Fielder's Choice Ice Cream

169

1119

768

22 days ago

This is the most delicious ice cream in my local area. I will not go anywhere else. My grandchildren ask for Fielder's Choice by name. I was in a mood yesterday. This is a small Slider Sundae. Three scoops of ice cream. Hot chocolate, strawberries, pineapple, banana, nuts, whipped cream, sans cherries. I have never ordered anything larger than a small. Fair prices. Friendly staff. Picnic tables, outside. Driver through, plenty of parking and they (now) take credit cards. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Lori S.

232

230

626

2 years ago

Very good and another place that has Grapenut Ice Cream!! Service was great, place is very casual. They do offer an ATM machine as this business is cash only. They have plenty of parking, a drive-thru and a lot of picnic tables! The prices are good and you get a lot for your buck! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Kevin B.

2

7

0

11 months ago

The best ice cream at the best price. Super large serving and a friendly staff to boot!

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kara B.

0

6

2

9 months ago

I guess it was ok, honestly though I haven't tried anything that I can give a great review of because the cost was higher than any price I've EVER PAID IT SEEN for ICE CREAM!! It's not bad enough the prices are already high, but they nickel and dime you with every cent so if you add things in your ice cream so you aren't just eating plain ice cream you can end up with a $15 ice cream!!! Why?! IDK because it's not that great and Cold Stones was cheaper!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Daniel B.

Elite 25

2

35

32

2 years ago

Fielder's Choice is simply the best. Incredible tasting. Large portions. Great service. Comfortable setup. Locally owned by a great family. What more could you ask for?! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Beth C.

Elite 25

511

184

398

3 years ago

What's not to love? A family run business (baseball themed) started 15 years ago with 6 locations throughout Maine. Offering over 30 flavors of homemade hard ice cream, 6 soft serve flavors, homemade brownies and cookies. The serving sizes are ridiculously large with a small price point. Not to be missed, Fielder's Choice Ice Cream is without a doubt a home run!! read more

Fielder's Choice Ice Cream - FIELDER'S CHOICE ICE CREAM MAINE - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sabattus, Maine

Helpful 1

Thanks 1

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Jay M.

0

5

7

3 years ago

Fielder is the best ice cream around . I love the baseball ball them . Also love that they so many flavors of soft severed ice cream and there always coming out with new flavors . The environment is good to take your kids your family and your dogs . If you haven't tried it the blueberry ice cream is to die for read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Jonathan J.

51

305

1163

6 years ago

We always have to get some ice cream, especially in the summer right? Well, at least that's what w me do, we always try to keep things local and when we're in Brunswick it's Fielders choice, the portions are huge and the staff are always great to talk and place an order. If your looking for some great ice cream this is your place! read more

Fielder's Choice Ice Cream - a truck parked in a parking lot - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sabattus, Maine

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Joe P.

29

26

83

3 years ago

Growing up in the land of Graeters (in Cincinnati) I have incredibly high expectations for ice cream. Fielder's Choice is in the same league and I don't have to have it flown to my house to eat it. Massive servings too, so a small is plenty even for monsters my size. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Monica L.

222

1411

0

5 years ago

Fielder's Choice (all their locations) is my favorite ice cream place. They have a really great selection of flavors and unique sundaes. Yesterday, I had one of my favorites -- the Heath Bar sundae with coffee Heath Bar ice cream. It's AMAZING! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Kelsie B.

0

2

0

2 years ago

Always great service! No matter how long the line is, this team is efficient and always kind!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Richard S.

64

52

42

3 years ago

Large volume of ice cream. Wish it tasted better but if you are a quantity over quality person this place is for you. I only have experienced their soft serve. The place is nice with lots of seating and occasionally the tables are cleaned. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Christine W.

171

10

0

4 years ago

Large variety and tasty ice cream. We can find something for the whole family, including sugar free!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Kiki R.

3

19

0

4 years ago

I'm in Maine visiting family and they took us to Fielder's Choice. I had the maple walnut and a bite of the butter pecan, too. I have to say it's some of the best ice cream I've ever had (and I'm old). My only warning: be prepared for a LOT of ice cream! read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jeffrey T.

