1. Five Guys

0

New Haven, CT

Cancel

Open app

Search

Five Guys

3.9 (129 reviews)
Open • 10:00 am - 10:00 pm

Order Five Guys Takeout or Delivery

Five Guys Photos

FIVE GUYS ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Moderate noise
Casual
Good for groups
Good for kids

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Five Guys

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Kevin M.

Fast service and friendly staff eager to assist. Order prepared to perfection. I will def return on our next trip to New Haven

Behind the line
Kawone H.

**Update** I finally received an email response to my experience complaint wherein notification of a full refund was issued for my order. Management processed the refund as promised! I appreciate that someone listened to my issue and responded. While I never asked for a refund, the fact that someone heard and provided a remedy certainly changes my perception of Five Guy's. Thank you to whoever listened!

a receipt for a restaurant
Russell W.

The food was fine, but the prices, yikes. Are all Five Guys this way? Was my first time at one in a long time, but can't imagine I'll be back at those prices. Better than fast food chains by far, but not my type of place once we start hitting that price range. A cheeseburger, large fry and a bottle water $23 before the suggested tip pops up. The burger was good, albeit rather greasy. The place was satisfactorily clean for a fast food joint, but not great, and the vent hoods seemed in need of repair. You could see them not drawing properly when they dropped new fries, and the whole place was hazy. Can we PLEASE bring back the old size ketchup packets (likely not in their control, unless they opt for those larger ones with the peel off lid), or put in a pump? I'm sick of having to open like 9 of them. "Back in my day, ketchup packets rabble rabble rabble!"

Ed G.

Friendly staff, clean bathrooms, and clean restaurant. The burger and fries were great. Holy cow the prices are a bit crazy though. Burger, small fry, medium drink $23.00 (including 15% tip). Meh maybe next time I'll try a less expensive option.

Soggy, oily, uncooked, french fries! Ugh! What a waste
Tommy B.

Thanks for the saggy oily uncooked french fries five guys! I went to order this takeout. If I wanted to cook my own food, I would've just stayed home. I guess I'll turn these boiled french fries into mashed potatoes. Proper training five guys, proper training!!! if you're really craving five guys wonderful crispy fresh cut fries drive 15 minutes to the orange five guys were they really take pride and care about what they're doing.

Regular fries, believe it or not

See all

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Great burgers a little greasy but that's what burgers are. Great real fresh french fries. A great place for gluten free fries.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

16 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

15 years ago

best fresh burgers and fries for your money even out here in ohio i just wish there was one closer to me in prospect ohio

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

A few months ago I would have given them 4 stars. They seem to be slipping lately. I think the burger made my 10 year old sick tonight.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 4 of 4

Ask the Community - Five Guys

Review Highlights - Five Guys

“I decided to order a bacon cheeseburger and regular order of fries online because I live about 15 minutes away.”

$14.99 Cheeseburger

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Louis' Lunch

Louis' Lunch

3.7(1.3k reviews)
3.2 mi
•$$

This place was SO packed. I was literally standing in a little corner like a sardine, eating my…read morechips and watching them make burgers on what looked like a beef-patty toaster. It's a small place, but clearly very busy and very loved by the community. I definitely commend the staff for being so patient, especially with how crowded it was. My coworker wasn't a huge fan of her burger being cooked on the rarer side, so I asked if they could make it a little more well-done. One of the staff members got a little upset and explained that they cook all of their burgers the same way. I understood where they were coming from, but it definitely made for an interesting experience. From what I heard, this is one of the places associated with the early history of the hamburger, so of course we had to come see what all the hype was about. Everything is cooked to order and made fresh, and I have to admit, the burger was delicious! It was also really cool to watch them prepare and cook the burgers in such a unique way.

