Incredible pizza. Cheesy, medium thickness, delicious sauce. The best of north Jersey! Cheesesteaks to die for. Workers are friendly. Delivery guy takes credit or cash. They always overquote the delivery times and arrive earlier which is nice. All around I'd give 6 stars if I could. read more

There was a time when I would've told anybody or even stood outside this pizzeria and screamed at the top of my lungs to come in and try their food. But just recently recently, the two pies for a particular price on Tuesdays that price went up. The quality of Pizza went to ship. I'm gonna safely assume that the father does not run the business anymore and the sons have become extremely greedy because they want a particular lifestyle. Don't take me wrong. The boys that owned the business are nice kids, but not the brightest. I recently made an order of a particular item, and was charged a tremendous amount of money when they fix the order they charge me three more times and put every individual piece in a separate container which I thought was a waste. The only good thing about this "pizzeria", is the Pizza and maybe the smiles when you walk in. Other than that, they could scrap their whole menu. The place is always clean given to the delivery boys that are always wiping down the tables and sweeping the floor floors. So if you order from here, take caution, most of the food that you order from there are frozen and then heated on a flat surface except for the pizza dough. Other than that, you might as well just go to Costco and buy yourself. I'll give two stars only because the pizza dough. read more

If you're in Haledon & in the mood for some quick pizza, this is the spot. They have been here for as long as I can remember. I'm in my 40's. I've Never had a bad experience. They are consistent. It's your basic, standard NJ pizza. It's better than pizza in other states but if you live in NJ/NY than it's nothing to write home about. The prices are fair. The staff is friendly and the restaurant is clean. Check them out if you're in the area. read more

Haledon Pizza - two slices of pizza on a paper plate next to a can of soda - Pizza Near Me - Haledon, New Jersey

See all

It's so good, the pizza is the best food I have ever had. The chicken fries are also very good. The staff is very friendly. The service is also very good. The atmosphere is pretty good. This place is better than any other place I recommend Haledon Pizza. read more

The staff at this pizzeria exemplifies outstanding customer service from start to finish, always with a smile. They prioritize their customers above all else, which is a key ingredient for any successful business. read more

Pizza is the best I've had in a long time. I ordered a white pizza, tomato and garlic. The crust is delicious the pie outstanding. I've also ordered plain. New to the area. Ordered twice very consistent so far. Give it a shot. It's really good pizza. read more

They need a new chief burnt meat this is the 3rd sandwich burnt from them spending 30$ for burnt sandwich thanks read more

Haledon Pizza - Burnt Philly - Pizza Near Me - Haledon, New Jersey

Hands down the best pizza I've ever had - and I've gotten NYC pizza! Whether it's fresh, been sitting around in the box for a while, or reheated in the oven the next day, it's unmatched. And for a great price! I normally get a large plain, extra cheese, or pepperoni pie. The dough is the best part! It's soft but not thin, so the cheese and grease don't make it soggy. Even the crust is soft! I normally eat it as is, but sometimes I shake extra garlic powder on it and it tastes great. I will say though - you probably won't like the pizza here if you prefer crunchy crust but I'm sure you can request it to be extra crispy. *Tip: If you live nearby, it's best to order for takeout because delivery sometimes takes a long time - especially on Fridays and Saturdays (they're closed on Sundays). I'll post pictures next time I order! read more

It is really bad. I did order a pizza with wings and I got it after an hour but it was so salty, i did try to eat it but i couldn't, I tried to call back the restaurant no one's answering. The phone , What am I supposed to do? , please help !!! read more

Haledon Pizza - a box of chicken wings and pizza - Pizza Near Me - Haledon, New Jersey

Best pizza ever! Kid friendly & their Zeppoles are real deal. Great family environment in the store and super clean read more

Great Pizza, great service, fast delivery. I ordered 2 pies and a calzone on a Friday night to be delivered by 6:30pm, they came at exactly 6:30 and everything was hot. The Buffalo Chicken pizza was perfectly done, great crust and flavor not covered in blue cheese like some other places. They deliver to Haledon, Prospect Park and North Haledon. The prices are great compared to some other places nearby, and the quality trumps every other place in North Haledon. read more

Haledon Pizza - Haledon special - Pizza Near Me - Haledon, New Jersey

See all

Oh this fuckin place!!! this is another place that I would literally fight family for, I would stand in the middle of the street with any member of my family and absolutely square up for even half the last slice of one of these pies this fuckin pizza has been consistently great pizza for like 25 fuckin years idk how long this place has been open but I've been having pizza here for at least 15 years and it has absolutely stood the test of time I've seen negative reviews for this place and I can assure you if you think the pizza here is bad you're probably a dick head I can take some shitty service or maybe wrong order or whatever affected your review I get that BUT that being said if you think this is bad pizza you're a dick head and I don't trust you as a person... I posted a picture of my pizza ..look at that fuckin thing look at it tell me that doesn't look amazing I ate the whole fuckin thing in like 17 minutes no exaggeration I the whole pie was gone crust and all in 17 minutes ... I'm not a big person read more

Haledon Pizza - a cheese pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Haledon, New Jersey

Favorite pizza spot ever! My town has millions of pizzerias but once we tried Haledon pizza we are stuck with them lol. Yummy pizza and wings and their delivery comes really quick. I also love how the delivery guys come with an option to pay with card in person so I can leave a proper tip. Awesome read more

Never even got to try the food. They had zero slices out on the display but they had a full cheese pizza not even cut yet I asked them can I just take that whole pizza they said no we need it for slices. Enough said it was my first time there and will definitely be my last. I wanted to buy the pizza and they didn't want to sell it to me I don't know what kind of pizzeria does that. If I had ordered 6 slices then what would they have to say? I actually wonder if they would have told me i have to wait for them to make another pizza or not. Terrible service not very inviting there are plenty of other places nearby that are better which is what I did. I figured I'd give them a try do something different, what a mistake read more