Elite 18

121

260

176

6 years ago

Omg. Huge portion sizes. Wicked creamy ice cream. Best so far we've had in Maine. We can't wait to go to the Brunswick location which is closer to us. Love the baseball themes. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Benjamin C.

136

548

273

13 years ago

This place was recommended by a co-worker who said, "it's cheap and you get a lot of ice cream." While we don't consume vats of ice cream, I'm always up for a good deal. It was a bit of a drive for us, but the weather was nice and the top was off the Jeep. They have both soft serve and hard. My understanding is that they make it all in house. We opted for the soft serve "baby" cones...having experienced other rural ice cream baby cones where they are the size of a large Mr. Softee in NYC. (Not that I have seen, would want, or could afford a large Mr. Softee.) I went with the black raspberry and my wife chose a split chocolate/peanut butter. True to our experiences, these were big cones...hers being monstrous. (I think they had to make it big to fit both flavors). I'm not exaggerating when I say her cone was easily a large size even at other, similar (rural) establishments. But hey, it's not just the size that matters. The flavors were very, very good. In my quest for black cherry ice cream on the East Coast, I tend to choose berry flavors. This was very tasty. My wife's chocolate was fairly average, but the peanut butter was the best peanut butter soft serve she's had. It was delicious. Both of these monstrous baby cones came to a little over $3. Not too shabby. read more

Business owner information

Josh J.

Thanks for checking us out and providing such positive feedback! Hope…

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kristen C.

38

3

0

3 years ago

Yummmmmyyyy Ice cream! Cones are so big sometimes you have to eat too fast to really enjoy every moment of it!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jessie L.

8

310

116

8 years ago

This place is cash only and no restrooms for customers. Sorry this place isn't worth it.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mallory S.

Elite 23

9

54

115

5 years ago

Love taking our daughter here every year since we have moved into our new house. It has become a family tradition and i love it. Fast and friendly service and awesome ice-cream read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tony R.

154

843

2781

9 years ago

I've been to many, many ice cream places over my years including Coldstone. I have never had such a huge portion of ice cream for the amount they charge in my life. $2.99 + .55 for waffle cone for a small. Believe me, the small is the size of most LARGES elsewhere. You know how the ice cream always melts and drips out the whole in the bottom of the cone? Not here, they put chocolate sauce inside the cone and the ice cream stays in the cone! Problem is. there is so much ice cream around the outside, you better be a fast eater! If you want the cone, (and who doesn't) ask for a cup to set the cone in. They also offer soft serve, and all the usual suspects of ice cream delights. It was a Tuesday night, in which they close at 8:30, but when we left about that time there was still a long line at window and a long line of cars at the drive through. The system for the line moving is pretty good, one window to order and pay and next window for pick-up. And BTW, cash only, Credit cards just slows down the line. read more

Fielder's Choice Ice Cream - Blueberry on the left is a SMALL! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sabattus, Maine

Helpful 4

Thanks 0

Love this 4

Oh no 0

Eileen C.

Elite 21

37

272

75

9 years ago

BRING CASH!!!! They only accept cash. The portions are huge: if you're on a diet clarify the size before ordering)! I shared a small ice cream with my sister and it was enough for us both (gives you a good idea of the size). We shared the coffee heath flavor. Boy was it amazing! I like hard served ice cream as opposed to soft served. Would I go back: I certainly hope so! read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Susan L.

0

12

6

4 years ago

Best ice cream! Tons of flavors plus sugar free for diabetics and fat free too. Super large portions!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lynn S.

0

5

0

6 years ago

They have the best ice cream around many flavors to choose from. We love going here after day at the beach

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Larry M.

33

6

0

9 years ago

Lewiston was my birthplace. Fielder's ice cream will always be my favorite. San Diego has nothing to compare to it. Quality, price and friendly people a winning combo. See you this summer so I can get my fix. Monique from San Diego read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

T M.

0

22

5

7 years ago

Not really sure what else you could ask for or what you'd want from an ice cream shop, to rate it low? I mean, if its cuz they only accept cash, then that's the deal. At least they offer an on-site ATM for you to easily access so you may get cash. And do you blame them? Banks charge a % each time you use their merchant service machine. The ice cream place would be out of business from all the $ lost on accepting it. Their flavors are more than adequate to appease your tastebuds, the portions are the largest anywhere around, the place is clean and the line moves rather quickly. Plenty of parking. Large grassy fenced in area with picnic tables. A small play area for kids. Oh, and they even have a drive thru. I guess I'm lost, what's the problem here? Do yourself a favor. Pony up the $5 and get a Muddy Cleat or a Dugout Floor sundae. Incredible. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

E C.