Louie's Lunch - New Haven, Connecticut: History Doesn't Excuse Poor Customer Service…read more Louie's Lunch has a long history in New Haven and is widely recognized for its connection to the early hamburger, dating back to 1895. There's no denying the historical significance of this establishment, and I respect the fact that it has been around for generations. However, history and reputation can only carry a business so far. Perhaps this burger was something special back in the late 1800s, but in modern times, I found it incredibly lackluster. Being famous and being delicious are two entirely different things. Nostalgia might bring people through the door, but it doesn't automatically make the food live up to the hype. What made the experience even more disappointing was the customer service. For a business that attracts visitors because of its history and reputation, you would expect the staff to appreciate the customers who keep that legacy alive. Instead, the rude attitude and lack of basic courtesy left a sour taste in my mouth that had nothing to do with the food. A historic business should understand that customers are not simply walking wallets. People spend their hard-earned money, often travel out of their way, and stand in line because they want to experience something special. They deserve to be treated with respect, not made to feel as though their presence is an inconvenience. At some point, a business has to ask itself whether it is focused on customer satisfaction or simply relying on its name to keep the money coming in. A famous history may bring customers through the door once, but good food, respectful service, and a worthwhile experience are what make people want to return. Louie's Lunch may have history, but history alone isn't enough. In today's world, customers expect more than a famous name and a story from 1895. They expect a good experience, and unfortunately, this one fell short. Being a historic landmark should be a reason to take pride in serving people, not an excuse to neglect the very customers who keep the business going.

Photos
Louis' Lunch - Dining room

Dining room

Louis' Lunch - Who knew white bread could be delicious? LOL! Very tasty burger indeed.

Who knew white bread could be delicious? LOL! Very tasty burger indeed.

Louis' Lunch - Storefront

See all

Storefront

Prime 16 - IPA BATTERED ONION RINGS

Prime 16

4.0(863 reviews)
3.4 mi
•$$

Prime BGR in New Haven was a fantastic find! The location is super convenient to the Omni and being…read moreopen for lunch made it an easy choice for a midday stop. The restaurant was clean and quaint, and the western beef theme was done just right -- fun without feeling over the top. We started with the beef nachos and they were absolutely perfect! I ordered the pickled jalapeños and onions on the side for my dining companion and was secretly thrilled I didn't have to share them. The burger flight featuring their top three burgers was phenomenal. Every burger was flavorful, perfectly cooked, and memorable enough that I immediately regretted not ordering the onion rings too. The chef even came out to make sure everything met expectations, which was a really nice touch. Heather was a lovely server -- warm, friendly, and attentive throughout the meal. I also heard these burgers are going to be featured on a food road show soon, and after eating here, I completely understand why. They were excellent. If we're back in town, this will absolutely be a repeat stop. Highly recommend Prime BGR for both the outstanding food and the great value!

This place is a true New Haven treasure! We went on the first trip to New Haven and we both had the…read moreMarseilles Burger with fries and I can tell you that this is hands down the BEST BURGER I have ever had!! The owner was there on both of our visits and he is top notch, he made sure that our visit and our food was truly something to write about. You don't find restaurants like this anymore and if you're thinking it's just another burger place you will miss this gem!! 10/10

Photos
Prime 16 - The bar area

The bar area

Prime 16 - The Big Kahuna ($23)

The Big Kahuna ($23)

Prime 16 - The Smoker Burger ($19)

See all

The Smoker Burger ($19)

