Great ice cream! You get a large portion for the price. Both the soft serve and hard scoop ice…read morecreams are delicious! Definitely recommend stopping in!

Local ice cream shop, reasonable prices with average serving sizes. They only take cash or check,…read moreNO credit card. They have Gifford's hard serve ice cream. They also have soft serve. They also have specialty like milkshakes, Sundays, blizzard style, floats etc. They have a decent selection of hard serve ice cream. Customers do not go inside, the window is where you order. There is no drive through.

How does this place only have 13 reviews. This place is p h…read moree n o m e n a l. The ice cream is actually good. Like really. Maybe it's cause it's summer and it's 100 degrees but this ice cream did something to me, it filled my soul. The butter pecan was perfectly salty. And the view, come on. So good. My friend said this is the best sorbet he's ever had. My boy friend got the blackrasberry softserve refreshing and full fat tasting and good. #bringbackwholemilkfaticecream

Sunset is the perfect time to go out for ice cream here in Randolph. The sun sets above Gardiner,…read morejust across the river. The green space behind the ice cream shop is just exquisite. So refreshing after a warm day. When I say this menu is large, I mean it! There's something for everyone. Whether that's sugar free, lactose free, dairy free, sherbet, sorbet, frozen yogurt, soft serve, hard serve. Full sugar. Full fat. Full milk. Full TASTY! They've got it ALL. No cap. Sundaes, Shakes, banana splits, root beer floats, slush puppies, slushes with ice cream, energy drinks, smoothies. Oh my god. I'm never going to check off the entire menu. It's enormous. Service is quick too! Make sure to tip!!!

I had a brownie sundae today with the Sweet Reese ice cream (chocolate ice cream with peanut butter…read morecups). Let's just say that it is going on my list of all time favorite desserts. I can't wait to go back and get it again. The only bad thing about this place is that they don't post a list of their flavors with descriptions. How hard would that be? It is annoying to see lots of flavors with names that you have no idea what they are.

Cool little place…read more The claim to fame here is their unique flavors, many of which I've never seen anywhere else. That being said, many are fruit flavored, which I don't like so much myself. Their more typical flavors are about on par with other local independent ice cream shops. I've heard rumors that the quality tanked after the owner left. Maybe this is why. What makes this place special is how it's ingrained into the landscape. The view from the back patio is one of the coolest of any place I've ever been. It's worth a stop just for that. Location: 3* Convenience: 2* Service: 2* Product/quality: 3* Aesthetics: 4*

Homemade Ice cream- check Homemade Waffle Cones- check…read moreCute spot close to the Coastal Maine Botanical Garden- check Quick service - check Reasonable Prices- check This place is the perfect spot for ice cream and I'm so glad we stopped here on our way back from the Coastal Maine Botanical Gardens

Cute & quaint! We weren't planning to stop but when we saw the sign one late afternoon, we took a…read moresharp right into the parking lot! The line moved quickly and the service was great! Really yummy ice cream (they did samples as well). We got the affogato and loved it!

The ice cream is delicious! Tried Elvis, apple pie and apple caramel. Selections were limited…read moresince it is the end of the season. The flavors they had did not disappoint!

Good ice cream in a historic building. Hated the loud club…read moremusic they had on But otherwise it was a charming store

Nice to get.m out of the busyness of downtown. Great staff even helping sing Happy Birthday!read more

Ice cream was good although hard to eat because she piled the scoops out sideways instead of up so…read morewe were racing to eat it before it melted and hit the ground. Definitely more consistent hours than the place an across the street. We stopped in twice during our week visit.

Fielder's Choice is my go-to ice cream spot whenever I'm in Maine for the summer. They have so many…read moreoptions...soft serve, hard serve, sundaes, milkshakes, slushies, floats, and more. You can either drive thru or walk up to order, which makes it super convenient. My personal favorite is a double hard serve with coffee Oreo (so good!). Just a heads up--they're cash only, but there's an ATM on site. Always a treat and definitely worth the stop!

Delicious! Traveling through the area and came back twice! Being from the Dairy state, ice cream…read morehas to be good- and we loved this place. Lots of varieties, and my husband loved he could get a sundae with any flavor. And no matter how many in line, service was quick. And lots of picnic tables for anyone enjoying outside. Great place.

1. They have a drive thru 2. There one scoop is like 5…read morescoops 3.must visit when you are in Maine 4. Ice cream is hella stretchy!!!!! 5. You guys should come to delray, FL 6. It's f-ing delicious

No trip to Maine in the spring and summer is complete without a stop at Fielder's Choice. There are…read moremultiple locations. The sizes are very generous and a great value for the price. It is cash only. My baby-size cone was $3.59. They have a drive through but I find delight in staring at the menu board and going up to the window to order. The employee who served me was very pleasant. I was served quickly. There is plenty of parking. There are picnic tables and a large grassy area so you can enjoy your treat and the kids can run around. I recommend Fielder's Choice.

Unexpected, Fun, knowledgeable and worth the trip…read more My neighbors sent me a picture of their eclairs. I brought my guests from Dallas. We went twice. The owner and his son are friendly and happy to tell you about every ice cream flavor: Where it's sourced - Improvements being made (peppermint without red 40). Try a flavor. Find your favorite and get a pint or more for a reasonable price. In a state full of Giffords, it's nice to have more options.

Awesome! The factory is surrounded by beautiful scenery but the real beauty lies inside. The ice…read morecream flavors are extremely creative with several flavors I've never seen elsewhere. The flavors are executed perfectly. The sundaes and frappe's are also excellent!!

Off the beaten path. Had a great selection of flavors and different ice cream things.... Lots of…read moreice cream soda blended items. We opted for peach ice cream and something called a witch's brew Shirley temple. So big (16 oz) can't imagine the 24 oz version. The place was very clean with lots of benches and a play area. The staff was pleasant and quick. I'd stop back but I'm not getting coffee soft serve.

Witch Spring Hill ice cream offers plenty of flavor options for any taste. They also have some food…read moreitems available. The wait time is reasonable, and the service is friendly. They have a few tables on site under an awning.