Stopped in for a slice before a show at The Sanctuary across the street. Crust was somewhere between thin crust and traditional. Just the way I like it. Counter service with a couple of tables. Nothing fancy, but seems to be a local hangout...comfortable. read more

Ferati's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Butler, New Jersey

See all

The best pizza around. Always perfectly baked. Everyone I introduced to Ferraris loves their food. The Grandma pie is exceptional

Stopped by on a referral and maybe something changed but it was not good. Meatball and Chicken Parm Sandwiches. Staple food for any restaurant like this. Sauce was tasteless and barely coated the sandwich, very little cheese on parm sandwiches. Meatball was very strange and cutlets were cooked in old oil for sure. Everything tasted like mush. I get that it is a Wednesday night but it was very disappointing. $34 for 2 sandwiches that all but a few bites went in the garbage. Live and learn I guess. read more

This review is for a takeout order. Solid plain pie, very good garlic knots, and pretty good cannoli (a little sweet for my taste). Would order again. read more

Ferati's Pizza - Each order = 2 pieces - Pizza Near Me - Butler, New Jersey

See all

This is like elementary school pizza out of the freezer. Bland, floppy, little to no flavor -- nothing about it is good. Service is friendly but that's the only redeeming quality. read more

Ordered cx Alfredo. Took an hour. It was penne Alfredo with a couple of overdone c cutlets thrown on top. The cx was not cut up and after sawing for 5 minutes I called the owner (which I never do). He offered to replace the food (I've now been waiting 1 1/2 hours) and then had the nerve to tell me to give the other food back to the driver! Seriously? You're just going to throw it away anyway. So I threw it all back in the greasy bag and put it on the porch where the driver (who we tipped $4) originally left our meal without even bothering to knock. I will NEVER go back there and we live right down the road and frequented the establishment. Word to the wise Mr owner, when you screw up don't ask for the food back that you're just gonna throw away anyway. read more

Love Ferati's. We have never been to the restaurant. We order via grub hub. The deliveries are on time, pizzas are hot , and never have been given the wrong order. read more

This was my first visit to Ferati's. It was a Saturday at 3:30pm after a hike. I ordered a slice and the Ferati's Special sandwich which has spicy chicken, peppers, onions, mushrooms etc. The slice was super thin and basic but many people prefer that. The "small" sandwich's covered the whole plate. I enjoyed my very thick and hot meal while watching traffic and listening to neighboring conversations. This sandwich made me smile. read more

Ferati's Pizza - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Butler, New Jersey

See all

It's a nice small quiet place. It has street parking. I went in ordered 4 slices of Pizza and had a Bottled Soda from their stand up refrigerator. They have a small Counter Top with Bar Stools and 4 small tables. The Pizza is GREAT!!! And then I had some GREAT Garlic Knots. Everyone in Butler knows about this place & it's always busy. It's So Much Better Than AJ's!!! I HIGHLY recommend it. read more

Excellent cheese pie and extremely fast and friendly delivery drivers (20 minutes for 4 pies on an NFL playoff Saturday!). I grew up in the area and was loyal to AJs but I'll definitely be giving this place my business when I'm in Butler. read more

Love their pizza great place great people definitely good food Great service family owned restaurant making their food like it was made at home two thumbs up to Feratti s read more

The pizza cooked thin crust is a classic. Their grandma pie is also to die for. Mozzerella sticks are a must along with a side Caesar. Best for pick up or delivery. read more

I haven't been to the actual restaurant but we've ordered a few times through GrubHub. But tonight. Wow! Just amazing. I needed meatballs salad and sides. Just so delicious. The BEST garlic knots I've ever had. Delivery man was so friendly. I will have to stop in here this weekend to eat with my kids. Thank you! read more

Food was ok. Pizza was delivered with half the cheese stuck to the box. Not enjoyable

I would love to give this a 5 star because the staff is very nice and accommodating . Which is why I'm still giving it a 4 not a 3 star . My main issue has always been the pasta dinners . I've tried with red sauce and without. The pasta dinners always have lots of water in the pasta . I've even mentioned it when ordering please make sure they drain the past well before saucing it . I've Still got watery pasta and marinara or francaise sauce . Very disappointing. read more

