Hidden gem! My sweet tooth was calling me and I happened upon the establishment. It was pretty…read moreclose to my hotel so I was sold. My friend ordered 2 scoops of cookies and cream on a waffle cone. I ordered 2 scoops of chocolate with specialty dark chocolate on a waffle cone. The young lady assisting us behind the counter highly recommended it. When I tell you we sat in silence until we nearly inhaled our ice cream. It was so delicious. The richness in the flavors was definitely memorable. The portion sizes of the scoops were consistent and worth the value (around $11 for both). I would return whenever I'm in town.

Great little strip mall ice cream shop! We celebrated the last day of school with a kids cup of…read morebirthday cake ice cream with rainbow sprinkles and a turtle sundae. Both were great! The young man running the shop was friendly and helpful. You'll find a couple tables inside and a few more in the covered outside area. Not much atmosphere, but some damned good ice cream!!!

Out of town and wanted something sweet . Yogurt was delicious plenty of options. Customer service…read morewas very cold, distant and not friendly at all, but I would recommend to try their flavors.

Solid price, good topping selection and great yogurt selection. Why ask for a tip though when all…read moreyou did was put my dessert on the scale and then tell me how much it costs, I made the dang thing!!

A 5/5 rating for service and cool ice cream shop with games…read more They even make candy on certain night gets and can visit as they are making it. The shop initially began as a toy shop and evolved into a local place to hang out with specialty items and even 3 walls for disc golf enthusiasts. Staff was really helpful and let us try samples before settled on ice cream. They also have vegan ice cream and without traditional milk for lactose intolerant . Absolutely recommended.

Lofty Pursuits opened in 1993 as a small skill toy store. Skill toys are toys you play with and…read moredon't play with you. It's the difference between a video game and a yo-yo. It started with a small solid line of Kites, Darts, Yo-Yos and Juggling equipment. Now they have a place can watch them making candy and ice cream shop with fun flavors such as Java jive and Pirates Plunder. Vegan icecream and toppings? Yes!! They have those , too. If you are a disc golf fan they even have 3 walls filed with discs and disc accessories. Nostalgic games and even Tallopoly Tallahassee Monopoloy. They have board games you can play insides as enjoy brunch or their yummm soda fountain shakes. Staff was warm and friendly as sampled icecream. My family really enjoyed the not overly sweet icecream flavors.The vanilla bean was delish! Definitely worth a return visit when come back to Tally!!

I visited Bruster's for the first time last night! Very good ice cream and pleasant service. The…read morenice weather helped us to stay longer with our group of friends for May the 4th. I'll be back!

Nice local spot. Plenty of parking along with a drive-thru option…read more Orders are placed either at the drive-thru or at an outdoor window. They do not appear to have much in terms of indoor seating, however they do have a nice outdoor area where you can enjoy your treat. Plenty of options including ice cream, sorbet, cakes/pies, ice cream sandwiches, shakes, sundaes, splits, mix-ins etc. The ice cream is good, not spectacular. Definitely a nice treat in the Florida heat. Service is very friendly and efficient. They do not accept apple/google pay. If they accept physical cards remains a mystery, as the consensus of the crowd was cash-only, though I'm not certain if that's the case.

When I think about going somewhere for some ice cream, quality definitely comes to mind. Why would…read moreI go to an ice cream shop if the ice cream tastes like it's store bought? In fact, the brand that is used here is Mayfield. I was not impressed at the fact that there are no options for toppings. I literally felt like I paid $4.75 for one small scoop of store bought ice cream in a basic cone.... (waffle cones were $1 extra) I can't knock that the store is very colorful and inviting. It would make any child's day to head here for ice cream and candy. (There is an entire wall full of various candies that can be selected and weighed. I noticed it was $10.95/lb. There are also a few tables where you can sit down and eat and a TV playing kid appropriate shows, but no sound. In my overall opinion, this place is extremely overpriced but cute. It will probably generate good revenue because of the location, but there are much better ice cream shops in town.

I had a chance to try this place today and I was impressed! I had the strawberry cheesecake…read moremilkshake and I got my wife a couple scoops of butter pecan. Both items were very good and I will be back soon!

The cookies are very sweet but when you know what you're getting, they're very good! Restaurant was…read moreclean, food was fresh and service was fast.

Coming here will leave you wanting "mo" sweets!…read more As far as cookie places go, I didn't think I'd find one to top them all but Mo Cookies may have done just that. Not only is it colorfully decorated and quaint, but the cookies bring big flavor and are sure to quench your sweet tooth. We got 3 kinds and debated ordering more to go, they were that good. Even the basic frosted cookie was so delicious, with the right proportions of cookie to toppings. We really loved the guava one (my mouth is watering just thinking about it again). We came in with minimal expectations just wanting something sweet, but left with happy tummies and a new favorite cookie spot! Give me mo!

Went to a place next door for lunch and noticed this jewel. After we ate our food, we came to…read moreJeremiah's for a cool treat. I wanted a little ice crem and a little Italian ice - and this is exactly what I got! My portion was just right to top off the meal I had just eaten. I ordered vanilla soft serve with sugar free Italian ice, which was very good (jelati). My daughter ordered the Orea mud pie jelati. We both enjoyed our treats and will plan to return. Of note, there was a bit of a wait because only one person was working the counter and there was a line. But we weren't in a rush, so it was not a problem.

ICE ICE BABY | Restaurants and shops have come and go over the decades at Village Square but I was…read moresuper excited to see Jeremiah's had moved in. It's the perfect hangout spot in the 'burbs of northeast Tallahassee and we grabbed a quick sweet treat after dinner. I don't know if it's just me but I found the menu super confusing as a first time Jeremiah's customer. I pieced together the menu and the various combo/layer-in options to finally order the small Scoop Froggy Frog (mint chocolate chip) gelati swirl with mini chocolate chips. It was a lot bigger than I expected for a small - which was a pleasant surprise. We brought our dogs so we sat at one of a few tables outside while munching on our treats. Will definitely be back to try the Italian Ices next time!