Hello all. Today we tried for the first time 5 Star Pizza. We had it delivered and it didnt miss. It arrived HOT like it had just come out the oven. All the toppings were fresh, nothing was old. It had the right amount of sauce and cheese to counter. For a first time I was very impressed with this pizza, not to mention it was HUGE. So for this I have to give them out of 5 read more

The food is always good. Delivery is fast and the driver is always nice! 1000/10 recommend if I could!

AWFUL! DONT EAT HERE!! I went in there the other day and had an extremely disturbing experience. While my food was being prepared, I witnessed an employee angel spit into my food. This is a serious food safety and health violation. Customers should never have to worry about something like this happening. I am very uncomfortable and disappointed, and this situation needs to be investigated immediately. I expect this to be taken seriously and handled appropriately, as this behavior puts customers at risk. read more

Best pizza we have EVER had!! We both agree this was definitely the best pizza we have ever had in our lifetime. We are 58 years old and 61 years old respectively that's a lot of years and that's a lot of pizza. This was by far the best pizza ever we got the large pepperoni powerhouse two nights ago. We don't live in the area we are from North Carolina, but we are headed back but before we go, we had to have another one. Biggies was my man's favorite before, but no longer he is reformed as am I. Tonight we're going to get the pepperoni powerhouse again, but in the 24" Piezilla size. It's massive and we are excited about it inviting friends over so they can try it. I only wish you guys were in South Charlotte, North Carolina, or I wish we could take you with us. Even the servers were very, very accommodating since we were late a few minutes after midnight and they were still nice as Piezilla!! read more

Truly is a 5 star pizza pie, My first time there this weekend was really good and tasty, the everything and the meats , garlic rolls, pizza rolls. The service was very fast , This is a to go location by Avondale , not a sit down restaurant. read more

See all

I've praised this location for over a decade. In the last 2 years prices have raised, quality is nonexistent, pizza barely arrives the same as last time or even decent, and through it all I kept ordering because at least there were coupons and discount codes. Now those get sent maybe once every 6 months and they never work. I know the economy has tanked and ingredients cost more, but the consistency is trash, the quality is horrible, and there's no discount worth anything. I hate the owner of papa John's for being a horrible person, but at least it's cheap, I know what to expect, and there's a discount for being a loyal customer. I haven't ordered from this location in 8 months, despite trying. It's just too expensive with zero quality to match. Please bring back your old partner or manager, whoever it was that actually cared, because this is an insult to the community read more

Ordered a pepperoni, crispy pizza with garlic butter crust. My expectations were low since it was late and really only option. I received the pizza hot and fresh to my hotel and was shocked by how delicious every bite was! This really is 5 star pizza. The dipping sauce and wings were also very yummy! I'm a pizza lover and have to say, this is some of my favorite pizza ever. I will always be sure to grab a pizza here whenever I'm in the area! read more

If you're looking for some of the best pizza in the area, this place should be your go-to. Their pies are always made fresh, and you can really taste the difference in every bite. Whether you're craving a classic Margherita or something more adventurous, they've got you covered. The delivery service is impressively fast, which is perfect for those nights when you need great food in a hurry. We order from them regularly, and they never disappoint. Highly recommend giving them a try--you won't be disappointed! read more

Five Star Pizza is one of my favorites when I'm in Gainesville or downtown Jax. It's consistent and dependable. And for me they do my pepperoni and extra cheese pizza perfectly with a side of garlic knots. This is not life changing pizza...but for games or late after a night out it's always on my short list! read more

Five Star Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

The best pizza in town by far! Great prices and fast delivery . Pizza is always hot and orders are all correct.

I've ordered several times and the pizza is always delicious!! tonight I went to pick up my pizza and it turned out someone else got my pie... the ladies at 5 Star made sure I was taken care of and made a situation that could be bad, GOOD!! Thanks 5 Star, you get 5 stars! read more

Five Star Pizza - The Everything Pizza is amazing! - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

One of the best pizzas you can find in the area, especially when they make the entire pie fresh. Super speedy delivery too! We order from them all the time and highly recommend read more

Good pizza. The ease of ordering & picking it up beats everyone else. Courteous employees.

