Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Gray Gauntlet Games

    5.0 (1 review)
    Closed Closed

    Gray Gauntlet Games Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Gray Gauntlet Games

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    2 years ago

    It's a lovely little store, with wonderful pricing. Helped get me into Warhammer, so cheers to chat!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Gray Gauntlet Games

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Hobby Shops 1,476 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    HobbyTown

    HobbyTown

    3.0(34 reviews)
    2.6 mi
    $$

    I'm not quite sure why I've never been in HobbyTown, but I was in the neighborhood and had some…read moretime between obligations. So, I stopped in to check it out. HobbyTown is located in the long strip center adjacent to the former Weekends Only (and soon to be Vasa Fitness). It's definitely not the most active strip center, however, it seems like a good location for this type of business. HobbyTown is a franchised retail toy/hobby store with over 100 locations nationwide including three in Indiana (Granger and Evansville also have one). It's based in Nebraska. HobbyTown has a bit of a retro vibe, craft store meets hardware store meets toys like RC vehicles, RC aircraft, models, toys, games, learning toys, arts and crafts, and trains. I would probably describe myself as a wannabe hobbyist. I found myself completely captivated by the trains, RC options, and some of the models. I loved models as a kid - I was lousy at putting them together, but I really enjoyed it. They also had more board games than I expected. Parking here is pretty easy. It's not the most accessible building, however, it's not far from Concentra with a great curb cut. The store itself was pretty easy to get around, though aisles are occasionally a bit crowded. I had no difficulty and found the place friendly and helpful. The prices are pretty consistent with other hobby/toy shops. Yes, you can spend a lot here. For sure. You can also find affordable hobby options and gift options. A five-star might be a tad generous, however, I really liked the place and loved the variety of toys and hobbies. I enjoyed hanging out for a bit and got some great ideas. I'd say it's pretty certain I'll be back.

    I used to go here for model train items but for about the last 8 months the shelves are nearly…read morebare. I asked an employee what was going on with the lack of restocking and he said they just can't get things since Christmas. They didn't restock before that (not just train items out of stock) so that doesn't make sense to me. The older men that work there are not very friendly at all. If you ask them something about anything they act like you're stupid if you didn't already know. They are just rude old grouchy men. So because of those issues I'm done going there. It is too bad because at one time it was a great place to go. I guess I will buy more online and look my questions up there as well. I wonder if they are getting ready to close?

    Photos
    HobbyTown
    HobbyTown
    HobbyTown - Showing my kitty what I got at Hobbytown

    See all

    Showing my kitty what I got at Hobbytown

    Hero's Emporium - MTG Commander

    Hero's Emporium

    4.5(11 reviews)
    7.2 mi
    $

    This where I go for all of my tabletop gaming needs. It's always a treat when I get to go to this…read morewonderful business, which may seem hushed and quiet during the day, but it only adds to its mystique and charm that would be typical of a magic shop. This place works great for me because it's really close to my house and it's locally owned. That way I don't have to drive a long way to find what I need for my Dungeons and Dragons campaign. The Hero's Emporium has always had a great selection of brushes, paints, and miniatures that I have come to rely heavily upon as a Dungeon Master. I am always able to find the miniatures that I am looking for whether that be a female gnome paladin or several packages of gnolls that I can paint and throw at my party. All the miniatures are very reasonably priced too, so I can get even larger miniatures like a storm giant for only around $15. For as long as miniatures take me to paint, this is well worth the money. I also want to mention that they offer a decent selction of dice sets to choose from, which is important for any D&D campaign, especially when your dice are fickle. I also love that they offer both old and new sourcebooks for D&D as well as official Nolzurs paint sets, and Icons of the Realms. This gives me a large pool to choose what will be most exciting for my party. Finally I wanted to mention that this business has also done tabletop nights. Although I personally have not attended one of those events, I support the space this business is building for the tabletop community. The staff has also always been very welcoming and helpful, making sure that I am finding everything that I am searching for. I am also occasionally able to find expansion packs for a bit more obscure card game called Smash Up here, which is delightful considering that it's so hard to find in just a regular store like Target. I will continue to come back and support this business in their mission to help the tabletop community thrive.

    Great selection of D&D and MTG stuff!…read more Also lots of other games, miniatures and accessories. They also have lots of weekly events and leagues to join. Fun atmosphere, great staff and customers!

