Forever Diamonds

Gary and his staff came highly recommended. My wife's engagement ring needed to be repaired. Her…read morering never left our sight and the repair was completed in a matter of minutes. The ring looks as great now as it did the day I bought it for her 25 years ago! !Everyone there is very nice and knowledgeable. I will make my future jewelry purchases there ! Joe

I went in with a swollen finger and two rings that wouldn't come off. Sean greeted me immediately…read moreand was so kind and helpful, I felt so at ease. He promptly and gently cut the rings off and assured me they could be repaired. Relief! But the kindest part is that he did not accept any money for the service. I will DEFINITELY be back when it's time to repair and resize those rings. Thank you, Sean and Gennaro Jewelers for your utmost professionalism!

Good Old Gold

4.7

(143 reviews)

We recently attended Good Old Gold's Christmas Party event on December 7th, and it was absolutely…read morebeautiful! From the moment we arrived, the holiday spirit was everywhere. They had Santa outside taking photos with the kids, incredible Christmas carolers filling the air with music, and delicious refreshments throughout the store. The entire staff was warm, welcoming, and ready to help. They had multiple raffles going on--and we were lucky enough to win one! Helen and her team truly put together a magical event that made everyone feel special. While we were there, we purchased a beautiful cross for my nephew. Vincenza assisted us, and she was so sweet and helpful throughout the entire process. Good Old Gold continues to impress us with their customer service, attention to detail, and the genuine care they show their guests. We can't wait to come back!

We've used Good Old Gold now for my wife's engagement and wedding rings as well as random needed…read morepieces of jewelry over the years and resizes. The staff is incredible and always nice and quick to help, the prices are reasonable and they have a very good selection. In the past we've worked with the owner's daughter (I'm sorry, her name is escaping me) for my wife's rings and this time a really nice young lady named Chloe. Recommended.

Busy Bee Jewelry

4.0

(84 reviews)

My husband and I had such a great experience working with Sue to design my engagement ring last…read moreyear that we came back for wedding bands as well. Sue was so friendly, helpful, patient, and responsive during the entire process and everything turned out beautifully! They were ready so quickly, too - we couldn't have been happier. It was nice meeting Ziggy as well and you can tell they really are attentive to a customer's needs. Customer service is top notch! My husband grew up in the area and highly recommended Busy Bee, so it was all very meaningful for us. We would definitely return in the future!

Worst customer service. Makeup prices in their head. Poor quality…read more My boyfriend bought me a diamond bracelet from here- in which they gave him different prices on different sized diamond bracelets which is fine. But when I went in to exchange for a smaller diamond bracelet they gave me a different cost than what they told him when he was comparing them Fast forward a few months and my bracelet broke! Went in to get it repaired and charging me $30 to fix when it didn't even last a few months! Will not be back- highly discourage anyone from trusting their jewelry with this place

Collectors Watches

4.2

(94 reviews)

Steve was very professional and responsive to my messages and addressed all concerns and questions…read more Their wire prices are rock bottom and no nonsense, I did a FaceTime call just to feel comfortable with wiring money. They overnight my watch from NY to CA the next morning which was amazing service.

Bought a Tudor Heritage watch today . Excellent service, immediate response, very honest , good…read moreprice, delivery over night fedex. My first time buying from them, but already looking for another watch from them. 1000% trust in them

Great American Jewelry

4.3

(45 reviews)

I was in the store earlier today looking to sell a 14k gold chain that I have had for almost 30…read moreyears. I couldn't have been more happy with the service I received. Thank you so much Laurie your help, and the great conversation we had.

Great Service Kind Staff All my needs were met - Resized a ring, fixed watch and Amazing Brighton…read moreJewelry and wallets and Pocketbooks and overnight bags. Love this store.

