This place is amazing. I am not sure if it is the crust, the sauce, the cheese, or all three, but…read moreI might have to drive over the mountains, every time I want delicious pizza, from now on. Nice and clean, very friendly staff and the food was ready pretty quickly. We ordered the Insalata caprese and a medium supreme pizza to share. The only thing that would have made it better, would have been some balsamic glaze for the insalata caprese. Balsamic vinaigrette just doesn't cut it.

We just ordered Carry out . It came within 20 minutes and the food was delicious and hot! The…read moregentleman on the phone who took our order was delightful as was the delivery person! My husband ordered the chef salad and I ordered the meatballs. Both were delicious.!!

New to the area and decided to check the local pizza places out. Tony's pizza by far has amazing…read morepizza compared to others! I always order takeout and have had very easy experiences every time. Will be trying more menu items in the future!

When you say Tony's Pizza and Italian Restaurant, you had best pronounce it as Eye-talian, like the…read morelocals do. Because in here you can get burgers and jalapeno poppers and bacon cheese fries and wing dings and Hawaiian pizza and sweet tea and every other sort of dive-bar food. And your kids can have grilled cheese with fries, or mac and cheese, or cheese pizza. Because we shouldn't, not even for a culinary moment, subject your kids to any cultural experiences beyond what Fishersville, VA can provide. Now there is an obscure law in Virginia, that says that "al dente" is some sort of Communist plot and not a way to cook pasta. As a result, just like every other Italian restaurant within 500 miles, the pasta is overcooked into a flabby, submissive state. You show that pasta who's boss, Virginia. The tomato sauce, as well, said nothing besides just tomato sauce; and the meatballs were more balls than meat. The wines come in Cabernet and a couple other colors, clearly decanted from boxes just minutes ago. I am not a picky fellow, but I just couldn't eat it. It was all just calories. I give two stars gladly for the help, who were just as polite as pizzeria pie, and talked all sorts of kindnesses to us from beginning to end. Understand: these are very sweet people running this place. But authentic Italians: please just don't eat here. You will be really sad and angry if you ignore this advice.

The pizza was delicious. This is exactly what I needed after a long day of hiking. I am picky about…read morepizza. I need a good thin crust, delicious sauce and enough cheese. This fit the bill. Also the tea tasted freshly brewed. All around a great experience.

Pizza was great. Would go back. Kids loved it also. Had the Hot Honey Pepperoni pizza and it was…read moregreat. I never give Five Stars to anything but their pizza was close, 4.5-4.8 easily.

This place has the best Pizza around. We drive an hour each way just to eat here. We haven't…read moregotten past the pizza yet but the Cheese Steak subs are next on our list to try. I have seen the ones they make that other customers are eating and they are huge! I can't wait to try one! They are in the process of updating the restaurant so look past that. Don't pass this place up! Give them a try, I guarantee you will not regret it!

I don't know what has happened to this place. It's disgusting. It used to be a great place to…read moreeat. We have been eating there for over 20 years. The entire place needs remodeled and a deep clean. No soap in the bathroom, all the salt and pepper shakers look like they have never been wiped down, the drink machine is gross, looks like no one there cares. The last two times we've had their steak and cheese it was less than 1/2 the steak it used to be. Takeout is a hit or miss. If you go inside to eat, close your eyes because it will make you sick looking around. Last evening was our absolute last time.

The pizza was awesome. The pasta dish was hot and very good. Large portions! Staff…read moreWas friendly and very good service. We will come back again when we're in the area.

Oh my god! This place is an unassuming put packs a flavor punch...we stopped in after hiking to…read moregrab water at Foodlion. We were enticed.by the Smells of magic wafting in the air... We've sent there twice and never been disappointed. Looking forward to going back next time we are passing through.

We ordered via DoorDash because we were snowed in in Massanutten. We ordered a chicken cheesesteak,…read morefries, buffalo wings (they were spicy, but good), garden salad, garlic breadsticks (yummy). The food was delivered HOT. We were so hungry that I didn't even think to get pictures.... would certainly recommend!

This IS my Go-To for Pizza, Stromboli and a good Greek Salad. The food IS always amazing and the…read moreservice IS superb!

My fiancé and I came to eat dinner here for my birthday. I'm originally from California and my…read morefiancé is from the area. We found them on yelp and it was amazing. The house made dough and sauce are really the star of the show. We LOVED the Augusta Margarita pizza. It's such a simple pizza but they absolutely nailed it. The staff were super friendly and lovely. We were there on a Sunday, so we got to sit outside. It was such a nice evening and the food was absolutely phenomenal. My fiancé is telling his family in the area about the place and when we come back to visit. We definitely plan on coming back.

Only a had pizza, so I can't comment on the beer experience; a large meat lovers to share. For…read moreso-claimed 'gourmet' pizza, I found the toppings very ordinary and not particularly generous. I expected more considering the ratings. It was good, but frankly my local bar/restaurant that serves pizza and beer is superior foodwise (actually, pizza-wise, is what I can claim to have an opinion about). Service was slow, albeit friendly. I think their kitchen may not be on the same floor. Thats gotta be inefficient. There were a couple musicians playing which was nice. Casual.

I'm probably rating this too high because I LOVE their calzones. This is my favorite place to get a…read morecalzone, I come here most years on my birthday. However, the rest of their food sucks, especially the appetizers. So if you go, I only recommend the calzone, but it will blow your mind if you're a calzone lover.

I ordered the Chicken Marsala at Scotto's Italian Restaurant in Waynesboro, Virginia without seeing…read morethe previous reviews first. After trying it, I wish I had read them beforehand because I would not have ordered it. I only ate two pieces before giving the meal back because it was that disappointing. The dish was very bland and lacked the rich flavor you'd expect from a proper Marsala sauce. The mushrooms tasted like canned mushrooms, which gave the dish a bitter taste and poor texture that really hurt the meal. I understand they are a small business, and I always try to support local restaurants. However, if you are serving food to the public, it still needs to be edible and meet a basic standard of quality. When I expressed my disappointment, they would not remove the item from my bill. Instead, they only offered a 10% discount, and I still had to pay for a meal I barely touched. Overall, a very disappointing experience.