2

55

17

8 years ago

Love the maple, maple walnut, blueberry and peanut butter! I am us wish they had a preemie size because the baby is a little too big. Love this place!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Tracy B.

49

4

0

8 years ago

Good ice cream!! Very creamy.. my favorite is the pumpkin ice cream in a waffle cone or a windup

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Roxanne B.

Elite 16

58

59

97

11 years ago

You get what you pay for and isn't that all that matters in the end? Staff is friendly parking can be a headache when it's busy but they have a drive thru which is different for and ice cream stand. Also wish their cups were bigger when trying to mix my toppings an ice cream I got more Heath topping on myself than on the spoon. read more

Fielder's Choice Ice Cream - The dugout floor - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sabattus, Maine

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Nancy R.

0

26

0

8 years ago

Love this place. Excellent homemade ice cream and large helpings. Stop by whenever we go fishing.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Michael G.

2

20

4

11 years ago

They make their own ice cream! What else can I say! Did I mention that they make their own ice cream? In the words of that great Mainer, it's Wicked Good! Did I say that they make their own ice cream? read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Laura B.

47

5

0

5 years ago

Cash only, but the ice cream is scrumptious, and their serving sizes are big! Thanks to the teen ice cream scoopers! Tip them well, folks! Slinging ice cream is hard work! (Oh, and, just so we're clear, the chocolate sprinkles are called Jimmies! I don't know why. It's a New England thing! Like wicked..."They have wicked good jimmies!" ) read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Samantha D.

0

14

7

8 years ago

Fielder's has huge portions and reasonable prices. We go to the Sabattus location the most, the staff is always kind and we've never had a problem with our orders! We like the drive-thru, but we don't have kids. When we bring my niece (3.5 years) we sit at the tables. They're usually clean, but sometimes sticky. The playground has a ton of puddles and mud if it has recently rained, but it doesn't really affect us unless we have my niece, then we lure her away with a promise to visit a different playground nearby. As far as dairy free options, I miss the Dole Whip, but the berry sorbet is good. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Kelly H.

0

16

0

10 years ago

Unlike a lot of ice cream places, Fielders Choice is nice and doesn't look run down. The staff are friendly and their homemade ice cream is creamy and flavorful. The prices are reasonable and you get a good amount of ice cream. This is by far my favorite place to get ice cream! read more

Business owner information

Josh J.

Thank you! Building/property maintenance is definitely a priority of…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Irene W.

0

19

4

10 years ago

HUGE PORTION for your money. Hard and soft ice cream options NICE Friendly and efficient staff and 5 min from home base. Cannot miss here

Business owner information

Josh J.

Thank you for the feedback!! So nice to hear :)

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Antonio L.

0

9

1

9 years ago

Ice cream is always amazing, along with huge portions. My only criticism is that the company needs to honor alternative forms of payment. I rarely have cash, and generally just go elsewhere by default read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bonnie L.

15

21

33

11 years ago

Best Icecream around! Very tasty and flavorful. I enjoy going through the drive thru. Portions are big. Baby size is like a medium size! They have one in Sabattus and in Manchester. read more

Business owner information

Josh J.

Thank you for the positive feedback! We are glad the drive-thru has…

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Jeremiah K.

8

54

35

11 years ago

Sabattus icon! Good place. Average tasting soft serve. They have good combinations and add ons, and GREAT Prices.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Julie R.

12

23

5

14 years ago

Best Ice cream my family has ever eaten. Made fresh locally with many flavors. The price is very reasonable too.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Gwendolyn R.

0

15

4

8 years ago

My family has been going her for years. I moved to a town that only had dairy queen and always make the hour long drive to go to fielders if we are going to get a treat. It's my favorite and so glad that there is one in Brunswick now!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Katelyn P.

