This place has really gotten sloppy and careless. Like they just don't give a shit about the quality of their food leaving the facility. I have had every single order from there recently in the last few months been completely wrong or horrible quality. Burnt pies. Over done fries. Just a couple examples. And when you complain, the owner doesn't even hold his employees accountable or himself for that matter. I will gladly go out of my way for better quality and customer service. read more

Gallery Pizza - Well done and under seasoned fries. - Pizza Near Me - Erial, New Jersey

See all

Ordered a chicken cheesesteak hoagie came with no tomato or lettuce. Chicken wings were just ok. The French were good.

Has always been my favorite pizza spot but the last two deliveries have been delivered cold. The driver doesn't even walk up with the insulated cases, just the Pizza box in hand. read more

Quaint local pizza joint. Ordered a cheesesteak with onions, peppers and mushrooms, a panzoratti and fries. The cheesesteak was good and was enough for two. The bread was nice and soft. I would ask them to toast it a little next time to give it more consistency. My wife said the panzoratti was great. Like and inside out plain pizza and the friends were good. Overall great lunch items, service and quick turnaround. I will definitely check out other menu items when in the area. read more

I love coming here for a slice of pizza at lunch. There is always a broad selection of slices and the prices are extremely reasonable. The service is friendly and quick and the restaurant is very clean. read more

Nice experience. Placed order via phone friendly , helped substitute my order. Picked up order and it was ready . I would give it a five stars but I wasn't able to get two toppings I wanted. Pie was hot and tasty . read more

Ordered white sicilian with no oregano on 9/18/24. Don't know what the issue is, owner not around perhaps? The inconsistency of the quality of the pizza is making me search for somewhere else. Considering the pizza was $28, I dont think that's an unreasonable expectation. The crust was precooked then cheese on top, which was lighter amount than normal. Never saw the crust done like this before. Ricotta amount was good. However no oregano does not mean no garlic. Gonna be awhile before I give them another chance. read more

fast service...great food...never disappoints....and the place is always clean..love it!

I had pizza for lunch today in the Marlton area - one of my top 5's and remembered that I forgot to review Gallery. Twice I've had their take out at my man's family's house. Twice - YUMMMM! Mind you, I USUALLY do NOT like Sicilian pie. But, what do you do when that's all that's offered? YOU EAT IT! This Sicilian is THE BEST I've ever had! The bottom crust isn't greasy or nasty like I'm used to. I couldn't believe it! I'm curious to try their other menu items; however, I love pizza so much that I'd be hard pressed to try anything else! read more

They have amazing pizza here! Fries are good! Pasta dinners are delicious, comes with salad and bread!! Worth a trip!! read more

I ordered a salad with some added things. There was an extra charge for it, and I wasn't given the extra things in myself horrendous

Gallery is our go-to for excellent Sicilian pie! The sauce is awesome n crust just right.

I would NOT recommend this pizzeria: Gallery Pizza in Erial, NJ. This is my WHAT slice looked like when I opened the box!!! I ordered a pizza with mushrooms. They said it would 15 mins. My husband & I were out in the parking lot when we ordered. We entered 10 minutes later. The pizza was cold. It must have been on display. They threw mushrooms on them. It's very obvious that they were not heated up within the pizza. Their pizza sauce is dreadful. Dont buy from this Place. Travel a couple of miles and go some place else. I will NEVER return. This place deserves a Negative 5 as a rating!!! What a waste on money and time. Shame on you and the Managers that allowed this to happen. read more

Gallery Pizza - I would not recommend this pizzeria: Gallery Pizza in Erial. - Pizza Near Me - Erial, New Jersey

Make sure you order from the correct location. I f'd up, but there was no incentive to return. Money lost and it seems the bottom line is more important. Maybe they can call the number that was listed to check in ... that might help another patron. read more

We really enjoy the pizza here. Service is always good. We usually do take out but I have come in for lunch from time to time. Dining area is set up like a pizza parlor. Try the Canoli there. read more

Really Gallery, waited over an hour for a single order of a pizza. Arrives cold not Luke warm, tepid, room temperature, but cold. Paid almost 30 bucks. And it was just plain nasty after I had to heat it up in the microwave. Sauce tasted like someone empties a can of dice tomatoes and American cheese on it. That's you helped me make my decision on buying a pizza oven. How worse could it be. read more

