We ordered via DoorDash because we were snowed in in Massanutten. We ordered a chicken cheesesteak, fries, buffalo wings (they were spicy, but good), garden salad, garlic breadsticks (yummy). The food was delivered HOT. We were so hungry that I didn't even think to get pictures.... would certainly recommend! read more

This IS my Go-To for Pizza, Stromboli and a good Greek Salad. The food IS always amazing and the service IS superb! read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Greek Salad w/ Oil and Vinegar - Pizza Near Me - Elkton, Virginia

See all

second time I've ate here and they next day my leftovers are all moldy. posted on the fact my food was moldy and had other people say the same thing happens., NASTY DONT RECOMMEND, go too ciros or something because they are going to get sombody real sick one day read more

Highly recommend this restaurant for Italian fast food. Our waitress was amazing. She pretty much served all other tables but was very patient and helpful. We food is very tasty too. We ordered a small Stromboli which was sufficient to feed 2 people and a cheese pizza slice which was simple but tasty. Pretty casual vibe. Our vegetarian friends ordered zita and loved it as well. We also took a to-go raspberry donut cheesecake from here and it was to die for. So amazing. Make sure you add the caramel and chocolate sauce as well. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Meatlovers Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Elkton, Virginia

See all

Do you want the good, the bad and the ugly??? Good...pizza Bad...not much room Ugly...They're closed on Sundays or their phone no longer works read more

Went to get a regular meal with the ole lady and come to find out they had a Monday special fettuccine Alfredo and let me tell you we loved it so much I would kiss the chef on the lips!! Also the waitress was amazing and very polite never let my drink run dry. read more

Pizza toppings not out to the edge. See pic. Not seasoned - bland Crust VERY hard to cut. Great service considering just one waitress Hard seats. Loud read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Meat lovers pizza +ricotta - Pizza Near Me - Elkton, Virginia

I have had takeout twice and finally have eaten in at Goodfellas! I was pleasantly surprised at such a great view of Elkton you have. Everything was bright and spotlessly clean. My server was wonderful. I visited a few minutes before opening time on the day of the car show. She welcomed me in even though they were technically not open. I have only ever had one dish at Goodfellas. Sorry I don't have a picture! It was absolutely delicious!! I had the steak and cheese sub with lettuce, tomato, and mayo on it. It was so fresh and perfectly plated. The lettuce was crisp and the tomato was red. This little place is not to be missed if you are in Elkton, VA and want something quick and yummy. It will not disappoint! read more

We've lived in the area for 5 years and never checked it out. Was craving pizza today so today was the day. We were not disappointed. The pizza is Napoletana style which features a thinish crust, light sauce and cheese. It was as good as we've had anywhere locally. Service was fantastic! I did not give a full 5 stars bc we didn't try anything else on the menu. We saw lots of great looking stuff coming to tables though...calzones, strombolis, subs...all looked good. The place is small inside and there's no outdoor seating. Sunday lunch was slammed bc of the after church crowd. No one seems to wait more than about 15-20 mins for a table though. read more

I loved this place before the pandemic. Quality has gone down but prices have gone sky high. The quality of their Parmigiano cheese is terrible. Sour at its best. How can you mess this up?. You have the best location in Elkton. Stop cutting quality on what is already the cheapest food to make. Improve on flavors, it doesn't take much. Does the owner ever eat here. You have great servers wanting to please everyone. The grilled chicken salad is fantastic. As a owner you should try all items. We need a great Italian sub. Don't try to make a fortune on a few. A sub and salad should not cost 50 bucks. No wonder the place was empty. I gave this 1 star only because of great service not food or price. read more

I wasn't expecting to find good pizza in Elkton, but this pizza warms my New York heart. I grew up in New York, I went to college in Connecticut, I know good pizza. Hard to get good pizza in Virginia, especially in this part. But this is good pizza. Greasy, delicious, and super tasty as pizza was meant to be. I am impressed. Quick service, friendly staff, and most importantly of all, delicious delicious pizza. Would highly recommend. read more

We ordered subs to take to a local brewery. The food was ready quickly and delivered to our car! The ingredients were fresh and delicious! Great experience! read more

It's a small mom and pop restaurant. You can pick up or dine in. The waitresses are really nice. The food is amazing for the price. The Stromboli are so cheesy and so delicious. The pizza and the fries are great also! read more

We called ahead on our way to Massanutten. The food is really delicious! We got the meat lovers and they did NOT hold back on the meats. Almost too much meat? Something to consider. Service was kind when we picked up. The place was busy so it seems to be very popular. Overall enjoyed. read more

Very friendly staff, and reasonable pricing. The greatest pizza I've ever had, no, but a solid pie. The garlic cheese bread was decent, not much garlic to it, and the dipping sauce was wholly forgettable. read more

This is one of our spots. Friendly staff and i like their pizza's and other options. Small with enough seating for maybe around 20 people give or take. Quite a bit of carry out. Parking can be a little tricky at times. read more

We just picked up our takeout from Goodfellas on a Friday night around 7:30 PM. Although they looked busy, our food was ready in 15-20 minutes, just like they said it would be. Their hot wings were extraordinary- some of the best we have ever had. Their stromboli was also delicious. I highly recommend this local pizza shop! P.S we are staying at the Massanutten Resort, only ten minutes away from this shop. read more

No way. Pizza was dry with no sauce. I literally should have bought breadsticks. I ordered 2 cheese pizzas and 2 pepperoni pizzas and it was regrettable. Don't waist your time or money!!!!! read more

