Genuinely enjoyed this place. Was a little nervous because I wasn't sure if they were going to be authentic Italians Lol... our server was super kind. Very patient and Quick. The food came out fast. Extremely hot that it burned my mouth and the big ziti was cooked to perfection with a creamy sauce and lots of ricotta because we asked for that. The environment is giving classic pizza place. I also thought it was pretty clean. The big city came with bread. That was really tasty. Super Joey on the inside, crunchy in the outside, and the Red sauce was awesome. I would come back! read more

Amici Pizza - Chicken parm sandwich without red sauce (instead Alfredo sauce) & extra motz - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida

See all

Great place for food and drinks !! The staff ( including owners ) are very friendly and efficient ! I'll definitely be going back.

The Margherita pizza, chicken parmigiana sub, and mozzarella sticks lacked flavor. Not sure if it's the breading or the sauce but it didn't have that YUM. The Sicilian pizza though was tasty along with the cannoli. Our server was very dry. Probably was busy since we went on a rainy Friday. Bathrooms were clean. They have outside seating and several parking spots. read more

See all

Fellow reviews on Yelp led me to Amici's. The location and entrance are a bit unexpected but inside is all business. Great casual atmosphere and friendly staff. You can actually smell the fresh bread baking. This is our second time here. We started with regular slices while we waited for the chicken parm hero. We loved the slices so much that I immediately ordered a Sicilian pie to go. Their sauce is really good on the pizza as well as the pasta. For me it's all about the sauce and the bread. And they execute them both perfectly. Chicken parm hero was also great for exactly same reason in addition to real chicken cutlets. You can see the full cutlet not like some other places that just chop up chicken tenders. Amici's does it the right way. My wife loved the rice ball. The garlic roll with side of meat sauce is dangerous because you won't want to stop but it will fill you before the meal. Eager to try more... read more

Amici Pizza - Garlic roll with meat sauce - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida

See all

I've been coming here since they opened. The food is always good and the new location is well designed and allows for outdoor seating. I love the Stromboli and I get it with extra sauce since it's too good to share. Really should give them a try read more

The pizza and garlic knots are very delicious at this location. Service is always delightful and the staff is very friendly. Definitely a good option. read more

Italian food is much more than pasta on a plate. Or pizza on a platter. The recipes are typically time-tested over generations of family. Variety IS the spice of life and IS an integral part of Italian cuisine. With that said, part of the intrigue of eating Italian is exploring the wide variety it presents. Northern Italian versus Southern Italian. Deep dish versus thin crust. You get my drift. Fab One and I were on the going-home side of a wonderful Sunday drive. We started thinking about dinner. Go home and cook, OR??? That's the moment us Foodies love. Finding an excuse to getting online and doing some visual food sampling. Digitally, we travel into Mexico, the Mediterranean, Italy and more. We ultimately set our baggage at the door of one place we desire to explore further. To step through the door is to begin a journey of tempting tastes. We hope... That's when we settled on Amici. The reviews were good. They painted a virtual picture of what we were looking for. WE were in the mood for Italian food. I must admit we've driven Highway 54, or Wesley Chapel Blvd as it's called, for many years. And I can never remember having noticed Amici. Maybe I spotted the building, but it never registered there's a potential Italian hideaway hidden there. No matter. As soon as we walked in, we were happily greeted by several of the crew. Taking a seat, Nick came over and introduced himself. Nick is a really likeable young man. His manner exudes kindness and caring. He started his employ at Amici's doing the dishes. A hard, hot job. But he's in the right place now, making customers feel welcome and giving them a great reason to return. I wish him well in his endeavors. We already knew we wanted to get a pizza, so our menu moments were brief. We ordered The Works Pizza - Large 16 inch. A side salad filled the void in our tummies and the void in time until Nick placed OUR pizza on the bent-wire pizza platform. The first food impression was solidly excellent. Fab One and I both leaned in, and over that pie. Don't you love leaning in like that? Breathing in, to catch the bubbling aromas rising up in those little plumes of steam? This pizza was an Italian Masterpiece. LOTS of ingredients covering the crusty acreage. My favorite was the mushrooms. They were not overcooked shriveled up and burnt fungi. They were still moist, succulent and packed with taste. WE were absolutely raving about this flat food phenomenon! We raved to Nick. And to the couple next to us. And we asked Nick to send word back to the kitchen as well. Kudos! A thoroughly enjoyable meal, with superb service. AND, on the way home, seeing that little brown pizza box on the backseat brought happy thoughts to mind. LEFTOVERS! We all know leftover pizza is KING! Tell them Beth and John suggested this place. Amici means friends. read more

Amici Pizza - The Works! - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida

One of my favorite places to eat in and truly enjoy a well crafted pizza. It arrives to your table within minutes and the quality is outstanding. I like to support small, local businesses and this is a spot that I've been coming to for years and years. It's a top notch option for pizza. read more

Best Italian in Wesley Chapel. Staff is super friendly and Restaurant is spacious and has a family joint feel. Service is fairly quick and the food comes out piping hot. The pizza is delicious and the dough is on point. Perfect between crispy and chewy. You have a set list of premade pizzas or you can choose your own toppings. They come in three sizes and a large can feed a family of four. Tried the pasta of the day (seafood in white sauce) and was positively surprised. Pasta was not overdone, it was very hot and generous in seafood. Garlic knots are a must! read more

See all

I love their pepperoni pizza by the slice! I love the food and the atmosphere is great. Totally worth all the crazy traffic happening.