Honestly i wouldnt even feed this food to my dog if you can even call it food. This is not it Gio smh do better. I realized i shouldve never went to this dump, they suck at making pizza and they suck at customer service. How this place has been open for so long i have no clue but trust me Gio i could give two fucks if u dont me to eat that rat poison u call food. read more

Always a great pizza or cheesesteak or Hoagie. Fast service. Only had one issues when I ordered online but they made my sandwiches fast so I can't complain. read more

Best pizza in Sicklerville hands down. Cheese slices are great as are the Sicilian. Fantastic wings to boot

This business has been here many years and I thought their pizza was simply the best but there must have been an ownership change or perhaps staff changes due to Covid or workers deciding that they can do better financially by staying home and collecting "free stuff" from the new socialist agenda but their product quality has slipped considerably in the past year prompting me to try other options. read more

Been ordering here for a while now. Today I'm suddenly out of their delivery range. 1.8 miles. 6 minutes. Person on phone says sorry about that. read more

The food here is good. Not over the top great, but good. The customer service however, apart from the cashiers, who are totally fine, is deficient. I don't expect the current owners to know me. But I have been buying here for many years and I do not enjoy the chilly, indifferent demeanor of the current operators, who turn out food that is good. Not over the top great. Sorry to say so. read more

Great food, everyone is friendly, best pizza in town. I would recommend going to Gallery Pizza in Erial.

Not sure about the food, but if you like being on hold, this is your place. My first phone call I was hold for 4 minutes, I hung up. My wife ordered her food from another store. I called again and was on hold for 4 and a half minutes. I went to get my wife's food and while in the car, just to see how long I would be on hold I let the call go. Got her food, got home, made a sandwich, had a drink. It was good. 38 minutes later they picked up the phone. 38 minutes. Lmao. I don't know about the food, but this place obviously doesn't want my business. read more

Outstanding pepperoni pizza and an outstanding grandmothers pizza both pies were cooked to perfection best local pizza shop in the Gloucester Township area read more

I haven't been here since I was a kid. So 20 years ago. We did a drive by happy birthday for my grandmother from PA. We decided to get Sicilian as a throw pizza. It was delicious!!! Just like 20 years ago :) read more

After a night of absolutely no sleep and a full long day of work all I could think about was food and bed. Fortunately for me the gallery is on my way home from work. Tonight I ordered a Manicotti dinner that came with a salad and garlic bread and for the price it's a steal. The only thing that took me by surprise was the cheese in the manicotti. I felt as though it clumped together and didn't have the right taste. So I called when I got home and spoke to a young girl who said they would deliver something to my house. I appreciated it and I was delighted to see the owner came to my house. He was nothing but in a professional manner and very sympathetic. He even told me I could keep the dinner but I told him I couldn't keep that and the new order he had just brought me. He reassured me that he would taste the manicotti and get to the bottom of it. I sincerely appreciate him for being so accommodating, and taking care of one of his customers. I should add I'm a loyal customer because I'm always in there having pizza! Thank you so much! I couldn't be any happier with my service. read more

Gallery Pizza - a piece of fish wrapped in tin foil - Pizza Near Me - Erial, New Jersey

Favorite pizza place! Quality food! Pizza, salads, pasta, sandwiches, no matter what we get , it is always fabulous! Quality ingredients means excellent food!!! read more

Pizza is amazing. Love it and my son says it tastes just like the pizza in Italy. It don't get any better than that. The Sicilian is the best Sicilian you will find anywhere. Sauce is everything people. Love this place glad they are in my town. read more

I have no problem travelling just to get their 5 cheese pizza. This pizza is the one I judge all other white pizza by. I love this pizza! Everytime I order it everyone is very nice and friendly when I pick it up. read more

We have tried various pizza places around us since moving in over 6 years ago, this one we didn't realize was nearby until recently. We had seen the ads/coupons in various clippers or mailers but never realized how close it was. We order from the Chinese place all the time! We ordered for the super bowl this last year and got a Sicilian pizza and fry wings with buffalo sauce and BBQ on the side. The wings were phenomenal!! The pizza was also really good! We have gotten the Parmesan garlic wings too but the wings are best if you order them dry with the sauce on the side. Delicious! Sometimes it's a decent wait, but only on typically super busy days. Usually it's around 30 minutes or so. Definitely worth a try! read more

