Stopped by here for a quick lunch after shopping. Delicious! The best pizza we've had in a long time. We went for the cash only special, 2 slices and a drink. We added another drink and shared the pizza as the slices were huge. One cheese, the other veggie. A pleasant happenstance for sure read more

Our new pizza spot. It's a bit of a drive but well worth it. Staff is super friendly and the sauce is what you want when you're looking for that NYC style pizza! Came on a Friday so had cheese only.... will be back for EVERYTHING! planning on trying pasta dishes soon as well! read more

Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe - White pizza and Grandma Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

See all

best pizza in tampa area. I've tried all the spots and this is my go to. Grandma is classic and has great flavor! Regular and sicilian always on point too. Great quality and a taste of NY in Florida read more

Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe - Regular NYC Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

Really good pizza at a fair price The crust is nice and the sauce tastes homemade. Lunch special is 2 slices and a drink for ten bucks. A solid spot for great pizza read more

Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

Moved to Wesley Chapel area so needed to find good local pizza shop. Read about Fratellis and figured let's try it. Ordered a chicken Parm Hero, a Sicilian pie and garlic knots. Everything was delicious. The pizza had just the right amount of sauce and the bread was not too thick. Great fresh sauce flavor. The chicken parm was also so good. And the garlic knots were out of this world. Everyone In the shop working or eating was from queens so I felt at home. Really good local pizza shop! read more

Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe - Chicken Parmigiana hero - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

See all

I have had Grandma's pizza but this is the very best, John does a masterful job creating the perfect pizza. The best pizza in Tampa. I have been searching for someone that makes Grandma's pizza for several years. It is worth the drive. Thanks John. read more

Heard the owners are from NY, so we decided to take a drive to check out this pizzeria. Well this place did not disappoint The pizza here is just like being in NY. The Sicilian (square) is the best I've had since moving to Florida. Other slices we tried were also some of the best. They make a grandma's pie which is hard to find outside of NY. They offer hot entrees, sandwiches, salads and wings. There are a few tables both inside and out. Plenty of parking in the shopping center. read more

See all

I can't believe I forgot about this place. Their NY style pizza is hands down the best pizza ever. I highly recommend this place. It didn't take that long to wait for it. The place is a bit small, but most people take their pizza to go read more

Friday 9/13/2024 Once again, another spot that my cousin strongly recommends and praises but will it deliver in terms of expectations? We made a order over the phone and I got 12 ct bbq wings, grandma pizza slice, 6 ct garlic knots and a regular nyc style pizza 16". For some reason the pizza (& slice) got cold relatively quickly even though we got the pizza as soon as it was ready and it was only a 7 min drive to get back to house. - the grandma pizza slice was decent with a decent texture and it was easily better than the nyc style pizza. - The nyc style pizza 16" was alright with a soft texture but it was nothing that was special or impressive to me. - The garlic knots weren't bad but they were pretty average. - The bbq wings were pretty basic but they were alright. Yet again, another spot my cousin has greatly overrated. read more

See all

Have the Roma! Nice tomatoes. The ingredients are just better. If you like true Italian and Bronx, NY quality pizza! Always have to get the ricotta as well. read more

We stopped there tonight and grabbed a couple NY style pizzas and some garlic knots. Pizzas were fantastic, garlic knots, not so much. The guy at the register was quite the social butterfly, he may have said a word. But let's face it, if you're looking for pizza and not personality, this is your place. read more

Awesome pizza. We've tried others in the area and nothing comes close. Grandma's Pizza is amazing. The owner is friendly. The pizzas are a bit pricey, but you get what you pay for. My family loves it ! read more

I felt like I was back in an NYC pizza shop! Pizza by the slice with a great lunch deal (any 2 slices with a drink for $10). Sicilian was my favorite, but classic was also good with a great undercarriage on the crust. Service was quick and friendly. read more

Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe - Grandma's Sicilian and white pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

See all

If you want good authentic New York style pizza, Fratelli's is it. Fast and friendly service. The owners are great always nice to chat with. Anytime I come in for a pie it's always fresh. read more

