We love the food and the friendly staff! Our realtor recommended Gaetano's when we moved here 8 years ago and we've been ordering from them ever since! read more

Gaetano's has the best pizza and sandwiches. Tonight I had a honey dijon chicken cheesesteak on a garlc bread roll, absolutely delicious! The pizza is outstanding I have many pizza places that are close to me, but I say skip the rest and stay with the best! read more

Always have a deliciuos eating experience, I highly recommend their pizza with its very soft breadstick crust and the roasted pork sandwich with broccoli rabe and shatp provolone on a garlic bread roll. You will not be disappointed read more

I love the cheesesteaks and chicken tenders; they are the best in the area. I recommend Gaetano's.

Gaetano's is definitely unique, that's for sure. If you want to purchase a large cheesesteak, you're going to get much more than you bargained for, that's for sure--expect something massive. Of course, there's nothing wrong with that; if anything, it's a gift from the gods above. Their pizza is incredibly good; it has a unique flavor that you're not going to find anywhere else. I really love it, to be honest. Management has always been utmost kind to me. I find them to be very nice, unlike some of the other people who've reviewed this establishment. Perhaps they were just biased and writing based off a bad experience. Nevertheless, give this place a try. The only downside is that it's takeout only. But, if you're in the immediate area, that should be no problem whatsoever. read more

Overly talked up sandwiches aka Cheese Steaks they are good not excellent. They need to do something about the extremely rude order takers (willing to bet they are family). Get them off the phones! Call to place order this evening, answers all short, give address "Sorry, not delivering there tonight", attempt to explain I'm placing a large order, was hung up on before getting it all out. Call back "Told you, were not delivering to your area tonight, unless it's pick up. I can't help you". We need over 10 sandwiches "Your picking them up,Yes?" No, we need delivery. "CLICK". Guess they have so much money they don't need ours. Will never call there again. read more

Amazing subs. Seeded roll is the bomb. Stuffed sandwiches for the price. In and out in 10 minutes with a monster of a meal to go. Friendly enough staff. Recommend! read more

The cheese steaks and pizza are good and the drivers are very nice. However the order takers are rude. This has happened the past three times and today I told her how nasty she was as I am trying to support small family business and should not be treated this way. She must have thought it was funny as she laughed and didn't even attempt to apologize.Poor customer service and I won't be ordering there any longer as there competition is more customer focused. read more

Mixed feelings about this place... The portions are huge, but some of the food is bland. If you order the right stuff out can be quite good, but there are some real "gotchas'" on the menu. For example, because the rolls are so thick and huge and there is so much meat on the cheesesteak, it seems there is never enough cheese to balance it out. But, the cheesesteak wrap has less meat and bread and is really good because of the better balance. The pizza cheese is bland and adding more of it does not help. It also tends to float to one side of the pie because of too much sauce. I got a sicilian once it was a huge mess. Salad, gyro, wings, poppers, grilled cheese and tomato, and most hoagies (except Italian) are delicious. The hamburgers are awful. I would recommend starting small and see if you like it. If your taste buds are more sensitive than mine (kids perhaps?) this place could be a real bargain for you, especially for parties or if your fridge had lots of room for leftovers. read more

Gaetano's - Geatano's mushroom & extra cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Croydon, Pennsylvania

Staff is rude. Manager is a c***. They wanted the person who already drove 20 minutes to get the food to drive back to prove that there was no cheese on a cheesesteak. I guess the moron doesn't understand that it's 2017 and pictures can be sent through smartphones. If you're going to call them "famous cheese steaks" probably should put cheese on it. If you have any self respect stay away from this place they don't care about their customers at all... read more

Gaetano's - "famous cheese steak" - Pizza Near Me - Croydon, Pennsylvania

Burnt roll on pork roll sandwich fryers are dirty can smell and see how dirty the fryers are. Figured give them a chance again after a year and still the same yuck burnt smelly food. Health department needs to do an investigation soon. When you are a cook for a living and smell dirty fryers run don't walk read more

It was the worst Sicilian pie I ever tasted. They actually took Neapolitan pie dough, stuffed it in a square Sicilian cooking sheet and literally through it in the oven. The cheese and tomato sauce was spread unevenly, the dough was very thin and the pie was super oily. This was the second time my girlfriend and I ordered from this place. Last time we had their cheese steaks and wings, there where much better but way over priced. I don't think we'll be going back. read more

This place gets 5 stars only for it's steak sandwiches. I got food there yesterday, and everything else was par or below. The prices are expensive and the place itself is a dive, which is odd considering their Grant Avenue location is so nice. Parking is horrible. I can't say enough about their steak sandwiches though. They are freakishly huge and delicious. They are expensive, but consider the amount of meat you get as part of the price. If they didn't have the best steak sandwiches, they wouldn't even rate one star. That all being said, call em up, and get a cheese steak delivered, and be prepared to share. read more

Gaetano's - One mushroom cheese steak. - Pizza Near Me - Croydon, Pennsylvania

TodAy was the first time I ever ordered from this place and it will be the last time ever. The person who answers the phone is extremely ignorant I was asking about a special they sell and she told me to hurry up because she had someone else on the other line as if my Business wasn't as important. My food arrived and it was missing an item when I call same lady picks up the phone and tell me well I can credit you I said I rather have the item she said well it's going to take a long time and hung up without saying hey sorry or nothing she was irritated because they forgot my stuff as the first person we come in contact with customer should be treated with a little bit more respect and because of her I will never order here again food was good but I go to places for good service as well read more

If I could give -1000 I would. This place is a joke. They didn't put cheese on a cheesesteak I ordered and they had the nerve to ask me to come back when I live 20mins away to prove to them that they messed up? She actually called me a liar. read more

Gaetano's - a plate with a sandwich on it - Pizza Near Me - Croydon, Pennsylvania

Always ordered from them sometimes they made a mistake my son just me to the area I told him to try it he did they came twice with the wrong order and then the third time I called they started screaming at him yelling at him and telling him not coming then we went to pick it up and they threw it at him awful. read more

Ordered two cheesesteaks. No cheese... Manager was was completely rude about it. She didn't even care to try to help us.