Roma Jewelry

4.6

(10 reviews)

Finally an honest jeweler. I'm so happy I found Roma. Manny is a pleasure to deal with and treats…read morehis customers with great respect. He's an expert gemologist and jeweler, doing this work his entire life. His experience is far greater then any salesperson at any department store. I have been here several times with small amounts of jewelry to sell. Manny was very patient and offered better prices then anyone else did. His showcases are filled with beautiful unique precious metal chains and gemstones. Everything is sparkling clean !! Don't go anywhere else. Roma is a must !!

I have followed Roma from the beginning days of Atitas Flea market. I hated going to the flea…read moremarket but the great customer service and the reasonable pricing made walking through racks of knock off clothing and cheap toys bearable. When Atitas closed, Roma moved to his brick and mortar store in Massapequa. Of course I made the trek over there to buy my wife's engagement ring and later our wedding rings because all my siblings (and grandfather, lol) who bought engagement rings from Roma were happy with the purchase and of course, the appraisal afterwards. Plus the engravings were well done and included in the price. I highly suggest coming here for fine jewelry because they do not rush you while making a huge purchase and their pricing is completely fair. Just be cognizant of their hours, it's a little weird and rarely open after 5pm.

Lana's Jewelry

4.8

(18 reviews)

EXCELLENT SERVICE!!! got my new watch resized! super accommodating gentleman! EDUARD IS THE MAN!!!!read more

I've been to Lana's Jewelry a few times over the years. First to buy an emerald birthstone ring,…read morethen for switching out some watch batteries and most recently to get my wedding band and engagement ring fixed. Long story short, had to get my rings cut off a couple of years ago at the hospital and sadly, they were mangled!! Brought it in to see if they'd be able to help at all. Given how bad the hospital had left my rings, I did not have very high expectations. Shockingly, I'm thoroughly impressed with how my rings turned out and forever grateful to them for giving me the ability to wear them again!

Rontal Jewelry

4.5

(26 reviews)

So I've been a few times and have forgotten to write a review but decided it was time…read more The unparalleled service and personal warmth from Dali and Ben are what make this small jewelry store uncommon. I have purchased gifts as well as had remodeling done on several pieces and have been thrilled with them all. The quality of the work and the materials (diamonds, platinum, gold) are top notch. Nothing is done half-way. They are professionals who are qualified to assist and design and sell. I have recommended them to many of my friends and I will continue to be a customer for all my jewelry needs.

Dali & Ben always make you comfortable & aim to please. They provide quality & friendly honest…read moreservice with expert workmanship.

New York Jewelry Outlet

(1 review)

I will admit that this place looks a little iffy on the outside and its location is tucked away…read morebehind a grocery store. Not the best first impression. But I had the unfortunate task of selling my ex-husband's wedding ring (yay?) and I happened to be doing other errands in the same shopping plaza. So I figured I would give them a shot. My intention was to sheepishly get a quote and maybe shop around at some other places. However, I was so pleasantly surprised at how nice, understanding, and FUNNY all the employees were about this awkward task that I decided to just take their offer and be done with the whole thing. Rob weighed the ring in front of me, testing its authenticity for metal content, and gave me an estimate based on their current rate for gold purchases all while laughing and joking and making me feel like I was making any other transaction. Then, to top it all off, after he gave me the cash for the ring, he offered me fancy chocolate cookies or a mystery wrapped bottle saying, "I know divorces are hard, so I can offer you something sweet or something to get you drunk. Which would you like?" How hilarious is that?!?! So thank you, Rob (and his brother Stan), for lending some well-earned closure to that chapter in my life; perhaps I'll be back with my other rings.

Levit Jewelers

(22 reviews)

Very kind gentleman that runs the place, went to another place to get my watches batteries changed…read moreand couldn't do it, this gentleman changed both within 5 minute! very cheap price on batterie replacement and picked up their great ring cleaner as well. Very great stop with a lot of variety of jewelry for the short wait. Will definitely return again next time.