Stopped in this local pizza place for a late lunch. It's located in a strip shopping center in Wesley Chapel by the Grove, where there are now tons of restaurant options, but I always try to support local as much as possible. It's a small place with limited seating. A large party of 8 would definitely take half of the available seating. Their menu has lots of pizza options, but it also includes some appetizer and pasta choices, along with a couple of desserts. I decided on the penne ala vodka, one of my favorites. So I'm pretty picky about the sauce. OMG...first of all, I usually ask for extra sauce because, to me, dry pasta is not appealing. I forgot to make that request but found I didn't need to. The dish came with the perfect amount, coating each noodle with just enough. Secondly, I usually add garlic powder and parm cheese for a little more flavor, but after I took one bite, I found the pasta and sauce to have the perfect burst of flavors...creamy, tomatoey, oniony, garlicy heaven. No additional seasoning required! The dish also came with a few garlic knots, which allowed me to soak and eat up the extra delicious sauce. Next time, I would probably add a protein. The only downside to my meal was that they had limited beverage selections. They offer a few bottled soda, water, and beer selections. I'm someone who prefers to have a fountain soda with ice....but that certainly won't deter me from returning. I dropped in at a time when the restaurant wasn't too busy. The staff was friendly and service was quick. The table next to me ordered two large pizzas that looked absolutely tempting! I will definitely have to return to give that a try. Two thumbs up for this local pizza joint. Will definitely return! read more

Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe - Penne ala vodka and garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

A gem. These folks can make pizza. Wouldn't recommend the cannoli though. The pizza is so darn good that it makes up for it.

First off we always order here but the last grandma pie we got was dried out this def was not a freshly made pie to order we had to throw it in the trash it tasted like it was laying around all day long and put it in a box for us extremely disappointed and because of this we won't be back! read more

The food was fantastic! Best pizza I have had in a long time! Definitely will be back

Great pizza! Good service! Thanks for everything! We got one cheese and one half cheese half pepperoni with garlic knots. Wasn't greasy, great taste! Classic pizza! read more

Best pizza in Florida. Highly recommend. Definitely coming back. Some seating is available, very casual. Chill vibes, great service

We are originally from Chicago and I now live here. This was my second visit brought my family visiting from Chicago they set up table quickly(ambiance felt cozy). Pizza, lasagna and shells ohh my. My vegetarian daughter also loved their Tortellini Alfredo with spinach! Owners treated us like family too! Food left an impression on all of us sooo delicious! I'm a foodie so I give it a 10 out of 10. read more

Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe - At Fratelli's - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

Pros: The crust , sauce and cheese are a significant step up form the chains. I didnt feel as bloated after eating this compared to Papa Johns. They have Grandma Pizza - which is a square thin crust pizza which has a more robust sauce and sauce on top of cheese with fresh basil. From what Ive read, this is common n NY/NJ but not in FL. If you go , consider getting one of these (I got it on a previous visit) 4.5/5 They sell pizza by the slice as well as whole pizza. Cons: The jalapeno toppings on one of my pizzas had NO heat. Even Papa Johns blows it away. The pineapple was just ok. I think they're better with traditional toppings like pepperoni/olives etc. There is not a lot of dine in space inside. They have a few tables outside, but since FL is hot most of the time. They don't have as many specialty pizzas as Eddie and Sam's. I feel like in the last 5-6 years, Ive lost interest in pizza somewhat. Maybe bc most of the restaurants near me are the chains. Maybe because I've found more new cuisines that Im into more than when I was little and had it during TMNT soaked sleepovers? Who knows? I live near USF, so this is about 30 minutes away. While I like Fratelli's more than Papa Johns, It can get expensive for multiple pizzas a la Jet's. If you live near Wesley chapel and you are a high level pizza consumer, this is manna from heaven. read more

Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe - 16 " NYC pineapple/ham/jalapeno - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

See all

Absolutely amazing. It's been so long since I've had good pizza. Service is amazing and you won't regret getting a square. We will return.