Was in the area staying at Massanutten "resort" and was craving pizza! Found this place by way of yelp and was pleased it didn't disappoint. Pizza was ready quickly and was delicious, the whole family enjoyed it. We got 2 large Pepperoni Pizzas. read more

This is obviously a local hotspot and was busy the whole time we were there. The tables are quite tight. The food, while nothing spectacular, was good and came out as soon as it was done. This meant that we got our meals at separate times, but that didn't bother us. We had steak and cheese, fries, and the Stromboli. The highlight was the tomato sauce. We could've eaten just that and been happy read more

My family are owners at Massanutten and highly recommend this restaurant just 10 minutes away. Excellent pizza, steak and cheese, soups, salads and sandwiches! Friendly and accommodating waitress and everything on the menu is customizable! Definitely try it! read more

What a perfect spot to get lunch after a hike! The service was friendly, attentive & excellent. The kids each had a pasta dish which they raved about & cleaned their plates. I enjoyed the meatball parm sub and felt like I was back in NY. read more

extremely frustrated. I simply ordered an XL pizza and mozzarella sticks. I was told it would be ready in 25 minutes but I ended up waiting 40 minutes to only be told it would be 10 more minutes when I asked for an update. when I requested a refund I was told it was too late, the pizza was already in the oven... I replied, "it's been 40 minutes..." after walking back to the kitchen (and I assume talking with the cooks), I was given my refund in cash but no pizza or decent customer service at all. i wish I could simply speak to the owner to understand what the standards are. it's very rare that I complain at all but this warranted a negative review. read more

Pizza was wonderful and service was great! Everything was very clean. Would definitely recommend!!!

The pizza was very good and the service was excellent. The pizza came out quick and hot.

We stopped at Goodfellas for dinner on a Wednesday night. The inside has about 10 tables. Service was excellent. Food was excellent. We didn't even order pizza. read more

Was good food and very reasonably priced. We had five people and everyone enjoyed everything. The lasagna tasted fine but was just made differently than you would expect. I will go again read more

I don't go here often due to location proximity to my home but my local pizza place was closed. We ordered a Calzone and it was perfect! Just the right amount of cheese and "toppings" read more

Our family was staying at Massanutten resort and a few of us were looking for sine good pizza. Small restaurant but friendly staff. We ordered garlic bread sticks with sauce. Great starter. We shared a x-large pepperoni and sausage. Enough for 3-4 people. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - X-large pizza - Pizza Near Me - Elkton, Virginia

Delicious calzone and meatball sandwich. Lots of locals having lunch. Clean, fast, friendly, attentive service and they have nice little extras like extra sauce packed for our leftovers. Clean bathroom. read more

Called and placed an order and it was ready when they said. Friendly service and some good pizza and chicken tenders. I would definitely go again. read more

This place isn't a Michelin stared gourmet restaurant, but it does have "something for everyone" with friendly service. Go in expecting a small town pizza place, and your expectations will likely be exceeded. It is small inside, so all the tables may be full at busy times. The staff does a good job at prompt service and is very friendly and helpful. It's clean, including the bathrooms. The food is solid but not amazing. The pizza could be found anywhere, but is completely acceptable. There is a wide selection of sandwiches and subs, hot and cold. There are past options. Calzones and strombolis. Prices are extremely reasonable. The whole family can find something and you won't spend too much more than fast food. read more

Contrary to what information on this site says, they DO deliver, even at lunch time. Good pizza, subs, pizza rolls, grilled chicken salad. Convenient. read more

Goodfellas in Elkton Va. Is a great sub & pizza shop . You need to stop by if your in the area.

I love Goodfellas! they always get my order correct and it is so quick, easy and so yummy! i get food from here 4-5 times a month!! Highly recommended if you are in the Elkton/ Massanutten area! read more

Great food!! Amazing service!!! Our waitress is the same every time & she basically has our orders memorized!! Very sweet lady!! When you go, be sure to ask for Their Brown Sugar Icecream!! It's amazing!! read more

I love the fact that Goodfellas delivers. Unfortunately the food wasn't amazing. Our pizza toppings had come off the side on the pizza during travel. The pizza and wings weren't anything special. I had the Ruben with fries. They didn't toast the bread and the sandwhich completely fell apart. The fries were bland and they didn't send the ketchup that I asked for. Wouldn't recommend this restaurant. read more

Goodfellas Pizzeria - The pizza was a mess when it got to our hotel room - Pizza Near Me - Elkton, Virginia

I walk over here for a couple of slices of pizza once a week. I've had their Philly Cheese Steak and it was very good, also. The pizza is very good, and I will explore the rest of the menu in the future. read more

After being told that they could not deliver, despite advertising that they delivered, we agreed to place our order and pick it up. The lady on the phone was polite and friendly. Once we returned home, we realized that one of our subs was wrong. We ordered a steak and cheese wrap, no mayonnaise, add oil and vinegar. What we got was a steak and cheese special sub with mayonnaise. When I called to speak with the lady at the counter she told me, "oh it's probably just the cheese, not mayonnaise." She then proceeded to tell me that we didn't order a wrap, we ordered a sub, and to next time make sure that they understood what I was ordering before hanging up. In addition to the awful customer service, the only correct sub out of the bunch was mediocre at best, lacking any flavor or originality. read more

For $8 the ziti bolognese is a good value. The dish was served hot, hot, hot with a side of dinner rolls and butter. It was flavorful and filling. The server couldn't be nicer or more attentive. The food was a 3.5 and the service kicks it up to a 4. read more