Let me start by saying I don't eat burgers unless it's from In N' Out. I am picky about my red meat, an even pickier about my burgers. I don't do In N' Out to-go either because it doesn't taste the same as dining in. This review is being written for two reasons: 1) to compare In N' Out with Five Guys as everyone seems to do, 2) to compare Five Guys locations.
The young lady at the cashier who was bubbly and sweet was Cianna. I told her about my 1st experience at Five Guys a few months ago, the one around Almaden Expwy area, and that it was just o.k. but I was willing to give it another shot. My boyfriend told me the Sunnyvale location is busier and produces tastier meals than the Almaden Expwy location we went to for my first visit. Cianna was patient, listened to the story of my first experience, and vowed to make my 2nd visit a much better one.
First visit to Almaden Expwy location: tables weren't that clean, kind of had to wipe it off ourselves. The cheese was not melted on my burger which is SUPER disappointing in general. And the water from the soda fountain machine tasted terrible. Please use a stronger filter or something.
Second visit to Sunnyvale location: Cheese still not melted on burger. Soda tastes good, not watered down or anything. They get an "A" for customer service because MY particular visit and encounter with Cianna and her team that day was attentive. But still, the bun at Five Guys just sucks. It doesn't hold up well to all the ingredients, especially if you order your burger "all the way," meaning all the extra toppings on the board stacked on. The last few bites of my burger are messy and falling apart, a huge reason why I don't consider Five Guys as my first choice when I want a burger. Skip the traditional sesame bun guys, because your fingers sink into it as you take each bite, and it's gummy with its bread all flattening as you eat.
In N' Out ALWAYS takes GOLD when I want a quick and cheap meal that doesn't break the bank and is consistent in quality almost every single time. The cajun fries are delicious at FG and that's where they have their leg up over In N' Out. They hook it up when you order the "little fry" but their choice of sauces are boring. In N' Out and their "spread" gives your burger and your fries that extra something special you were looking for. In this day and age, simply offering regular ketchup and mustard just don't cut it in my book. How about 2-3 exciting sauce combinations offered that people can self-serve and dip their fries into? And please melt your cheese...if I wanted raw, unmelted cheese I would ask for it...also looks like processed cheese like Kraft singles quality, instead of a good piece of cheddar like Tillamook or something. When you order "animal style fries" at In N' Out, you can see the thick cut piece of real cheese that gets put on top and melted down. Five Guys, please don't cheat me on my cheese with that fake looking stuff. The patty is juicy, I'll give them that, but overall, it's not some super exciting burger I crave, as I do In N' Out burgers.
Bottom line, In N' Out burger + Five Guys cajun fries = best burger and fries meal, hahaha!
If I went back to Five Guys it would be to Sunnyvale location, not Almaden, and would look forward to Cianna as my cashier again. At the end of my meal she even caught me before I left the door and checked in on how my meal was. I gave her the complete 411 and she thanked me for my feedback. I truly appreciate customer service like that, showed she really cared. Thanks girl! :) read more