Their birthday cake face cream is the classic best and all of their ice creams are perfect! Highly…read morerecommend!

Knowing the ice cream is made with local dairy and in small batches makes indulging so much easier…read more It's almost always busy and service has always been great. If there's a wait it's worth it. It's places like this that's actually made me never wanting bigger named ice cream brands again. Quality is great, tastes amazing and for what you're getting it's super affordable.

I took my granddaughter there on 8/9/25 we both had never been before. Walked in she instantly…read moreliked the kid friendly play area. I let her take it in for a moment then we went to the counter to see what we wanted. Two young guys were standing behind the counter. I spoke to Them. Neither one said a word or acknowledged us. I grabbed my granddaughters hand and walked out. I will never beg anyone to take my hard earned money. Went to Island Creamery, greeted when we walked in the door. Do better!

Every thing was good clean employees amazing customer service amazing staff 5 stars for sureread more

I was in need of Gelato lol. Also love the cooper sharp sticks. Decided to try some banana…read morepudding too. All were great.

Address is wrong. Wouldn't let me check-in. Staff is less than bright. The scoops were just a…read morespatula smeared on a cup. Cups were considerably too small for the product. No lids. The top I was given didn't cover anything, it just spilled out if the side. Absolute mess to take with me. Didn't end up eating much of it. Plus, you have to pay separately for that place and the Pretzel place even though they are the same building with the same worker.

Beautifully decorated cupcakes that taste as good as they look! My turkey cupcake was the cutest…read moreand my favorite was the black bottom cupcake. A super moist, light and fluffy, cupcake with nice texture when you bite into mini chocolate chip morsels. Everyone loved the pumpkin roll which was such a treat! The pumpkin roll was moist and not mushy. The pumpkin roll was the preferred dessert over the pumpkin pie! I think it's the cream cheese filling which sweetens the classic fall dessert.

Great service and great flavors!!!!!!!!! The macarons were amazing as well as the cheesecake!!!read more

Every time I've been here it has been a treat but today I write because Cheer (sorry if I…read moremisspelled your name) was a delight, he really took the time to listen to a customers silly request and made sure we were happy. Man deserves all the raises.

I think their cakes are really good. They have that PUNCH. It's a party in your mouth. I ordered…read morefor the First time, quilted coffee Carmel cake. This was by far the best. What a delicious flavor!

I Ordered a "traditional Smith Island cake " , for a goodbye party with only a 24 hour notice with…read morea special greeting on the cake. Smith Island cake is made of many thin layers of yellow cake with a rich fudge like chocolate icing. This cake is the most popular , but my favorite is cookies and cream , Neapolitan or fresh strawberry in the summer , which is super moist. Smith Island cakes have been made since the 1800's , when women on Smith Island would send them with their husbands on the Autumn oyster harvest . If only the women knew that this would become Maryland's official dessert and be shipped nationwide!

The Smith Island cake was delivered on time and my mother simply loved it. She said the chocolate…read moreused was divine. I'll definitely be ordering again. We don't eat cake on birthdays because we can't find good ones in Maryland where we are. We usually just have pie for birthdays. The next birthday is my aunt's, so we will try a a different one then.

Love 2 scoops! Recently had the peanut butter brownie ice cream it was great! Everyone in my party…read moreenjoyed their ice cream.

If you want yummy ice cream that is made local, try Two Scoops and Waffles in downtown Salisbury…read more They have many flavors to choose from and many other sweet chocolate treats.