Service was good. Pizza is average. Too doughy for me. Orange County is right now.Crust is spongy. Very average pizza

Son said the Philly Cheese pizza was really good. The crust is hand tossed and tasty. They were opened late so we were glad for that. There is no place to sit down inside so your pizza will be to go, but that didn't bother us. Pizza maker was super nice. We will definitely visit again read more

All good besides the delivery part some people have do not knock and just leave at door for a reason please follow directions you never know if a baby is sleeping or dayshift worker etc or maybe someone is home alone and doesn't want anyone else to know or even are ordering to get there before they arrive home etc. I've ordered here before and didn't have this issue so it kinda upset me because I have a dog and didn't want her barking and waking up neighbors. Edit to add I live in a little bit of a rough place and so you know knocking at the door at 2 AM when I specifically have leave at door is going to alert anybody and when I told the girl on the phone like hey maybe don't knock when people say don't knock like you kind of scared me a little bit she said oh well you were expecting me so idk why it scared you. We live in an economy where 60$ of pizza should give you what you ask for. read more

They put a lot of toppings on and I appreciate that. It arrived quickly and I appreciate that. I didn't go inside.

Was so bummed when they weren't going to be part of the vendors at Fest 2024, glad that they figured it out at the last minute and I was able to see what everyone raved about. read more

Five Star Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Florida

Best pizza I've ever had and best in Gainesville by far. For a town with so many strong options such as Piesanos and Gumby's, it's hard to pick a go to in town however Five Star Pizza makes it easy to make that decision. It's got great people at the front servicing you when you walk in. They're amazing at what they do and they honestly don't charge enough for how amazing the quality of the pizza is. You can see in the kitchen everything is clean and healthy and fresh most importantly. I'd recommend this spot to anyone who wants to eat pizza in Gainesville. Their sides are also fabulous definitely 5 stars in every regard as their name implies. read more

Five Star Pizza - 16" LARGE PIZZA - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Florida

See all

How could I give them any less!!?? New Year's Day 2:00am. The place is jammed packed with drivers, cooks, and a manager who was also making pizzas!! People were: walking up and ordering (like me), picking up online orders, getting red-boxed pizzas flying out the door, coming in from deliveries, answering the phone, playing music, standing and waiting....all at once! It was a cacophony of hands, noise, food, and money, yet all in a ballet. It was a performance! It was alive! Waiting.. waiting... for my name to be ca......"ERICH!" YES!! Already paid for and in my hands within seconds, a hearty thank you, and a half dozen jealous glances, as I walk briskly away with my meal! Yummy worth it!! Get you some!! read more

This is really one of my favorite local pizza spots! Aside from the fact that they stay open until 3 AM, the pizza is always hot, cheesy, and just overall amazing. I always recommend this spot to my friends and family when they come in town. read more

Five Star Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Florida

Open late when everyone else wusses out. Open until 3am 7 days a week. That alone is worth five stars.

--- **5 Star Pizza - From Stellar to Subpar** Visited 5 Star Pizza twice. My first order was fantastic--pure pizza bliss. But on my second visit, the hype had clearly worn off. Barely any beef on my pizza, and they were stingy with the cheese. Why is it so hard to ensure toppings reach the edges? And for heaven's sake, can someone evenly distribute the ingredients? It's pizza, not rocket science. And oh, did I mention it's also a bit pricey for what you get? Sadly disappointed. read more

We ordered pizza for 100 people for a large event. The giant 25 piece pizzas worked perfectly for serving a crowd and it was delicious. Plus, it was delivered hot and on time to the minute. Why anybody would order from a crummy pizza chain restaurant I don't know. Five Star is local, and it's real food. read more

Pretty good pizza but pricey. Base pizza is $16 and $2 per topping. For that money, there should be double the veggie toppings I got. How much do green peppers and onion cost? I ordered through Uber Eats but store deliveries themselves. I give kudos to the delivery person for following my directions to my apartment. Most don't. read more

Five star pizza I have a bone to pick with you because the pizza took over an hour to come and it was cold and dry. I asked for a refund but they laughed in my face your employees are mean and they were on their phones. One of the lights were out. The bathrooms were broken and it was disgusting. I will never coming back here. read more

Great pizzas . Good price. Always a discount or coupon specials. Delivers quickly. Several location.

