Tonight we stopped here and we pass this place frequently. We visit Boise often and have to go through mountain home to get back to Nevada. It was absolutely amazing. Pizza was good to perfection and the cinnamon knots even better. 10/10 recommend! My fiancé said the service was nice :) read more

Best pizza in Mountain Home hands down Super delicious I always get the family deal read more

Good NYC style pizza for a reasonable price! Highly recommend the chicken bacon ranch pizza. Delicious flavor! Recommendation is to make a dill pickle pizza!!! (Hint hint). Seating area sufficient to handle our party of 9. Take out availability allows you to enjoy your delicious pizza at home. Staff is happy to make a recommendation and accommodating. read more

It's the best pie in Mountain Home, ID. New York style pie, seasoned and adaptable to what you want. As an ex-NYer I can say it's baked right. Not much on ambiance, gimme my pie! read more

You can't beat the daily special of 1 or 2 slices +drink. Amazing, crisp NY Style pizza. Outside of that, a delicious assortment of pizzas, calzones, wings and more. I wish I could say more but it's just plain simple: The Pizza is awesome. Staff, while busy making ingredients and food, are chill..and the restaurant itself has a nice hole-in-the-wall pizza joint vibe I like. only small complaint I personally got is the arcade machines. One is dead and the other is...well needs a fix the last time I tried it. (might be better or worse now)...but thats me, not a factor overall. read more

Wow what a surprise. We left Boise this morning on an adventure for finding a place to eat and to our surprise we wondered into Mt Home. The pizza was fresh and delicious the gentleman working was attentive and courteous. We will return for pizza and calzone again. read more

This pizza was well balanced. Every bite was a delight. The crust was tasty. I'm excited to have the leftovers for lunch.

The pizza slices are huge! A really good go to pizza if you are wanting something cheap and big. This is more of your night out and munchies kind of pizza, so don't be expecting a super fancy pizza! read more

Reminds me of home. I'm from Jersey and we specialize in pizza by the slice. Crunchy crust and cheeesy cheese. Thanks for bringing some of the east coast to the middle of nowhere idaho read more

Fatty'z Pizza - two slices of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mountain Home, Idaho

I guess I'm kinda picky when it comes to pizza? I'm not a fan of Pizza Hut or Dominoes so usually I toss a $4 Trader Joe's frozen pizza in the oven but we finally ordered from here. It was delicious, the crust was perfect, not crazy thin, but on the thinner side and cooked to perfection. The toppings were generous but not too much, it wasn't too greasy or acidic. We ordered the extra large and it is gigantic! Plenty for dinner for three and the kids were back in the box finishing it off before bed! This will definitely be our new local pizza place on those days when the frozen stuff just doesn't cut it! read more

Food is great, but the customer service is crap. And I wouldn't recommend delivery at all. We were told 35-40 minutes but it was closer to an hour and a half. Not a good thing when you have a hungry group of kids read more

The best NY style pizza I've had! Consistently a perfect pizza. Eric the main cook/server is friendly and sure knows how to make a great pizza! read more

Fantastic pizza and wings. Excellent delivery and quick. Very nice. Friendly service thank you

Best pizza in Mountain Home! Glad to find this place. It sure beats the larger chain pizza places , decent variety, order came quickly and was very good. read more

Who ever was working tonight was either high or on something. We ordered two pizzas picked them up and to come home to not the pizzas we ordered. Went back at 7:59 and they ran to lock the doors and they clearly don't close till 9 pm we knocked on the door and we said we didn't get the pizzas we ordered . They shrugged there shoulders and turned up the radio full blast to ignore the situation. Shitty service I say especially when Covid happed they were out of yeast to make pizzas I had gave up my supply to give them to make sure they were able to stay open during the pandemic. This has happened to us many times . We will not be returning. read more

I ordered takeout and the pizza was actually really good hot, cold.....not so much, and reasonably priced but I didn't feel super welcome while I waited for the pizza to finish cooking. Maybe an off day for the staff or maybe even me. Not sure but I'd order pizza from them again but if I get the same unwelcome vibe I probably won't go back. read more

I order from Fattys on average once a week and the food is always delicious. Never been disappointed by the quality and service. If it's a busy day usually Friday or Saturday its best to order in advance because they do get busy. Best pizza I've ever had and the wings are out of this world good. Everything on the menu is WONDERFUL. The family size salad is huge and I can customize it to add the toppings I like and eat it over a few days. If you haven't tried this place yet you are missing out! read more

This place is amazing! If your looking for a NY style pizza and are sick of the national chains these guys are as authentic as you can get in town! read more

Excellent pizza. Friendly staff and service. Love the delivery option as well. Will be coming back often

Really good pizza, love the Hawaiian and we also custome make our own using their garlic sauce.