In search of a good pizza place while out of town, Fratelli's had the highest rating and best reviews! I have got to agree, the pizza is amazing! Thin and crispy crust, the sauce was perfect, and you can tell they use a good quality cheese. I also tried their garlic knots and they were absolutely delicious! Nice and soft with a good amount of garlic flavor. The man at the front was very nice. It wasn't too busy. I placed a phone order and my food was ready in 20 minutes. I am definitely coming back when I visit again next month! read more

Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe - Large 16" - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

Fratellis is one of the best italian food places in Wesley Chapel! We love their penne ala vodka and grandma pie! You can't go wrong with anything on the menu! Fast and friendly service- family owned! We are regulars and love supporting small! read more

The pizza always fresh the gravy(sauce) is out of this world. Dunk the bread in the gravy, mama mia. A lil taste of NYC.

I might be prejudiced but the BX flavor comes through in the pizza served up in this friendly establishment. Good crust but what stood out most to me was the fresh, flavorful sauce. It's definitely not from a can. It's my go-to whenever I'm in that area read more

The pizza is very good. But what I love is the service and their wings. Wings are a very good price, and a good size (big) and delicious.

A Loaded cheesesteak was, for the first time in my 50+year life in eating cheesesteaks from a variety of places here in Fl but also when visiting in MD, living in PA but anywhere, theee worst! Not sure whether it was the bread or their choice of only mozzarella cheese (as they don't have options there for provolone or even American for that matter, according to the man who served me at the counter). Wow! ...I've always preferred mine w provolone cheese. That's never been a problem in prior establishments. But it was just tasteless and it actually included onions, green peppers, and mushrooms. I had to add mayo, lots of salt, pepper, and some oregano on my own. I have no idea how you can go that wrong with a cheesesteak. But it happened. I actually at one point thought I was losing my sense of taste and smell. But it was just a very bland sandwich and perhaps the roll was old. But more importantly, my experience there was less than warm. The guy behind the counter never once greeted me, but continue to talk to someone seated there who happen to also be a fellow employee. The place was otherwise empty. He asked me once how my food was and I told him it was "so so," and then after that, he seemed to have an even worse attitude. So service was poor. In fact when I left, I cleaned up after myself. One other person was seated in their eating and the guy never once acknowledged me again or said goodbye or "thank you" for coming. So, food and service were off...way off. I won't be back!! read more

Several years ago there used to be another pizza joint a few doors down in this strip mall. In my opinion Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe is a big step up. It's pretty easy to find New York style pizza around here, but finding a version that isn't mediocre is a different story. Fratelli's definitely has one of the better versions of New York style that I've tried around here. They also have a nice selection of pasta, salads, and wings. read more

Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

I'm quite a pizza snob (former New Yorker in search of the closest thing I can find to my home state). I stopped by Fratelli's to grab a pickup pizza this past Friday night after hearing from others in my neighborhood that they were the real deal. I am often leary of others stating "real NY pizza" because I am super picky about the dough. I am SOOOOO glad I gave Fratelli's a shot and ordered a large white pizza with spinach. This pizza was EXACTLY what I have been looking for....nice dough (not too thin), crispy crust with bubbles, plenty of ingredients on top and perfectly seasoned. I was so happy to pick up the box and feel the weight of this amazing pie. I need to go back and get another pie along with some garlic knots very soon!!! Staff was very courteous and working extra hard with tons of takeout orders from others supporting local business. Be prepared and respectful of their wait time as they are doing the best they can. My wait was an hour for Friday night dinnertime and it was beyond worth the wait. If you are looking for the real deal in a Wesley Chapel pizza place, you need to grab a slice or a pie here. I can confirm it tastes like home! read more

Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe - White pizza with spinach added. So perfect!!! - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

Great pizza! I drive from Odessa just to get a pie from this place! 10/10 and the owner is really nice. The grandmas pie is phenomenal.

