Pizza was fabulous! This is not a sit down pizza restaurant, but an order to go. They were pretty busy for 10 pm at night, but 15 minutes and we had hot, cheesy goodness sliding down our throats. Car picnic if you like there was ample parking in the small strip mall. Would have given 5 stars but I had to walk through a cloud of smoke to enter and really wished they had some indirect seating, but the staff was friendly and it met the need for pizza after the beach. read more

Five Star Pizza - Half pepperoni 18" EXTRA LARGE - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

The store overcharged me! The site says $21.99 for an 18" deluxe and they charged me $29. When I pointed out what was on the site instead of making the situation better he instead goes back and forth with me to convince me I was wrong. "Well that explains it the site hasn't been update but the price changed". WTF is that? You know this but don't verify the price on the phone when taking the order? I am really pissed because I've never had this happen before and we've been eating and love the pizza since early 2000's. I know I'm one person but I WON'T BE BACK and everyone I've encouraged to visit, I will tell not to bother. Bad service tonight read more

This is my first time trying out Five Star Pizza and I enjoyed it. I had the cheese sticks and the boneless chicken bites. They were very filling, hot and fresh. I want to come back and try the pizzas. The service was fast and ambiance was casual for quick grab and go. read more

I stopped in late one night, ordered a pizza and sides. The staff was amazing, and the food was delicious. I considered moving to town but drove 3 hours to bring my fiancé here to try it. We'll get some to-go boxes because this place is incredible. read more

Five Star Pizza exactly what you want -- fast, friendly service and a laid-back, casual atmosphere. The pizza comes out hot, fresh, and loaded with flavor, with a crispy crust. Great quality for the price and always reliable when you're craving pizza. read more

Five Star Pizza - Cheesy bread sticks - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

This is hands-down my favorite fast food pizza spot, and I honestly don't know why more people don't know about it. My family orders from here all the time, and everything is always so, so good. Plus, the leftovers are just as delicious the next day. read more

Five Star Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

I was at the one on 56 street. I ordered and went in. Soon as I walk in a guy yelling at someone about how late they are open. Then when I said I have to leave to get cash because they don't take tap. That same guy said "you can Cash App me for $2 extra" NOT PROFESSIONAL AT ALL!! I used to get pizza from here but that is ridiculous! How can I trust my food with people acting like that to customers??? Wish I could give 0 stars read more

Not Bad! They crank out pizza fast! So nice to have decent pizza so quickly right in downtown Temple Terrace. This is very close to New York style pizza, at a reasonable price. read more

25 bucks for a dominos sized 6.99 deal pizza never again false advertisement at it finest

Told 45 minutes took 1.5 hrs and pizza was cold. Way overpriced, $32 for a large thin crust with 3 toppings. My kids were hungry which is the only reason I took the order. Guy was an asshole who took my order. I have ordered from them for years and no more. Terrible service. I guess being a once a week customer who tips well makes no difference to them. read more

Pizza was fresh & delicious!! Customer service was great, they came outside to find us once our pizza was ready to make sure we got it fresh. 10/10 recommend! read more

Love five star pizza. I've been getting pizza from here for many many years and I find them to be consistently good.

Food is always great for the price and I love the way they do their crust. They also offer huge pizzas for large gatherings. Service is always quick and polite too, everyone stays busy. While the store itself is a bit of a hole in the wall, the space is used efficiently for picking up orders. read more

This is the worst pizza I have ever had, barely has cheese on it and the toppings are overcooked. Never again..

been coming here 4 years and had nothing but great experiences. not sure if they're under new management or not but their pizzas are definitely smaller and slowly climbing in price for some reason. the service tonight was terrible, didn't have one of the pizzas ready tonight and got confused when we were ordering. on top of that we received subpar pizzas and weren't offered any complimentary items or a gift card for the extra wait and confusion. read more

THIS PLACE IS BOMB! Open so late and always consistent. Very good prices and the employees are always friendly. Delivery is kind of expensive but they are super easy to get to and you can't beat their pickup prices. Even with delivery, I'd say it's worth the price. They do a proper thin crust pizza and I'm in love with the pepperoni! If you're looking for a proper small pizza place, that saves your info for next time, discounts galore, and is now promoting Breast cancer awareness, this is the place. -From 2 hungry and hungover college students read more

Our company orders pizza a few times a month from five star. They usually get the order wrong forgetting details like garlic crust or extra sauce or well done. We will no longer order from them. read more

Five Star Pizza - No garlic crust. Not well done. No extra sauce. Why even bother ordering if they're not going to pay attention to the details. - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Ordered delivery Half cheese w/regular marinara sauce and half bbq chix/bbq sauce The person taking my order advised that they can't guarantee the sauces won't mix. Pizza was perfect and pretty tasty! read more

Five Star Pizza - Bbq chicken, half cheese - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

The worst pizza I've ever had, DiGiorno is better than this restaurant. I honestly don't know how this restaurant is still open for business. read more

See all

It's almost impossible to mess up pizza. That's all that's need to be said. Pepperoni Rolls read more

Five Star Pizza - Pick up a soggy slice and allow all of your uncooked toppings to fall right off. - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

