The Chipwich!! My favorite sandwich on Nantucket! Sourdough is soft and doesn't rip apart your mouth. Parmesan aioli is to die for. Bacon is cooked perfectly. Turkey melts in your mouth. Just the right amount of chips. (I don't always get tomato just because I feel like the sandwich is already perfect without it, even tho I love tomatoes!) 4 stars only because they are pretty slow. (Compared to Provisions which is speedy) read more

See all

Only stopped in quick to grab a soda. Not really any places in that area of town near the ferry that have drinks and walking around builds up a thirst. Anyway, the 2 clerks I dealt with were friendly and personable. And the service was fast and easy. Its an interesting place, alchohol, sandwiches, and some basic need items. There's a definetly a positive energy to this place and you can feel it upon entering. read more

Quick service. Had vegetarian option. Fresh and tasty. Great for wanting a quick bite to eat. read more

Fresh Nantucket - Lunch with a friend - American Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

After getting sandwiches here last year, I made it my business to go back and get them again! The service is so friendly! The sandwiches are creative and delicious! The ambience is cool and cute. They also have a lot of beverages to choose from to take on a picnic as well as share on the beach or in your hotel. read more

Ordered Breakfast sandwich on a bagel- bagel was hard as a rock and barely edible. Normally the food here is excellent so maybe they used day old bagels. read more

I will say, I saw the prices and I avoided for a long time until I finally tried a sandwich...WORTH EVERY SINGLE PENNY!! The freshest best sandwich I've ever eaten in my entire life, hands down! Don't delay just go!! read more

Fresh Nantucket - Fresh Club! - American Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

$22 for one of the smallest Kale Caesar's I have ever had! I ordered 2 on my daughters recommendation and when I picked up the bag it was so light I thought they had forgotten one! The guy behind the counter was so busy being 'too cool' that when I asked for 2 chicken caesar salads he said 'do you want chicken with that?' It was tasty but the dressing was scare. Unfortunately, the cost alone has put me off ever going back. $46 for 2 tiny salads! read more

Fun vibes at this place, with a nice diverse menu, and a relaxed ambience during my late/end of season visit yesterday. Also had the largest selection of Nantucket Nectars on hand that I have ever seen, haha. My "tree hugger" sandwich checked all the boxes of various veggie selections, plus a hummus base. I might have enjoyed it more if the bread was more refined beyond what seemed to be a rather plain wheat bread base. I would come here again if it was on my regular route. read more

The vegetarian (Tree Hugger) sandwich is amazing albeit expensive at $16.00.. However, I really did not mind given the size and taste. It had glazed balsamic, carrots, cucumbers, and spinach, avocado, just to name a few of the veggies. The multigrain bread was harty and tasty too. It is huge, so I recommend sharing it. There is not any seating in the restaurant/store however, the water along with benches are just a short walk away. They packaged my sandwich with plenty of napkins and used a biodegradable bag. read more

After eating here multiples times during our week on island, I was shocked to see/read bad reviews of this place. Every food item we have gotten, we've absolutely loved! We've had their breakfast sandwiches, smoothies, caprese sandwich, tree hugger, the turkey sandwich... all were amazing. All the ingredients are fresh and tasty. Not only is the food good, but store has a nice vibe and workers are super friendly. ***realized after we got our last order there, I wanted to leave a review so only got a picture of my breakfast sandwich that day*** read more

Fresh Nantucket - Breakfast ast Sandwich with siracha aoli - American Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

The Treehugger sandwich was one of the most disappointing sandwiches I've ever experienced in my life. After a couple bites, I had to re-read the description to make sure it did indeed claim "hummus" was in there. Because I didn't see or taste any hummus. It was really really weird. So I basically paid $12 for a sandwich full of lettuce and tomatoes. Yippee! :: rolls eyes :: My advice is to go to Provisions Sandwich Shop for your sandwich needs. They're located one block away near the Straight Wharf. read more

Fresh Nantucket - Treehugger Sandwich - American Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

Great little sandwich and smoothie shop. Not the fastest service though and like lots of the sandwich shops around town no seating.