Very decent pizza and they have good tasting meatballs. Have only ordered here a few times but so far so good. This Butler/Bloomingdale area has seen numerous management changes to multiple restaurants in the last year so it's been a huge adjustment finding good pizza or anything really ! read more

The pizza was tasty ,very good but the slices are small. Very nice customer service! The sauce was delicious and crust was just right I would definitely order again I ordered a slice ,it was small but delicious. Maybe they can make the slices bigger . You need to order 2 slices to have a regular slice of pizza read more

We're continuing our mission to find the best Margherita pizza in North Jersey! Recently, we tried Ferati's Pizza in Butler, NJ. We ordered their 18 inch Margherita pie, a thin Sicilian, and a small peperoni pie. First, the customer service here was five stars. We arrived to pick up the pies but had to wait a good 20 minutes after waiting another 25 minutes before driving to pick it up. We weren't ignored; both guys at the counter kept checking in and updating us. After paying, they gave us a free 2 liter soda for waiting so long. Most pizza spots we've visited so far could care less if we wait or not; this just shows you how much customer service matters. Up first, the Margherita pie: the fresh mozzarella was perfect, the crust was not too think, not too thin, and the sauce had a nice taste especially with the fresh basil. The only issue with this pie - canned plum tomatoes. If they used fresh plum tomatoes on this pie it would've grabbed first place as our favorite Margherita pie, thus far. Overall, we would would try it again since everything else was cooked perfectly and the right ingredients were used. The thin Sicilian - nothing special; your ordinary Sicilian pie, sauce, cheese, but the crust was a bit soggy which hurts it rating our of the three. The peperoni pie was an equal to our favorite so far - Danny's Pizza in Bloomingdale. Both pies have a very similar taste with a slight edge to Danny's due to their crust. But Ferati's pie was very good and definitely worth another try - it wasn't greasy; cheese was melted perfect, the crust wasn't too thick or thin with a nice soft middle. Overall, 4 stars to Ferati's due to their caring attitude and a pretty damn good Margherita pie! Great job guys! read more

Ah-Mazing service ! I placed an order with Galaxy Diner and was informed that for some reason or another they didn't receive it and I was charged anyway. I called Ferati's in a frantic attempt to replace the cheesecake and Zeppole's to be delivered to my daughter... They came through in the clutch and delivered the goods! SAM & MAGGIE Are tonight's MVP's !! Thank you both so much! Signed, a hungry New Yorker read more

Awesome pizza! I recently ordered several pies, a gluten free pizza and Mac & cheese bites for my daughters bday. The food was delivered on time and piping hot. Excellent cheese pizza with a great taste. The Mac and cheese bites were crazy delicious! The gf pizza was perfectly cooked and even came with its own cutter. Sam was very easy going and very accommodating. I would recommend Ferati's to anyone! Thank you, Sam! read more

This is my favorite pizza place. The foods always so fresh, the service is always so friendly and fast, and the owner is one of the nicest guys I've ever met. This is a great community pizza spot, but their meals are excellent, my dad lives the shrimp parm, I love the eggplant parm, or penne vodka, the food is so great. This place does get super busy on Friday and Saturday nights so your best bet at a quick delivery is is there mid day or midweek, but it's well worth the wait! read more

I just had the worst meal ever from a local pizzeria. I ordered the Chicken Cacciatore because it sounded like a nice meal on a cold night. When it arrived in less than 30 minutes, I knew it couldn't be anything great. But when I tasted it, I was angered to no avail. My order asked for extra potatos and mushrooms. There were no extra mushrooms and not one piece of potato. NONE. The sauce was watery and bland. The pasta was days old ( it broke into pieces when I pierced it with my fork) and the two pieces of chicken breast, paper thin and overcooked, was inedible. Needless to say, I won't be ordering anything from this establishment ever again. read more

Had our first meal from Ferati's tonight and we were quite pleased. We ordered a simple Sicilian pie and a cold antipasto for a first order. Picked the food up and it came piping hot right out of the oven. The restaurant is nothing to write home about as far as ambiance is concerned, it isn't even air conditioned, but the food was first rate. We loved the pie, and the salad was full of fresh ingredients. This was our trial order, and since they did a really nice job on this meal we are surely going to try something else next time. read more

We used Ferrari's to cater a graduation party. The food was excellent and they were professionals from beginning to end. Highly recommend!

