The best pastrami sandwich on Long Island? Yes, the hype is correct. What a blessing that FiveHigh has come to our town. I fnally treated myself to the hot new sandwich in town (well, new to me), the house-made, thick-cut Outrageous Pastrami. God tier and worth every penny. I later sampled the insanely delicious pastrami Reuben, which was equally killer. Love this place! read more

FiveHigh Marketplace - house-made, thick-cut Outrageous Pastrami - Health Markets Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Okay so this spot was delicious! Firstly, I enjoyed how this spot looked from both the outside and inside- very well kept. Only downside is no visible bathrooms on site. I came after a hike at Cold Spring Harbor so this would've been nice for me to use for washing my hands. They have some high chair seating inside but my friend and I opted to sit at the tables outside. They have a couple of round tables so definitely come on a nice weather day if you plan on staying. Service was fine- they seemed very self aware and diligent to get my order prepared within a certain time frame as when they handed me my food they apologized for the wait and it wasn't even that long of a wait at that point. Food wise, here's what we had: Sides: -Steak Fries: these are not in the menu so I had to ask if they had fries. These were DELICIOUS! Perfectly crispy and fluffy on the inside. I'm happy I ordered these to pair with my sandwich. Entree: -Cajun Chicken Sandwich: (Cajun chicken cutlet, avocado, onion, tomato, cheese) AMAZING! First of all this was HUGE so it's a good thing we ordered one to share! This was so delicious through and through. The combination of everything together was perfect and this sandwich was PACKED. I'd definitely order this again! Drinks: -Green Hulk Smoothie: my friend thoroughly enjoyed this smoothie! -Beach Vibes Smoothie: this was nice and refreshing as it has some orange juice in it. Pretty good spot and I will be back- hopefully to try the pastrami sandwich next time! read more

See all

We did a pick up order - there was a lot of parking in their mini lot. Service was quick and they were friendly. They have different prices for cash vs card. We got large steak fries which was OK but I wouldn't get again. The chicken fantastic was great - it's on a roll and it's a little spicy so if you don't like spicy don't get it. The rodeo was also great and it is on a hero. My kids loved the chicken parmigiana. They also loved the Nutella shake but didn't like the strawberry and cream smoothie - it has strawberries, honey, and yogurt; the latter being the reason why they didn't like it so if you or your kids aren't fans of Greek yogurt don't get it. The blue devil smoothie tastes exactly as the list of ingredients so if you don't like one of them I do t recommend you get it. The smoothies are one size and all very heavy, I wish they had a smaller size as the price for each one was around $11-13 with card fees. read more

See all

So delicious! I've already been here a few times since our first visit. They have excellent quality sandwiches: build your own, or choose one of their signature sandwiches! We tried: Their AMAZING Pastrami Sandwich, Cajun Chicken Sandwich, Spicy Chicken Sandwich (their spin on Popeyes Sandwich), SEC breakfast sandwich, build your own salad bar, smoothies.... they also have hot food, and your usual convenience store items. Service: The owner and his staff have a real passion for what they do, and it shows! Everyone is super nice as well. Inside and out: They have the perfect spot for on-the-go convenience in Huntington...their own parking lot, and it's free! I have been on time crunches and needed a quick sandwich...I was able to get a warm perfect SEC in under 5 minutes. Feel like hanging out? They have chairs and a high rise table against the windows to sit and eat as well! read more

See all

Looking for a no frills deli near my employer. Happened upon this innocuous marketplace and ordered a low fat wrap. Turkey Wrap: lots of turkey, lettuce, tomato, onion, lite mayo. It was average, but my order was also average. Price: Wrap, quarter pound of mac, and a Celsius came out to $23. This should probably be closer to $15, but it is unfortunately comparable to prices in the area. Mac: WOW! 10/10 I find it so hard to find good mac salad these days. Tasty, either no mayo or lite mayo, and al dente. They hit it out of the park with this, and I will be back for the mac and mac alone! Friendliness: The guys behind the counter were cheery and pleasant. Sometimes you aren't even acknowledged at these small delis, but the staff here are friendly and personable. I will be a regular here. read more

