My family has been going here since it opened. Not only are their pizzas, sandwiches and dinners…read moregreat, they'll make things for you that aren't on the menu. Use the app for takeout, it's great. Calamari Fra'Diavalo is my personal favorite. Can't say enough positive things. The catering they've done for us over the years has always been over the top quality food and plentiful. Great job Santo and Frank!

I was starving, and this was the first pizza place I saw with something truly rare, abundant…read moreparking. Destiny. Pizza was good. I had it cold because that's how I like it. No complaints there. Service was... philosophical. The place was empty, yet it took a while to be noticed. The staff seemed deeply committed to important discussions with friends. Once I finally received my pizza, I stood by the door, hanging like a lonely pepperoni, waiting for someone to remember I existed. Apparently there's another register somewhere in the back. So I took a small pilgrimage through the restaurant, paid, and escaped with my dignity and my slice. They do have a seating area to the left. I didn't explore it. At that point, my relationship with the establishment had run its course. Would I go back? If I'm starving and the parking lot calls to me again... nah...

The SAUCE!!!! That's it! As long as it's got the sauce,…read moreyou're good. And almost everything has the sauce. Delicious...the only place to go for true Italian flavor.

Love the pizzas. I ordered a chicken California cutlet sandwich. It was amazing. Services…read morefantastic. The best part now is that they accept credit cards. That is 100% A plus

My wife and I stopped in the other evening to Star Tavern because we had heard good things about…read moreit. The pizza was excellent. We sat at the bar and had beer and wine. The people there were very nice. We really enjoyed talking to the lady behind the bar serving us. Her name was Dena or Dina. We were very impressed. We will definitely return. A. Y. Leonard

Great classic tavern & pizza spot! We got two pies: Buffalo Chicken and Old School Everything. I…read morereally enjoyed the thinner bar pie crust, and the toppings were high quality. The anchovies on the Old School, however, were a little bit strong/salty; they could probably have had a little less of that. Otherwise, overall great food, nice servers, and cool local tavern vibes. Would love to be back and I highly recommend to all!

Saw this place on TikTok and had to try the thin crust. The interior shows some age, but in a…read morecharming, old-school way. Only a few people were dining in, so I was seated right away, and our waitress was wonderful. I do miss the days when a small one-topping pie wasn't $18, but that's how it is these days. Now the pizza. The crust was outstanding. It has a really cheesy flavor too; as El Presidente would say, "very Parmi." It was a little on the oily side, which is expected with pepperoni, but still a great pie and I'd definitely order it again. The garlic knots were ridiculous. 4 out of 5!

Been seeing their viral videos all over fb and IG so had to finally come out from queens …read more The flavors are on point , thin crust not bad at all. Zingada way to much peppers for me for sure , but a good pizza finished it all alone The special dish with chicken cutlet with mash on top and vinegar sauce was very good but again way to much vinegar and peppers I'd get just without and or maybe another sauce . I saw others getting other items which I'd try next time . Service was fast good and attentive, food came out fairly fast since I was the first person to be in the place for the day . Next time have to try the meat lovers and shrimp And also loved the dining room area really clean and fmaily style

Came here again, this time for pizza. We started with the Caprese salad. Excellent! The jersey…read moretomatoes, fresh mozzarella topped with basil was so fresh and flavorful. We then had the pizza. All ingredients are imported (from what I understand) and it was sooo good. It was just enough for 2 and I didn't have that heavy full feeling afterwards. We finished the meal off with homemade pistachio ice cream. Oh baby, was this good. The restaurant has a nice homey feel and the restroom this time around was spic and span spotless. When I was telling a friend about this restaurant (which has a new owner), she said the prices are a bit high. I totally disagree. You know the old sayng... You get what you pay for. Well you get that here. The quality of the food is exceptional and I gladly pay for quality.

There are new owners at our favorite local Italian restaurant. I ordered an eggplant sandwich and…read moreit was definitely the best I ever had. The bread was nice and crunchy and the eggplant cut very thinly and cooked just right, not to mention a great tasting sauce. I will definitely go back for a sit down dinner soon Mark S

I'm a pizza snob originally from NYC and this place is excellent. On par with the best pizza I've…read morehad from NYC. Highly recommend the popular choices but you cannot go wrong with any of them.