Three Sheets

Three Sheets

4.1(136 reviews)
2.9 mi
•$$

Nachos: Picture this. You're sitting with your closest friends on a perfectly youthful Thursday…read morenight, because you just couldn't wait for the weekend to begin. You're playing some ridiculous game you made up in an instant, and your laughter echoes through the bar, along with the strangers voices and the blaring music. You walk up to the bar, where a mirror stretches across the wall behind the bartenders, and you catch yourself in it, along with a few lingering eyes. You laugh at the audacity of youth, the absurdity of it, and look at yourself a little longer. You're young. Your hair's long, your eyes are dark, your cheeks and nose are red from the cold outside that has settled into your bones. You zone out at any reflection you catch yourself in, because you can feel the time passing. The bartender finally makes their way to you, and you order a plate of nachos that makes its way to your table on its own. There are so many hands reaching in, and you don't even notice when the table started overflowing with new and old friends. You take the first bite, and suddenly you're gutted. They taste incredible, perfectly flavorful. You have no idea where the feeling comes from. It's mushrooms and salsa, perfectly salted. It's relief and familiarity all at once, like the spark of something new that feels good because it's familiar, like it was waiting for you too. You close your eyes and melt into its warmth immediately. You open your eyes and suddenly, everything around you starts to move. Winter coats pile up on the hooks by the door, then disappear into spring. The patio opens with local indie bands, then closes with the sun coming up. The stool beside you fills up with the Irish guy you had the most awkward first date with that you counted the minutes. Months later you run into him again, and you laugh about it together until your stomach hurts. At the table near the windows, a girl you barely knew raises her voice at you over something out of your control, and you realize you don't want this. You cut her off, and she disappears from her seat. You see yourself passing through time in every corner of the bar. Old friends fade into the back of the mirror, and new ones take their seats in the same booths, laughing at the same jokes. The eyes around you linger as they pass. A guy at the end of the bar looks up every time you laugh. Someone holds your gaze in the mirror a beat too long, then looks down at his drink. You notice every one of them and hold on to none, because you can't seem to stay in the moment. Everything is already passing by while you're still standing in it. "SO?! What are you going to rate them?!" says your new friend sitting beside you, who just found out you write these ridiculous reviews for fun. You realize you seek out nachos the way you seek out love. It's a deep, familiar desire. You keep chasing the first bite that made you feel like this. He's waiting for your answer with a big smile on his face. Your hair's still long. Your cheeks are still red. Nothing has changed, but somehow, everything has. "Five," you say. "Five out of five." All else: I've said enough. This bar is my safe space and happy place. The bartenders are heaven-sent. P.S. I was listening to Chasing Cars by Snow Patrol writing this, hence the drama.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

Not sure when Richter's was sold and became Three Sheets, but it has a similar vibe. Really like…read morethat they put a stage in the second room and have local acts come play and get some exposure. Didn't try the food or cocktails, but decent beer list. Bartenders were nice and attentive, even when crowded. Not a fan of the weird circus vibe in the band room, back room could use some seating.

Photos
Three Sheets - Main bar

Main bar

Three Sheets - Nachos

Nachos

Three Sheets - Menu 2023

See all

Menu 2023

Tavern On State - Flat iron steak with forbidden rice

Tavern On State

4.5(195 reviews)
3.8 mi
•$$$

We've eaten here before so it was a known "great place" to go to celebrate an early Father's Day…read moredinner. I'll try to keep this short: the appetizers, the main courses, the drinks and the service were all exceptional! Not a bad plate in the bunch. Our server, Brendan, was knowledgeable and explained the items we had questions about. The octopus and salad appetizers were tasty and served separately so our table wasn't overcrowded with food and dishes. The main courses (a very large burger, a mushroom and ravioli dish and a spicy porgy and rice offering) were cooked to perfection and looked very enticing on each plate. We had booked for a table in the outdoor garden area which was a little misleading in that our table ended up being in the little alleyway exiting into the street but that was okay as the night was comfortable weather-wise. Dessert was a shared tiramisu served in a ramekin. Thought it might have been a little small for the cost but it was tasty and devoured in very short order. At no point did we feel rushed or forgotten which is no mean feat considering the size of the crowd both inside and out last night. Kudos to the chef and staff for a very enjoyable meal and evening out. Definitely worth a visit, highly recommend this place for ambience, food quality, and attentiveness of service. Stop reading, make a reservation, and just go!

I really don't want to write this review. I've been here twice in the last 4 months. I'm allergic…read moreto seafood and fish and it seems as if so many entrees, including a steak dish, contain seafood. Overall, the food was fine, a bit pretentious but fine. The dining room was so loud esp when the bartenders were shaking drinks as if they were starring with Tom Hanks in "cocktail" We had the pea salad which was very fibrous and chewy (a 10 second Blanche wouldn't hurt) and the burger was tasty but served with frozen French fries, and way too much of them. Considering the style of menu, frozen fries don't belong on the menu. The fish was overcooked and dry. Overall, it's an inconsistent experience. Dinner for 3 was $200 with 1 shared app, 2 burgers and the fish course plus 3 drinks.

