of the hibiscus, and a glass of the honeysuckle French toast. They were all good but my favorite was by far the French toast. You HAVE to try this cider, especially during the fall. In the words of Ryan Reynolds, it's like fall in a cup! We sat outside on the patio and enjoyed live music while we drank our cider. The band, 2 Hat Champ, was played some great funk music which really added to the experience. They also had Roman Candle pizza available for purchase. I can't wait to go back for the Honeysuckle French Toast and to try some new ciders!!

    Hanna G.

    We loved the laid back atmosphere of this cidery. All the ciders were unique and delicious! We each did a flight and a cheese board. We will definitely be back!

    menu
    Allison H.

    As the name implies, this place is definitely hidden. They opened their patio this summer and have a few picnic tables and high top tables (ps the patio is dog friendly). Our group got a few flights to try all of their draft ciders and agreed that the lemongrass lavender cider is the best one of them all. They mentioned they are undergoing renovations indoors and hope to have a tasting room set up by November. Their menu seems to rotate based on what's available. Overall, I had a good time, and I'll be back in the fall to see what new flavors they come up with.

    Amanda R.

    WHAT A HIDDEN GEM! In town visiting family over the 4th of July weekend. Needed to kill some time and looked for a cider place - viola! This place is off the beaten path, however, there was a steady flow of people on Saturday afternoon. We tried a couple of flights and they were all pretty great. Table favorite was the French Toast and Pina Colada.

    Hard cider flight and charcuterie board

    See all

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Amanda R.
    0
    109
    89

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Mark W.
    57
    90
    15

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Ben M.
    6
    19
    0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Always a great variety of unique flavors. Enjoyed everything I've tried here. Definitely recommend visiting.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Hidden Cave Cidery

    Do you have dog friendly indoor seating?

    Hey, yes we do!

    Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

    Review Highlights - Hidden Cave Cidery

    Every cider I've had has been delicious, and I've heard they're going to have gluten-free beer on tap soon.

    Mentioned in 6 reviews

    Read more highlights

    Orchard - Pecan pie in a skillet. No crust

    Orchard

    (26 reviews)

    Orchard is a tasteful little spot on Verona, so named because John the owner also owns field full…read moreof apple trees. You get the sliced apples in the salads and the bottles of apple bourbon up front. The hot tea is no charge, but the iced tea is not. Both appear to be Lipton. I got an Arnold Palmer, which was quite good. They didn't mix it so it had a toquilla sunrise feel. The appetizers really stood out. The animal fries were not your squirt cheese in n out style. These were thick cut steak fries, with Wisconsin melted cheese and ground beef, topped with thousand island like aioli. The other wunder starter was the hot pretzel. Thick with kosher salt applied to buttered crust, it's served on a charcuterie board with cheese knife. Perfect for cutting bite sized peices fresh before you dip. Cheese sauce and stone ground mustard. Burgers were good. Sit down restaurant style, thick and perfectly grilled to order. A little gooey but the buns soaked up the juices. Salads come with standard fancy greens, topped with thinly sliced apples, with whole pecans. The vinegrett was decent. Soup that day was country vegetable. We passed at fire because it sounds very Campbell soup from a can. A couple minutes later she came out and said chef made her taste it, so she could adequately rave about it. Turned out to be rave worthy. Not stewed to death, hearty crispy and nutritious

    We checked out Orchard during Restaurant Week for lunch. I ordered a Knife and Fork Caesar Salad…read moreand the Margarita flatbread. The Caesar salad was excellent with super crisp romaine and a fresh house made dressing. I wished that the plate was bigger, as it was loaded very high and hard to not spill. The Margarita flatbread was ok, nothing special. My dining mate tried the Fried Cheese Curd app and a Smashburger with fries for his main. The curds were deliciously crunchy and gooey. Some of the best curds in the area. His Smashburger was good, but the fries were outstanding. We also tried hot cider, since cider is Orchard's claim to fame. The cider was excellent, although a bit pricey at $6.00 a cup. We splurged on some mini-donuts for dessert, but they were just ok. The vibe of Orchard is open and inviting. Our server was excellent, no complaints.

    Drumlin Ridge Winery

    Drumlin Ridge Winery

    (56 reviews)

    $$

    Drumlin Ridge is elegant from the moment you pull into the driveway. You drive up the hill and find…read moreyour parking spot. Then you will enter the winery and go up to the second floor. The inside is lovely and clean. One end has merchandise for sale. And the long bar is where you decide which ones you want to try. Once you've marked them on the menu, they will bring them out to you in a carrier. You can do flights of three, six, or just buy a bottle. Or a taste. The outside is just beautiful. The seating areas, the umbrellas, the view, and the vineyards themselves. I recommend highly you come in summer, spring or fall and sit outside and enjoy your wine like we always do. I know the categories of their wines as dry, but, I found that they were more in the semi sweet side. They're sparkling wine, and the rosé were amazing. The reds were great as well. We ended up tasting six red wine and bought one bottle. They also have charcuterie, boards, and pizza. Go to this winery. You won't be disappointed.