I would first like to say that I very much doubt that the owner or staff have anything to do with this, as I know the owner is a great guy and the issues I experienced seem as if they have their origin with corporate. They have drastically altered their pizza, I suspect they have begun to use prefab pie shells. The crust tastes like dried out cardboard (not an exaggeration) and it lacks any plyability whatsoever. The cheese is also gross, though their sauce seems unaltered. They've quickly gone from being the best delivery option in town to bring on par with hungry Howie's or cicis. This is the second and last time it's happened to me and they've now effectively lost a lifetime customer. To the owner, please let your corporate/whatever structure know how miserable of an idea this change up was and how impactful it liable to prove in lieu of five star's unique niche market. I would rather just drop by Moon River or order Papa Johns at this point. Literal frozen pizza is better than what you're serving now. This is so very unfortunate. read more

I understand now why most of my friends and neighbors in Riverside and Murray Hill get their pizza from Five Star Pizza. They estimated 30-45 minutes delivery and it got here in about 27 minutes. The pizza was so hot and fresh, it literally just came out of the oven. The toppings were top quality and the cheese was real mozzarella, laid on thick. We took advantage of a special and had some hot chicken wings included. Weren't too spicy, but it was a nice heat and the crunchy garlic bits on the wings was awesome. The prices are less than the "big 3" and if you check online, they have some great specials listed. As for delivery, two of the big 3 (PH & D) do NOT deliver to my section of Riverside, so the fact that Five Star is willing to go even further - to downtown Jax - is a definite plus. Overall, I am very pleased with Five Star and plan on ordering again. read more

Like Allie A. said, sometimes us gals are just too damn lazy to cook (most likely we're just too tired from work) & need to make it a pizza night. I can't argue with genius. The Boy has ordered here before for the Pac Man fight and said that he liked their pizza as I had a brief flashback from my college days scrambling to finding dollars for the delivery guy. Maybe I was just really hungry or that exhausted, but our large half meat lovers with half veggies pizza was really delicious. I mean DINE-o-freakin'-mite! Overall, I would order from this location again for delivery. A large pizza is more than enough for two and there's no split charge. He can have his and you can have yours. Also, they usuall have coupons and specials. P.S. And ask for some extra garlic butter, dressings and marinara if you're excessive like me to dip your pizza bones in or those yummy garlic rolls. You'll thank me later. Fast, friendly delivery with reasonable prices. 5-Stars for Five Star. :) read more

See all

The pizza tastes pretty decent. The crust is definitely lacking and looks/ tastes pre- made. The wings are similar to papa John's or dominos which are frozen. Wanted mild Buffalo but I'm not sure what to call what they put on them. read more

After going on their website to get a refund or at the very least a new pizza still no response. They don't care. Never order from here

Best pizza in jax. Sometimes they get the order wrong so always make sure to check your pizza before you leave but even when it's wrong it's tasty. Also everyone who works there is super nice! read more

Love their pizza! Always order delivery and they are very fast! Their pizzas are huge and we always have left overs. Our fave is the everything pizza but like the bbq chicken as well. read more

This food is amazing!!! The pizza is outstanding and the wings are nothing short of the pizza! I was making leftovers when I accidentally burnt my pizza. Even though it was burnt the pizza was still amazing!! And the wings are perfect for anybody's taste buds!! This place is underrated and I encourage more people to try it!!! 10/10 must try again! read more

Hot fresh and the flavors were amazing. We had the everything pizza and it was so good! 29 dollars for a pizza and wings though? A little out of my budget for pizza. Nonetheless it was delicious as always. I give this place five stars! Yum! read more

Fast, cheap, and delicious pizza. My go-to for delivery. They even sent me a Christmas card!

Best pizza and super fast delivery! Comes with the best garlic butter sauce and super cheesy. read more

Five Star Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

If I could give ZERO stars I would!!!! Manager cancelled my order when I told him I was on the way to pick it up because apparently they do not deliver 5 miles away from their location. He lied and said that someone with a similar name called in and cancelled their order which I find funny. He said that he credited back my credit card after telling me they don't deliver which was incorrect because he told me that I could pick the order up that it was already made. He then hung up in my face while I was speaking, picked up and hung up again when I called back, and hung up a third time when another associate answered and was giving me the information of the owner and when he will be in to speak to tomorrow after refusing to give me his name. UNPROFESSIONAL and I will not be going to this location EVER again!! They have left a very bad taste in my mouth. What a first impression! read more

Their pizza is sensational and staff is friendly and helpful, esp., their location on Plymouth