Photos
Tavern On State
Tavern On State
Tavern On State - Grilled octopuswith fingerling potatoes

See all

Grilled octopuswith fingerling potatoes

Hot Murga - Badmaash's Mac and Cheese ($15)

Hot Murga

4.7(88 reviews)
2.8 mi
•$$

I found this place while randomly looking on DoorDash. They had a happy hour special, so I decided…read moreto check them out. If you enjoy the flavors of Indian food as well as one of those quick service, hot chicken restaurants you probably would enjoy Hot Murga. The chicken sandwich comes in five spice levels from no heat to super hot. I got the standard hot, and it has some kick, but it wasn't overpowering. Then again I enjoy spicy food. I also ordered their spiced mac & cheese. Again, not spicy at all, but flavorful. Also a good portion as I have leftovers for later. I had my food delivered, but this establishment is close to the Yale campus and street parking can be a bit tricky on Howe St. and around Broadway. I've been inside of the space once when it was a different restaurant some years ago, it's not a large space, but I'm pretty sure comfortable if you decided to dine in. If you ever find yourselves at a crossroad between wanting Chick-fil-A and Indian food, this would be a great alternative.

A fun take on fried chicken, but with "Indian" flavors. I got the Murga Sandwich (hot) and…read moreBadmaash's Mac & Cheese (medium). Honestly, I didn't think the Murga Sandwich itself had too much flavor - the fry was good and the chicken was juicy & crispy, it was just a lacking seasoning and even "hot" was not super spicy. The spice itself also tasted very one dimensional - just spicy, with no seasoning. Overall, I was a bit disappointed by the sandwich itself, but would be interested in trying some of their other sauces. The Badmaash Mac & Cheese was the redeeming item of the meal though - this is basically a Mac & Cheese, covered in tikka sauce & their spicy sauce, and topped with fried chicken. It's definitely a unique flavor, and I think the tikka masala sauce went really well with the cheesy mac texture. Definitely seems like the kind of late night out comfort craving, because it is super heavy. p.s. - pro tip, the sandwich itself is $12 but the sliders are $6 and definitely larger than half of a sandwich (probably closer to 2/3rds). So I'd get 2 sliders for $12 instead of a sandwich.

Photos
Hot Murga - Interior

Interior

Hot Murga - Masala wings, Murga Masala Sandwich, Badmaash's Mac and Cheese, Badmaash's Fries

Masala wings, Murga Masala Sandwich, Badmaash's Mac and Cheese, Badmaash's Fries

Hot Murga - Hot Murga wallpaper

See all

Hot Murga wallpaper

Jordan's Hot Dogs & Mac - Tijuana Double Dog ($13.99) -- not worth it

Jordan's Hot Dogs & Mac

4.0(168 reviews)
3.8 mi
•$

Came by for a quick lunch on a Tuesday at 1 PM. When I entered there was one other person looking…read moreover the menu, but by the time I left things had really filled up with people waiting for their food! I needed something quick to go so I just got the fried chicken sandwich. It took about 20 min for my order to come out, though there seemed to be quite a lot of phone and delivery orders coming out in the meantime. Their prices overall seem great, and I was pleased with the freshness of my sandwich! The restaurant itself is a smaller diner with both booths and bar seating but I opted to take my food to go. I will definitely be back to try some of their 50 cent wings or their buy one get one free plates next time I'm in the area!

Kind of disappointing. I drove 7 miles to get there because Google gemini said they served Sabrett…read morehot dogs. They don't. Not their fault. I ordered 2 hummell dogs with kraut and mustard to go anyway. All the signs said they were $4.50 ea, but after buying a small soda my bill was $14.00! It wasn't until I got into my car to eat them that I started to realize they must have charged me an awful lot for mustard and sauerkraut. I don't feel like going back and making a fuss, but I won't go back to eat there either . Just for the record the man serving me was very nice and the hot dogs were actually pretty good when I finally ate them but I really wanted Sabrett dogs and I guess I'm just going to have to keep looking for them somewhere in Connecticut. I didn't catch it

Photos
Jordan's Hot Dogs & Mac
Jordan's Hot Dogs & Mac - The O.G. Mac Dog

The O.G. Mac Dog

Jordan's Hot Dogs & Mac

See all

Five Guys - burgers - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...