FiveHigh Marketplace - Quarter Pound of Macaroni Salad - Health Markets Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

I like this place. Recently opened, it was my son in law that suggested lunch here because of the pastrami sandwich (affectionately called their "outrageous pastrami"). We both share a love for great deli and BBQ, so I naturally jumped at the chance. Warmly greeted by the owner, we went straight to ordering what I'm guessing is their signature offering and I'm glad we did. What came over the counter was a piled high, 12oz stack of goodness on rye, with one curious difference...yes, it was still hand cut (as all great pastrami sandwiches should be), but it was thick cut. As the owner explained, the meat is so tender, it would just shred in a slicer and it was a perfect explanation. Over the years, I've had my fill (pun intended) with dry, characterless deli meats, but this one was eye opening. Tender, flavorful with plenty of speck (go look that one up, it's an essential way to order in any proper NY deli). Coupled with a cream soda, it was a perfect lunch and another great place to add to my rotation. On-site parking, all cards and a few window seats to watch the world go by. Sure, there's a ton of food opportunities in Huntington, but if you're looking for an honest pastrami sandwich, this place gets my thumbs up! read more

See all

The best F@ck!ng pastrami on Long Island. Don't bother anywhere else. Don't sleep on the eggs and pastrami too . Owner runs it , he's awesome , lets people park there at night bc parking is crazy in downtown Huntington. This place should get 6 stars read more

The cappuccino I ordered was not a cappuccino, but apart from that the egg wrap I got was delicious. Definitely a top notch spot in the area! A good deli you can rely on. Definitely recommend. read more

Huge shoutout to the owner, Ben, and his team for such great service. FiveHigh Marketplace is a CLEAN deli with delicious food! I came in for a sandwich before my half marathon tomorrow and boy it was packed out! The sandwich is stuffed and came out fast, the employees were friendly and what a great location! If you have not stopped by to welcome them to the area or you haven't tried their food yet, you're missing out. I am so happy I stopped in here and now I'm looking forward to my next visit!! read more

FiveHigh Marketplace - Health Markets Near Me - Huntington, New York

Probably the best pastrami sandwich I've had on Long Island. Katz is still the best, but this one is worth trying. Very tender, Juicy meat (more so than other pastrami) with a distinct flavor profile that's different from any pastrami I've had before. It didn't have as much bark as i normally like. Not overly fatty, which is a plus. It's 22.95 for 14 oz. read more

FiveHigh Marketplace - Pastrami sandwich - Health Markets Near Me - Huntington, New York

We wanted something quick while waiting for tires to be replaced on our car so we decided to head to Huntington for a pastrami sandwich. We had what we thought was the best pastrami sandwich at Herschel's in Reading Terminal Market. Considering the not so easy ride to PA, FiveHigh is a great substitute. The meat was juicy chunks, not dry slices. The only issue I had was I think the rye bread was too fresh. Granted we ordered online and it was probably sitting there longer than it should have but the bottom slice was soggy. Again, maybe we wouldn't have had soggy bread if we ordered on the spot and ate it right away. We literally went in, picked up the order and walked out, so I have no idea what else they offered or what the rest of the store looked like. We took our bag and consumed it in the car. Later, as we pulled away, I noticed that they had 3 tables set up outside. I guess we didn't have to eat in the car...next time! read more

FiveHigh Marketplace - Pastrami - Health Markets Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

I tried the new spooky lattes and the pumpkin spice smoothie and they were so delicious! The pumpkin spice smoothie was surprisingly so refreshing! It had a blend of banana, pineapple and felt really fresh! The service was so friendly and fun, I can't want to try their food next time! read more

FiveHigh Marketplace - Caramel marshmallow latte, pumpkin marshmallow latte, chocolate marshmallow latte and the pumpkin spice smoothie - Health Markets Near Me - Huntington, New York

We got a smoothie and two egg sandwiches. The coffee machine wasn't working. It was pretty expensive for what we got.