Quality of the food matches the price. Wings too salty for my taste. They are battered or something they aren't normal wings. I also ordered 30 minutes before I came and no one started cooking the food until I got there. read more

Pizza is ok. Not sure why it has high stars. Like I said it is ok. Like most pizza places in this area. One day good; one day ok; one day bad; very inconsistent! Delivery is ok. read more

I literally live 2 miles away and they said it's too far????? How trash is that? After taking my order and we waiting 30 mins ????? Seriously ??? read more

By far the BEST pizza around town! Every time I order from Haledon Pizza it's always quick and easy. Customer service is great! Everyone is friendly and approachable. Delivery has always been fast and friendly. Thank you Haledon Pizza! I have to say they're home made lasagna is AMAZING ! read more

This place has Great pizza, i have been coming to this place since i moved to haledon around 2003. And i love the new renovations.

They are rude and hypocritical. I constantly walk and drive past and see them with their masks down. They don't respect customers. Their food is okay but their customer service is BAD. read more

It's been around since 1998 and this was my first visit to Haledon Pizza. It was 12:30pm on a Saturday. I ordered the large pepperoni pie with extra cheese as I took a seat and waited only 10 minutes. I received friendly service. The place is a bit run down but clean nonetheless. There is no music or television but most orders are to go. There are four tables that seat four each. The pie was actually quite good with a soft crust which I prefer. read more

See all

Called to order at 9:30 pm for pick-up. They explained that the kitchen was closed? Why put that you close at 10pm, if you actually close at 9:30? Laziness is unacceptable to me when it comes to businesses. Other than that, the place is slightly above average. Prices you can't beat. read more

Old school neighborhood pizza shop!! Was getting my hair cut next door took longer than normal so I was late to make dinner for the kids so I picked up 2 pies 2ltr bottle coke and on my way home I went ! Driving I realized I was charged like 18 bucks ???? Called the shop to make sure I did not get away with theft the guy on the phone said no sir it's Tues 2 pies for 15 $ wow ! I said thanks and that's that . Got home and we ate some of the best pizza we ever had . Thanks Haledon pizza read more

Great pizza and great staff!! Delivery time is on point. However, they really need to update their dining area. Those booths need to go to the junkyard. Please get tables and chairs and working tv for customers. I would love to stay and eat here. read more

The food is okay, but the service is terrible. I went in with a ten dollar bill that I received from another store as change. I gave the cashier the money and he immediately accused me of handing him counterfeit money. He held it up to the light and had multiple others in the store do the same. This went on for a couple of minutes. He made absolutely no attempt at discretion. I had to go across the street to the store (who gave me absolutely no trouble, by the way) and get change for the $10 bill for him to accept my money. Extremely unprofessional. read more

wow i ordered their haledon special it was really really good called in was asked if i wanted well done which i thought was a weird question but i asked which is better and that it was my first time. so i got it well done wait time was negligible and the pizza was hot and tasted delcious. reasonably priced $15 something. read more

Hands down best local pizzeria. I've been ordering from here ever since they opened and I have yet to be disappointed. The place is usually just a pick up or delivery kind of pizzeria. But there is available seating. Don't expect to be thrilled with the seating though, not that pleasant. I've always been picking up my orders and we've gotten close with the owner so that's been a plus. And delivery orders have never been more than 20 minutes of a wait. And prices are cheap, really cheap. Anyways, the food. Pizza is awesome. Sandwiches are awesome, get the cheesesteak. The best around. And the mozzarella sticks. Also the best. And staff is willing to adjust your order to your liking. Just go there and have some pizza. You're welcome. read more

Decent pizza at a decent price. Often we order from here. Thin crust, real cheese. Not overly Greasey. They have eat in but it's really great take out delivery. Fast delivery. read more

This is probably my favorite pizza ever! Sauce is made fresh and is not thick at all. I recommend this pizza to everyone I meet. Most definitely Kid Friendly. Staff is very clean and friendly. Gives off a family vibe. Prices are very inexpensive compared to other pizzerias in town. You have to try the regular cheese pizza . Maybe try a whole Pie.. I sure can eat a whole one in one sitting! read more

Antipasto was terrible, did not taste fresh whatsoever. Came in to pick up my order and the people behind the counter did not seem too friendly. read more

This place makes the best pizza around this area. Yes, understanding there are so many pizza joints around here, it is a high bar. Come here, and try their plain pizza pie. You can taste how good the pizza truly is. read more

Love their pizza, mozzarella sticks, and chicken parm dinner!

Meatlovers pizza has Real meatballs! The mozzarella sticks are great. This is the best pizza I've had so far in this area.

Best pizzaria in north jersey ! Very respectful places and great prices ! Cant go wrong with haledon pizza

My favorite take out pizza place ever. I've been going here for the last 20 some odd years. I've moved a little bit further now but still try to stop at least once in while. Very great pizza and classic great take out read more

Great pizza, great dinners and heros, fast delivery, and very reasonable prices. I am very impressed!

I've been coming to haledon pizza for years! Place is always consistent with the food and do not have any complains thus far.

Great quality food... Hidden gem in New Jersey... Honestly one of the best pizzas and sandwiches you'll taste... Must try of nearby...

The best pizza that you could honestly get in town for a great price l. Their pizza never fails to disappoint

Great pizza and great service! Delivery man was at my door within 30 minutes of ordering. Glad I listened to my neighbor and gave them a try. Crust is on the soft side rather than crispy but has good flavor. I will order again! read more