This is a great place for fast and cheap pizza. I ordered it online & it was ready by the time I drove there (about 10 min). The garlic rolls were kinda dry but the pizza and toppings were delicious! read more

Five Star Pizza - Garlic rolls - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Florida

See all

We have been customers of the downtown location since undergrad days in the early 90s when they first opened, and have friends/UF alumni who request 5Star upon every visit. It is consistently good and not gourmet expensive. Quality and abundant toppings and super fast delivery. If it ain't broke, don't fix it! read more

Twenty years ago when I was a student at the University of Florida, I used to love Five Star Pizza and so did everyone I knew! It tasted like cardboard, but at $4.99 for a 16" plain cheese pie ($3.99 on the Monday following a Gator Football victory), you couldn't beat it! I passed through Gainesville last week for the first time in I don't know how long, so I had to stop at Five Star. First thing I noticed was that they were just as fast as they were 20 years ago. Back then if you ordered delivery whether on campus or off, it would usually arrive in 15 minutes on a regular weeknight (longer on the weekends). For this visit, I walked-in and ordered the typical 16" plain cheese pizza. The guy rang me up and told me that it would be about 10 minutes and then added, "Actually a little bit less. Only takes about 7 minutes in the oven". Next thing I noticed was that the price had gone up considerably in 20 years. Including tax, I paid $11.70 for a 16" plain cheese pizza. I couldn't believe it when he gave me my total. But I figured I hadn't had Five Star in years and may never have it again, so what the heck. But if it cost that much when I was in school I probably never would have ordered it. Last thing I noticed was that the pizza tasted a lot better than I had remembered. When I was a student, I knew Five Star wasn't good pizza, but I still enjoyed it. But when I tried it last week, I noted that either I had forgotten how good it was, or that it had gotten a lot better in 20 years. It still had the familiar flavor I was used to from Five Star. The crust and the cheese tasted pretty similar (but better). The crust was actualy similar to Papa John's crust. But the main difference was the sauce. There was a lot more sauce than I remembered there being during my college days, and it was a lot more flavorful. Overall, my favorite thing about Five Star is the nostalgia from my college days. And while it has gotten a lot better in 20 years, it is also a lot more expensive. I'm not sure whether or not it is worth what I paid. It probably wasn't, even though it was pretty good. But since I no longer live in Gainesville, there are a ton of options that are a lot better for about the same price, so if not for nostalgia, I probably would not pay $12 for Five Star. It definitely doesn't compare to pizza in the Northeast. But still, not bad. And definitely fast! read more

See all

Great delivery pizza at any time of day. The kids loved it and delivery was great. The texture of the cheese on the veggie was different somehow than the cheese and pepperoni. Wondering if they use vegan cheese in that and will inquire next time. Veggies on the veg are mostly raw. Will purchase again when I need pizzas after midnight in our small college town. Thanks for being here for us 5- read more

The pizza is decent. Good prices. It's just not amazing like everyone hypes about. Would eat here again

Easy choice. Always a solid bite, and fairly quick delivery. Nothing fancy, but that's what you enjoy/want from 5 star pizza.

Matt was so nice on the phone and he was really helpful when we placed our order. I could not recommend this place enough to anyone who is hungry for a delicious pizza. This is the spot. read more

Gainesville's pizza scene is on point (Vs pizza, Satchel's) but 5 star is the place to get cooked to order, made from scratch pizza. It's well priced, fresh, real ingredients made in house. Where else in Gainesville can you get pizza at 4am? read more

Five Star Pizza - Beautiful - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Florida

Very solid pizza with many different tasty options. Not the cheapest pizza by any means but they have multiple sizes to feed large crowds and pepperoni rolls are definitely a nice add on. Also ready extremely quick as my food was ready for pick up in less than 15 minutes even though it was prime time. read more

Name doesn't lie - this place is 5 stars. Good prices, good pizza, fast and easy. The piezilla is the best for big groups.

More than you can ask for from a cheap pizza place. Their servers and staff are exceptionally friendly and work around the clock to ensure quality. I've yet to meet anyone who doesn't love Five Star Pizza- especially delicious if you add a hot dog from the hot dog cart down the street for what's known as a Fest Taco! read more

I gave my address but the delivery driver couldnt figure out where to go. But I gave my address. Google maps is a thing. It works. But the driver couldn't find it. So now im waiting outside in the rain looking for him. I already tipped, so now I feel like im being robbed of my time, my money, and my food. This is absurd. He also yelled at me on the phone for his own inability to find the address that was given to him. read more

Five star is supposed to close at 4:30 AM. I tried calling at 1:00 AM and nobody would answer. I have a coupon book with codes that would not work on their website. The lack of service was disrespectful and uncalled for. I tried calling multiple times and nobody would answer. They need to do a better job with better customer service read more

Last time I got a pizza it was burnt so tonight I asked her to not send me a burnt pizza again. So what did I get, burnt pizza again. Deliveryman was not nice about it. I told him the pizza was not good and he told me I did not know what I was talking about. I didn't know what I was talking about. Something is burnt or not. This was burnt. read more

Pizza is ok, cinnamon rolls is horrible. Had to repeat myself in the phone 5 times and they still got my order wrong. When i got there and told em about they were very rude about it too. I love Five Star pizza, but this certain location sucks read more

The PERFECT drunk pizza. Reminds me of Costco pizza. It will hit the spot if you're craving pizza, but it won't blow your mind.