Good food, great service. Our server Nick was great. Professional, attentive, and explained the menu very well. I started out with garlic knots. They were soft buttery, just the right amount of butter and flavor. Also started with the BBQ maple wings, also very good. Then main courses were chicken piccata, fettuccine with chicken, and a sausage roll. Everything was great and with large portions. The pricing is fair for entrees from $16-20. The food is amazing and tastes as if you are having family dinner at home. Highly recommend. read more

Came to Amici after being recommended up and down that this was the best pizza place within 20+ miles. After having been here, I'll say it's a decently good place, but, to recommend this purely on this, I'd have to give it a lower score on that alone (but I won't judge it based on that). Walking in I noticed that place was built to support not only the full restaurant, but, to support a great deal of take out (based on the size of their kitchen). The place had a Chicago style decor, and what looked like comfy diner style tables/chairs. The menu was simple enough, and the servers were friendly. The price of food was ok, but, overpriced for the area. I got two pizzas, the vegetarian pizza and the margarita pizza. The margarita pizza used the wrong types of cheeses, and seemed to be a cheese pizza with slightly less sauce (standard cheese). The vegetarian pizza was surprisingly good, crispy, but soft, with more vegetables than I've seen (and very filling). I don't think I'll be back here again, but, it was interesting that everyone's recommending this place. read more

Pretty good pizza while in that area. They sell by the slice too! Service was good and friendly. Parking behind off of 54. Cute little pizza shop. read more

Amici Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida

I came in to get a slice and was reminded of what good pizza was like. I'll definitely be coming back!

I am so mad! I called Amici pizza for a call ahead order for 2 pizzas so we didn't have to wait when we got there. When we got there, the place was empty! First clue!! The (I think was the owner) came in about 5 minutes! One pizza was hot just out of the oven! The second pizza was cold like it was sitting there for a while!! My husband was furious. I ask him not to make a scene because we were with our grandchildren and I didn't want them upset!! Let me tell you this is the last time we would go there! They should be ashamed! So, Medley and Mirada Residents don't waste your money!! There are too many pizza places to go to!! Stay away from Amicis Joyce W read more

I went there for take out. the service was great and the pizza was excellent. I recommend them.

Nice customer service friendly prices the hostess was good and also the pizza was great. The cheese sticks were great and the bread knots were good. The only thing that wasn't as great as it thought it would be is the iced tea taste like water I wouldn't order that. read more

Amici Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida

See all

This was our first time visiting amici's. We ordered. Cheese pizza (excellent and perfectly done, not burned, perfect amount of cheese and sauce) and cheesesteak hoagie, also perfect and crispy not wet or soggy and spaghetti. We will definitely be returning! We had great service, polite, friendly, and attentive . The place was clean and ample parking. Thanks for a great experience! read more

This was our second time at this restaurant, first at this location, I like the new digs! Brightly lit, clean and well staffed. We tend to eat out at off hours so we aren't in contact with as many people as peak dining would bring. However, they would only sit us adjacent to other patrons. I asked to be accommodated elsewhere but the young hostess said only the one section was open. It was an hour to close so I didn't know if I'd be rude to persist bc of cleaning at the end of the day. We opted to stay and eat. Our server was very attentive and had good tableside manner. Food came our hot and quickly. I'd say the food is good but nothing super special. The sauce was a bit watery for my liking and lacked robustness. Excelent portion sizes and you definitely don't leave hungry! All entrees come w a small house salad and garlic bread. I had the eggplant parmesean which was served w a large side of spaghetti. Hubby had baked ziti w meat sauce. read more

See all

This place is hit or miss for me. Pizza is really good. Strombolis are okay. Too much bread. The pasta dishes are a no for me. Ordering takeout is the best option because service is slow and inattentive. Our first visit was 5 star because it was their pizza and because it was takeout. I've sat and eaten here on 2 separate occasions: once for dinner and once for lunch (yesterday) and yesterday's service in particular was awful. I was on my lunch break so I only had an hour to eat. I ordered 2 slices and it took 30 minutes and then another 20 minutes for my server to stop chatting with one table to bring me my check and at one point when we needed refills on drinks, she was in the kitchen on her phone. I think I'll stick to ordering ahead and takeout pizza, but hence the drop in ratings. read more

