Ever since our beloved to go to pizza spot burned down, my husband and I have been on the hunt for a good sit down pizza spot. So we finally gave Good Fellas Pizza a try and my goodness, why didn't we try them sooner? The pizza and wings were delicious!!! First off if you're anything like my husband and I who love oldies, you'll appreciate the ambiance. They have oldies playing in the back ground and the pictures with two tvs give a great add on. Kat helped us, and she was simply amazing, super friendly and a great person to have a conversation with, she made us feel right at home. We will definitely be back! Most people don't know: ***M-TH 5pm-closing they have a special: get 1 XL pizza with 1 topping for $16.99!!!*** **I know the parking for most people is a problem. But you can utilize the parking at TacoBell or KFC, they said they have no problem having costumers park there.** read more

See all

Get the slice special: two big slices of pepperoni pizza for around $6! Can't beat that. This is not really a sit-down restaurant; while they have a very limited amount of seats, you really just order at the counter and that's it. Get the food to go. read more

Food arrived cold.. I ordered for it to be a scheduled delivery by 6pm.. Cold food.. next time I think i wont order.. twice is frustrating enough.. The food is delicious but they cant follow simple instructions..u asked for thin crust.. I got thick.. I asked for utensils and plates cus im at a hotel.. and Both times they failed me. I GAVE YALL A SECOND CHANCE CUS YER DELICIOUS BUT I DONT LIKE EATING SPAGHETTI WITH MY HANDS.. maybe next time someone will give a hoot and put some utensils.. napkins.. and a plate or 2 for the hotel people man ITS NOT R9CKET SCIENCE.. U GOTS ONE JOB!! MAKE THE DINING EXPERIENCE WONDERFUL AND WHY do u send 20 packets of hot chili seeds.. but nothing else.. good lord.. are yall stoned in there? read more

Service is great! Really nice people. Pizza is good and I really like the wings and their onion rings here. They have a lot flavor. Yesterday when picking up our pizza I noticed they added fried oreos! They were delicious! Perfect dessert for me. Next time I'll try their churros and ice cream but I love my oreos!! read more

Good Fellas Pizza - Fried oreos on the menu. Im hooked! Yumm.. - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

Pizza is yummy Subway yummy Cashier Kat so friendly Love the vibe Price affordable read more

See all

The pizza is no doubt a 10/10! The service is great and Kat was an amazing person to talk to. I've been coming here for about 2 months and i absolutely love it. The atmosphere is very calming and made me feel right at home. A great place to chill and eat food read more

While it was nice that they were able to accommodate a customization of a pizza, when it arrived at my house it looked like this. The toppings were not evenly spread out and the bottom of the slices were burnt black. Usually the pizza here is pretty good but this was extremely disappointing. Paying nearly $30 for this pizza was not worth it if I was going to get burnt pizza and toppings mostly on one side of the pie. read more

Good Fellas Pizza - Veggie pizza with alfredo sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

I am honestly not a big pizza person because I always feel like most places taste the same, but I decided to try Good Fellas Pizza today and I was so surprised at how good it was! The crust and sauce were perfect, and the veggies/meats tasted super fresh and flavorful. The lemon pepper wings were also delish! Good Fellas Pizza was definitely some of the best I've had in a while. The place itself is really cool too. I called to place my order and when I arrived I didn't realize you could actually sit inside, and it has a nice, relaxed vibe with cool stuff hung up. The girl working at the front was so sweet and welcoming, which made the whole experience even better. For someone who usually doesn't care much for pizza, this spot definitely changed my mind. I would 100% order from here again! read more