I'm so glad we went with Levit Jewelers instead of a big, commercial brand. My now fiancé worked…read morewith him to design my engagement ring and I had absolutely no idea. When he proposed, the ring was even more beautiful than anything I ever imagined for myself, and I never even went ring shopping. It feels so personal and meaningful. After the proposal, my fiancé told me that he and Dary actually looked at each diamond in person and hand-picked the one for my ring. That level of detail and care is something you just don't get anywhere else, and it really shows when you look at the ring. I had a tiny issue that was my fault and needed fixing. Dary took care of it immediately and was so kind about it. You can tell he truly cares about his customers and his craftsmanship. I stare at my ring all day and I'll definitely be going back to Dary at Levit Jewelers for our wedding bands and all future jewelry. Couldn't recommend him more.

MMPC Pest Solutions

4.8

(775 reviews)

Samuel arrived on time and immediately began to assess our property's vulnerabilities to rat…read moreincursions. he took the time to listen as I explained our history with pest control and responded with a variety of solutions. he explained the pros and cons of each solution and how they work in the short term and long term to manage and reduce rat incursions. Samuel was professional, courteous, and efficient with our limited time. recommended!

We've had a problem with a rat for a minute; this POS made a hole in the wall and when I tried to…read moreblock his only entrance spot he started chewing on the wood I used to block it. I called MMPC and they sent someone within a day (there was a snow problem in NYC so they ended up not being able to come on the same day, otherwise they would have). Anyways the issue was resolved in like 6 hours. So great.

Alterations by Marisa

(16 reviews)

Marisa is not only a highly skilled seamstress but also a lovely, warm person. I brought a dress to…read moreher that needed some creative alterations and she surpassed all of my expectations! She took pieces from one dress and added them to my dress to fit it exactly to me. Please don't hesitate to call Marisa. She really is the best!

My new found tailor. She is wonderful. I waited to find a dress for my daughters wedding and then…read morefound her thru Yelp. Well she made it happen for my dress, my sisters and my Neice who was a brides maid. We literally picked up the dresses two day before wedding. She is reliable and absolutely the sweetest. Will recommend her to everyone!!!!!

Design and Build Landscape

(16 reviews)

After much thoughtful deliberation I hired Design and Build Landscape to remove old shrubbery and…read moreplant new shrubbery in the front and side of our home. From beginning to end, Lance and Robert provided a professional, careful approach to the project. The crew was careful, neat and specific with the planting and I am so very happy with the end result. I would happily recommend them for any landscaping job.

Design and Build is a very efficient and trustworthy outfit. Lance & Robert went out of their way…read moreto explain what exactly they would do in order to benefit us. They were meticulous and very orderly. They achieved all the objectives & landscaping that we wanted. I recommend them very highly and I do look forward to working with them again.

Home Aid Appliance Repair

4.8

(13 reviews)

Had issues with dishwasher and Jose had to come back 3x to finally assess the dishwasher is broken…read more He googled a lot to show me his findings. Like dishwasher detergent goes bad after 6 months. Would have thought he knew this basic knowledge

Don't lose this number! We called at 11 am for an issue with our dryer, I suspected the belt broke…read more Call back within 10 minutes, service tech Jose got here at 11:45, done at 12:15!! Great service, nice people and good value, not cheap but done right!!!

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

19 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Erin W.

0

2

0

9 years ago

My Fiancé purchased my engagement ring as well as my wedding band from Forever Diamonds. Both rings are absolutely beautiful!!! Soon after our engagement we went in there to get my rings re-sized and I was greeted with professionalism. Everyone we in countered was friendly. Albert was the main person we dealt with and I couldn't be more pleased. He went above and beyond for us, even to make it appoint to find my future husband's wedding band (which is a very specific ring). Talking with him was like talking to an old friend who you haven't seen in awhile. We felt very at ease dealing with him and I highly recommend that if you are in the market for jewelry to go to Forever Diamond and talk with their knowledgeable staff. We will certainly be returning customers. read more

Ann B.

