SUPER STORE!!! It's a wonderful new addition that's close to home. The staff is very helpful and knowledgeable too. Make sure to check out their cheeses, they're too die for! read more

The only reason I didn't give this place 5 stars was because they told me they had ordered me a beer for pickup and it wasn't there. If you've gone to beer distributors they are mostly disgusting places. It's almost shocking how bad these places can be. Gary's changes that mold completely. I'm reviewing based on the beer selection. It is MASSIVE. They have SO many different styles including 6 packs, 24, singles and big bottles. Also the best prices I've ever seen in a beer distributor. The staff is very knowledgeable and they are open pretty late. If only more places would take a lesson from these guys, they have the liquor/beer store PERFECT. They even do tastings on Thursdays. If only they didn't blow up my mailbox so much that would be nice. They offer a loyalty program that has NO discounts what so ever. I go there sometimes twice a week, it would be nice to have a reward program where that offers discounts Gary! read more

Gary's has to be my favorite store for all things wine and champagne. Though the location is super convenient I'll often go out of my intended way to stop here. The pricing is just as fantastic as the quality of wines that Gary procures. The staff has always been helpful when we needed a suggestion or two..bonus points if you get to speak with Gary himself! Their beer selection is quite large and they have a fair amount of desirable craft brews. They carry bombers, six packs, cases. I've also found the staff in this section to be pretty helpful and knowledgeable. The liquor section has plenty of spirits to choose from. There are a few brands I wish they would carry but the excellent pricing makes up for it. Let's not forget the deli counter with delicious sandwiches and cheeses, and be sure to browse the specialty crackers, chips and other goodies! Love it! read more

Absolutely the best customer service, especially Jessica at the cheese station, amazing person.

From a craft beer and hard liquor perspective, this giant liquor store is underwhelming. While wine is all well and good, I'm all about beer and hard liquor. They do have pretty good craft beer, via rotating heavy-ups on seasonal items, but honestly I expected more. 18 feet of shelf of 22ozz bottles and good six-packs plus assorted other items spread out over two rows - just not enough for me. I'm the type of guy who can walk into a craft beer store and spend $80 if I find good stuff - in the few times I've been here, it's been under $20. It's just not enough quality and selection, and what they do have they have in 2-3 places on the floor and in the cold case. In the liquor segment, I love to look at flavored vodka to see selection. Here again, just not great. Lots of standard vodkas, just flavored options weren't there. Their whiskey selection was good, I just know that for a place this big I'd hope it could meet my needs for hard liquor as well, and it can't. The only reason I'm giving 3 over 2 is that the store is huge, clean, neat, and does have a big wine selection. That's just not what I'm looking for though. read more

This place has a great selection of wines, beers, and liquors. The gourmet food section is an added bonus. Also, the people who work here are very helpful read more

WOW snooty cashier today. She was busy at one station so she called for another cashier. I unloaded my bottles at the second station and after no one came (as usual), she told me to move all my bottles to her station. I asked why cant you check me out over here? She replied in a nasty tone, "because I am HERE!". So I moved all my bottles to the other station. She then COLDLY checked me out. If this is how I am going to be treated from now on I will return to Total Wine and More, (which has slightly lower prices anyway). read more

This is one of my favorite liquor stores around. I will go out of my way to go here instead of one of the many other places around. Here's why: The staff is always very friendly. More than once I've been approached by staff when I was browsing to see if they could assist me in finding or recommending something. The layout of the store makes it easy to navigate through and there is always something new to check out. Often times they'll have samplings or some other special near the front door. The wine tastings. Hello! I like any place that's going to let me sample before I buy. Besides that, they often have cheese and crackers or chocolate out to sample as well. If you're stuck in traffic on 23 N any time of the day (which is very likely), I highly recommend you stop in and browse around. You're guaranteed to leave with something (or many things) in hand! read more