I thought I'd try this place out today (it's on my work commute). I was looking for a really good cheesesteak and boy did I find one. Three sizes, I got a small, with mushrooms, and it was perfect for me and I am a big guy 250lbs. It was on an Italian seeded loaf bread (huge) with a lot of meat! It was so full and it made me so full I couldn't finish it! FRESH mushrooms not canned, 3-4 slices of real american cheese and on a fresh roll. I love Gaetano's steak sands! In the pictures below you can't really tell how big the sandwich is unless it's right in front of you. read more

Excellent buffalo chicken cheesesteak. Super fresh bread and hands down best I've ever had. Chicken fingers are more like filets. Huge portions and nice people. We always order delivery which comes quickly and hot. However, i do agree with the other reviewer that hot and cold items should be bagged separately. Oh...and for you calzone lovers?..it's a must. read more

I love there food it is so good like the large bacon cheese fries is 6 bucks and i can't get the taste out of my mouth

Gaetano's catered a business lunch while I was in town for work. Great cheese steak as far as this Arky is concerned. I loved it, and wish we had something similar in my hometown. read more

This place is atrocious. I work at a local business and every time we order from here it is always incorrect! Sloppy service, sloppy adequate food. Choose any where else but here. read more

I much prefer the original Gaetanos in Willingboro but live closer to this place. Was much better when first opened but noticed during last visit that portions are smaller and taste is meh. Ordered a cheesesteak with fried onions and i had a hard time finding cheese and the onions werent really cooked. Next time i'll go to NJ. read more

I order here at least once a week and I love the taste of their food but my biggest complaint is that they can NEVER get my order correct!!! Not once since I've been ordering from here has the order been right!! They either get my order wrong or they forget something!! I just don't understand how this ALWAYS happens??? read more

The only good thing about this place is the amount of food you get for your price. The taste is subpar and for the third time I was forced to order from there this evening. They put their salads in the same bag as the hot foods. I just received my incorrect order, my hot wilty salad and of course they forgot my dressing for the third time. I would call them up and return it but since I am a guest in this location I would hate to think that spit or some other revenge would end up in my hosts food the next time they order their hoagie from there. I DO NOT recommend this establishment. Go to Croydon pizza instead... they may not deliver but at least the food is tasty and my order is always correct. read more

Claims to have award winning cheesesteaks, from who I have no idea. There whole business model must be quantity over quality because honestly who thinks "well this steak is a sloppy soggy gross mess but hey there's like 3 feet of it", I wouldn't bother especially when there are better cheaper steaks a half a block away... read more

Favorite Pizza place in Croydon. The pizza sauce is sweet but that's what I prefer. Pizza fries are really good. Prices are a bit high though. read more

Recommended by my uncle as i was fishing for a good place to get him a gift card for his birthday. My huzband and i each got a cheesesteak and mozzerella wedges. Everything was fantastic! The seeded roll my cheesesteak came on was an excellent surprise. I'll probably never want a regularr italian roll again! Will definitly be ordering from here again. (P.S ny uncle will be getting cash for his birthday as they do not offer gift cards but he said its the only place they ever order from!) read more

I had friends out on my boat and they stopped here to pick up some hoagies for everyone. After trying them I had to know where they got them from because they were amazing. They're huge, tasted very fresh, and not a bad price for the size! I found the place myself yesterday and the best part is they said they'd deliver to the marina. I'll definitely be a repeat customer in the summers! I'm looking forward to trying their cheese steaks everyone seems to rave about. read more

Stopped here for a slice of pizza. Two stars because the slice was quite large. Too much cheese (hard to believe but you put too much) and the crust was too thick and not cooked all the way through. read more

Recently moved to the area and was looking for a pizza spot that reminded me of the places in New Jersey. Unless you're in the mood for a good cheesesteak or a plain pizza DO Not Waste Your Money HERE. I ordered a antipasto salad for myself and a chicken wrap for my daughter. Disappointing! BLAND. Big Portions But not big flavors. I will not order from this place again. read more

I agree with the cheesesteak review. The mini is massive. I can't imagine the bigger sizes. Also, the next time you order, my wife and I swear by the chicken parm wrap. You will not be disappointed. Wings were ok, not great, not bad. Probably wouldn't order again though read more

Great food but unfortunately professionalism not the same. I ordered delivery last night for dinner and when the food was delivered both sandwiches were incorrect. The slip even had the right sandwiches. So I called and told them they were both wrong and they said they will send out the right order. 30 minutes later food is delivered and the delivery guy only has one sandwich. I called again and the manager got nasty with me and said we are not delivering anymore food and if I wanted the other sandwich I would have to pick it up. So I did pick it up and they were so mean and the manager was just staring me down. I will never order from them again. read more