0

1

0

8 years ago

I've been to ice cream shop all around America and I would have to say my top #1 favorite ice cream shop in Fielders Choice! It is all around one amazing ice cream shop all the flavors are amazing and the workers are so welcoming, but my all time favorite part about Fielders Choice is their decorations and really bringing the baseball field tot he ice cream shop! Absolutely love Fielders Choice! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 2

See more reviews

More info about Fielder's Choice Ice Cream

637 Sabattus Rd
Sabattus, ME 04280
Directions
(207) 375-4400
Call Now
Visit Website
http://www.fielderschoiceicecream.com

Hours

What time does Fielder's Choice Ice Cream open?

Fielder's Choice Ice Cream opens at 12:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Fielder's Choice Ice Cream close?

Fielder's Choice Ice Cream closes at 8:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.

Mon-Sun 12:00 PM - 8:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Fielder's Choice Ice Cream take credit cards?

No, Fielder's Choice Ice Cream does not take credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Fielder's Choice Ice Cream have catering options?

No, Fielder's Choice Ice Cream does not have catering options.

Does Fielder's Choice Ice Cream have a drive thru?

Yes, Fielder's Choice Ice Cream has a drive thru.

Indoor Amenities

Does Fielder's Choice Ice Cream allow dogs?

Yes, Fielder's Choice Ice Cream allows dogs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Fielder's Choice Ice Cream have bike parking?

Yes, Fielder's Choice Ice Cream has bike parking.

Does Fielder's Choice Ice Cream have parking?

Yes, Fielder's Choice Ice Cream has parking options. Private Lot Parking

Other Amenities

Is Fielder's Choice Ice Cream wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Fielder's Choice Ice Cream is wheelchair accessible.

Does Fielder's Choice Ice Cream have free WiFi?

No, Fielder's Choice Ice Cream does not have free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

Homemade ice cream! Large Sizes!

History

Established in 2006.

We started back in 2006 and have been growing ever since! Our customers seem to enjoy the large sizes and homemade ice cream :)

Meet the Business Owner: Taylor W.

Hello! Thanks for checking us out! We look forward to the chance of earing your business!

More Info

Health Score

Jillson's Farm and Sugarhouse

4.6(9 reviews)

1.4 mi

•$$

Jillson's is the first sugar house that I visit every March. Their gift shop is always open, even…read moreif they're not boiling sap. You can buy it all here! Maple syrup, jams, jellies, even MAPLE JELLY! Maple butter, maple cream, maple taffy, candy, maple pepper, maple sugar. Maple maple!!! Plus they're so welcoming and kind.

Fresh produce all year & plants in spring are wonderful! Get there when I can and highly recommend…read morethis farm store! People are kind and friendly.

Dark robust is the best

Yes please

See all

Two Mom's Diner

5.0(5 reviews)

6.2 mi

Breakfast was great. The wait staff is inviting and very friendly. Comfortable atmosphere.read more

The food was great, the servers wonderful. It's a great little hometown place right here in Lisbon,…read moreMaine. We will be back.

The Ice Cream Shoppe

5.0(3 reviews)

22.3 mi

I'm glad the owners took over this "treat" location. Over the years, this location was perfect for…read morestopping in for a treat. I'm glad the Ice Cream Shoppe bought this location to continue providing treats for the area. The selection of ice cream flavors is one of the largest lists I have seen in a long time in this general area. Most of the ice cream is not locally made, it would be almost impossible for the amount of flavors they offer. One thing you can't forget, it is a locally owned business and employs great staff members from the area. The service was very friendly, upbeat and efficient. They were so welcoming! The ambiance is pretty similar to when it was Honeycone Social. Very casual and a place to eat, chat, play a game and just relax. We really enjoyed our time and felt bad, we stayed a little pass closing, finishing up our card game and sundaes. They didn't seem phased by it. We never once felt rushed, although we were trying to hurry. I recommend this place for all ages. They have milk free options as well. When the weather is nicer, they kept the wonderful outdoor seating areas as well.

Solid servings and great flavors! Wish it was closer to our house…read more Our family loves this spot.

Menu board on right as you walk in

See all

3- Scoops: Pistachio, Strawberry Cheesecake + Blueberry Cheesecake (Vegan)

Crestholm Farm Stand

4.9(9 reviews)

18.0 mi

The best ice cream in the Oxford area! So many flavors to choose from & all are delicious! We live…read more45mins away and make the trip because they are so friendly & the ice cream is so good!