See all

Nice little spot for pizza in Whittier. The food here was really good. Our party of 5 ordered 2 Large Pepperoni pizzas, a dozen buffalo wings and the chicken Alfredo pasta. The pizza was delicious as it had great sauce, pepperonis and cheese. The crust was also good, crispy with a lil fluff. The buffalo wings were covered in a good amount of sauce and were crispy. The chicken Alfredo was also good as it came with a good amount of diced up chicken and sauce, not too dry but not over doing it with the sauce. Theres also a freezer where you can grab bottled drinks from (no alcohol is served here from what I could see.) Service is simple there. You place your order and pay at the front, grab a seat at a table somewhere and they bring it to you. Ambiance was cool as they have a lot of goodfellas/mafia styled portraits all around along with a couple of TV's to watch some movies while you eat. Just cool mafia decor everywhere. It's not too big of a place and decently sized. Only thing I couldn't find was the restrooms as it's decently sized at this location and I didn't see a parking lot for it. I don't recommend parking in the nearby restaurant parking lots as they might tow you. There's parking out in the front on Whittier blvd or near the local neighbor behind. Overall, I would recommend this place for anybody in the mood for some pizza. Good pizza by Goodfellas. read more

See all

Good pizza. Really good wings. But it's been several times now where I want to order delivery and their door dash is closed for orders. I get when it's close to closing time but they say they're open until 9pm and I was trying to place an order at 7:10pm. Pizza is a late night classic, but I can never order from here due to this. read more

I've been driving by this new pizza spot since it's close to my house and decided to pick up a pizza. I chose the house favorite The Don Corleone, It came with pepperoni, sausage, and jalapeño. Wow, this pizza was delicious, well crafted, and bursting with flavors. I also ordered the potato's wedges, which were also very good! The decor was Goodfellas theme with exceptional customer service that was very friendly, welcoming, and attentive. I think we found our new favorite pizza spot, we'll definitely be back and tell others!! read more

See all

Great pizza'! 2 strikes. No regular forks (only plastic) and don't come here if you need to pee. No restroom for customers.

Loved that they sell pizza by the slices. These were hearty slices too. I think it was between $8-10 for 2 slices k can't remember by they heat them up and add a sprinkle of fresh mozzarella, that was a nice touch. Would definitely recommend to try and stop by. I found a spot of parking in the street right in front of the store. Also something is definitely special about their crust lol. I loved how fresh it was, kinda reminded me of sourdough. read more

See all

First time trying this place. We ordered the appetizer platter with bacon wrapped onion rings, stuffed jalapeños, and buffalo wings. We also ordered a pepperoni pizza. The pizza was our favorite. Service was ok and the ambiance was nice. They were bumping the oldies which was pleasant for me. read more

Food was very tasty. Facility clean. The staff friendly. Parking can be a challenge unless you park and walk. read more

Delicious!!!! Fast!! Pizza, the pizza was hot and ready to eat. Customer service is great delivery person is great. We order from here all the time number one spot Forrest. read more

I really wanted to love this place. The inside is so cool. I love the movie decor! The service was fantastic, the staff were friendly and helpful but I have to be honest, the food lacked flavor. The jalapeño poppers had good flavor, but weren't spicy and didn't have any heat to them at all. The spaghetti wasn't too bad, just your basic spaghetti and marinara. The garlic knots were good, but the pizza was very bland. There wasn't enough sauce on it and the sauce lacked seasoning and flavor. The consistency of the cheese was chewy, almost as if it cooled, but we were eating it hot. It looked good and I was so excited, but I ended up pretty disappointed. We also got the wings which weren't bad, but I've had better. Overall, I wouldn't say this place is worth the money. I've had better at dominos. That's saying a lot, cause I've had the best pizza in Manhattan, and I'm still on the hunt for something around here that's comparable. This one was just a miss for me. read more

See all

This is probably the best pizza I've had in a long time. Lots of taco spots in town and lots of pizza spots too but Good Fellas is different but definitely in a good way. All the ingredients taste fresh. The cheese used is delicious and the chicken wings and jalapeño poppers were delish too. Service was friendly and fast. The dining room (though small) was very clean and comfortable. Like I said there are A LOT of choices here in Whittier but I highly recommend that you seek this place out and give it a try! read more