0

2

0

9 years ago

My husband and I recently visited Forever Diamonds since I wanted something special for our 25th anniversary. I went in with one thing on my mind but with Stan's help came out with something even better than expected. Stan suggested taking my 1990's marquis shape diamond and placing it into a halo setting. Along with a new diamond wedding band the end result is breathtaking. (I actually told Stan 'it looks fake' when I picked up the rings because I couldn't believe how beautiful they are!) Stan also suggested a beautiful new ring for my husband. Stan was extremely helpful, creative, patient and kind. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend anyone to visit Forever Diamonds. Ann B. read more

James W.

0

1

7 years ago

Hello, Just wanted to say I came by the other day with my brothers to create an engagement ring and we spoke to Albert the owner and he was very informative and helpful with us! I appreciate the Honesty and excellent customer service they provided us throughout the entire experience. They helped me create the dream ring I've always wanted and I couldn't be more happier! Definitely recommend this jewelry store to all my fellow friends and family. Will be back soon! read more

Jacqueline R.

0

1

0

11 years ago

This is a great family-owned business with the convenience of Long Island shopping but the inventory and access to everything 47th Street in Manhattan has to offer. I have been a customer for over 15 years and have truly enjoyed watching Albert, Stan, and Robert build and upgrade their business to the beautiful store they have now. Gifts, artwork, sunglasses, and jewelry are their specialty - there is something for everyone! read more

Mike S.

0

3

0

9 years ago

My family and I have been using and trusting forever diamonds for so many years!! They have such beautiful good quality jewelry at such fair prices! I trust them and will continue to use them for all of my purchases and repairs. They have customized so many amazing pieces for me with the finest quality and design! I have gotten nothing but amazing compliment from every piece I have ever purchased from them !!! read more

Michael P.

24

2

0

7 years ago

I was told about Forever Diamonds by a co worker, Jimmy Vee, I wanted to buy a ring for me and my wifes 30 year wedding anniversary. When I walked in I was welcomed right away. I didn't know what I was really looking for but the staff and owner himself help me in design a beautiful ring. When I gave the ring to my wife see was speechless and happy to tears. Thank you again for a beautiful experience. read more

Scott C.

0

1

0

9 years ago

My wife and I have been customers of Forever Diamonds in Massapequa for over 15 years. Albert, Stan and all the employees treat you like family. They have high quality jewelry, superior craftsmanship, competitive prices and also have financing available for qualified customers. I have recommended many friends over the years and they are always satisfied with Forever Diamonds, check them out. read more

Cindy R.

0

8

0

6 years ago

I have been going with my husband to forever diamonds for many years... they feel like family.. Albert the owner is charming and very knowledgeable... Stan has assisted us in creating beautiful pieces custom for us... We look forward to our next occasion so we can go back and buy another one of there beautiful pieces of jewelry..will not go anywhere else,,,, Cindy & Mr. Nunzio lol read more

B M.

0

3

0

9 years ago

My husband and I purchased my engagement ring and our wedding bands at Forever Diamonds. The staff/owners are always attentive to us whenever we need cleaning and adjustments made to our jewelry and we never leave disappointed. I would recommend Forever Diamonds to anyone looking for a place to purchase top notch jewelry and wonderful customer service. read more

J W.

0

134

0

5 years ago

Always a Good Experience when I walk In Kind , Polite and a very Large selection to choose from at least this is Jeweler I can trust as I had a Terrible Experience with Great American in Massapequa I gave them a 18 Karat ring to size and They Ruined it at Least Here I Know the Work is Honest , Sincere and Most Professional Happy To Be a Customer read more

Joey A.

353

1

0

9 years ago

Stan's the best! Bought my engagement ring here and he was in contact with me the whole time. My fiancé loved it! She had picked out the ring setting on pinterest and I showed Stan a couple pictures of it and he was able to completely duplicate it! Great service! Great people! Great PRICE! Highly recommend Stan and his place. read more

Dana P.

