Guys Pizza Co

I only order delivery, so I can't really rate the dining experience. The food is good. Their pizza…read moreis very doughy, which I like, but I understand if others don't like it as much. The varieties of food on their menu is also great, and their desserts are delicious. Delivery has always been right on the money if not earlier than expected. Food has always looked great upon arrival. No complaints.

The pizza was undercooked and doughy. There wasn't a lot of sauce and the meat wasn't correct. I…read moreeven asked for it to be well done. Hard pass.

Takeout chili

See all

Gionino's Pizzeria of Medina

3.3(34 reviews)

1.1 mi

Definitely a little better quality than most other pizza places in Medina but miscommunication or…read moreconfusion over order EVERY time I've ordered here; I'm sorry to say this but it seems to always be one of the younger workers who are to blame for this. It ultimately deters me from ordering more often than I do. I wish the coupons were a better deal or that they offered rewards like Pizza Hut. Their subs are very good but very small and for that reason (in my opinion) very overpriced.

We love Gionino's! My husband says it's the best and his favorite! the pizza is very tasty! It's…read morealways fresh!

Gionino's!!!! Yayyyy

Pepperoni pizza

See all

Gionino's

Courthouse Pizzeria

3.7(171 reviews)

1.3 mi

Stopped into Courthouse Pizzeria while spending the afternoon in Medina Square. The location is…read moregreat, right on the corner of the square. We grabbed a high-top window seat, which was perfect for people-watching and taking in the charm of the downtown area. The pizza is thin-crust New York style, and the slices were a decent size. We each ordered a slice and shared a drink. At $5 for a cheese slice plus $1 per topping, I felt it was a little pricey for a single slice. I wished I had just ordered a whole pizza instead. The restaurant itself is small, cozy, and ideal if you're looking for a quick bite while exploring the square. The young man who took our order was very friendly and welcoming. Unfortunately, my experience with another staff member wasn't as positive. When I asked for a to-go cup for my son's drink, the young woman helping us came across as rude. Overall, I enjoyed the atmosphere, the convenient location, and the pizza. A few service inconsistencies kept it from being a 5-star experience, but I'd still stop in again when visiting Medina Square.

Stopped to try for the first time. Pizza was ok. Light on the sauce. The sauce and sausage seemed…read morelike food service ready to use products. Not fresh / homemade. For the price of the pizza, this would have helped the value perception. Pricing was a little high. Ordered a side salad. This was nice! Good portion and fresh veggie toppings. We ate in the store. There was a very strong sour beer or sewer odor present. Not sure if it was coming from the little bar area in the back of the store. It was a little underwhelming for our first visit.

Inside

Pepperoni Pizza

See all

The menu

Master Pizza

3.7(36 reviews)

5.2 mi

•$$$

If you want a fast pizza, this is not the place. Hour wait…read more Having said that, toppings were plentiful and it was pretty good. The toppings being plentiful also lead to a higher cost structure. When did pizza cost more than a steak? This is a splurge by but I think overall worth it.

The food is good but the games this company does with coupons is ridiculous. Constantly changing…read morethem or coupons they advertise on their own website doesn't work. MP30 MP50 MP70 it's all a joke. Call and complain and they don't care. I'm done ordering anything with them. Management is a joke....

Meat just looks and smells off. Throw away and ventured out to another restaurant.

The pizza we ordered undercooked, left a bad aftertaste in our mouth 2 pizza's $25 won't go back,

See all

Thin crust pepperoni - excellent

East of Chicago Pizza

3.4(19 reviews)

1.2 mi

Yesterday, we ordered four pizzas from East of Chicago for delivery. Fourty-five minutes later, the…read morepizzas were delivered. They were hot, fresh, and tasty. We ordered two cheese, a veggie, and a pepperoni. I ate the veggie pizza and it was delicious. It had diced tomatoes, banana pepper rings, and something else that I don't remember. The pizza was on par with Marco's and Papa John's, which I like. I'm glad we tried it because we'll be ordering from here again.

This is a definite yum yum as Grandma says! Their pizza is always amazing! So good! The subs are…read morealso very good! We tried the cinnamon bites and they are out of this world! The service is quick!

Cinnamon bites!

Pizza!

See all

Lager Heads Brewing Company

4.7(44 reviews)

1.0 mi

Lagerheads is a great place for pizza! The pizza is absolutely delicious! Also there's a great…read moreselection of beer we lucked out because our favorite bartender Wendy was there that night!

Visited for Medina's Christmas in July bar crawl, great menu options and drinks offered, friendly…read morestaff, cool facility, lots of seating. Free popcorn in the corner near the bar! Strong Christmas Ale (Winter Mischief 8.5%)

7/26/2025 current specials

Ribs

See all

Ribeye

Antonio's Pizzeria LoSchiavo

2.9(28 reviews)

3.3 mi

I've been a fan of their pizza since first having it in Parma when I was a teenager. Love the old…read moreworld style crust. still like it simple just pepperoni and mushroom.