Funny, I'm upping Five Star pizza to a Four star rating. As someone who is a bit too lazy to cook on a regular basis, we find ourselves ordering a lot of delivery, and we've tried everywhere in Riverside/Avondale/San Marco. Five Star is consistent, good, and always delivers the same thin crust, greasy, foldable yumminess for a pizza joint. read more

The wife ordered the Pizza with garlic butter crust, NOPE didnt happen. She ordered me an everything Pizza with NO jalapenos, well the Jalapenos were there. Good thing I am not allergic. She ordered hers to be square cut but they couldnt even get that right. read more

After placing an online order for a work luncheon with another restaurant, days in advance to find out upon arriving for pickup they were closed I went with my trusted five star. They delivered metaphorically (I went for pickup).Thanks for saving the day! As always the food is always on point. Staff is always super friendly! read more

I had been kinda bummed the last few times because either the dough hadn't been rolled out enough or was too risen or something. It was just so puffy and the crust was wayyy too thick. I was never gping to complain though because different strokes and all but tonight that pizza was PERFECT. Nice and thin. Idk whats different but I hope the change lasts!!! read more

This is it- The Pizza Delivery place. This place delivers very good pizza at a very reasonable price. If they delivered any faster, they would interrupt me while ordering! Five Star is the delivery champion! read more

Double bacon cheeseburger ordered this evening was great! Today was the first time in years that I have had a pizza actually string on me when you dug out the first couple of slices! Awesome job! read more

Five Star Pizza is THE best pizza place in Jax. It's a couple miles from my house (but so it Little Caesar's (they still exist?), Pizza Hut, Moon River, Mellow and Al's. I'd choose 5Star every time. The crust is delicious and so is the sauce. The price is really good and the people are super nice. Delivery is quick and pick up only takes about 15 minutes so if you're starving and close by I recommend the pick up option. PLUS they send me random coupons in the mail where I get $5 and $10 off no matter what I purchase. Michael Scott from The Office "Pizza. Great equalizer. Rich people love pizza, poor people love pizza, white people love pizza, black people love pizza... do black people like pizza?" read more

Have never had a more disappointing experience with this place in my life. My coworkers and I order nearly 10 times in a week from here. The boneless wings weren't very hot. They don't toss their boneless wings in the sauce. They give you a dipping sauce on the side for it. Manager was rude. Person answering the phone barely knew what they were doing. Definitely paid for some overpriced Great Value brand chicken nuggets. I am so disappointed and will not be recommending this place or I ordering from here again. read more

I had hoped to order to my house on the west side of jax when I asked if they would deliver to there. They proceeded to ask me my name as if that had anything to do with whether they would deliver and I was eventually told no. Less than a minute later we decided we would in fact pick up, I'm pretty picky about my pizza coming from NY so I would rather travel to get a plain pie that's at least ok. I was put on hold for a few minutes, hung up, called right back and was hung up on after saying hello and when I called back AGAIN was told they weren't taking orders because they were too busy all within five minutes of my first call where she stated she would take my order for delivery. Shitty customer service and seems prejudice. read more

Five Star Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Five Star Pizza on Plymouth St Downtown Jacksonville sucks pending who is working...... When they have good workers on duty pizza comes out exactly as ordered..... 90% of the times you will not get what you asked for...... Under cooked dough and toppings you didn't ask for is their specialty read more

I wrote a bad review and the owner said they would make it write ,to call ,so I did and it was five start not the owner, they still charged me didn't give me no credit or discount, nothing will not be doing business ever again with this place read more

There are places that make fantastic pizza and most times you have to GO there. There are also places that make REALLY good pizza (better than the brand names), local, and deliver. That's these guys! FIVE star pizza staff, and drivers have been awesome and very nice. We live nearby in Mandarin. They ARE fast!!! They are good!!! And they get my pizza for delivery busIness. Always fast always good, give them a try! Ask for the garlic dipping sauce too, great with their crust. Consistent, tasty, fast delivery, and prices right! 4 stars because I DO reserve 5 stars in Yelp for the amazing! read more

You guys are fake, and rude! I seriously have had Breyer pizza at papa johns this is ricloiois..... I called ahead of time at the club and you guys failed. Gross, ttyl read more

I'm so happy they deliver now... we ordered a large pizza...half with pepperoni and it arrived steaming hot...the price is definitely worth it....everything about the pizza was great..... Don't feel like cooking then order a pizza...you won't regret it read more