    What a delightful find! We stopped in hoping for an…read moreafternoon of wine on a patio and possibly some food. And they delivered that! It helps that the weather was spectacular! You walk in and go upstairs to the tasting room. There are options for a 3-wine tasting and a 6-wine tasting. We obviously went with the 6...but also because the offering options were numerous and so many in each of our preferred wheelhouses. They pour the wine and give you a glass holder with all of them at once, so you can take it where you want to enjoy your wine, which I really like. The patio was welcoming and the view was wonderful and we enjoyed our initial tasting so much, we opted for ordering food and getting a bit more wine to drink to extend our visit! I got a large pretzel which was...fine. I expected and hoped for something more/better, but it was fine. My friend got a pizza and it was pretty alright as well. I am mostly just pleased and grateful that they have fairly substantial food options to enjoy with your wine. The tasting notes on the wine list are spot on, so pay attention to those! But also, try something new and different! The Almond bubbly was a delightful surprise! And the coffee infused wine was a bold offering. The staff were lovely and friendly, but also weren't too pushy or up in our business. It struck the perfect chord. Highly recommend a visit here if you like trying wines in Wisconsin!

    Geneva Taphouse - Pub pretzels and cheese

    Geneva Taphouse

    (43 reviews)

    $$

    Our group stopped by Geneva Tap House around 6:30pm on Saturday, July 5th for a quick drink before…read moredinner. It's a fun, casual spot with a spacious layout--there's seating on the main level, upstairs, and outside as well. The self-serve, pour-your-own system is a great feature. After a quick check-in with the cashier, you're free to sample and pour what you like. The taps offer a wide variety of options, including beer and wine, which was a pleasant surprise! There was live music playing during our visit, adding a really nice touch to the laid-back atmosphere. They also offer snacks for purchase (paid at the cashier). One suggestion: it would be nice to see more non-alcoholic options besides just soda--maybe a craft NA beer or mocktail for those not drinking (like myself). Overall, it was a quick but enjoyable stop. We'd return again. I also noticed they offer bingo some nights- that's always fun.

    I absolutely LOVE this place! The concept is so great, very different than your usual taphouse or…read morebar. You walk in and get your lanyard and the lowdown. You get to pick your glass and try as many or as few beers or ciders as your heart desires - well, there is a limit on ounces. But, this is such a fun experience. The indoor and outdoor areas are awesome - very spacious and updated. There are a few food options as well and the setup is very seamless. This place is quite efficient and I love it! Can't wait to come back!

    Campo di Bella

    Campo di Bella

    (37 reviews)

    $$

    We had been looking for a local farm-to-table experience when we found Campo di Bella. Our first…read morevisit was a Saturday evening which consisted of a five course meal. Everything about the evening was exceptional. The first course was bruschetta, followed by a refreshing fresh salad with lemon dressing. The main course was flank steak, cooked perfectly. This was followed by a cheese board with delectable cheese samples from local dairies. For dessert, they had an absolutely amazing home made vanilla ice cream. It was rich, creamy, and very tasty. We enjoyed it so much, that we immediately reserved a second dinner which had cider braised pork shoulder as the entree. Again, the meal was exceptional. It started with prosciutto wrapped cantaloupe. I've never had prosciutto sliced so thinly, it was tender and flavorful. This was followed by a butternut squash soup that was thick and rich. I didn't know butternut squash could be so flavorful. I cleaned my bowl so thoroughly that the host jokingly asked if they forgot to serve me. The pork was next. Served with honey crisp apples. It was tender and perfectly juicy. Again, a cheese board was served before dessert. All very tasty local cheeses. For dessert, a French apple tart. I could have eaten a whole tray, it was so good. I've now been there over 20 times. Every time has been exceptional. They offer a variety of wines, ciders, and local beer to go with your meal. They also make their own vermouth which is sweet, with a hint of clove. It's so good, in fact, that we like it on the rocks. Not mixed. The host, Mary Ann, is wonderful. She takes time before each course to provide background on the home grown or locally sourced ingredients. She also gives a history of the farm and her family and, if the season permits, offers a tour of their farm. Marc (Mary Ann's Husband) is the chef. He is a culinary wizard. As I mentioned, I've been back over 20 times, which equates to almost 80 different dishes. All of them amazing! My only criticism (it's a minor one) is that the room is small and cozy and it can get a bit loud inside. It depends on the crowd, but it can be a bit hard to carry a conversation. In summary: exceptional food and exceptional people. I could not recommend it more. Update (12/13/24): We've been coming back to Campo di Bella for the last 5 years. At least 60 times or more and we've never been disappointed. Marc and Mary Ann are incredible hosts that continue to create amazing meals and experiences.

    We had a five course dinner, and each course was delicious. The appetizer was just the right amount…read moreof food to whet the appetite, and was lovely. The second course was gnocchi. The texture of the gnocchi was so very pleasing - little pillows of goodness. The main course of polenta, mushrooms and house-made italian sausage with polenta was hearty and wonderful. As always, the cheese course was very tasty with several lical cheeses I had never before tried. (I look forward to having them again at home . Dessert was divine! I am not usually a fan of chocolate, but this was delicious! At this restaurant, they use local ingredients as much as they can, too. Give Campo a try if you haven't already. You are in for a real treat!

    Hidden Cave Cidery - cideries - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...