Not nearly enough staff to manage an afternoon on a Saturday. They do make good desserts, but waiting an hour and a half to two hours to get it as absurd. read more

Great experience. Brownie Brady provided excellent service. Definitely would recommend due to personnel. Lovely singing voices. read more

Always pretty cleanly. Always friendly staff. Staff always sings when they receive a tip. Everything that we have ever ordered here has been great! My favorite is the Founder's Favorite in a waffle cone. The waffle cones are always warm and fresh here. Due to COVID, they currently do not have any indoor seating. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Founder's Favorite (Like It) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

Well..... where to start. Ok......I'm a huge ice cream lover. Like.... anything chocolate with peanut butter.... I'm gonna try it and I am certain I will love It. Today at Cold Stone was a very questionable experience. Here's why.... We ordered around $40 worth of ice cream. And in 3 of the 6 orders, something was missing. It's unfortunate because we got our order to go and did not see the missing stuff until we got home. There was a lot of disappointment. There is a certain expectation. We all have it when we go to Cold Stone. Today was one of those days where I was totally let down. I was so disappointed that I didn't even take pictures while I was there. But I managed to take a few shots of them being enjoyed. Even if they were not made as we wanted. My Peanut Butter Cup Perfection was a little short of perfect. But I ate it anyways. One last thing.... if you give a 20% tip the team members will sing a song. I watched them do that for everyone before us who tipped. I was literally looking forward to our turn. I tipped even the 20%. NO SONG. My feelings were hurt. Like for reals. read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

There was a line of 5 families, 2 of about 5 and then the other size of 2 But nothing that should be to overwhelming for 5 people behind the counter. But it definitely was disorganized. Nobody can hear what you want to order bc of the noise. And the girl got everything I said wrong and someone had to fix it. I got a buckeye apple and orange peels. My wife yelled across to the cashier her order just for someone to take her order. Very disappointed read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Yum - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

First time at this establishment and I was not disappointed! We walked in and was greeted by the friendly staff. Having never been there, I had several questions to which the young lady cheerfully answered as I was making my selection. I settled on Peanut butter perfection, it was just that, a creamy blend of chocolate ice cream, peanut butter and peanut butter cups! WOW! Additionally my girlfriend had cake batter batter. It was cake batter flavored ice cream with brownie bites and cookie dough! It was amazing. Additionally, leave a tip to hear a funny jingle by the staff. Great place for a sweet tooth during the hot summer months! read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Cake Batter Batter Batter - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

See all

Received coupon in the mail. Was attending a birthday party and was in charge of the cake. Have only tried DQ ice cream cakes in the past and are "meh" about them. Figured it wouldn't hurt to try a competitor. Easy online ordering and picked the date and time to swing by for my cakes. Upon my arrival called in and was promptly greeted. A minute later my order was out the door and I was on my way. Best part: the CAKES WERE DELICIOUS!!! Not only ice cream, and icing, but real layers of cake too. Needless to say, the cakes were a hit and I was the hero. Thanks Cold Stone! read more

This is by far my favorite ice cream and my favorite location! They have at least 20+ flavor s to choose from, and 10+ mix ins! You want a cone? Waffle, sugar, or cake? Bowl? Waffle or paper? My favorite is cheesecake ice cream with kit Kat!! read more

Best ice cream in town!! For my coffee lovers- try the mud pie mojo (it's the best thing on the menu). I will ALWAYS get my birthday cakes from here! They are too good & you can customize them. read more

Horrible customer service. Rude staff. I was told I could not get any samples . My wife and I come here regularly and now we will never be back. Better Management is needed for the little kids that work here. read more

I love Cold Stone! This is a very nice location that also offers cake pops and Rocky Mountain Chocolate factory items. The girls who works here are very nice and I love the ice cream! I tried the banaa bread batter and it was the best ice cream I've eaten so I got the churro sundae with that instead of vanilla and it was delicious! My son got the brownie sundae with the oreo ice cream which was also very good! Great location, I would recommend it to anyone! read more