    Photos
    Hero's Emporium - Seeing The Shakes Ups rock the house!!!!

    Seeing The Shakes Ups rock the house!!!!

    Hero's Emporium - Hero's Emporium

    Hero's Emporium

    Hero's Emporium

    See all

    The Game Preserve - Outside

    The Game Preserve

    4.2(27 reviews)
    4.8 mi
    $$

    Been coming to The Game Preserve since before they moved into their current location, back when…read morethey were operating out of the storefront next door. Watching a good local game shop level up to a better space and somehow get even better in the process is the kind of origin story worth being loyal to. The selection here is the real deal. Puzzles, board games, TCGs, and enough variety to make you forget you came in with a specific mission. For me that mission is almost always the Magic: The Gathering singles wall, which The Game Preserve stocks with the kind of depth and organization that makes the whole experience feel less like digging through a binder at a flea market and more like consulting the Jedi Archives. Everything is where it should be, which sounds basic until you've experienced the alternative. The staff is where this place genuinely separates itself from the competition. These are not people who just work at a game store. These are people who actually play, who know the cards, who understand why you need a specific version of a specific card for a specific deck and don't make you feel like you need to explain yourself from the beginning. Case in point: on one visit a staff member helped me track down the perfect Sol Ring for my Commander deck. Not just any Sol Ring. The right one. That level of product knowledge and genuine engagement is rarer than a foil mythic and worth just as much. The rewards program is a legitimate reason to make this your regular stop if you're a frequent buyer. Points add up, the benefits are real, and it actually feels like the store wants your repeat business rather than just tolerating it. Five stars, long time customer, no plans to stop. The Force has always been strong with The Game Preserve and the new location only confirmed it.

    This is such a cool games spot. You can find an assortment of board/card games (most I had no idea…read morewhat they were). They had different type of dice (up to 8 sides) and chess boards which was cool to me. Some of the games seemed a bit expensive for me though. This is a great store for people of all ages. You are bound to find something that you like. Exploring this store was definitely fun and I saw a few cool gift ideas for friends who love trying new board games. The place is well organized, clean and has some fun decor. The staff is friendly and helpful.

    Photos
    The Game Preserve - Inside

    Inside

    The Game Preserve
    The Game Preserve

    See all

    Michaels - Storefront

    Michaels

    3.7(32 reviews)
    3.7 mi
    $$

    There was a time in my life when you could easily catch me doing the trifecta of stores here -…read moreMichaels, PetsMart, and Marsh. Alas, life changes and I don't really frequent this corner anymore with Marsh long gone and PetsMart no longer having as many live animals as they once had. While I'm not exactly a crafty person, I've seemingly always found something I like at Michaels. It's also always been a prime option for me when I've needed something framed. I'm not a fan of Hobby Lobby for a variety of reasons - so, on those rare occasions I need something in the craft arena this tends to be where I go. I'd been looking for an affordable Christmas wreath along with a couple basic decorations. I saw the Michaels Black Friday ad and decided to stop by after church today. This location has accessible parking, though it's not ADA (there's no actual signage). There's an appropriate curb cut and automatic doors. As is nearly always true for craft stores, the aisles tend to be a bit difficult for wheelchair users. I do like that they have the shorter carts. Store personnel tended to be friendly and I will say that craft-oriented shoppers tend to be friendlier than the "cut in front of me and you'll die" shoppers at your usual big box retailers. Michaels was definitely decked out for Christmas and it really dominated the store. They have pretty much all self-serve kiosks for check-out these days - I like that they have big screens (let's face it, Michaels has a high number of older shoppers). I didn't find everything I'd hoped to find at Michaels, though I did find a couple great items at great prices. Check out was quick and the rep was super helpful. Heck, I even signed up for the rewards club (3% back on all purchases, 6% once you hit $300). They also can look up your receipts if you need to make a return - great for folks like me who tend to lose receipts. Michaels has classes, events, and they still have a great selection of frames. They're great for knitting supplies, hobby activities, art supplies, and much more. For Christmas, you can get quite a bit at a wide variety of prices. This was a solid experience. It sure wasn't five star, especially because some of the aisles definitely had some accessibility issues, but it was a very solid four-star and I'd definitely go back. I will note they frequently have items outside their door - in itself wonderful, however, at times they do block the sidewalk in case you're wanting to go to PetsMart next door. Haverty's has taken the old Marsh spot.