Gary's Wine & Marketplace has been through an internal reorganization with personnel in regards to beer stocking and sales. A few important things to note: - They will still secure sixtels and kegs for purchase, however, costs appear to be 10$ higher now than before. Looks like they are trying to make things up with higher profit margins. Its still nice that they can get any type of keg though, as long as distributors stock it. - Generally, they used to have slightly cheaper case pricing (a buck or 2 off) when purchasing 2 12-packs. Does not appear to be the case anymore. Bummer. read more

Where do I begin. 2 weeks ago I hosted a welcome back function, and figured what better way to welcome in the summer and everyone back into each other's lives, than a wine tasting. These guys, in particular Chris, killed it. They did an amazing job. They brought 5 different wines, 2 chards, 2 cabs, and a rose, all under 15 dollars for us to sample. Way to go guys. read more

As an uneducated and reluctant wine shopper, I have shocked myself by enjoying this place. The best thing about it is the employees. They seem sincerely happy with their jobs. The store reflects their hard work, it is scrupulously clean and visually pleasing. Employees ask if you need assistance without being pushy. I like being left alone, but when I've needed it, they were helpful. Prices are reasonable and their food selection is great. (The clean restrooms are a plus, too). read more

The TRUMP of wine warehouses This guy is a real shyster. First, no case discounts. But that's OK. I bought a nice wine priced $31. At checkout, the receipt said I saved $8 on the bottle. I asked the cashier about that and he said the wine "really" cost $39 even though the price on the bin was $31. OK. The really slimy thing was that I saw the "25% off (or more) on all 750ml bottles in the store" in an email and posters outside the store. I went back to buy more and the wine was priced $28. If you're not good at math, go there because you will feel great about saving 25%. Others should avoid. Not even Total Wine is that creative with their fake savings. read more

If you're looking for a specific wine, this is the place to go. They have a very large selection and the employees can always help you find what you're looking for. They also carry beer/liquor, but I find their prices to be a couple dollars more expensive than your average liquor store. read more

Great prices and selection, staff are very knowledgable, Gary the owner is often there and very friendly and helpful.

We were in Wayne doing some car shopping and came across Gary's while on our way home. Being a fan of upscale grocery stores we gave it a try. Great selection of Wine and Liquor as well as the requisite glassware and accessories. They also have a pretty decent beer selection down the far end of the store. They had the two beers that I was looking for (DFH Namaste & Ithica Flower Power) Yay!! Their prices were a little better than what I'm used to paying. I was also able to pickup a nonic pint glass for only $3.50. HalfTime is still top of the list in my book (plus it's closer to home for me) I do wish that they could sell Wine, Liquor and Beer in the same store in NY, but oh well. I would def go back to Gary's if I found myself on Rt. 23 in the future. Bueno!! read more

Very Poor Delivery Service! Ordered 3 times from Gary's Wine in Wayne and it always takes over 6 hours on Delivery even if you order early in the day! When you call all they have is one excuse after another: short staffed, someone out sick, not sure why driver is taking so long etc. This is Poor Customer Service to paying Customers who should receive good service! read more

Let me be clear, Garys has a great selection. Whoever orders their wine does a great job, a little pricey bu the wines are there. Im ok with spending an extra dollar or two for wines that are hard to find. They however seem to think they're the only store in the area. when i go up to the counter with 30 -40 bottles in my cart and they don't ask if im ion their wine club it kinda pisses me off. that's probably occurred 80% of the time. So i have to ask, that is when i remember. If i inquire about a wine that's in the $10-15 range not uncommon to hear "that wines only 1199 we haven't had that in year. You know what Gary's ill take my $20,000/ yr wine budget elsewhere. we're done. Any one of the stores i go to will give me the same 20% markdown on a case off prices that are already lower, and they're happy to order a case of whatever i like. Any store in NJ is able to get wines that are available in NJ. My buddy Julio at Fairway will get whatever i like and stock it in the store. if i want the case i buy it or someone else will. no snooty wine clerks and quite frankly that have a great selection. Theres another great store in Secaucus, and then total wine in River edge. Garys was convenient but they can kiss my ass. read more