Called them to order for delivery and hung up on me and never answer my call back, I guess they don't need business

My husband and I ordered two pizzas for delivery on a Friday night and they were ready just when they told us. Not only was the pizza quite excellent and definitely surprised us in quality and price, but the delivery person was very professional and friendly! This is a pizza place we will definitely order from again! read more

We've lived in Mountain Home for a few years now and this was our first time trying Fatty'z! This is by far our favorite pizza place! Pizzas are HUGE and YUMMY! We got wings, a salad and garlic knots as well. Everything was dang good! So glad we tried it out! read more

I'm newer to Mountain home, and this place does not disappoint, great pizza for a great price! I've ordered here on several occasions to feed myself and the husband, or to feed my army of a family and I've never heard any complaints. read more

Solid pizza in downtown Mountain Home. NY style. Would stop again when back in town. A simple place and the people are super nice!

Pizza was delicious! Really tasty. Thinner, crispy crust, great quality toppings, big portions! Staff was super friendly, helped us squeeze in a pizza even though we were cutting it close on closing time. Thanks! read more

My step dad and I stopped here on our road trip from Oregon to Oklahoma. I read a couple reviews beforehand and all were good. We were looking for some place quick but not fast food and this was perfect. Service was great, pizza was yummy, and bathroom was clean! They have pizza by the slice (big ones), and when we were there they had five different options (bacon and chicken, Hawaiian, etc.). They also have good dipping sauces. It's a little off the Main Street, but totally worth it! Thanks! read more

Fatty'z Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mountain Home, Idaho

Usually have really great luck here during lunch, but we were so disappointed with our 2 hour wait then received our food cold AND burnt. read more

Fatty'z Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mountain Home, Idaho

We have a winner! Today we ordered a couple of calzones and they did not disappoint! They were big and full of flavor. The cheese was so creamy, we both couldn't stop commenting on it. We'll be back for sure! read more

What an awesome find! It's hard to find great New York style pizza and these guys hit it outta the park! Perfect crust! Definitely will be back again. read more

This place makes an awesome pizza. The crust is perfect and the service is awesome. Best pizza I've had period!! read more

Fatty'z Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mountain Home, Idaho

I really wanted to like this place :( . The most striking disappointment is the lack of care the employees have. We came in and the girl taking our order was texting while making our pizza. Then we go outside to wait and come back and come to find they burnt the pizza and we're going to start a new one. By this time a guy I think took over since he is the one who started our new pizza. When we came back he just put the pizza in the over(we walked all the way to Bealls and back) so I don't get why he didn't have it in the oven by then. The guy was busy with a kid behind the counter and had her help make the pizza which I'm fine with but I thought it was weird because we were waiting on a new one after they burnt our first . He was more busy entertaining the child instead of getting out pizza out. The cleanliness of the place is bad as well. The bathroom was messy and in clean. The cloth on our table had holes in it. The whole restaurant is littered with random things like flags on the windowsill that make it look messy. Over all the place lacks competence and customer service and that is why I will not be trying them again. The pizza was alright, nothing to write home about. Also I asked for the WiFi password, the looked at me and said I don't know it. Then asked someone for it. I didn't even hear back from her. I was left wondering if they were just ignoring my request or just gave up finding it... read more

This is the place I go and het pizza there garlic knots are so good as well they always give reasonable time est

In LoVE with your garlic knots! Extra marinara add red pepper packet! Tuesday $5 dollar special--- addicted. read more

See all

I ordered one slice to go around lunch time. Meatzza. Yum!! Crunchy crust and fresh... just tasty. I definitely want to try another slice

My second trip here was definitely better than the first time. Great pizza and calzone and friendly staff. I'll definitely be going back on my next trip to mountain home! read more

Best pizza I've had in a long time! What a gem. Just passing through Idaho, read tons of reviews and settled on this place for dinner. The ingredients are fresh and the pizza will not disappoint! read more

Love Fatty's Pizza. It is our go to Pizza. Great service and always get our topping correct.

Best New York City pizza outside of new york Try the jalapeno ranch sauce it's great Worth going to Mountain Home for

Ok pizza. Being from New Jersey, expectations are high. It'll do for now but crust needs to be cooked a few minutes longer and the sauce is too sweet. Excellent customer service and now that they offer delivery, I was pleased. Will def call again. read more