Stopped here for lunch on a Friday after seeing some social media posts about their pizza. So the…read moreboys and I drove out. Upon checkin we were told that there would be a 45min wait for the food as the guy there was the only person working. How does the management allow that? They were busy too. Get my guy some help! We wanted to try it regardless and it turned into more like an hour. I really liked the pizza - we got a pepperoni and a Buffalo chicken pizza. The crust curb was great and for just a one-man team the pizza looked like we were the only people there. Even though ordering bleu cheese I didnt detect any on it - Hatt said it was sparse. The pepperoni was good - had a nice array of spices on it as well. Overall this place was good - I will be back and I'll call in ahead of time. I guess they don't take deliveries during the day ?

Called, to make an order. Phone isn't working the greatest, but you didn't have to start laughing…read moreon the phone and telling me you can't hear me, thats unprofessional and very rude.

Amazing pizza! Service was great and the space is large and combined with a bar. Lots of parking…read more They had an large pizza over, my mistake was taking it to go. After 30 minutes still tasted great but know it would have been better as soon as it came out. Highly recommend if in the area!

My friend and I came here for a late lunch after a hike. It's a cool little pizza spot that also…read morehas a convenient store attached to it. They're dog friendly as well on their screened in patio. We did the lunch special which was the tomato soup and half pizza combo. We got pepperoni pizza and it was so good! There's a bunch of games to play too. We started playing checkers until our food was ready. The staff were friendly as well. Real cool spot, would come back!

Love that they serve pizza by the slide and full pies. Very much NY style pizza. Other great…read morepasta options on the menu!

I had little to no expectations stopping here for a weekend getaway, but this was some of the…read morebetter NY style pizza I've had in some time. The woman working the counter was not the nicest upon originally checking in (I was too early for the pizza and she made that clear to me), but the food made up for the dry attitude. I don't normally go for white pizza as well, and thought their version was spectacular and full of flavor.

Tucked in along Route 28 is this incredible little bar/dinner that I just had the pleasure of…read morefinding. Nice hometown, country feel where I'm sure they have their own ' NORM!". Food was AWESOME. I had the cheesesteak and it was PERFECT! And actually hot when I got it with a wonderfully fresh bun. My cohort had the Fish and it looked so good I bummed a piece! Then wished I had ordered that too! Portion sizes provided lunch the next day for me. Staff was very attentive and kind and our server Tracey couldn't have been more kind and down to earth. A++++. I will be back:)

Food was cold but ok. Service was not great. Waitress was young and I am thinking inexperienced…read more Busy but for a Saturday night should have been expected so only one bar tender and one waitress might also have been why service was not great. Will try again on a different night.

Amazingly large portions. Great taste and service. A must when in the area. Breadsticks are the…read morebest

This place is fantastic! Only carry out since Covid however makes little difference because you…read morecould never eat everything without taking some home anyway! Portions are HuGE! So many good things on the menu but so hard for me to go away from my go-to chicken parm dinner . Chicken is always tender and juicy and pasta and sauce are great ! Homemade bread is also a treat !

We're from out of town and recently bought a property in Berkeley Springs, so we've been working…read moreour way through the local restaurants. Honestly, most have been underwhelming, with only a few exceptions. Mythical Pizza was a very welcome plot twist. We happened to drive by and pulled in on a whim. Even from the outside, the place has personality. Inside, we were greeted warmly by who I think was either the owner or manager. She explained how everything worked, gave great recommendations, and immediately made the place feel welcoming. The decor is quirky in the best way: Bigfoot, aliens, cryptids, paranormal touches, and a little gift shop. It sounds like it could be too much, but somehow it works. If a pizza place and a roadside folklore museum had a charming baby, this would be it. The menu is surprisingly broad, with pizzas, specialty crusts, pastas, salads, folded breads, strombolis, wings, desserts, and more. Since there were too many interesting pizzas to choose from, I ordered the "Flight of the Squonks," three 5 inch signature pizzas. We tried "The Alabama White Thang," "Attack of the 50' Meatball," and "Sprout Man and the Masters of the Pizzeria." All three were genuinely very good, creative without being weird for the sake of weird, and the crust was excellent. We also had barbecue wings. The wings themselves were juicy, meaty, and well cooked. The barbecue sauce was fine, though next time I'd probably ask for sauce on the side and try another flavor. The place was packed, which felt like a good sign, and the energy matched the food: fun, unpretentious, and better than expected. After a disappointing meal elsewhere the day before, where the price point really wasn't justified by the food, Mythical Pizza felt like a small-town restaurant win. Great vibe, warm service, creative menu, and very solid food. Definitely coming back.