Love/Hate relationship with Gallery. When we first moved in the area, our friends had ordered from here and it was great! We started to use them ourselves and then noticed that they never got an order right. Order a plain and a special, they have one ready for you. They tell you 25 minutes, and you wait an extra 20 while there. We switched to Guiseppe's and they were awesome...until they closed. We went to Epiro's (good stuff) until they did something weird with their crusts (looked pre-formed and tasted the same). Back to Gallery...called in an order and they got it half right again. To make it worse, they seemed to blame me for the error! They told me it would take 20 minutes for the other pies. Then the other guy said 10 minutes and they proceeded to have a pissing match over who was right. Long story short, they do make good pizza, they are always busy, they just don't seem to care about the details. read more

Always our go-to pizza spot for Sicilian close to our house. Can be a hit or miss depending on how busy they are but we've ordered here so many times over the past 20 years that they only miss a few times (and when they do it's still pretty good). FYI - No matter how busy they are it takes 45 mins for take-out of a plain Sicilian pizza. Every. Single. Time. read more

As a young man I use to visit Gallery. Sometimes I'd be so upset and go to Gallery and it made me happy. Their pizza helped me so much. Still love em. read more

Gallery Pizza - Two of Gallery pizza's biggest fans. - Pizza Near Me - Erial, New Jersey

See all

In my opinion by far the best Sicilian pizza around,very good sandwiches and always fast service whether eating in or taking out..The owner Pino is always slinging pies and saying hello.. Highly recommend if you havnt been,worth the drive!!! read more

I grew up in North Jersey just outside of Manhattan where there's family owned pizza places all over and everyone takes a good pizza for granted. I moved away from my home town in the 80's and have lived all over NJ but never found a pizza that reminded me of what we used to have growing up. King of Pizza in Berlin used to come the closest for me until we got a Gallery Pizza flyer in our mailbox and tried it out. From the first bite I knew I found my spot. Now it's Gallery all the way. We order about once a week now when I don't feel like cooking. The husband loves the meat lovers pizza. My son and I are happy with just plain. So glad we got that flyer! read more

Oh Gallery, you are an Erial staple. Not many great pizza options in the area. I find myself going to Epiro's down the street more often because it's cheaper. We had a coupon for Gallery so we got a white w/riccotta, a plain and a pepperoni to share between 6 people. There was about half a pie left. The pizza was pretty good. Their white pizza has great flavor. The pepperoni was pretty greasy, but that shouldn't stop you from eating it. It's slightly better quality than Epiro's, but more expensive. Always a toss up! If you are looking for a different pizza, my favorite in the Erial area is most definitely Nick's on Berlin/CrossKeys Road. Phenomenal. read more

I wish I could give 0 stars. Last night they ruined my entire birthday party. I called in and scheduled a delivery and it was sent to the wrong address. When I called originally, I didn't have to tell the young lady on the phone my address because it was on file. When i realized the pizza hadn't arrived I called to see were the miscommunication happened to get the matter resolved. The manager had the audacity to call me a liar. I came into the store to try and pick my order up, I gave the man my address to pull up my order and he said it wasn't ready yet, so i left. I've order here plenty of times because this was my favorite pizza spot, so they have my address on file (i know from past orders). The manager has no customer service skills or concern for the customers. There was clearly an operational error last night, but the manager insisted that I was lying and continuously questioned and tested my character, he was way over the line and disrespectful. He refused to remake my order or give me a refund, despite their mistake. The manager also had the nerve to tell me to go to the address his driver dropped off the pizza & get it from them. I will never bring any business back to this place, I can't respect a business staff with no integrity. I wonder if there would've been this much fuss if my skin didn't have any color read more

Been going to the Gallery since I was a kid. Great steaks. The chicken cheese steak is amazing. They season it really well. The fries could be better. Sicilian pizza is always great. read more

Decent pizza place in Erial. It is our go to pizza place when we order. The Sicilian pizza is to die for. The staff is always friendly and the orders are alway on time when picking up. read more