Always excellent food. Take out order today was very poor (long) service. Ordered early 11:30am for…read morea noon pickup and ended up staying an additional 30min till order was ready. Manager gave a small apology for wait but that was it. Great food..but service needs to pick it up!

Dry Sicilian - very little sauce

See all

Antipasto Salad

Romeo's Italian Kitchen

3.4(5 reviews)

2.3 mi

Best pizza in town. Fabulous employees and one of the kindest owners. We take the family up to OT…read morefor pizza often. The best.

Not impressed by any means. Ordered a bowl of chili, mozzarella sticks and 2 orders of wings wings…read moreand a club sandwich. Chili came out looking like warmed up dog food. No cheese, onions or crackers with it. And the spoon was already in the bowl. Could only stomach about a quarter of it. 20 minutes later the remainder of the food arrived. Mozzarella sticks as well (which should have been an appetizer). Was not worth the wait. Was told they were really busy yet watched food come out for guests that arrived after us. Won't be back.

Cheesy Breadsticks. Yum.

$4.00 bowl of chili that had the consistency of canned dog food.

See all

Medina Brewing Company

4.1(30 reviews)

1.2 mi

Loved the beers, service was good, nice bar tucked away under farmers table, was a good vibe. Food…read morewas separate but still in the same room, from big dog daddy's.

I love to leave good reviews, I look for the good in EVERYTHING but I saw very little to leave a…read moregood report about. My complaints- 1-When full this place is LOUD. The decibels are equitable to a chucky cheese when the mouse walks on stage for the first time. It's in a basement which gives dark depressing vibes. 2- There is nothing to do (accept wish you went somewhere else) they have no games, no play area. 3- Orders were wrong or messed up. My Shirley temple was grenadine and soda water. Their summer shandy was mediocre. 4- Over an hour long wait for food

Hallway signs

Live music

See all

Santosuossos'pizza Pasta Vino

3.3(127 reviews)

3.4 mi

Our party of 4 visited for dinner on Friday September 11th, 2026 for our first visit to this…read morerestaurant. We were warmly greeted at the door and shown to our reserved table. The ambiance of the place felt very welcoming. Our server, Abbey, was there instantly to take our drink order, and gave us exactly enough time to peruse the menu. She was very engaging, and seemed like an old soul...such a cute personality. The food came out in a timely manner, and may be some of the best Italian food that we have had in a long while. Keep up the great service Abbey, and thank you for a great dining experience Santosuossos. Overall experience.....outstanding !!!

Bummed it took me this long to try the place!…read more Tucked into the corner of a small strip plaza it's easy to overlook this restaurant and I sure did for far too long. We finally went this past Sunday for Father's Day and had an absolutely wonderful experience from start to finish. Service was excellent; very attentive and helpful wait staff and the place was very clean and welcoming. Food was outstanding; we started with a couple of their garlic cheese breadsticks and coupled with their fresh table bread we almost got filled up before the mains arrived. Next up, salads which were also fresh and paired with their house Italian dressing, outstanding, and we needed more of the fresh bread (had three hungry young men with us). Last up our entrees and we had a little of everything and it is all yummy. Wife had a Cobb salad that looked excellent and was. One son had the pasta with meatballs plus a cauliflower crust pizza, another son had a regular pizza with pepperoni, onions and sausage, our friend had the chicken parm and I had the veal parm. My veal was incredibly tender and delicious (waitress recommendation btw) and not much was left on the table. Four soft drinks, one very full pour old fashion (for me), two appetizers and six entrees and the total bill was $197 which was a hell of a good deal for the dinner we were served. Trust me, we won't wait long to come back. Fantastic restaurant!

Seafood pasta

See all

Dessert

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

4 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

James M.

13 years ago

I just got a burger from guys pizza... Their burgers are great! Way better than 5 guys and they deliver!

Meagan W.

8 years ago

I've been getting the guyzones for years here they are amazing I love them! Worth it!

Valor K.

3 years ago

Good food! Highly recommended!

Ryan A.

11 years ago

Great tasting pizza and gyros

Guys Pizza Co - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Medina, Ohio Restaurants near Guys Pizza Co

BEST of Medina, Ohio Things to Do near Guys Pizza Co

BEST of Medina, Ohio Desserts near Guys Pizza Co

BEST of Medina, Ohio Coffee near Guys Pizza Co

BEST of Medina, Ohio Breakfast near Guys Pizza Co

BEST of Medina, Ohio Dinner near Guys Pizza Co

BEST of Medina, Ohio Burgers near Guys Pizza Co

BEST of Medina, Ohio Shopping near Guys Pizza Co

BEST of Medina, Ohio Thrift Stores near Guys Pizza Co

Best of Medina

Things to do in Medina

Browse Brands

Guys Pizza Co

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Guys Pizza Co also viewed

Romeo's Pizza

3.1

(15 reviews)

My 13 year old son raves about this place... I was never impressed until today. I decided to place…read morean order for myself instead of just my regular kids pepperoni pizza. I settled on the vegetable calzone. Absolutely delectable!!! Perfect amount of sauce, perfectly browned, a hint of real grated Parmesan cheese. I can't say enough good about this calzone! I will be ordering again. There are a few pizza places around here, but from now on Romeo's has my Money! Oh and I'm actually sick with a cold, which means this will be even more delicious when I'm better!