I'm currently 5 months pregnant and was craving pizza. Ordered the Philly cheese steak pizza with a side of garlic butter and OMG. Insanely delicious. I told my husband to be ready to eat Five Star every week now until the baby is here. read more

Always consistent. Always fast. Always delicious. Really can't go wrong with a pizza from Five Star. It's also the most affordable option nearby. Tons of offers and coupons, plus additional coupons and sales sent to us via mail and text. Really can't go wrong with Five Star. read more

You would genuinely get better quality at Cici's pizza. We paid $30 for the large pizza and wings deal...asked for extra crispy wings and they BURNT THEM. Pizza is terrible, old tasting ingredients. Don't advertise having fresh ingredients if it's not true. Complete waste of money I'm so upset. Never going back. read more

Five Star Pizza - Extra crispy or extra BURNT? - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

See all

I did not expect much from this late nite pizza place but all my food was good! Thank you guys read more

Five Star Pizza - Pepperoni pizza and cheese bread - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

Absolutely wonderful! Best $$$$ but would be Ruther Glen would establish!!! Tucked away but the treasure hunt is well worth the find. Love this spot! read more

Five star service. They were really patient with me even when I was cranky over the phone because I was hungry. The pizza came out extremely hot and delicious. The service was really fast too. If you're in the mood for some pizza come on over. read more

Shit was bussin bussin and open late. I really enjoyed the cheese and the crust was perfect

So many pizza places close early in Tampa, but Five Star was open late. We got a large with onions and pepperoni, and the pizza exceeded our expectations. Would get again. read more

Best Pizza in Miami. Quality of the food , friendly staff and consistency, never had a bad pie! Highly recommended!

I want to say we ordered this pizza last night at 1:45am..... (our kids were obvy asleep) lol BEST PIZZA IVE HAD here in Florida! The crust was so soft on the inside but crunchy on the outside... DROOOOOL! It had the right amount of sauce and cheese. we will definitely be ordering from here again! We also tried the pizza rolls that olive oil it was drenched in was super delicious! read more

Five Star Pizza - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida

I was staying at the Holiday Inn. Had late night munchies. Fast delivery. Pizza was hot & tasty!

We ordered the ALL MEATS large 16" pizza and a small 12" Pepperoni pizza. Very good flavor and helpful servings of toppings. 10pc Wings were baked and double well was not as crunchy as expected. Delivery was quick! read more

See all

Was actually very surprised how good this pizza was. Sure, its not what you would get in NY but it's really not bad for Florida. Ordered through uber eats on thursday night around midnight. Got delivered to Carrollwood and it was still hot. Will order again. read more

See all

The restaurant did not honor the promotion or the internet price! Went there to notice thevredturant is not clean, not busy, the delivery truck outside the restaurant was dirty and full of trash and it was rusty! The food is not that tasty at all! The chicken was burned, and the stake on the pizza looks like shaving thin paper!!! The bottom line, not clean, price is high, food is not that good. I was disappointed with the food, service, and price. Look for another place, or get $7 pizza from one of the large pizza places. read more

I will have to say I am not a Pizza guy. Well today I am, Five Star Pizza brought Pizza to the nurses at Moffitt Cancer Center! What a wonderful and heart felt gesture. Thank you so much for thinking of us! Thank you! And God bless! read more

This spot will always have special place in Florida college's heart. Boswell Hall can ALWAYS count on a quality pie in less than 20 minutes even at 2 a.m. Easily my favorite pizza place 5 Stars for Five Star read more

I order a pizza for pick up, as soon as I walked to pick it up one of the guys was arguing with the other employees, in a very rude way I was told that i needed a mask to come into the store, but non of the Cooks we're wearing mask and two other employees didn't have there masks on. I told them that how come I needed a mask if there employees didn't have it on. That's when one of the guy that was arguing told me I needed to leave the store. I don't mind wearing my mask but make all employees wear them too. If you expect your customers to wear it. read more

I ordered my pizza at 5:59 Wednesday July 27 2021. The pizza tasted... weird, old, and like that bread towards the expiration date. I started picking off the toppings and cheese and found a weird grayish lump. I SWEAR I found MOLD on this pizza. I kept digging through other slices of pizza and found one the size of a quarter! It's black on the bottom of the pizza and like right in the middle - this grayish-green blob. I called in and asked them to just check the dough to save other people, didn't ask for a refund, DEFINITELY didn't ask for a remake, and basically got called a liar by the assistant manager. Next day I still feel sick. Why not even check? Tell me this situation has been resolved. People please check your pizza! read more

See all

Pizzas awful reminded me of chuck e chees pizza, super thick sauce is dry. Wings were under cooked had to put them in the oven

While visiting the area more frequently and having the time to eat something quick than a burger joint, I ordered from here and it wasn't bad at all. Much better than any of the pizza chains. The hours are quite awesome of course as it was late. I guess the only thing I could say is that my pizza could've been cooked a few minutes more and a bit more cheese. Plenty of toppings otherwise and very satisfying! Service and time promised was on key. Nice little place for sure! read more

Five Star Pizza - Five Star Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Tampa, Florida