See all

My first time here I got the basic stuff . It was good but I would have to come back and order from menu they have at the restaurant read more

See all

This is almost the worst pizza. The quality of the cheese is cheap. There was barely any sauce and the little bit of sauce that was on the pizza had no flavor. The pizza crust was overloaded and over powered with oregano or rosemary. The meatball sandwich was also a major disappointment, the sauce and the meatballs were flavorless. The only positives is that they use fresh mushrooms and the Chicken Wings were good. I would order the wings again but not the pizza. read more

We came here for some quick pizza before our kids' bed time. We ordered the last two single slices on display for the kids and they didn't give them to us until our entire order was ready 30 min later. Customer service was lacking. Side note they said they didn't have a restroom so our poor 3 year old daughter had to go outside and use the bushes before she had an accident on their floor. Apparently they're not kid friendly. read more

Very nice spot ambiance is nice inside I like the food and I would recommend trying the wings service is fast and employees are nice

Just ordered from DoorDash and their pizza is delicious! Will be ordering again soon!

Loved the food. The pizza tasted great even the next day. I'd diffenrly go back! The dining area is pretty small but that's alright

Amazing pizza dough ! Amazing crust ! Reminds me of Dominoes back when it first started and thick crust was thick and soft crunch . This location burned my first pizza and had to wait 20 minutes more to remake it . I was bummed and disappointed, but when I got home, the pizza was nice and gooey so fresh so tasty as I mentioned above it took me back. I think this is the best pizza in Whittier. read more

Pizza is good, not great. Pizza was soggy and not cooked enough, but the taste of the sauce and cheeses was very good. Service was bad. I ordered online and when I went to pick up the order, the lady at the counter was giving me the wrong order. I told her it was wrong because I had ordered two pizza's and a salad and she was giving me one pizza and wings. After arguing with her for almost 3 minutes, the customer behind me said that it was his order. So after waiting another 10 minutes, I got my order. When I got home they had given me the wrong dressing, and made the salad wrong. Overall, I'm being generous with a 3 stwr review. I probably won't be going back. read more

It was okay. They have a nice deal to get a huge slice of pizza and soft drink for $5. The people working the place are nice and pleasant. Pizza itself is 5/10. read more

Good Fellas Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

It was our first time trying this place. Great service, great food and fair price. We'll definitely be back.

Ohhhhhh Maaan!!!! That was Good Fellas!!!! I like to support local restaurants and I'm glad I came across this pizza joint. I enjoy a good crust, most reviews talk about it, they were right. It's crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. What more can you ask for? I also read about the single slices... I guess people really enjoy that 3 people were there for that in the short time I was there. I ordered the works. It has everything!!! Cheese, Ham, pepperoni, Italian sausage, onion, tomato, mushrooms, pineapple, bell pepper, and olives,(I subbed for Jalapeno's) it's an explosion of flavor. The sauce they use is delicious and blends everything perfectly. It was surprisingly not greasy. They loaded this pie up!!!I mean LOADED!!!you will need both hands. I ordered over the phone and the young lady said 20 minutes I got there in exactly 20 min, 2 min later I saw my pizza coming out of the oven. I also ordered jalapeño poppers, and wedges, they were both crispy and delicious. I was given plenty of pepper and cheese to go. I will definitely be back. I definitely encourage you to come try this place. read more

Good Fellas Pizza - The works - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

The people are nice but this place just doesn't work for me. I picked it up in store and even though they had just opened, it just didn't feel "ready." The font is cool for the building. The website is hard to navigate-- ended up having to call my order in like it's 1987. My husband and I ordered a medium two-topping pizza and it just tasted like the separate pieces. Hard to describe but nothing was like "OMG DELICIOUS. I CANT WAIT TO EAT THIS AGAIN." Meh, at best. Skipable for me, but I'd be willing to try again.. read more

Great food,great amphitheater for being a lil pizza spot me and the wife loved would be going back,also great service and clean