0

1

2

5 months ago

This is the only jewelry store I trust. They're always so welcoming and do an amazing job fixing and improving my pieces. I have several items from them, and the quality is consistently beautiful. They're also very honest, which I really appreciate. Definitely my go-to spot I wouldn't go anywhere else. read more

Lauren V.

0

2

0

7 years ago

I had a great experience here on Friday. They helped me pick the perfect gift for my boyfriend and a little something extra for my self! ! Their customer service is superb and I walked out of the store extremely satisfied. I will be going back!! read more

Catherine B.

0

2

0

9 years ago

I visited Forever Diamonds today on the recommendation of a friend.. Stan was so helpful and knowledgeable. I purchased a beautiful new setting and I am thrilled with my new ring. They were courteous and very friendly. It was a great experience. read more

Marianne K.

0

1

0

2 years ago

This is a beautiful family owned business. Their selection of jewelry can't be beat. This is the only place we shop for jewelry and the only place we trust. Beautiful people and they always treat you like family. read more

Mary Jane Z.

0

1

6 years ago

Had a great experience with Stan @ Forever Diamonds reset my Engagement ring & couldn't be happier it came out beautiful will definitely go back again for all my jewelry! read more

Hr C.

0

2

0

12 years ago

Guys are great! Made engagement ring process about as easy as it gets A+++++++ From now on whenever I need jewelers, I know where to go. read more

Gina M.

0

1

0

3 months ago

wonderful service, amazing selection highly recommend! Purchased baby bracelet for christening and baby earrings read more

Amy N.

0

1

0

11 months ago

Very gracious listening and assistance Recommend shopping here. Pleasant and clean, beautiful choices. read more

Forever Diamonds - jewelry - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Forever Diamonds also viewed

East Islip Jewelers

3.8

(10 reviews)

I took my late sister's silver ring in because the large agate stone was moving and I wanted it…read moresecured. Vanessa suggested adding prongs. The prongs did not look good. I used AI to get alternatives. I brought in a picture of a partial bezel that looked good and would secure the stone. Vanessa said we need to make a new ring. I agreed. When I picked it up, I was aghast that a completely new ring was made, not like the old ring and not like the ring in the picture. They actually rubbed out the details in the picture I gave her. When I reprinted it I saw the details they did not do. It looks like a man's ring now! Vanessa said they tried twice and cannot make me happy and she returned all my money. There was no effort to fix their mistake. Just go and good luck with what is now, a man's ring!

I am not a jewelry person but i wanted some custom work done to a cross that was given to me as a…read morechild from a family member who passed away. They took my family members ash diamond and made it look perfect in the cross. Vanessa the rep who helped me when i walked in was very welcoming and did not make me feel weird about the request. John the jeweler who did the work did a phenomenal job. I couldn't be happier. Not only did it come out great but the cleaning they did to it made it look brand new again. It was literally almost black with tarnish. I will be going back whenever i need it cleaned. I would recommend them to anyone.

From Italy With Love

4.7

(95 reviews)

Great doing business with Jeff. Fair offer would recommend to everyone looking to buy or sell.read more

Extremely pleasant staff with upfront pricing on their items. I came here for watch battery…read morereplacements and was very pleased with the service and the reasonable rate of $10/watch.

Wm Mazza Fine Jewelry

4.3

(6 reviews)

Horrible experience. These people charged 3x the in store quoted price. They added services that i…read moredid not request and did not perform the service i did request. I was told to google a remedy for my request, which i did and was an easy fix.

Kind, courteous and helpful. Beautiful unique modern pieces. Let them know your price range and…read morethey will find you something special. Do not waste time or money at Macy's or a department store. Jewelry here blows it away. Everything gets beautifully wrapped too. Excellent! Seriously have gone in $200-300 and got awesome gifts.