Great location in town allows them to treat customers like crap. Food was ok, two sandwiches for the kids were almost inedible. They were as rude as could be, unless your a local. Not going back and I'm sure they could care less. read more

The BEST on island! AMAZING! I visit Nantucket often, for many years now, no matter where I have tried for a to-go sandwich spot, Fresh is always the best. My favorites are the BLT (add turkey + cheese) and also the Capone. I also love their Greek Quinoa Salad and their Egg Salad Avo Toast. My guests always want to go here when they visit too! They have an awesome selection of cocktails and unique boozy cans which are so perfect for the beach - i have not seen the stuff they carry anywhere else on island! Not only is the food amazing, the staff are so friendly and you can tell they like working together. The vibe is exactly what you are looking for on an island - playing awesome music all the time!! https://www.tripadvisor.com/ShowUserReviews-g29527-d1458532-r793784577-Fresh-Nantucket_Massachusetts.html# read more

Don't order on the app, you'll have to wait twice as long for your sandwiches. It's going on an hour and I'm still waiting for sandwiches I ordered. While in the store I wanted to purchase a drink and cashier took three people ahead of me while standing there then gave me an attitude when I brought it to her attention. Done here. read more

We got sandwiches here during a weekend visit to the island. We called in our order for four sandwiches and they turned it around pretty quickly, which we appreciated. The location in the center of town makes this a convenient lunch to pick up, but it can also mean that it can be pretty busy in there and their space is tight. It's pricey ($52 for four sandwiches), but that is consistent with most shops on the island. We'll come back for sandwiches again in the future, but Fresh isn't at the top of my list of places to eat on Nantucket. read more

My favorite eatery on Nantucket and one of the best sandwich shops EVER. The lobster roll will set you back ~$18 but once a year it's worth it. Service is very friendly but line is usually very long so it can be slow, be prepared for a bit of a (well worth it) wait. The sandwiches are the size of NY Deli sandwiches but better. All the ingredients are super fresh and organic. Also a plus - you can buy wine & beer here. Such good memories having FRESH sandwiches for lunch while boating around the island! This place is a must-go. read more

I understand it's covid and the ordering process is a little delayed BUT I waited outside the store after ordering in 88 degrees for 18 minutes for only two sandwiches. I was the only person there. They had at least five people working. Even if there were other online orders they were working on, having a customer wait outside in extreme heat for just two simple sandwiches is just plain bad customer service. To top it off they not only didn't apologize for the wait but they snubbed my thank you. The sandwiches were good but nothing exceptional and definitely not worth the wait. read more

What they said. We really enjoyed the restaurants we ate at, but sometimes you just need a simple meal. Fresh does flavorful and high quality with the Nantucket smile. We can easily recommend the Carnivore, the Nantucket Babe, and the Tree Hugger. All these went great with a cold one from the fridge and of course a few pistachios and chips to round out our picnic. read more

Fresh Nantucket - The Tree Hugger and a pair of Cisco Whale Tale Pale Ale. - American Near Me - Nantucket, Massachusetts

THE BEST! Perfect place for a delicious breakfast sandwich, or lunch. They offer a variety of delicious sandwiches, salads and fresh smoothies. The owner is very friendly, professional, and accommodating. This is my go-to spot for a quick lunch or breakfast sandwich when I'm on island. They also have a solid variety of wines, beers, and spirits!! Highly recommend. read more

Fresh is a super cute gourmet deli / Liquor Store smack in the heart of downtown. Reasonable priced. Nice selection of wines. Quick to check out! read more

Amazing fresh sandwiches and salads. Easy ordering system (paper, check off what you want) so no mistakes, and a great selection of wine and some specialty cheeses (aged goat, aged gouda, etc) We went back several times, and the quality remained high. Well worth a stop. read more

Love this spot. I have never had an issue with ordering on their website. Of course during a busy summer beach day you need to plan ahead and order way in advance. I ordered online this week and it was ready within 10 minutes of ordering. The sandwiches are great, way more meat than Provisions. Really love the rosemary chicken salad. The bread options are great, but I will say maybe 1/10 times the bread has been a little stale. The salads are also awesome, love the cobb salad. They have good breakfast options too. A little expensive for grab 'n go, but it is Nantucket. read more

So, we have stopped in this store many times just to pick up a bottle of wine. The selection is decent and the prices are reasonable. However today we stopped in to get fresh sandwiches which are made to order. I noticed that one of the employees making sandwiches sneezed into his hand and then reached for a bun to make a sandwich. I called this to his attention and he claims he sneezed into his shirt. I would never go back to this place again because of hygiene issues. All he had to do was change his gloves and that didn't happen. read more