I was interested to try out the new local pizza spot in Whittier, Good Fellas. They have a $5 slice and medium soda special! They offer a wide variety of pizza and food options like salads, fried chicken, mozzarella sticks, spaghetti, potato wedges, bacon wrapped wings and more! Now let's talk about the classic pepperoni, it was so delicious. Hands down one of the best I've tasted. It was the perfect temperature, Cheesy, the crust was crunchy and had a delicious garlic, buttery seasoning. The mozzarella sticks are fried without the average breading, an outer texture like that of a spring roll, it was great! Staff is friendly and the ambiance lives up to its name with the Good fellas movie playing and some Frank Sinatra tunes in the background. There's indoor seating only, quaint yet spacious. Will definitely be back! read more

Good Fellas Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

A good slice of pizza. Friendly service and a good meatball sandwich. The bread was well toasted, cheesy. Sauce on pizza and sandwich is tangy. Pepperoni is curled up with a spice kick to it. They had some classics playing from the 80's. Fries were okay. Just standard frozen fries that could have used some salt. The Meatball is seasoned well and has a nice firm bite. The cheese is pretty standard, but it was stretchy. Parking could be difficult to find. A pizza and drink is $5 and Meatball Sub was $7.99. read more

See all

When it comes to pizza in Whittier I'm Pizzamania all the way but Goodfellas is going into my rotation going forward. I'm not saying they're the same, but Goodfellas is good and I'll be back. Their slices are big thin crust with a garlic buttery flavor on the crust. It reminds of me the type of delicious pizza I'd find stumbling around downtown LA at midnight after hitting a few bars. It's dope to have an option like this in Whittier. So all you pizza nerds and winos looking for a good slice give this place a try I guarantee your satisfaction. read more

Good Fellas Pizza - Satisfied customer - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

My pizza goto was closed on Tuesday so I gave goodfellas a try. Order was ready as promised. There was a little seating area but not much, Service was good and on time. Pizza itself was a bit undersized for the price. Taste was ok. Good in a pinch read more

Good Fellas Pizza - Pepperoni and mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

PLEASE READ! THIS PIZZA IS DELICIOUS!!! I was originally going to go to KFC which is a business and a small street over and I saw the sign on their window for a giant slice and drink special for $5! I mean how could I pass that up! Upon entering it is brand new so it smells like new and super clean! I ordered the pepperoni and got a side of ranch and they were super nice and they had wrote thank you on the box and I couldn't wait to get home to try it! The pizza: the crust is crunchy on the outside and very soft on the inside the flavor of the crust is perfect. It's sweet buttery deliciousness and they add what taste like garlic butter. The pepperoni was delicious and cooked so perfect there's places where the pepperoni has like a weird eggy aftertaste but not this one. It was delicious and perfect saltiness. The cheese and sauce were to die for the sauce is garlicky and the sweetness from the tomatoes make it oh so savory! I savored every bite and I cannot wait to go back! read more

See all

Great little pizza shop located on Whittier and Greenleaf. Their $6.99 pizza slice and drink special cannot be beat. They literally give you two slices of pizza! Their potato wedges are crispy and well seasoned. Throw in the cool mafia movie decor and I'm a fan. read more

Good Fellas Pizza - $6.99 pizza and drink special plus order some of wedges - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California

Very prompt service. I parked on Whittier Blvd. and had to wait a bit to exit the car due to the traffic. I ordered the two slice + drink special to go. Wow, the cheese pizza was excellent! I need to order a whole pie next time. read more

I stopped here for lunch I'm not from this area just came down for work for the week , I gotta say probably one of the best pizzas I've tried! We don't have great tasting pizzas like yours ! Definitely will be stopping by again if im ever in the area . read more

Pizza taste horrible very poor quality wet and mushy cheap toppings wouldn't eat from here again pizza was disgusting read more

Good Fellas Pizza - Medium pizza - Pizza Near Me - Whittier, California