The bartender was excellent, says she even stuffed the olives with blue cheese that were in our Old Fashioned. Although she had a bit of a potty mouth, she is an awesome drink-maker! I can look past the cussing if a bartender makes outstanding drinks. Our food was amazing, it was a fish fry Friday, all 6 of us loved what we had and our waitress was really good too. read more

Wow! The owner came out and talked to us about the menu and gave us a free appetizer. The food was great. We had a steak and stuffed shrimp. Steak had a better flavor than Cimaroli's. Shrimp and crab cake stuffing had a very balanced flavor with no flavor outstanding. The surprise was the au gratin potatoes. They had a rich cheddar flavor with salty breading on top. Everything was great including the free fried cheese curds. read more

Fredrick's Supper Club - Cheese curds yes - Supper Clubs Near Me - Milton, Wisconsin

See all

I went for girls night and ordered the 5oz lobster for 40.00. It yielded less than 2oz of meat. I immediately called over the server who got Brian Cherry the manger. He was rude, nasty even, he barked, "it's 5oz with the shell and walked away. " The shrimp in the shrimp cocktail was larger than the lobster meat. Won't patronize this place again. Don't order the lobster is a total rip off read more

! The Filet Mignon was sooo tender and the Bacon Wrapped Scallops were to die for. Our waitress Allie made the whole experience memorable. read more

Fredrick's Supper Club - The Filet Mignon was sooo tender and the Bacon Wrapped Scallops were to die for. Our waitress Allie made the whole experience - Supper Clubs Near Me - Milton, Wisconsin

My son mentioned he had an excellent fish fry there so we stopped in Saturday night around 5pm to try them out. They were fairly busy but said they could seat us, but we decided to wait and enjoy a cocktail first. Had a good old fashioned and a Manhattan, both with strong pours. I had their seafood au gratin and baked potato and side salad with blue cheese. The salad was fresh and crisp and the blue dressing was excellent; thick and chunky. I enjoyed my seafood and baked potato. My wife had the prime rib stroganoff and thought it was very good. I agreed; lots of tender prime and creamy pasta. Everyone was very pleasant, bartender, server and the head chef/manager stopped by to inquire about our experience. Old school super club, which I like, but could use a little updating of the decor. Will definitely go back. read more

See all

First time trying this Milton staple. Cute little supper club, lots of menu options. Decided to give the fish fry a try - it was Friday after all. Fish was fantastic, batter wasn't too much, wasn't greasy, fish nice and flakey. Au gratin potatoes were super cheesy. Hubby had French onion soup which was amazing, and the ground sirloin - which he thought was great. The Old fashioned flight was fun try different flavors. The waitress was really nice, the chef even stopped by our table to see what we thought as did one of the owners too, that in itself was impressive! read more

See all

22 hour slow roasted Prime Rib - Daily. Repeating - 22 hour S L O W roasted PRIME RIB - DAILY. My wife found this place on our way back from skiing on a cold January day in 2025. We try to find nice places near the expressway (I90/I39) on our route back down to Illinois. This is located on the main street in downtown Milton, Wisconsin. It's a building which dates to the late 1800s. The interior is dark, with wall hangings and dividers - the center divider is literally there to support the roof as the span is so wide. We walked in and were seated promptly, and served with a basket of bread and their maple and cinnamon butter spread. My wife ordered their surf & turf special, which was comprised of a 10 ounce Prime Rib cut with three crab-stuffed shrimp, while I had their King Cut 14 ounce Prime Rib and a baked potato. The dinners came with salad, which was a nice spring mix - see the picture. I was going to order the filet, but the 22 hour slow roasted Prime Rib was too good to pass up. Service was solid, the wine list was very good with several good titles and low corkage contrasted with other steak houses. We even got to meet one of the owners, and learn a little about the work he had done. Recent updates included a new ceiling, and renovation of both bathrooms. Honestly, this place has a lot going for it for a short trip off the expressway. Make plans to go to Milton and try out the Prime Rib. read more

See all

Great supper club. From beginning to end we thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. Our server was very friendly and gave us great suggestions. We had the sirloin and shrimp special, the salmon and the ribeye. All top notch. The Mac and cheese side was soooo good. The au gratin potatoes were good too. We also highly suggest the grasshopper for dessert. The place is cute and fit the feel of a supper club. We highly suggest. read more