Fine Jewelry by Stacey

4.2

(6 reviews)

I have been going to Stacey for years. They are friendly and reliable. Do not hesitate. Their staff…read moreis terrific and will not lead you astray.

I came in to exchange a Christmas present from my husband. Robin and Stacy were very helpful and so…read morefriendly. My experience shopping here made me so happy - I feel so good about what I picked out. I'll definitely be back!

Parthenon Framing & Printing

(14 reviews)

The people here are truly top-notch, and the quality of their framing is simply outstanding. Their…read moreselection is excellent, their lead times are remarkably good, and their workmanship is among the very best we have encountered. I only wish we had discovered them sooner. This praise is completely unsolicited--it is simply our honest experience. They have their business down to a science: knowledgeable, professional, efficient, and consistently reliable. Our office is based in Manhattan, where there is certainly no shortage of framing companies, yet we make the trip specifically to work with them on our projects. When that isn't convenient, they will even arrange to pick up the artwork, which makes the entire process incredibly easy. We recommend this company without hesitation for the quality of their work, professionalism, service, selection, and very competitive pricing. As interior designers, we work with many vendors and craftspeople, and we do not give praise lightly. They have earned ours. Quite simply, we consider them among the best in the business. GARCIA / MALDONADO, INC. Interior Design & Architecture

I've had a couple of pieces framed here. The staff is great and very thorough in guiding me through…read morethe process. Both pieces look fabulous! Can't recommend highly enough.

Ronny's Jewelry

3.5

(21 reviews)

•$$$$

I bought a gold cross and necklace for my son and it was an awesome piece…read more My son was very happy with his chain ! Quality Jewlery Thank you Jd

The best in the business! I've been buying jewelry from Ronny for years, the selection, the…read morelocation, customer experience everything is superb. I recommend (& challenge) everybody to come to Ronny and compare your current jewelers prices & quality of work to Ronny, & then YOU tell me who is better... #shouldhavewenttoronny!

Libutti Diamond Jewelers

3.8

(59 reviews)

Libutti Diamond Jeweler is my go to. Everyone is friendly, helpful and very accommodating. I was…read moresorry to read negative reviews from years back because I've never experienced or witnessed anything butvthevutand care.

Libutti has absolutely blown me away! I will be a customer for life. Thank you, Jamie!…read moreJamie worked my now fiancé to design and execute the most breathtaking and unique engagement ring that brought my vision to life. They take an unparalleled approach to customer service and make you feel like family. Jamie made sure I felt 100% comfortable with the ring fit and helped us fine tune the sizing to perfection.

Snug Harbor Jewelry

4.3

(12 reviews)

Dropped off an eco drive for a new capacitor and I was impressed that the person I handed the watch…read moreto knew exactly what was wrong. Then it took a week for someone to call me to say they couldn't do the work....a week. On the call I was told the watch was sent to another location, when I get there I get my watch handed to me and the girl there doesn't say a word to me until I'm half way out the door. Glad to see all the nice reviews for this place but me and mine will be going elsewhere.

Went in two weeks to have a watch battery replaced and was charged $20. Went in yesterday to have…read moreanother watch battery replaced and was charged $81. I do not trust this place as they are price gouging. Also tried on a few bracelets which was clearly old and used. I will not be returning to this place. Rip off

The Karat Shop

4.5

(23 reviews)

I had a great experience with sam.. he has answered all my qs whenever i reached out. I got a gold…read more18k white gold bangel.. it came beautifully in a blue box. He answered all my concerns with honesty. I paid in a few increments and he trusted me even after sending out the bangel. I also got an incredible price on it. Others charge alot more and price gouge. Sam charged me for the price of gold at that present time and some for labor etc. I got a great price for 37-38 grams of nice white 18k gold

I brought 2 items in for repair and when I went to pick them up, my solid gold chain was missing…read more They claimed they never received it. Stay away from this place! I will sue them in small claims court. Jean and Sam are crooks.

The Gold Source

4.6

(9 reviews)