I absolutely hate to write this review and this could've been a one off based on the other reviews. We ordered pizza, wings and cheese sticks. The pizza was burned to a crisp. The wings were super oily. The cheese sticks were okay. We ordered the New York pizza but the crust was black. It was just super disappointing. I hope the business owners see this and make changes as I'd like them to succeed. The marinara sauce was good though. read more

Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe - Burned pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

See all

4.5 stars in my book. Not yet fully 5 stars. This Italian restaurant is frequently visit by movie stars who is Italian descendants. This tell their Italian food is close to Italian taste. It almost can said "it is like my mom cooking". For for Asian like me I cannot tell what is truly Italian food. I only can judge what is good on the table. We order the Fratelli Special pizza. It has pepperoni, sausage, meatball, mushroom, onion and black olives. We got the 12" pizza. The pizza was delicious and the ingredients is nice not like typical pizza. We also got the garlic knots. It is dry at the bottom with good garlic and cheese sprinkled all over. We also got the finger food an old bay wings. The owner was nice enough to give us extra three wings to make up the size is too small. If you have budget, or just one a slice of pizza ( they by slice too), or good Italian food. You may found your choice. read more

See all

Stopped in here 30 mins before closing and had a granny slice. It was excellent and filling. I love how the owner is from NY; he's super helpful. I would come back here again. read more

Killed it! If pizza making is a craft (and it is a craft), these guys are Master Craftsmen. The pizza is all about the toppings, but the dough is an unstated treasure. As I was finishing my first slice of white, and getting down to the crust, the warm, soft, chewy dough, with just enough crisp to say"Im not soggy and greasy; I'm freaking delicious!" I didn't want that slice to end...So I ordered a couple more! The wings were tender and juicy with the perfect crisp. Maybe could of used a bit more seasoning (but that's just a preference). I haven't had a pizza place that has been my go to place for along time. I am happy to say I found it! I totally geeked out with their pictures of Tony Soprano and Crew, Sonny from Bronx Take, Godfather, Anthony Bourdain, Rosie Perez and others. The vibe is right and pizza is phenomenal! read more

See all

Best pizza place in Tampa. I recommend everyone try it no matter where you are from. Gotta try the grandma pizza.

Being from NYC, why did I go to a NY Pizza place in Florida is beyond me, but here I am. Definitely did not regret making this decision. My friend I was visiting really liked this pizza place and I can see why he does. We got a pie of Grandma's Pizza. Really authentic pizza, tastes soo good I had 11 slices, no joke. Yes, I later regretted eating all of those slices. The staff are super friendly, fun to joke around with, and great people to talk to. Would definitely recommend this pizza shop anytime! read more

Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe - Grandma's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

Great pizza. Say no more. Try the grandma square pizza. You won't be disappointed. The only problem is the staff has NYC feisty attitude. But that can be overlooked considering how great the pizza is. I did not try their other menu items but haven't heard any recommendations from the locals either. read more

Fratelli's Pizza and Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Wesley Chapel, Florida

Fratelli's This restaurant is the sole reason to have Yelp. The App exist to find restaurants like this. (Visiting from out if town) Spectacular pizza. I do not have to get on a plane to have authentic New York Pizza! This is the real deal. First we had a sampling of the Grandma Pizza. I wish grandma was around, I would give her a huge Italian kiss. The perfect blend of cheese and tomato sauce. Slightly sweet with a crispy thin crust. I am grateful grandma did not take her recipe to the grave like most Italian grandmas. Well worth the order. Try it. We ordered the Fratalli's Special . Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, mushrooms, onions and black olives. I ordered the 16" for my wife and me, taking a chance on leftovers. It was an excellent gamble. Now I wish I had ordered more. I live an hour away. The Pizza was a perfect balance of fresh toppings, Cheese and sauce. The sauce was not overly applied. The cheese was real and spaced right. Not over powering. The toppings were complimentary and matched so well. I almost ate the whole pie. Loved it. Thanks for making Pizza your passion. It paid off like the Lotto. read more

See all