Cold Stone Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

I love this place so much. Kinda better then Dairy Queen to me. Clean, delicious ice cream, line moves fast. They sing a cute song w/ your tip. read more

I can't believe I haven't reviewed this place! This is my favorite affordable ice cream joint. If I'm out east for work or family, and get the urge for something sweet, I hit up this store. I think the management here is awesome, and I always get a good end product. I make app into come during the day, Usually when Ronnie is running the place, simply cause she's fan-flipping-tastic! One thing that I'm not terribly fond of is the Rocky Mountain chocolates that take up almost half of the counter space. Pure chocolates have never been my forte. But the store seems to sell a good amount, so the added treats are warranted. I have forever been stuck on this company's Mint Mint Chocolate Chocolate Chip novelty. I LOVE the mint flavor - and pair it with some fudge and a brownie, mash it all together, and what do you get? A whole lotta yumminess :) read more

This location closed early, not really a hot deal but they looked directly at me and ignored me. I'm only frustrated because yesterday I went in and ordered, started taking to another person and they mixed Graham crackers in my ice cream instead of a brownie. Gotta do better. read more

It must be mentioned: this is a coldstone and a rocky mountain chocolate factory combined. A few months ago my husband and I noticed a rocky mountain chocolate factory on a map then coldstone on another map. After looking into it, it seemed as though the rocky mountain chocolate factory had closed and coldstone opened. Since it was in the middle of winter and there were 5 inches of snow on the ground we decided we weren't in the mood for ice cream. Today we wanted to have a sweet frozen treat and were shocked to see that it was a combination location! I got a peanut butter like it with cookie dough and my husband got the German chocolate specialty. As always, ice cream is delicious. The only reason I gave a 4 star instead of 5 stars is because I have another local ice cream stop that is near and dear to my heart. We also got some candies for later and the staff was very friendly! I'm so excited that I know this is a combination location now! I will go back for sure! read more

Cold Stone Creamery - This is a rocky mountain chocolate factory and a cold stone!!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pickerington, Ohio

Ice cream is one of the best cant deny that. The service is good But tge portions suck. Every other cold stone they fill the cups up whats the sense of a bubble top if its empty so i can see the icecream if thats the case put a flat top on it This is the only one that does that and I dont know why read more

Decent ice cream. The service is always super slow however. The staff never seems to have any sense of urgency despite the length of line waiting to be served. read more

Had the churro surprise, a "Hot Stone" specialty. And, boy, was I surprised. The churros' constitution was somewhat hard and rubbery, difficult to chew. As if the churros had been microwaved too long. The ice cream was decent though (praline pecan). The chocolates looked tempting. But at $19.00 a pound, I passed as soon as I woke from fainting at the price. Could have had a small truffle for $3. Passed on that too. I'll think I'll stick to Culver's down the street. Frozen custard is better than ice cream in most cases anyway. read more

Gave it one star even though I love the ice cream...here's why, maybe I should have asked how much the chocolates were before I ordered but who does that? It's candy...my GF and I ordered a medium and large ice cream and would've been about 10 bucks give or take then we saw the candies and said we'll take a couple of these and a few of that. I step up to the register and she says "69 dollars" I had to take a step back and make sure I was still in an ice cream shop... anyhow, I sucked it up and payed almost $70 for some ice cream and a few chocolates...I'll still go back for ice cream but just FYI they're candies aren't much better than a snickers IMO read more

I usually by ice cream to one of their competitors in the area, but I decide to have something different. I just have to say, I was disappointed. It was creamy and a bad way and it just didn't taste that great. I'm lactose intolerant, so I really have to be the mood to buy ice cream. I was really exciting and I went with something safe, the apple pie ala mode. It just didn't taste right, and I ended up tossing half of it. I don't think I've ever thrown out ice cream in my life. Now it could have been just the wrong type, but it was bad enough that I could no longer finish it. I'm the child of immigrants, so throwing things away is difficult for me. I will not be buying from this establishment again. read more