So I wasn't happy after my visit last week tonight I went to drink one of the beers I bought a 6 pack of. Well the enjoy by date on the bottle was in April it was purchased in June. Seriously not happy! read more

Gary's Buy Rite - Bought in June! Enjoy by date was April - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Gary's is a place I have been frequenting for years, way before he opened this Wayne location. This one is awesome. Huge inventory of wine and a great little market area with specialty food and cheese items. Anything you can't find they will order for you. No better wine knowledge in the area if you need help picking a wine. Great place, top shelf. read more

Have only been to the Wayne location once but they appear to have a great selection and prices are fair. They mixed up a phone order and it was a real 'rookie error' - not something I would have expected from a serious wine purveyor, which they seem to be. However, their management really did the right thing in how they corrected the problem so I give them kudos for that. Wasn't impressed by the store personnel on the floor but I guess as some companies grow they lose some control of the details. All in all - good. read more

This was my first time at a Gary's Wine. I do not drink alcohol so I used my gift card to buy sandwiches. I went here on a Thursday at noon in April. The deli area was clear of any customers. I ordered a Grilled Chicken Pesto sandwich. I was given a choice of bread. I brought the finished product to the cashier and paid. It tasted good but I would characterize the meal as small in quantity. On a June Thursday at noon, I ordered the Prosciutto & Mozzarella sandwich on Ciabatta roll. It was a bit tough to bite through. read more

Gary's Buy Rite - Sandwich menu - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Why would you buy wine anywhere else? Selection, price, customer service are flawless. It's more than wine, it's wine with integrity! Number in the country by far!!! read more

Fantastic selection of wine and craft beers. Knowledgeable staff. The market section has some unusual cheeses that I can't find anyplace else. Also some interesting sausages. read more

Ordered online for curbside pickup, received confirmation email and text, pulled up to the curb, and order was placed in trunk within 3 minutes of arrival. Thank you Gary's for limiting exposure during the Covid crisis, and for making this experience seamless. To all the employees, stay safe and stay well! read more

This is a great wine market. In addition to having a very large selection of wine, beer, and spirits, the employees are very knowledgeable and are always around to help you pick out an amazing wine. Plus, they have a sampling bar where you can ask to sample various types of wine. They also have a decent selection of cheese, crackers, salsa and things like that. read more

Wonderful wine selection; Frank is extremely knowledgeable and always helps me find the perfect selection for gifts.

Great selection. Great prices. The employees are knowledgeable. And they usually have the item I am looking for in stock.

Got some wine for New Year's Eve by default - HAD to pick them up at Gary's. I knew I shouldn't have but I was rushing to go to a dinner party and the family asked me to pick them up. I picked up a case of wine and by the time I got to the party one of the RED bottles had broken! Gary's didn't put any dividers between the bottles when they packed them! My car was a mess and I was embarrassed! The other wines were all sticky and covered with red wine, so I ran to a liquor store in Millburn and forked over the money to replace the wines! I'm sure the family would never have asked me to, but there was NO WAY that I was showing up to their New Year's eve party with wine covered wine! Shame on you Gary's! read more

We primarily go here for wine, as friends of ours live in Wayne, so occasionally we'll also get beer or liquor. As for their wine selection, it's robust and my husband has fell in love with wines from Gary's thanks to their tastings, which are quite often. I found the staff very helpful and knowledgeable. Usually when I go to a big box liquor store they only try to sell me what they need to push, whereas Gary's spends time with me to ensure I get just what I'm looking for. The prices are reasonable and it's a bonus to have the marketplace there with cheeses, meats, crackers, etc. It's a happy place for any wine lover! read more

A+ for selection but there prices are about 10-20% higher on liquor than most other local liquor stores Ive been in. I love there food selection and they have the best prices in the area on cold cuts other than BJ's read more