This is our favorite pizzeria, we order a lot and their veggie pie is so good! Fresh veggies and their mushrooms aren't canned which is a big one for me. The front of the house needs a good scrub and refresh but foods good. read more

Not sure I want to give a rating because I didn't try the food. They had two pies out and place wasn't inviting at all. Pizza could be best or worst, no clue and no desire to eat there. Going to stick with Nona's on franklin in Mahwah or Posa Posa in Nanuet Ny. read more

Great local place to order lunch at work .... always fast to deliver and always really good

Hands down one of the best Pizza places in the area!! We ordered 2x lg pies, one with pepperoni! The pies were thin crust and simply Devine !! Best of all, is their customer service .. Joe and Sam are super appreciative of local business! We also got their garlic knots and zeppoles... yummy ! Will definitely be back to this delicious pizza spot!! read more

Just ordered 3 pies (plain, buff chicken, and chicken bacon ranch) from here yesterday while at High Point Brewing/Ramstein Biergarten. All 3 pies were delicious would definitely order from here again. read more

Local Pizza lover , found most nights Pizza is right on the money . After ordering pizza here over 20 times at least. I can say "One of the Best Around ". Back in the old days some would say V&J in Wayne. But last few years that place has changed. Pizza has a thousand different taste options. Making a Great Pizza means doing it everyday and every Pizza. Something that I love about his Pizza. I know what I'm getting without Fear of change. read more

Everything I've tried from them is so delicious. Hands down my favorite pizza place! Their plain large cheese pizza is so good by itself too. Also tried their specialty pastas & it is more than enough food for the price! I was decently surprised with everything they have to offer. Also- the employees are super nice and very helpful! read more

This was our first time ordering from Ferrari's pizza and we were not disappointed. Pizza was cooked to perfection , crust was flavorful, the toppings were well proportioned to the pie. We are absolutely satisfied with our pizza and will be referring our friends and family to here. read more

Hard to write a review because this place is awesome sometimes and not so great other times. They have days that they get everything right and the quality is above and beyond and then there are days when it takes forever, they make mistakes and the quality is lower in taste and visually as well. There was a time when they were my go to place anytime but now I'm going there when it's convenient. read more

Great service! The foods quality is amazing. From pizza, to pasta & salads - everything tastes great and always fresh. Extremely friendly staff too. By far my favorite pizzeria in the area! read more

I can only review based on the pizza. That being said, the pizza is good, very good. Gotta add that the pies were smaller than the other 2 million pizza places within the few miles of each other but they were good. I will definitely try other dishes tho. Nice little place. read more

Solid pizza, good price, great service, easy order for delivery on yelp. I've never been to the restaurant itself so can't comment there.

The food is always good, sometimes delivery service can take an extremely long time, but they're literally 5 minutes from my place so I've no issues hopping on my car and picking up my order. Dine in experience has been great as well, staff is excellent. read more

Absolutely the best pizza not only in Butler but surrounding area.

I would have to agree with Roy. I used to live in the area and was passing through recently and decided to stop for a couple of slices and catch up with the old owners. It wasn't until I read Roy's review that I realized it was under new ownership. In fact, I looked on Yelp only after eating the slices and realizing they were not the same quality. The pizza here used to be much better, slices were bigger, pizza was better quality. Not only that, but it cost me nearly 7 dollars for two specialty slices. That's a lot of money especially considering they say that each slice should be $2.25 according to their prices on the board in the front of the shop. Also, three of the eight combo meals are no longer being offered which indicates to me that their menu has been compromised. Needless to say, no longer living in the area, I will not be returning to this establishment. read more

I'm not a bad reviewer , but when we went the flies were everywhere... 2 actually landed on my kids face n then on his pizza. I ordered before I even saw the flies and the filthy walls. Once we sat we threw everything out n left. read more