This place has very quick service but I haven't been impressed by their smoothies. With them marketing themselves the "Erewhon of Long Island" I had much higher expectations but every time I try one it just tastes like a plain blended bananas. While they are very pretty for photos, I would stay away at that price point. read more

FiveHigh Marketplace - blue devil smoothie - Health Markets Near Me - Huntington, New York

This place is INCREDIBLE!! First time I got the salad bar. You can choose AS MANY toppings as you want. There's so much to choose from, and it makes enough for 4 people. I added some grilled chicken for the lean protein for an extra $1.82 The price for all this is unheard of . The young lady is so kind and cheerful. When they added dressing, another worker helped- one with the olive oil and one with the red wine vinegar. Then they ask if you want it chopped, which i highly recommend. Greens, all kinds of vegetables, even hearts of palm, artichoke hearts, sun dried tomatoes. Brought the food to the house and was able to serve 3 people AND have plenty of leftovers. Next time I went had to get that amazing salad again. Also bought 2 large chicken vegetable soups because my dad was sick. My parents raved about the soup. Next time I go , I plan to get a pastrami sandwich. The meats look delicious. So glad they opened this wonderful store, and it's now my favorite place in Huntington ! Besides for amazing food and value, the customer service is hard to beat. They also have fresh smoothies and juices. Enjoy! Delivery is available too read more

FiveHigh Marketplace - Huge salad ( this is just 1/4 of it!) - Health Markets Near Me - Huntington, New York

OUT OF THIS WORLD PASTRAMI!!!! Seriously this is the juiciest pastrami I've ever had. The bark and brine is insanely delicious and the meat is tender and melts in your mouth. There's other pastrami places but none have the quality and taste like this one. Kindest staff, special shout out to Ben for making our visit all worth it. Will 100% be returning for the best pastrami sandwich in Long Island!!! read more

FiveHigh Marketplace - Outrageous Pastrami Sandwich - Health Markets Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Wow! I saw someone eating a sandwich at a local watering hole. Looked over and said to myself damn. That looks like a pastrami sandwich. A good one at that. Sure enough it was. Asked her where she got it and one day later this is what I got. My wife got the Cajun Chicken sandwich. She loved it Both sandwiches more than enough for two plus meals!! read more

FiveHigh Marketplace - Cajun Chicken Sandwich - Health Markets Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Stopped by this morning & ordered the Chicken Fantastic Sandwich, a Coffee and a turmeric Ginger Shot. Everything was delicious plus the staff was friendly and polite. Place looks clean & renovated which is amazing. God bless these people & their business. read more

FiveHigh Marketplace - Health Markets Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

This place is unreal. Look at this Reuben they make with their made-in-house pastrami. You can tell how good that is just by looking at it, and yeah, it was incredible. This place knows how to make a truly great sandwich and clearly they put pleasing the customer first. They deserve their success. read more

FiveHigh Marketplace - Reuben sandwich - Health Markets Near Me - Huntington, New York

The beast pastrami that I've ever eaten. Been back a number of times, and told all my friends.

Best Pastrami sandwich I've ever had, damn Mr. Ben knows how to make some good food! Also awesome that they're open so late - not many late night options available on LI. read more

I went to check out al the hype over their homemade pastrami. All the hype is well deserved. The pastrami is delicious, tender, moist, and flavorful. The store is immaculate and the service is friendly and efficient. I will certainly be back to try out their other homemade specialties (corned beef, turkey, etc,,,) read more

Amazing sandwiches -- MASSIVE!! Coming for the Katz deli title of best pastrami for sure. I loved the Reuben as well read more

FiveHigh Marketplace - Pastrami empanada - Health Markets Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