Nice family owned farm stand that offers lots of local items ! From fresh vegetables to meat to…read moreflowers to wood yard furniture ! I asked about sunflowers and they went and cut me some ! Friendly and helpful employees !

I hope they have the flowers I want!

See all

Fielder's Choice Ice Cream

4.4(67 reviews)

17.7 mi

Best Ice Cream in Central Maine Friendly Staff…read moreThree Scoops of ice cream for a small Can't beat it

Fielder's Choice is my go-to ice cream spot whenever I'm in Maine for the summer. They have so many…read moreoptions...soft serve, hard serve, sundaes, milkshakes, slushies, floats, and more. You can either drive thru or walk up to order, which makes it super convenient. My personal favorite is a double hard serve with coffee Oreo (so good!). Just a heads up--they're cash only, but there's an ATM on site. Always a treat and definitely worth the stop!

See all

Here's the Scoop

4.5(2 reviews)

18.0 mi

I have been going to Here's the Scoop since I was a kid! The selection here is great and the amount…read moreof ice cream you get for the $$ is amazing! There's nothing like having cold ice cream on a hot summer's night here!

This is a classic small-town ice cream shack. A surprising selection of Maine-made ice cream given…read moreits size. Never a wait, so why not stop for a cone?

See all

Sundaes with real whipped cream

Fielder's Choice Ice Cream

4.5(45 reviews)

17.1 mi

1. They have a drive thru 2. There one scoop is like 5…read morescoops 3.must visit when you are in Maine 4. Ice cream is hella stretchy!!!!! 5. You guys should come to delray, FL 6. It's f-ing delicious

No trip to Maine in the spring and summer is complete without a stop at Fielder's Choice. There are…read moremultiple locations. The sizes are very generous and a great value for the price. It is cash only. My baby-size cone was $3.59. They have a drive through but I find delight in staring at the menu board and going up to the window to order. The employee who served me was very pleasant. I was served quickly. There is plenty of parking. There are picnic tables and a large grassy area so you can enjoy your treat and the kids can run around. I recommend Fielder's Choice.

A Minor size Frappe (Sugar-free Coffee)

Baby size pistachio

See all

Downeast Ice Cream Factory

4.4(151 reviews)

29.3 mi

•$$

I ordered the Black Forest Sundae, which is supposed to come with 2 scoops... but they surprised me…read morewith 3 massive scoops and a mountain of toppings spilling over the edges. It was absolutely delicious, though a little messy -- I love extra ice cream, just not the challenge of balancing it while battling drippage. The location is perfect, right in Boothbay with plenty of outdoor seating to enjoy your treat. They have a huge variety of flavors, so there's something for everyone. If you're looking for generous portions and classic Maine ice cream stand charm, this place delivers.

My mom happened to notice this shop which happened to be right near where we were staying. It was a…read moreperfect stop for a sweet treat, a cold sweet treat that is. Once we entered, we were greeted warmly. It wasn't super crowded. I opted for a classic conehead type Sunday and the rest in my party opted for scoops of various flavors of ice cream. It didn't take them long to scoop everything and get it out. The hot fudge they use was actually pretty tasty. Overall, this was just a perfect stop for some ice cream. They have a lot to choose from and I mean a lot. So I'm sure you could find something that fits your liking. The bathroom was actually pretty clean.

See all

So good! Reese pieces sundae

The Ice Cream Shoppe

4.7(11 reviews)

17.5 mi

Sunset is the perfect time to go out for ice cream here in Randolph. The sun sets above Gardiner,…read morejust across the river. The green space behind the ice cream shop is just exquisite. So refreshing after a warm day. When I say this menu is large, I mean it! There's something for everyone. Whether that's sugar free, lactose free, dairy free, sherbet, sorbet, frozen yogurt, soft serve, hard serve. Full sugar. Full fat. Full milk. Full TASTY! They've got it ALL. No cap. Sundaes, Shakes, banana splits, root beer floats, slush puppies, slushes with ice cream, energy drinks, smoothies. Oh my god. I'm never going to check off the entire menu. It's enormous. Service is quick too! Make sure to tip!!!

YUM. Inexpensive. Wonderful view in town. Big portions. Friendly staff. Personally it's my favorite…read morespot in town and I stop in every time I come through!!!