***3 1/2 stars***…read more Maybe it lost something in transit or I didn't get the right pie, but I wasn't blown away by this place. I've had Tony D's on my list for a while, knowing it had a solid reputation amongst the North Jersey Italians (and what better demo to have it from?). Yesterday was a perfect opportunity to order/grab some pizza and bring it over to my top-tier chum in nearby Montclair for lunch. I didn't do a ton of recon so maybe there was a more obvious/modern method to ordering, but from what I could tell, this place was pretty old school and I just picked up the phone and called over - honestly can't remember the last time I did that, but it brought a nice whiff of nostalgia for me after years of ordering on apps. Didn't realize that Tony D's is literally right around the corner from my BFF Cloverleaf, so the location is pretty convenient if you're in the area. The parking in Caldwell can be pretty annoying, and even though I'm sure I could have rolled the dice I paid a little less than a dollar to park up the street further into a residential neighborhood. Given that Tony D's is exclusively delivery/pickup joint, I think they should pay for the spots right in front as a courtesy to their customers coming in and out; maybe they do and I missed it but if not... Anyway. The guy behind the counter was VERY nice/friendly, and even though I was a few minutes early based on the estimated ETA off my phone call, the pizza literally had just come out of the oven and was ready to rock. From that vantage point, top-notch service. The specific pie that seemed to be their go-to was the Drunken Grandma, which is usually one of my favorites (vodka sauce on pizza should be much more prevalent in my opinion) but I wasn't crazy about the chunks of tomato on it. In hindsight, would have been easy to pick off or even to request that they not be included to begin with, so that would be my recommendation based on this experience. I opted for a square plain pie, especially since I knew that a few young pups would likely be sampling the wares; seemed like an overall safe bet. Optics-wise, I thought it looked very good, and I don't regret going square here. The crust for me was probably the best part, and I made sure to strategically grab all of the corner pieces once we started eating. Nice crisp to it for sure. The overall taste of the pie just wasn't my thing. I wasn't crazy about the sauce (maybe another argument for the vodka sauce, right?) and the cheese was just okay. Tasted to me more like generic by the slice pizza, which isn't my preference. My top-tier chum liked it more than I did, so definitely could just be an issue with palate preference here but this might have suffered from inflated expectations. I'd give them another shot if a similar circumstance presented itself, but I'd go with the pie it's known for - there's a reason the Drunken Grandma is front and center in almost every review. Learn from me.

I have been going here for 25 years, it's my g to work Pizza place…read more Pizza is very good as is the food and sandwiches. Always a friendly smile form the guys at the counter. AAA+++

Great old school pizzeria with super friendly proprietors. Ordered a Sicilian pie. Light fluffy…read morecrust with just the right amount of char along with a perfect cheese to sauce ratio add up to a top notch pie. We also ordered an eggplant rollatini appetizer which was excellent as well. Definitely will be going back for more. Give it a try.

Wife brought this home tonight. Square pie, chicken tenders, buffalo chicken tenders, garlic twists…read moreand fries. I'm just upset we didn't know about this place sooner. Everything was delicious, fairly portioned and very fairly priced. I'm not going anywhere else from now on. I'm so full right now; I can't even breathe.

I bought five pies last week. They didn't offer me plates or napkins. Nothing. I asked does buying…read morefive pies at least get a can of soda. The employee ignored me.

Pretty Solid Thin Crust Style Pizza here at this small but still incredibly functional old school…read morespot. You'd be forgiven if at first glance you thought there's nothing particularly special about Livingston Pizza but the fact is that this place has so much more to offer than any first impression might yield. And upon further inspection it just so happens that yours truly has found this spot to offer an excellent Pizza experience. Like I said it's Thin Crust Style so to me that just means I get to devour more of it, Lol. The Sauce that they use here is a perfectly seasoned Marinara topped with a delicious Mozzarella blend which makes for a super delicious slice. Toppings are plentiful and fresh ingredients are evident in each and every tremendously tasty bite. Service here is friendly and efficient but they really don't want you to clogg up the counter so grab your slices and get out already, Lol Come And Get Your Munch On!!

Old school store is still the best. Our cheese pizza, pizza with Italian sausage and mushroom, and…read morestromboli were so tasty tonight! Ordering online will get you 10% off. Highly recommend!

This was my first time ordering from here & I decided to have it delivered, since it was freezing…read moreout and I don't drive at night. Delivery would be 45-60 minutes, so I set my timer for 30 so I'd be ready to put the light on in the vestibule for the driver to see. Before I knew it, I got a call that the delivery driver, Joshua, was at the door! It wasn't even 30 minutes! He must have cooked my food on the way over! Joshua was very pleasant and the food was very hot! I ordered a large half sausage pizza with a side of fried mushrooms, which were both delicious. The pie had a nice thick crust, which is how I like it. I never eat the bottom crust, but break off the thick crust and scoop up the toppings. It was perfect! The fried mushrooms were tender with a very crispy & tasty coating. They were a nice size and there were plenty of them...even had some left over. Everything from placing the order with a very sweet lady to my last bite was great! I definitely recommend trying this eatery. FYI: There is parking in the lot behind it (same as where Stephanie's Italian restaurant is, since there is no parking allowed in front on Bloomfield Ave.).

Love cedar grill. Owners are real nice people. Food is always on point and hits the spot. Happy to…read moresee they have fat sandwiches. One of my guilty pleasures. I love the fat cat. Minus the tomato. But all in all. Well done :)