See all

I read about this supper club in the local paper and with the encouragement of Yelp reviews tried it out last night. First of all, we were seated promptly at around 7:45 without reservations and on a Friday night. Services was top notch. Entrees come with two sides. We had French onion soup, and clam chowder, sizable salad and fries as sides. We had the fish fry, one cod three piece and sampler that had cod, perch and bluegill. Amazing. We've lived in a town adjacent to Milton and we're unaware of Frederick's. Clearly a locals preference but it will definitely be my go to supper club going forward. Menu offers many choices. Plenty of leftovers came home with us. Bring an appetite. Didn't try desserts this time but plan on it next visit. read more

Stopped on a Friday for the fish fry. COD was lightly breaded, but crispy crunchy. Perfect. Side salad was ample for a side, with fresh cucumbers, tomatoes and onions on a bed of spring mix. Will definitely be back to try the steaks. read more

Unfortunately, more bad than good. Good: Baked French onion soup, crab cake stuffed shrimp. Bad: Old fashioned's (we ordered rail due to a buy one get one book we had but their best was Jim Beam and they were flat and tasteless); filet mignon was tender but no seasoning or butter...blah. A house salad (no salad bar) was considered a side dish when we ordered the baked French onion soup. A small house salad should be included. read more

We had a pre-Christmas celebration for a family of five on Friday night. We had cheese curds which were excellent and the brussel sprouts could have been cooked longer. We each had a delicious entree and our server was great! We will be going back! read more

Excellent food and great atmosphere and service. Our waitress was great and very attentive read more

See all

Went here for the 2nd time. It was just as good as the first. The au gratin potatoes are awesome. One rib was cooked perfect. The grasshopper was also great. The service here is very good. And the supper club is a nice pleasant place to be. read more

Fredrick's Supper Club - Prime rib - Supper Clubs Near Me - Milton, Wisconsin

Amazing experience. Our server Jessica did fabulous job. Food was amazing. The bacon wrapped steak bites exceeded expectations. The crab cake stuffed shrimp outstanding and the prime rib amazing cut. Highly recommend! read more

Our food was amazing! Must try the cheese curds and highly recommend the scallops and any of their steaks! Can't wait to go back!

We always have great service at Fredrick's! This time, we had an emergency back home right before we ordered our dinners, and our server got our order ready and we were on our way with our delicious food to go. The bar staff is very friendly and even remembered me (and we don't get there that much, so it was remarkable!) since our last visit. Cute place with great ambiance and wonderful food. read more

I come from the West Coast to visit my parents in WI a couple times a year. The food and service here have always been exceptional. You have to love their blackened prime rib, but the prime rib stroganoff is an opportunity to branch out... read more

The food was great- between the two of us, had the prime rib and filet. Prime rib was one of the best have ever had. The filet was cooked well but didn't have a lot of flavor, but I am a filet snob and am often not pleased ( I need to order something different). Got three shrimp on the side and they were great and huge! Side salad was nice and onion rings were very nice. Wish our server was more friendly. She didn't greet us, didn't smile the whole time we were there and made us feel like a bother. The bus girl was much more friendly- she should be a server! read more

Ordered mushroom horde vore.excellent,like a meal.ordered their prime rib, house specialty,one of the best.Trudy our server was right on top of everything.Mike ,the owner, stopped to check on us.top to bottom,a great experience.a little noisy like a good busy restaurant should be.thanks!! Chris and Jan Ogden read more

All around an exceptional experience! Nice supper club vibe! Great bartender with great drinks, especially the old fashions! Excellent service. Food was phenomenal and included fresh warm bread with homemade flavored butter. The baked French onion soup was amazing and the Prime Rib was cooked to perfection, minimal fat, and extremely tender! Will definitely be back! read more

See all

The prime rib was very good. Was a bit of a drive from Janesville but worth it. Nice place in a small town. Would I come back? Yes, if I find myself back in Wisconsin and nearby, I'll come back. read more

We drove from Kenosha for my birthday dinner. The drive was worth it. The food was amazing! Trudy, our waitress and Grace, the bus girl, had excellent service! We have been recommending Frederick's to everyone! We look forward to going back, trying other items, and bringing friends! read more

See all

While there was nothing special about the interior of this restaurant, my steak was excellent and the service good. read more

Fredrick's Supper Club - a glass of wine - Supper Clubs Near Me - Milton, Wisconsin

Had a great experience for our first time! Food excellent and service was superb! We will definitely be back!