    Just about every type of craft and hobby supply imaginable. Additionally, there is a limited…read moreinventory of fabric and sewing supplies. The staff are very helpful though the store layout is a bit cramped for ease of accessibly. Aisles are well labeled. I find the pricing to be a bit high but the sales are very good (50%) and clearance (60-70%) even better.

    Photos
    Michaels - Custom framing counter

    Custom framing counter

    Michaels
    Michaels - Storefront

    See all

    Storefront

    Game Time - The Hobbit Prerelease Blitz event

    Game Time

    3.6(16 reviews)
    2.7 mi
    $$

    There are stores you visit and stores you have history with. Game Time in Castleton falls firmly…read moreinto the second category for me, which makes writing this review feel less like a consumer report and more like a transmission from a long time ally. Pre-COVID, Game Time was the premier MTG destination on the north side of Indianapolis. Double digit attendance weekly across multiple formats, Regional Qualifier events for the Pro Tour, the kind of competitive scene that made this place feel less like a local game store and more like a Jedi Temple for Magic players. I played in those events. I remember what this place was capable of when it was operating at full power. I came in on a Saturday for the MTG Hobbit prerelease event, which drew eight players. Eight. The play area that used to hum with the energy of a full Rebel fleet now has half its tables cordoned off indefinitely, like a wing of the Temple that nobody talks about anymore. It is noticeable, and it is a little melancholy if you were there for the golden era. That said, the eight of us who showed up had a genuinely good time. The event ran smoothly, the staff kept things moving, and cracking Hobbit themed prerelease packs at a table with fellow players is still one of the better ways to spend a Saturday regardless of headcount. The store itself remains worth visiting for TCG singles and sealed product. The collection is large, well organized, and if you are hunting a specific Magic card for any format, this is a reliable place to find it. The rewards program is solid and worth using if you are a regular. The staff is nice, knowledgeable, and treats you like someone who belongs there. Four stars for a store that was once the Death Star of competitive MTG in Indianapolis and is now rebuilding. The foundation is still good. Here is hoping the play area opens back up and the Rebel alliance returns in full.

    Went here for a OP Local Tourney. They had a good variety of snacks etc…read more People running the event did an excellent job. Only suggestion is getting more OP product to which they only had one starter deck. Overall great experience.

    The Well Coffeehouse

    The Well Coffeehouse

    4.4(397 reviews)
    1.5 mi
    $$

    What a great little breakfast spot! I came here for a quick breakfast with while in Fishers for a…read morebachelorette party. On a Saturday morning it was busy - you can tell this is the place to be! Luckily it's spacious and the line to order moves pretty quick. I got one of the specialty drinks, the iced honeydukes latte, which is sweetened with hazelnut and brown sugar. This was so yummy, creamy, and not overly sweet. My friend got the meemaw which was also extremely delicious and is made with housemade butterscotch syrup. To eat I went with a bacon, egg. and cheese on an everything bagel. It hit the spot. No complaints here!

    Lovely coffee shop in Fishers. The place was close to our hotel and local, so I was happy to try it…read morevs. going to the nearby Starbucks. Super happy we did. It's obvious that these people really care about coffee and roast good beans. I got one of their summer specialty drink, Wake up San Francisco. It was a blackberry lavender Cuban. Never had a Cuban coffee drink before and honestly, I forgot what the barista told me it was, but it was pretty similar to a cortado in its milk vs. espresso ratio. The coffee was really good and I loved the combo of blackberry and lavender. It wasn't too sweet or overpowering. The atmosphere was lively and friendly. It may have been a little too loud for me to actually work at, but I was also there during peak hours. Also got a chocolate chip cookie for and was delighted to see that it was actually cookies in the back! Great value.

    Photos
    The Well Coffeehouse
    The Well Coffeehouse - Grilled cheese

    Grilled cheese

    The Well Coffeehouse - Seasonal GF DF blackberry lavender muffin and chai

    See all

    Seasonal GF DF blackberry lavender muffin and chai

    Gray Gauntlet Games - hobbyshops - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...