See all

I came here after a family friend of mine recommended I try this place. I am glad I came here as this place is not too far from my home. The place is very spacious inside and I was tols to sit anywhere I like and someone would be over to help me. The waitress made my first experience here well worth it as she was very attentive and she continued to check on me. I just ordered a Mich Ultra, plain slice (requested well done) and an order of garlic knots. Everything was so fresh and made to order, the slice was better than I thought it would be. Good cheese to sauce ratio and zero flop on the slice since I requested to have it well done. I would say this might be my go to pizzeria that is local to me in the Wesley Chapel area. read more

Large portions. Great pizza. Super outgoing and friendly staff. I drive the extra distance just to get their pizza.

The pizza lacked flavor. I've had better frozen pizza. Service not that good. Napkins were thinner than a Kleenex.

Food was acceptable and ambiance was acceptable. I was extremely disappointed that upon walking in my family was not greeted. My wife even mentioned maybe we should sit ourselves. I mentioned the poor opening experience but didn't even get an I'm sorry. Very disappointed but since my wife and kids like this place we will be back again and give them another chance. read more

This place is really good. Liked the slice, Sicilian and rice ball ! Great prices and great staff. We will be back!

The perfect mom and pop Italian flavor I was craving. The bread loafs.... OUT OF THIS WORLD!!! Took me back to my childhood growing up in PR eating Pan de Agua. The chicken parm and tortellini Alfredo were very good. The star of the show will be the garlic bread rolls hands down. Thank you to the waitress with the cute black bangs and bow in her hair. You were excellent. Super accommodating and the right amount of attentive yet leave me alone to enjoy my dinner and my book. You can feel free to ask for any accommodation to your meal the kitchen is made to order and will make substitutions. Overall the perfect Friday night solo date night Italian comfort food during a rain storm. Will seriously come back with my husband and family next time! read more

My family just walked into this place to try it out for the first time on Saturday night at 630 pm. The restaurant had literally 50% of the tables empty and no one waiting. Yet the hostess tells us it's a 30 minute wait. We walked out and will not be returning again. Pathetic that they cannot handle more than half of their own table capacity on a weekend during prime dinner time. read more

This place hands down has the best new york style pizza and prices are great! Family owned and always great service!

This is a mom and pop down home basic Italian restaurant where you can sit inside or outside. The menu is an old-fashioned basic not fancy-schmancy not spicy Italian food just the way grandma made it. I come back your time and time again. read more

Ordered spaghetti for take out. Barely had any spaghetti sauce on it. It was very thin sauce spread on top.

I love Amici's. Their sandwiches and pizza are delicious, and the staff is always friendly. You can't go wrong with anything there. They also sell pizza dough, and it's amazing. read more

I love the vibe here. The place is family friendly and and the restaurant was packed and lively. And even with the amount of people in the establishment the food came in a timely manner. The bread was absolutely delicious, and even with my actual meal coming, I couldn't resist the temptation of the slice of bread. The salad was good too and I enjoyed reading the extensive menu. The pizza was bigger than I expected and had more of a softness to it - I, myself, am more of a thin crust person but found the pizza enjoyable. I visited with a larger party and we all received our food at a reasonable time. Overall solid restaurant! read more

See all

Can't say enough good about this place. Found it by chance one day and so glad I did. Their sandwiches and pizza are delicious. Staff is always friendly. Can't go wrong with anything there. Also, they sell their pizza dough and it's amazing as well. read more

Not being biased considering I know and love the management here....the food is TOP NOTCH!!! Real Italian food like at your Grandmothers

Amazing and fresh .exactly what I was looking for I highly recommend this place ! Glad to have this nearby read more

Great pizza. Only in area for a few days. Others had recommended Amici. They were great. Nice thin crust. Only recommendation would be add more meat on the meat lovers. read more

Eggplant rollitini is sooooo good. Made with ricotta mozzarella and spinach. Please don't ever take this off the menu! It's soooo delicious. read more

Today I went to this place after two years and the truth is it was horrible the person who served me did not pay attention to my order I asked for two portions of pizza she brought me one and she did not remember the other later when I told her she brought me something that I did not order I didn't say anything. The other person who was with me received his order incomplete. I felt bad because you go out with the hope of eating delicious food and they give you everything changed. I won't return to this place again. read more

I have always loved Amici's pizza but whoever is making the crust is making it too thin, now. It doesn't hold up the toppings and becomes soggy very quickly. Please return the old crust. read more

Update: We decided to go back and try different dishes from their menu. This time we ordered a medium Hawaiian pizza, and Steak Stromboli. Everything was delicious. Definitely, this will be our place when we are in the mood for pizza. read more

Amici Pizza - Hawaiian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lutz, Florida