Very nice people working here , tried the pastrami and although it was a little greasy for me the pastrami was delicious! Next time I must try the pastrami sandwich. The tuna and chicken salad wraps were amazing...they don't skimp out on meat or chicken salad or tuna. Definitely worth every penny. The strawberries and cream and blue devil smoothies were also very good. All in all an amazing deli so far as I can tell and can't wait to come back again. We just took our food to go so not familiar with dining in but the place also looks very clean. read more

Amazing food and drinks!! We tried the new fall drinks and they were incredible! The service is fast and the workers are so nice and helpful! The best deli in Huntington! Definitely check it out!! read more

FiveHigh Marketplace - Health Markets Near Me - Huntington, New York

See all

One of the best pastrami sandwiches I ever had, it's up there with Katz's. I tried the pastrami sandwich 4 times already and every time I have it, it just gets better and better. Sandwich is so large that I only could only eat half and I save or share the other half. Highly recommend. read more

Great pastrami sandwich. Had to take meat off so I could eat it. Flavor was great as well

Absolutely delicious pastrami sandwich, truly the best we've ever had on Long Island. Had to fight the urge to turn back and get another for the road. We'll definitely be back! read more

Wow did I finally find a place that makes a great chicken sandwich? I actually did! I was just driving through the village and I was like oh man I could go for a chicken sandwich but nobody makes them good. I remembered that this place opened a little while ago. I figured I'd take a look and probably leave disappointed. The person at the front who was probably the owner was really nice and even overheard that we both wanted to try eachother's sandwich so he said he'd be glad to cut them in half. We got the spicy chicken and the Cajun chicken. They were absolutely delicious! Good quality ingredients and very big! My husband actually got stuffed - that never happens. We were pleasantly surprised! Good to know I can get a good chicken sandwich! read more

Had a half corned beef half pastrami Reuben. Was outstanding. Highly recommend. Meat was high quality and delicious

Food is really good and fast service. Very fresh and large variety of healthy options. I got a fresh juice (made in front of me) and a salad from their salad bar. Highly recommend (plus they play fun music) read more

See all

Sometimes I will read a review and say I have to try that place. This was one of the few times that the product exceeded the hype. The pastrami here is so good. My wife and I could have easily split one sandwich... but then there would be no leftovers. read more

Love this place. Great food, drinks and the employees are all super kind and friendly.

Ordered through door dash- 2 bologna sandwiches and a smoothie total comes to $60...which is outrageous. Get the order and we were given pistachio mortadella. First off who the fu** eats pistachio mortadella. Second off I would never pay $60 for this. First time ordering here, will be our last. read more

Rarely do I post any reviews, pastrami on rye is awesome. Katz Deli eat your heart out! Worth the trip to Huntington.

Can any suburban NY pastrami sandwich come close to Katz's in NYC or Schwartz's in Montreal? These two are universally regarded as the best. Five High's 14 oz version, priced similarly to these two, comes very close. It is absolutely delicious, no doubt. I ate every last bit of it, picking up the broken pieces with my fingers, mustard and all. I wondered if a sturdier rye bread could have held it all together a bit better, as the sandwich does tend to fall apart. It is definitely shareable, if you are so inclined. I liked how the building is set off by itself with it's own little parking lot. All in all......I will be back. I'll try some of the other sandwiches too! read more

Friendly Staff, amazing food- Spicy Chicken sandwich was delicious! Will definitely return soon.

Came here to try the strawberries and cream smoothie from TikTok of course. My friend and I were starving and decided to try one of the Tribeca heroes. It was absolutely delicious and soo filling. After we tried our smoothies and loved them so much. Staff was super friendly and made our experience lovely. Try this place as soon as you can !! There are a few tables outside as well so you can enjoy your breakfast or lunch! read more

Best pastrami sandwich on Long Island. Their chicken cutlet heroes are also insane. Highly recommend.

The Cajun Chicken on Ciabatta with avocado swiss and chipotle mayo is phenomenal! Just enough spice! What a sandwich!! Stopped by for lunch on the road and was in and out. The service was great. read more