Waitress didn't even know about menu food was mediocre. Hard pass. All around. They claim to be accessible we had someone in a wheelchair and it was extremely difficult to get in and out read more

1/10 Worst restaurant experience I've ever had. Let me set the scene. Reservations at 5pm for a table of four. Myself and my boyfriend, and another couple. My boyfriend and I arrive promptly at 5pm and are seated. To be courteous, our waiter comes over and my boyfriend informs him that our friends called and are running about 30min behind, completely out of our control. Our waiter tells us that it's a bit concerning that they will be that late because it's a very high volume night at the restaurant. We obviously feel terrible because we both work in customer service and understand that this might cause them some inconvenience. Our waiter, whose name I think is David, was very nice about it and simply informed us of the concern. Minutes later the head chef, comes out of the kitchen and ever to our table. He puts his hands on the back of the chair across from us and begins to reprimand us like we are children saying, "You do understand what a reservation is don't you?", as his face was the shade of a ripe radish. He continues to explain to us how rude and inconveniencing we were even though we were on time, and could not control that our friends were late. We felt so unwelcome I went to the front and ask for our drink order to be cancelled and I was zipping up my coat to leave. The waiter came rushing over to diffuse the situation and we sat back down, as he was about to lose a table. After our friends got there, exactly 30min late, they took our order and told us that they rushed it ahead of the other orders to get us out of there quickly. It was the most unwelcoming experience I've ever had at a restaurant. As for the food, it was fine to say the least. I lost my appetite after being treated like an unwelcomed rodent. I would be surprised if he didn't spit in our food with how angry the head chef reacted. We came from Rockford, Illinois and our friends came from Naperville to try out this restaurant specifically. I wish I would have left and not spent my money here. Never will we return, and I hope the head chef does not come out of the kitchen emotionally driven by anger at anymore guests, to avoid more bad experiences. Thank you to our waiter for trying to make things better. They should let the people that deal with the people, deal with the people. read more

Second time here, the first time was Valentine special. Filet, Prime rib, lobster, scallop, shrimp, bottle of wine, sides, and salads. Filet and prime rib were good, seafood was just okay. Second time we ordered stuffed filet and prime rib. Meat could of used a little more seasoning. French onion soup was good, didn't like the augratin potatoes. read more

me and my 13 kids went here and i ate cheeseburger My second time there. The first experience was so good we (my daughter and I) came back. I jumped off the edge of sanity and ordered the "Emperor" cut prime rib so I could bring some home to my husband. It was listed on the menu after the "King", so I expected it to be large, but it still surprised me with how big it was. This bad boy was 4" thick! I have never ordered such a big steak before, and I laughed so hard when she brought it out! Soooo worth it! I would love to know who supplies their meats because it was the one of the most tender and delicious prime ribs I've ever had! Top quality! Seasoned and cooked to perfection as well. There are some very talented cooks here, the salad was delicious, the bacon wrapped prime bites were delicious and beautifully presented, hot fr read more

Fredrick's Supper Club - literly the boss - Supper Clubs Near Me - Milton, Wisconsin

It was OK. Atmosphere, eh. Food was fine, nothing special. Service was fast, but to the point we felt like they wanted us out. We had a reservation, there were plenty of other tables open and it was not near closing. Not sure what the rush was. No need to return. read more

Rarely write unpleasant reviews but I returned first steak for being cooked way overdone (ordered MR). Second steak came out half perfect, half raw as shown in photo. Taking the raw part home for the dog only. Really disappointing. Monday evening 6:00 with 4 other tables in restaurant. Server was great. Food, not so much. read more

Fredrick's Supper Club - Ribeye - Supper Clubs Near Me - Milton, Wisconsin

See all

First off, best service I have had at a restaurant. The food was like WOW Soooo good. Prime Rib was cooked to perfection and the cocktails were perfect. What a great night out. Also didn't hurt that the owner came out and thanked us for choosing his restaurant for dinner. read more