FYI - carry out only. No inside seating. Staff was friendly. No pizza place in town has seating.read more

Leonardos Pizza

3.9

(62 reviews)

Best. Fried. Chicken. Ever…read more I was at a family gathering and they ordered about 5-8 lbs of fried chicken. I was so happy, I ate 8 in one sitting.

I went here for a second time & got same thing as last time. This time it was an obvious 5******…read moremeal. Prices are amazing & portion sizes are great. Highly suggest to substitute fries for JoJos, as the JoJo's were amazing & you got a whole side worth. I do think I got more chicken on my salad than last time. The chicken tenders are absolutely phenomenal. Highly recommend for a great meal

Altieri's Pizza

4.4

(137 reviews)

I'm moving back to southwest Ohio and this is one of the only places i will miss from the…read morenortheast. Everything I've had from this place is amazing! Pizza, hoagies, fried chicken, jojos, and spaghetti. I even tried the coleslaw... it was amazing! The sauce they use is sweet and light. They fry the chicken perfectly. Definitely give this place a try. Another thing i love is the customer service and mom and pop feel. The staff is always friendly and it's always the same people working. You can tell they really love their job. They also offer rewards programs and punch cards. There's a different special everyday. You can get a sub, jojos, coleslaw, and a can of soda for under $9. There's not too many places you can get a good home cooked meal for under $10 a person. Definitely recommend if you're looking for a consistent take out spot with a mom and pop feel that won't hurt your wallet.

Like seeing an old friend after 40 years, I had Alteri's for the first time since 1985. Yum…read more Takes me back to the university of Akron Chuckery. I typically do not like pepperoni under cheese but for Alteri's it works. They ecen offered me a slice of their Spaghetti pizza at no charge. So cool. This is a take out only location.

Tonios Pizza

4.2

(13 reviews)

Great service! We…read moreordered pizza on a Saturday night. Wait was about 40 minutes for a salad, pizza and Stromboli. Food was ready when we arrived. They bring it down to your car which is great if you are like me picking up with kids. Everyone loved the food. Pizza was delicious and the Stromboli had a good amount of meat. Plus plenty of dressing for the salad.

My wife and I are nomads traveling the country in our RV. Tonios Pizza is one of the best we…read morehave found! We had a Deluxe pizza and garlic parmesan knots. They could nicely compete in a larger market.

Decheco's Pizzeria

4.0

(148 reviews)

I have 2 favorite pizza places but one over shines the other. Decheco' pizza is my favorite. I…read moremostly get the white sauce with whatever im feeling like at the time. Price is fair yet a bit higher ( you can find coupons on google ) still the pizza is amazing. Other one is more of a sit down restaurant in barberton & this ones close by. The pizza Guru's are cool & very helpful. Not a lot of seeting & designed more for take out. It is wheelchair accessable & Great Pizza!

Celebrating pi day with the best kind of pie! We grabbed a Sausage & Pepperoni pizza, Hawaiian BBQ…read morePizza, and chicken and jojos with coleslaw meal from the Fairlawn location. Good flavor and had plenty of leftovers. This location is take out only, no area to eat inside. Plenty of parking spots and I received a text message letting me know when our food was ready for pickup.

Marcello's New York Pizza

4.3

(34 reviews)

Great little take out place for NYC style slice. They also have meatball subs, chicken parm…read moresandwiches and more! Very friendly owner told us all the pies that she ready.

Ordered the large New Yorker. It has a spicer sauce with pepperoni, mushrooms, and sausage…read more The spicer sauce was imperceptible. I prefer a heavier sauce and it was kind of runny. It tasted good and the portions of meat were good. I dunno. It wasn't bad and it wasn't like I had to have it again. Maybe I'll give it another whirl down the road.

Antonio's Pizza

3.1

(50 reviews)

Chicago style pizza in Copley, Ohio? You bet. It's deep dish…read moredouble cheese and the best pizza ever. When they deliver, they are gracious and polite. When you order, they explain the menu. It's a customer-focused experience. Just love this pizza!

How dare you call this a Chicago style pizza!! Personally offended by this strange meat pie I…read morereceived. With that being said, we do order this pizza frequently. It's ok. Nothing I would recommend as the best pizza ever but a decent average pizza

Mark & Philly's

4.1

(76 reviews)