Use the app at your own risk. I ordered my food, waited the appropriate time, then went and proceeded to wait another 20 minutes only to find out they hadnt even started it... Now im waiting for my refund since i wasnt willing to wait another hour for my lunch. read more

Decent food, but hopelessly disorganized and can't handle more than two people in line without getting flustered. Today, I put in an order for 4 sandwiches with close two hours notice for pick up. On arrival, nothing prepared and they kept saying it was being prepared. Logan, finally had a meltdown and said they had 45 sandwiches before us. Not going back. It's fine for pick up of a bottle wine or cookie, rest take a pass. read more

Amazing sandwiches and smoothies! Fresh is the perfect stop before the beach - they even sell liquor and beer.

Luckily there was no line when I arrived. I ordered the Nantucket Babe, which has Honey Glazed Ham, Brie, Granny Smith Apples and Whole Grain Mustard on Honey Wheat. It was a huge sandwich, but the meat was SO salty, and there was way too much spread, so I ended up finishing only half and scraping off some of the sauce. It's pretty expensive for a sandwich ($9), but I guess you are in Nantucket...If I ever make it back there, I will try one of the other take-out places next. A guy did see me enjoying my sandwich on Old South Wharf so I directed him to Fresh. read more

The liquor we purchased was reasonably priced, unfortunately the gazpacho was horrendous. Honestly, not just bad, but horrendous. We've had upset stomachs since we had the few bites we did. It tasted as if they opened a can of tomato purée and put some cut veggies in it. Garbage. I might be back to purchase liquor but will never buy any prepared food again. read more

Enjoyed my curry chicken salad sandwich. Was good and my family have all returned here multiple times

The go to spot for sandwiches and smoothies. So good! Plenty of options, great quality. That line can back up quickly at lunch! Will be back! read more

Fresh is under new management and the reboot is amazing. The staff was friendly and accommodating. The sandwiches are awesome. I loved the Torpedo sandwich so much I ordered it two days in a row. I didn't feel like the prices were any different compared to other things in Nantucket. In fact, I think their sandwiches are on the lower end price-wise. One of the new owners is a sommelier so we asked him for a white wine recommendation. The one he picked out for us, Le Fief du Briel, was wonderful. Outside of sandwiches and wine, they have grab and go food, beach stuff (umbrellas and frisbees), t-shirts and hats. You can also order through their mobile app in advance so you don't have to worry about finding parking! I will definitely be coming back here on the regular. read more

Just visited Nantucket and found Fresh - the best sandwich ever. I am not normally big on sandwiches (prefer a salad) but the smell coming from inside drove me in!! The BLT (I know a BLT) is the best sandwich I have ever tasted!!! All the names of sandwiches are unique so I cannot remember them but the Chicken Salad is also amazing (with sliced grapes). The have a great selection of beer and wine so it is easy to bring the cooler, grab a bottle or two and a sandwich and hit the beach!! Highly recommend and we will be back! read more

The service is awful and the staff are rude. The sandwiches are ones you wpuld make at home and cost 15 dollars and up. Therw are numerous better places to eat such as Thw Hub or Provisions with better prices better food and bettwr service. Avoid thw angry and entitled staff who resent your presence. read more

The slowest and worst customer service ever. 45 wait in store after calling in an order 15min prior to that when it's NOT BUSY. One sandwich, nothing crazy. Ask for refund and get attitude from the girl at the cash register then looked at and treated like I'm the jerk. Owner was there, and did nothing to intervene. Maybe it was a mistake, but at least apologize. Know it's just food and beverage, and people will say "it's August", but can you at least pretend to give a s*** about your customers? Terrible experience, will not be back read more

Best sandwiches on the island. The Carnivore is out of this world! The location is great for picking up some food and booze for the beach or boat. Can not wait until they open for summer season! read more

Great sandwiches for lunch and nice options for breakfast. The price is high, but everything is on the island. To order, be sure to go to the back of the store and use the paper and pencils to put in your order. Takes a bit of time, but everything is made fresh to order. read more

I eat here almost everyday. The place is amazing and staff is super helpful. Real tasty sammys.

Loved the lobster roll. Great place to get food to take out and have a picnic!! Sat by the pier and enjoyed lobster while watching the boats !!! read more

sandwich very good, but slow cashier backed up the line of 20 or so people. She tried to charge me twice for my meal and overcharged the first time. read more