Sea Food Alfredo that tasted like pasta water with milk... no salt, pepper or any flavor at all other than watery milk... the pasta was cheep box quality that was cooked 3-4 minutes less than Al dente.... lobster tail was expected to be frozen but was handled so poorly that it was a round knot of over cooked flavorless meat that was harder to chew than the completely over cooked and brown prime rib that my GF ordered so for the $150 for two, I would give less than one star if possible... if you're a foodie and willing to travel and pay for really good chef prepared food, then go else where... so disappointing... the server did awesome.... read more

We went there for the fish, me and my wife. It was absolutely awful. We got baked cod. It was all dried out. We will not go there again. we went there May 2023 read more

4 stars because our service was excellent, our waitstaff was attentive and friendly. We were asked several times if there was anything we needed. 3 stars for cocktails & food. Wisconsin famous Old Fashions. Ordered them "pressed " was served super sweet. Spinach salad was good, lasagna soup was ground meat marinara with a sprinkle of Parmesan cheese. Smothered chicken portion was plentiful but dry. Emperor cut prime rib was also generous portion but was full of gristle and not tender. High prices do not match the food quality. This was our second time eating here and will be our last. Nothing special worth writing home about. read more

Tonight was our first time at Fredrick's Supperclub. We try different supperclubs throughout the year as we're able. This place is an amazing, wonderful, and nice place. The atmosphere is cozy, well decorated, and pleasant. The service was top notch, very friendly and helpful. Our server's name was Trudy, and she was great. She was well versed, helpful, informative and very nice. The food was also Excellent. The prime rib, perfect, my wife's 12 oz. Filet delicious, perfectly cooked and juicy. The stuffed mushrooms mouth wateringly delicious. The baked French onion soup was also Excellent, delicious, and Omg so good. We highly recommend Fredrick's to everyone read more

Fredrick's Supper Club - Baked French onion soup, Mmmmm - Supper Clubs Near Me - Milton, Wisconsin

My second time there. The first experience was so good we (my daughter and I) came back. I jumped off the edge of sanity and ordered the "Emperor" cut prime rib so I could bring some home to my husband. It was listed on the menu after the "King", so I expected it to be large, but it still surprised me with how big it was. This bad boy was 4" thick! I have never ordered such a big steak before, and I laughed so hard when she brought it out! Soooo worth it! I would love to know who supplies their meats because it was the one of the most tender and delicious prime ribs I've ever had! Top quality! Seasoned and cooked to perfection as well. There are some very talented cooks here, the salad was delicious, the bacon wrapped prime bites were delicious and beautifully presented, hot fresh bread crusty on the outside and soft on the inside served with a garlic cheese butter. This was a Tuesday night about 45 minutes before closing and the service was super friendly and spot on! We were very well taken care of. I can't say enough how much I like this place. The atmosphere is small and cozy, and very unassuming on the outside. I do love the flickering lights at the entrance. It's obvious that this group of fine folks really care about their customers and the quality of their food. Thank you for another amazing experience!!! read more

See all

A new place for me. Liked the reviews and thought I'd give it a go. Had reservations since it was a Friday. Arrived early and had a cocktail at the bar - nicely made. Friendly staff. The filet was recommend so I went that way and wasn't disappointed. Salad and baker were equally good (potato could have been warmer). A nice dinner at an old school place. Great stop if in the area. read more

Exceptional service! All of the staff were very friendly and frequently filled our drinks. We ordered appetizers - crab cakes, cheese curds and onion rings. The crab cakes were amazing as were the cheese curds. It was fish fry Friday and one person had the combo - the blue gill and catfish were perfectly cooked - flaky and moist. The pork chops lived up to their hype, the scallops were perfectly cooked as well, the prime rib sandwich was delicious and enough for 2 people. This was well worth the price. read more

Absolutely delicious food, been to a lot of supper clubs and haven't had a steak this good in a long time!! Perfect service, super friendly! Great menu items as well, lots of yummy entree's to pick from. Only complaint would be the bathrooms but the food, service and atmosphere make up for it ten fold! read more