Visiting from out of town and hubby wanted wings and I didn't feel like cooking so we found…read moreMythical Pizza here on Yelp. From the second we walked in, it felt very welcoming and friendly. I've never seen so many wonderful pizza options on one menu. I wanted all of them! He had the Alfredo Parmesan wings and he said they were delicious. I chose a pepperoni roll (I hear it's a West Virginia thing) and it was very tasty with a boat load of cheese. I personally like a spicer marinara for dipping but it was still very good. The staff was super friendly and helpful finding me the right souvenir t shirt with the Mothman on it. Oh and we tried the tiramisu and boy howdy! It was Dee-LISH!!! Def worth a try.

This was a great afternoon stop for some yummy Italian food. Pizza was delicious and it was done in…read morea fire burning oven. We sat downstairs the stairs were a little narrow. The bathroom was clean too.

Stopped in while driving between home and my kid's college. I was super confused by the parking…read morelot and trying to figure out where the front door of the restaurant was. I don't know if it was the day (the day before Thanksgiving) or if the place is just that popular but it was pretty busy. The restaurant is in a converted home, so there are all these little rooms. We were seated in a "front" room with the bar space behind us. The dining room was tight and full of people but warm and welcoming and didn't feel too crunched. Our server seemed a little flustered. She was busy but was attentive. I had the chicken parm sandwich, my son had the chicken parm entree. The chicken was pounded evenly and not too thin, breaded and crunchy. The red sauce was a little sweeter than my tastes prefer but it was enjoyable, on good bread and I demolished it. The kid's pasta was a little softer than I usually make it. Overall, it was a good experience. Their location makes it likely that we'll stop here again.

We were staying in Woodstock and just looking for an easy dinner after a long day. Ordering at the…read morecounter was easy and take out took less than twenty minutes. They nailed the cheese fries--perfection. Their pizza was just fine. The Italian hoagie was great! The grilled chicken and cheese sandwich was great! The chicken parm was soggy with sauce. But the price was great, the food was done quickly, and it was an easy dinner. We recommend it, if you are just looking for pizza shop dinner. There are booths and tables in the restaurant too! The garlic bread was NOT like garlic bread--very plain, in our opinion.

Supreme pizza and steak and cheese sub Highly recommend Good service Prompt delivery food was fresh…read moreand very tasty

The wings were very small like bite size for a 7 year old. i think this is horrible for the price…read more disappointed.

The pizza was hot and delicious. The crust was very good. It was more of a takeout restaurant. It…read moredidn't feel clean and it was old. The bathroom was clean enough but again it needed a renovation. The servers were very friendly. It looked like there was a connected dirty bar for college students next door. Even though I loved the pizza I wouldn't go back though it's worth a. Try if you're driving in the area as we were.

Awesome late lunch at Bella Napoli. I'm stuck with celiac disease but Bella Napoli has both pasta…read moreand rolls in gluten free options. I had shrimp parmegiana, steamed shrimp, and wow. So so good. Hubs had a small calzone ant it was nearly as big as his head. Great waitress. Nice casual vibe. Go there!

Stopped in here late on a Sunday evening. My fiancé and I got a large Stromboli and shrimp Alfredo…read morewith a crab dip bread bowl as an appetizer. Food was AMAZING, portion sizes were HUGE, and price was CHEAP! Our server Seth was 10/10, very friendly and polite! The entire experience and setting was perfect! Will be talking about the place to everyone I know!