I have never been so upset with a business in all my life. I live 5 blocks south of this place and they will not deliver to my home, apparently because it is a majority minority neighborhood. I've lived here 4 years, and while its a mixed income/race area, its been a lovely place to be as a student. After I placed my order, I called about 45 minutes later to find out where it was, and was informed that "we don't deliver to your neighborhood due to crime issues" Really? I ended up having to pick the order up (yes even though its 5 blocks away - by that point I was sober AND pissed off) I think their delivery policy borders on racism and I hope you take that into account. The owner gave me some blah blah about crime - and yet, since I have seen the actual crime stats for where he DOES deliver (all around this small area) and know that those stats are much higher than where I live (I am grad student with access to that info) i know he is wrong. Until he changes his policy I shall continue to tell the world how slimy this attitude is. Oh, and the pizza ended up being barely average. Guess I'm not missing much there after all. read more

Hungry...want food..its almost 2 am...no no I dont want steak n shake, or sonic or to sit down at the Clock or Perkins...Pizza? Hot gooey, saucey, salty cheesy pizza? YESSSSS! Is it gourmet? no. Is it the best pizza in town? no Is it the worst pizza in town? No (that would be little caesars/ Hungry Howies for the tie) for pick up/take out are they quick and efficient? yes are they priced correctly? Yes. For a take out large cheese? 7 bucks. and believe me at 2 am you dont need anything else BUT cheese on that. At a certain point in the evening/early morn they will just crank out the Large Pepperoni, Large Cheeses and thats it. like an assembly line and hand them to us tipsy, hungry people. It was delicious, and hit the spot. read more

For what it is, and for the cost...its pretty good. My friend orders this place to her dorm and she always gets a deal "campus special". Bottom Line: Its Pizza, its greasy, its good for what you pay for. Want higher quality? Go somewhere else and pay more. read more

I was on the phone calling them for delivery. All i heard in the background was goofing off, laughter, barking, and meowing and everything else possibly annoying. I couldn't understand the woman taking my order or anything and aside from that what in the world is $50 for 3 pizzas? Anyways they were very disrespectful except for the woman i was talking to, she had sense and was respectful. I would not recommend. read more

The pizza is simply awesome. Plenty of toppings and just the right amount of cheese. The crust is delicious. On top of that the price is right and the pizza is huge!!!! read more

Five Star Pizza - the menu and prices - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Florida

This is Boyfriend's pizza place. Boyfriend has issues with change, so this is now my pizza place. Boyfriend trys to be all healthy and limits himself to pizza every other week, which I find an unacceptably low pizza frequency. Then it occurred to me that I could have pizza without Boyfriend. So, for lunch the other day, I ordered myself a pizza. I went online because I have phone phobia. Their online system was confusing and difficult to work. But damned if I was going to call. I got my pick up order in and I got a confirmation email, saying my pizza was in preparation. It didn't give me an ETA. I chilled for 20 minutes and then set out to pick up my pizza. Man, that place is hard to find! I thought Google Maps was going to blow up my phone. It's sort of inside the block. That could totally be my issue. I'm new and very Google dependant. It's fine; I found it. I went in and got my pizza. Which I was pretty sure had been sitting there for 20 minutes. Boyfriend confirmed that was probably the case and that I should order and immediately go pick it up. Which is weird, as it is literally 4 minutes from the house. That's weird, right? Boyfriend told me this as he was eating my leftover pizza because apparently it doesn't count if he didn't order it himself. The pizza is good solid pizza. There's absolutely nothing wrong with it. There's nothing spectacular about it. I gave them special instructions; they followed them. They have a lightly baked option that Boyfriend likes. That's weird, too, right? This is a perfectly fine place to get pizza from. Just get it fast. read more

Bomb pie cooked to perfection #piezilla was treated very well I will recommend to all my friends and family. Definitely worth the trip from lake city read more

All I can say for Five Star is: Get the job done. I would describe their pizza as like a slightly better Pizza Hut. If that appeals to you, then you should grab a slice. It does to me, so I was pleased, but all the while knowing "There is far better pizza to be had." Good, not great. Not a terrible decision. read more

Quick and friendly service! And WOW - what delicious pizza (hint: Supreme pizza w/ yummy Brownies)!!!

Ode to the public school lunch lady! I guess this exceptionally low standard is appropriate due to the fact that this IS a college town. THE DESCRIPTION OF ONE LARGE CHEESE PIZZA...for the super "bargain" price of about $13.00! Mmmm... cheese that doesn't stretch and I am almost certain is one molecule shy of my child's playschool plastic pizza in her mini kitchen! The crust...hmmm...gluten free failure or did they rob the Catholic Church of the recipe for communal wafers crossed with a Dollar Store dish sponge! I love my garden, but DO TELL...What STRANGE fruit was that sauce derived from? Conclusion- EPIC FAIL! read more

Five Star Pizza - the best pizza in the world - Pizza Near Me - Gainesville, Florida