Best Deli! You get what you pay for. Greatest selection ever. Cleanest store, ever! Service top…read morenotch.

9 dollar BEC and it was special in any way. A desplay of…read moreshrinkflation and inflation at its finest.

They were a great spot up until about the time they renovated the inside. Service has gone…read moredownhill significantly. Not only are the new workers slower, but they don't seem to know how to make decent food. I've had an iced coffee which was like warm with 3 small ice cubes, the Fairway wrap which was missing lettuce and had two small slices of roast beef (it was primarily bread the size of a taquito) and most recently a bagel with cream cheese that had basically basically no cream cheese whatsoever. After so many tries I have to give up until something changes

I haven't met a sandwich from Locust Valley Deli that I haven't liked. They're experts in creating…read moredelectable bites, and I plan to try all of them.

Stayed here in Bayville for a week, so came here every day at least once. Everything was…read moreabsolutely delicious! Great staff too! We visit here from SoCal 2 or 3 times a year and always look forward to breakfast here! Five stars!!!

Our go to for breakfast, bacon is cooked just right not clumped up and greasy, within walking…read moredistance of our home.

My favorite thing: friendly, neat, fresh, awesome cold dishes, hot dishes to come! Last of…read moreneighborhood delis to visit!!! Dont't miss this GEM OF A DELI!!!

Step back in time to this neighborhood gem. Great Jelly donuts! Fresh bread and friendly people,…read morehighly recommend stopping in. Thank you!

Locust Valley Market had Bell n Evan's turkey on sale so I decided to go in and check them out. So…read moreglad I did. Not only was staff attentive friendly and willing to help. But they have a butcher on site who butterflied my turkey. Meat selection was wonderful, produce was fresh and their shelves were stocked. Didn't have to go anywhere else. Got everything on my list. If you're in the area or just want to check out the quaint village there are plenty of great restaurants and shops to explore too.

Absolutely a true "hands-on" market, great meat, produce & Deli superb, with Dave at the helm of…read morethe deli, always ready to help or prepare excellent food. If an item is not available, they will order it and service is what all employees are trained to do. Its my main stay for shopping and I am grateful they are in our small town of Locust Valley! Highly Recommend shopping here!

Awesome local butcher in Bayville , very interesting sausages , great beef /variety of cuts ,…read morepoultry and phenomenal fried chicken, sandwiches. One really cool product they offer is B.A.R.F Dog food (Biologically Appropriate Raw Food ) at a super reasonable price . Well worth a trip from all local towns along the North Shore of Long Island . Awesome local business to have in Bayville, local and family owned always a great combination Fantastic service in an old school butcher shop with some new twists

Got a Pork Cutlet Pasquale which consisted of fried hot cherry peppers with garlic. Also got a Ed's…read morecheesesteak which consisted of sirloin, caramelized onions and American cheese. Cute store.

When I was young, I used to go goto Bayville a lot. They had an excellent arcade, for those who…read moreremember. So being back in town, I decided to try some eating. "Bayville Deli & Pizzeria" is a combo, you don't hear about a lot. Pizza, deli are two different businesses, and for good reason. It's not easy to mix. Inside it's a decent size. It's a bit dated, but I love that it offers seating for guest. At the counter, the staff were very friendly. They took my order and went to work. Once I got it, I sat down to eat. However, when you want an egg sandwich, you expect a couple things. For starters, cheese should be melted. Second, they should add more ketchup when you ask. So my experience was underwhelming. I wish it could have been better. I love Bayville, but some parts are not always how we remember.

The Ice Coffee is bitter, and my friend got a hot coffee, which was gross too. One of the cashiers…read morewas not so nice. I expect a good coffee for over $5 (Large Iced). Sorry guys.

Everything went way above expected every time I treat my family every week to a meal at forest…read moreave grill. Can't recommend one particular meal because "it's all good "

Order at counter deli with about ten tables. Turkey chili soup was delicious with fresh tomatoes,…read morefirm kidney beans, lots of ground turkey and hint of heat. Came with bread and a small corn muffin. Breakfast sandwich came with home fries and coffee. Prices very reasonable. Worth a detour.

What a great little place. Large hot buffet. Plenty of sandwich options. Full range of snacks and…read moremuffins.

Food is outstanding!! Service is superb and super friendly. We love the subs Friday for lunch.read more

We walked into this location on Saturday at noon. Susan, the lady who helped us, was beyond…read moreamazing. She took our order with great precision and was very helpful in explaining the menu items. We ordered a bacon, egg, and cheese on a croissant, a bacon, egg, and cheese on a roll, and a grilled chicken hero with lettuce. However, since they were out of hero bread, Susan offered to make us a larger roll instead. We opted to get two rolls for the chicken. Our food was ready within six minutes. I have to give Susan praise because her service was truly exceptional. If I knew Susan would be there to help me every time, I would come back as often as possible during the week. When we got home, the food was delicious--everything was tasty and fresh. The coffee was excellent too, and I loved all the options they had. Fuimos a este local el sábado al mediodía. Susan, la señora que nos atendió, fue más que increíble. Tomó nuestro pedido de manera muy precisa y fue de gran ayuda al explicarnos los platos del menú. Pedimos un sándwich de tocino, huevo y queso en un croissant, otro en un pan de rollo y un sándwich de pollo a la parrilla en un pan tipo 'hero' con lechuga. Sin embargo, como se les habían acabado los panes 'hero', ella nos dijo que podía hacernos un rollo más grande. Optamos por pedir dos rollos para el pollo. Nuestra comida estuvo lista en seis minutos. Tengo que elogiar a Susan porque su servicio fue excepcional. Si supiera que ella me va a atender cada vez que venga, intentaría regresar todas las veces posibles durante la semana. Cuando llegamos a casa, la comida estaba deliciosa; todo estaba sabroso y fresco. El café también estaba muy bueno y me encantaron todas las opciones que ofrecen.

Excellent bagels! I went here 2 days in a row and really enjoyed my bagel w/ cream cheese each…read moreday. I had the sesame bagel with olive cream cheese which was super amazing. Then I had an everything bagel with lox cream cheese which was also phenomenal. Service was speedy, but it was 6:30a during the week, so your milage may vary based on when you go (time and weekends I hear get busy) and if there are specials on certain days. If I find myself in the area, I'm going here again!