TERRIBLE customer service. I recently ordered 6 bottles of wine from the online store but was sent 12 bottles of wine instead. I promptly called customer service to alert them of this error and a rude sales associate (who made me feel as if I was bothering her) informed me that they would send a box & mailing label for the return. I received the box but no return label! I called Gary's again and was met with yet another rude sales associate. Having had enough of her rude attitude, I pointed out that I had not once been thanked for calling nor had I been offered an apology for the inconvenience I incurred. The sales lady asked condescendingly, "What inconvenience? You put the wine in the box and close the box." Unbelievable. I had to lug the extra bottles up to my apt, make numerous phone calls to rectify THEIR MISTAKE and then lug the bottles BACK down and to the post office. WHAT INCONVENIENCE? ARE YOU KIDDING ME?! Needless to say, I will never order from Gary's again... Instead I will continue to patronize other more professional sites such as WTSO.com. I can see why people prefer to deal with bigger operations - you get more professionalism and better customer service. LESSON LEARNED. read more

We got our rehearsal dinner and wedding reception wines, liquor, and beer from Gary's and it was a fantastic experience! The wines recommended by the assistant manager Jonathan were great. He just knew what to do and got things done competently, unlike some other vendors. Wines were delivered to 2 different locations with no problem (with $100 minimum to each place). The reception restaurant had our whites and beers perfectly chilled. Their prices were also very reasonable. The only minor thing is the delivery time was several hours earlier than told, but we happened to be home, so that worked out fine. read more

Fantastic wine and cheese store . I found a cheese that I've been looking for a wile . Very great selection . Organic Italian semolina pasta . Olive oils . Great store !!! read more

By FAR the best wine / liquor store I've been to in a long time. Wonderful selection of interesting wines to try. Great craft beer section. Lots of unique snacks for parties. A great cheese department! Always something new here. Def a 5 star stop. read more

I must say I have been going to bottle king for a number of years, but about 2 years ago I started going to Gary's mostly because of the great customer service and selection of beer/wine that just out does BK. If you have any questions on wine selections this place is simply the best. They are knowledgeable and professional. Go here! I promise you will not be disappointed. read more

Placed an online order recently. I made sure I only ordered items in stock. Got an email confirming the order and advising it should ship in 2 days. My credit card was immediately charged. 5 Days later I called customer service and was told they were just catching up with orders from 5 days ago, located my order, assured me that everything was in stock and it would ship that day. 3 days later and after trying to reach customer service via phone and email several times to no avail, I simply replied to the order confirmation email asking they cancel the order. Later that day, I start getting emails and phone calls from customer service apologizing for the mistake and explaining that they never had half of the items I ordered to begin with and offering to allow me to come to the store and pick up the other half the order I placed over a week ago. I get that everyone is ordering online due to the coronavirus but if a store is going to close and only allow pick up or delivery they should ensure their infrastructure and staff can handle the volume of orders they are accepting. Not only did they screw up this order, their rep lied to me and said everything was in stock and would ship that day when that absolutely wasn't the case. I used to shop at Gary's regularly and spend a considerable amount of money each month on good wine. Not any longer. I'll never shop at Gary's again. read more

Fantastic selection of wine of course, but also a pretty good beer selection. The wines are varied and of high quality, and the staff can help pick out good ones. The wine and meat samples are also a nice touch. My favorite part though is the beer where they have a nice selection of craft and some rarer beer like trappists and lambecs. read more

Place has gone down hill... bottle king and total wine have a better options don't waste your time

Absolutely the biggest and best. A step above you're average liquor store. Cheese station. Fine meat station. Staff that recommends some of the best wines you can find in whatever price range you're looking in. Just the best of the best for a liquid store in their area. The madison NJ store is also very good. read more

The customer service at Gary's Wine and Marketplace is exceptional ! The staff was warm and friendly, not to mention extremely helpful. Everyone at Gary's went above and beyond to make sure I was completely satisfied. I was hugely impressed with their selection of liquor, wine, and craft beer. Additionally, their prices are very reasonable. I will absolutely visit Gary's again and would highly recommend them ! read more