I love Graeter's and had to come try their new flavor - Flying Pig Tracks, vanilla with peanut butter cups and fudge swirls. It was good but wasn't as fudge-y as I had anticipated. Still a good treat after dinner. This location was super clean, workers were good and fast and great at multi-tasking. It's a warm spring day so the drive thru was pretty busy but I was able to get served in a timely manner. read more

See all

Graeter's Ice CreamBlack Raspberry Chip Banana Split Waffle Cone After dinner treat read more

See all

We love their ice cream, milk shakes, and coffee chillers. It is always clean and well maintained. The customer service is awesome! :)

Took these grands for their first Graeter's experience. Everyone had Black Raspberry Chunk and it was excellent! Smiles all around. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Grandkids at Graeter's in Pickerington, OH - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

We can't come to Ohio without MULTIPLE trips to Graeter's! We think it's easily some of the best ice cream in the country! Any of their "chip" flavors are phenomenal. My favorite is salted caramel chip or sometimes I go for the Black Raspberry Chip. I tried the Toffee Chip this time, and it was also good. My husband tried the hot honey flavor and it was very unique and he really loved it. (Spicy ice cream anyone?!) read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Toffee Chip and The Hot Honey - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

Took my son for ice cream after dinner. Love Graeters but the customer service is not so good. We stood there while staff stocked ice cream was not acknowledge at all finally a manager looked up and said please stop and help these people. Then we proceed to the register and again staff is hyper focused on stocking the ice cream and ignored us. We stood there for another 10-15 minutes then I spoke up and said can someone please check us out we've been here for a while the young lady looked annoyed that asked and continued to stock Finally the older lady on drive thru came up and checked us out who was equally annoyed at the young workers who did not help.... Customer service training is desperately needed. read more

BEWARE. In an effort to restore their image, the Business Manager posted on my previous Yelp review saying they would make things right if I sent them an email. The email was sent and I have received no response. I paid for an item and was not given it, GRAETER'S STOLE from my family. read more

Very tasty! The service was very good and the ice cream was delicious! I'd go again very soon! read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Salted caramel waffle cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

The ice cream is delicious! The service is fast, friendly and just overall amazing! The dining area is clean. They have a cute area to sit outside as well as a drive through. read more

The best ice cream the workers were very friendly .The air conditioner made the eat in even more pleasant. Love the items I saw tshirt s Candy and air freshener for your car and the lip balm in ice cream flavors. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

We LOVE this place. Seasonal and surprise flavors are killer and the classics in a waffle cone.. it's heaven Do it. Just go there. It's delicious..enjoy your life. Staff also are great read more

Shalom, Never have I ever had this ice cream must say it was most delicious I had black cherry,chocolate chip, and young ones had cotton candy. As this was our little treat after super read more

We love coming here to enjoy a scoop of ice cream! They make the best milkshakes. Super yummy and delicious

In my humble but well-tested ice cream opinion, Graeter's is the best mass-produced ice cream brand. Many flavors feature their bittersweet chocolate "chips," delicious fudge chunks ranging from slivers to massive chocolate pieces larger than your spoon. The types of flavors are relatively simple (coconut, mocha, vanilla, black raspberry, etc) but rich and well-done. This location was huge and offered limited edition flavors in addition to the staples. There is plenty of seating and also Graeter's merchandise. For the true fans, they offer pints, quarts, and cakes for purchase and dry ice containers for those traveling long-distance. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Single scoops of mocha chocolate chip and toffee chocolate chip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

Best, most creamiest scoop of deliciousness! By volume the best gourmet ice cream ever!

Always a great option. Love the seasonal flavors. Elaina's Blueberry pie is a favorite. The coffee flavors are awesome. They are a great place for some cool treats. Service is always friendly and patient when u want to sample many flavors. Definitely must visit. read more

I hate this location soooo much . literally every time i go here i get scammed out of my money. someone needs to tell the employees there that IF SOMEONE ORDERS TWO SCOOPS THEY SHOULD BE ABLE TO COUNT ON ACTUALLY GETTING A FULL TWO SCOOPS. i would advise going to a different location read more

Black Raspberry chocolate chip ice cream with bittersweet topping is my jam. I get a "fix" every time I go through Cincinnati. Also noticed there are quite a few locations in Columbus now. read more

Not only was my order wrong there was hair in my ice cream, I don't recommend, the lady on the intercom was rude also. read more

See all

Me and my family love coming here to get ice cream I really recommend coming here and the service are great.

Maybe you heard Oprah and Sarah Jessica Parker liked it. Maybe a close, personal friend whispered in your ear that Graeter's Ice Cream is the best ice cream in America. Or maybe, just maybe, you've fallen on good fortune and tried it yourself. Lucky you. When I was growing up, a wee tot in the trenches of southern Ohio, Graeter's Ice Cream was pretty easy to come by. They were mostly in Cincinnati, but they popped up a couple out of town and so you could get it more readily. Well, now Ohio is almost bursting with it. It has now come to Pickerington. Where's that?, you might ask. Why, it's near Columbus. But more importantly, it's home to a Graeter's Ice Cream store. Ahh. So when I was back in town over Memorial Day weekend for a dear friend's wedding, after quick hellos at my brother's house, we got down to the important business: Graeter's. This is what we came for. Anyway, it was a delight, as always. We came here twice during our five-day trip and stuffed ourselves silly will luscious, creamy ice cream. My fave has always been Double Chocolate Chip. And I'm a purist ... I don't like to stray far from the double scoop of that. But I ventured into new territory this time and made one of the scoops Peanut Butter Chip. Heaven. And on the return visit, I got some sort of chocolate lovers-type sundae that was divine. It doesn't get any better than this. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Is this Heaven? No, it's Graeter's. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

We came through the drive through and the ice cream was delicious; however, we were not given a spoon and had to eat it with a spare pen we found in the car. It worked but now I have to throw away my perfectly good pen because it is covered in buckeye blitz. Also no napkins which was kinda lame. Good ice cream tho. read more

Very disappointed, Friday's and Saturday's after 9pm you guys are only drive-through! WHY? The line for the drive-through is ver long. Not a bright idea to do this on the weekends. read more

Graeter's ice cream has no equal, it is fantastic! I buy 6-8 pints for dessert for family gatherings. The chocolate chip variations are amazing - the "chips" are not chips but a "wave" of chocolate that is broken up during mixing. I highly recommend buying multiple "pints", which are actually single-server containers and eating them all at once. And then go back and buy some more. Eat it for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. read more

So great to see Graeters finally updated their uniforms. Those Turd-Brown shirts were terrible. Really like the new Purple look! Great Chocolate shake today! Keep up the improvements! read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

worst graeter's i've even been too. my ice cream has no taste at all and my chocolate cone is steal. barely can eat this! NASTY

The woman who worked the drive thru today 3/17 was so sweet and really made my birthday. I was struggling to get my birthday coupon and my app to load fast enough and she helped me out. Thank you so much! I wish I caught your name so I could personally say thank you. I've been coming to this store for 3 years. Never had an issue. The sorbet is always so good! read more

Was not impressed with the managers reaction towards me when I brought it to him and the girl who assisted me attention that she did not charge me for the ice cream in my to-go cooler. She only charged me for the cooler not the ice cream. I could have just left but instead I paid for the ice cream. read more

Unfortunately it's always hit or miss with this location, no consistency of accurate orders. Tonight I ordered a buckeye sundae and just got chocolate ice cream with whipped cream... thanks high school kids read more

Graeter's Ice Cream - "Buckeye sundae" is actually melted chocolate iced cream with whipped cream. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

Ice cream fanatic over here and I will say graeter's is just delicious. I always get the mine chocolate chip ice cream in a waffle cone! I just may eat to Much ice cream if that's even a thing. read more

I'm not a fan of Graeter's ice cream. I've only ever consumed it do to extremely rare impromptu family outings. I think the ice cream here has tons more sugar - I can barely taste the mint flavor. I'm convinced that Sweet N Low is the main ingredient in all their cold concoctions. I do like the simple set up for their stores. Plenty of tables and chairs, and no "fluff" to take up floor space. This store, being in a suburb city, seems to be predominately employed by high schoolers. They were polite and fast - perhaps the only two things I can give good remarks. read more

Graeter's Ice Cream is delicious! For everyone who loves Jeni's...I get it...it is delicious but EXPENSIVE. Graeter's has the taste and feel of childhood when its simple flavors touch your lips. In my previous review of the Skyline in Pickerington, this Graeter's is located in the same strip building as the Skyline. So, once you finish at Skyline - go have some Graeter's! My favorite flavors are the Black Raspberry Chip, Cookie Dough Chip, Peanut Butter Chip, and the Madagascar Bourbon Vanilla Bean. They also have very good chocolate malts as an alternative to the scooped ice cream. The staff is often a hit or miss when going through the drive-thru. They are either very friendly, or act like they hate their job. If you are in the area, stop on by the Graeter's for some ice cream! I would give it a five, but the staff notched it down to --- 4/5 stars read more

Black Cherry Chocolate Chip was good. Single scoop was a little on the small side for the price. All the tables were dirty.

It would be a five if management could get their act together & not leave their poor employees understaffed and exhausted. The lines tend to be long - which I don't necessarily mind - but today I noticed that one employee had literally gotten dizzy from exhaustion and had to sit down - leaving one poor girl to keep the drive through and a growing line inside moving. The ice cream is delicious. I go for a junior scoop when I'm being good...a medium double dip chocolate soda (1 scoop vanilla, 1 scoop chocolate) when I'm being naughty. This location is bright & clean. read more

ice cream is great, the poor kids though!!! Half of them are doing all the work while half of them dilly dally. One girl in particular had to keep asking her coworker to help the next in line. I feel so bad for them it's so chaotic read more

A scoop of Mocha Chip on a waffle cone made my rainy, sticky day 100 times better! Chocolate, melted, then drizzled into the icecream while it's churning, so that it slowly hardens, into random shapes and sizes. What a GENIUS idea!! The icecream itself is creamy, perfectly flavored with a nice balance of coffee and chocolate. The waffle cones are folded at the bottom to prevent drippings. Yum. I'm sooooo drizzling melted chocolate into my icecream maker! read more

I mentioned in a previous review my love for ice cream....and it is still true. I LOVE ICE CREAM! I adore Graeter's Toffee Chip ice cream the most. It is my down fall. I could eat this for every single meal. If I'm being honest though one scoop is a steep price, but it's worth a splurge every now and then...or weekly in my case! read more

Friendly staff, went through drive Thur! Excellent fast service! Best ice cream ever!

Sweet Lord the ice-cream here is awesome! Every different type I try is amazing but my favorite is their Peach, which is a very limited seasonal that comes out for two months. Their Strawberry chip is great as is their Black Raspberry chip as is their Vanilla Bean, as is their Mint Chocolate Chip. I'm not going down their list of flavors. They are all awesome and this is definitely the place to be during a hot summer evening, or anytime for that matter. read more

Oh Pumpkin Icecream... I cannot wait another month to eat your deliciousness!!!! read more