I loved this place! The staff was incredibly friendly and helpful. As soon as you walk in you order your lunch, they bring it to your table and then you pay afterwards. I got a BLT that was just right and my husband got a chili dog that he said was delicious. This is a casual dining place, not a fancy restaurant which is just perfect for breakfast and lunch! The last time we were down here, we had breakfast at Fatty's and that's why we came back for lunch today because breakfast had been so good. Definitely recommend! read more

Six years later and it's still delicious! Got the shrimp burger again and my husband got the shrimp po boy. Service is great. Friendly and inviting. Love the heart and memes posted throughout the restaurant. read more

See all

Delicious food, satiating portion sizes, fair prices, extremely friendly and accommodating service, very relaxed atmosphere. 10/10! I wish we had more restaurants like this where we came from, it was very refreshing that every employee we interacted with was so kind. read more

We have been coming down to Hatteras for years and now have a permanent place down here. I can only remember going to Fatty's once in all that time - took my kids for ice cream a long time ago. My husband and I decided to eat there for the first time last night. First of all, the decor is so quirky! Loved sitting there and laughing at all the funny signs on the wall. And I didn't catch any employees names, but the young woman at the register was delightful. Seriously. She knows that menu and was so helpful...very animated and sweet. She helped set the tone there, which is so important. The food was very good. I had fish and my husband had the shrimp and grits. Both were served hot and were fresh and really tasty. The young man who served the food was also very friendly and attentive. Fatty's is a very casual, moderately priced restaurant. I'm glad we gave it a try and we'll be back. read more

Good food and reasonably priced. We got in at 8:40 and Everything closes at 9 in this area so we were worried we couldn't find anything but Fattys came through! Manager said the fryer is still hot so what do you want, music to my ears!! We got fried fish, shrimp, coleslaw, and fries to go. Staff was super friendly and accommodating. They also have a great ice cream selection to choose from in a cone or bowl. Check this place out and you will not be disappointed read more

Food was pretty decent. We had a group of 10. When we ordered, they mentioned bringing all the food out at once. We thanked them, but said it wasn't necessary. They could bring it out as it was finished. The staff kept coming out and apologizing for the wait. Then they mentioned not having hot dogs and someone going out to get more. Had we known this, we simply would have ordered something different. Finally, I went to ask if they could bring all of the food that wasn't hot dogs so some of the kids could eat. The manager mentioned the food will fly right out once it's all ready. I brought 8 teenagers and didn't want to cause a scene, so I left it at that. The younger staff members continued to apologize and were very nice. Overall, it was a bad experience and I wouldn't return, in spite of the food (probably a 3 or 4 out of 5). read more

Came in here after a dinner for ice cream and was greeted by a friendly employee. When we entered, it was a bit overstimulating because one side is a place to sit down and order food while the other side is ice cream with merch. There is also a beautiful koi fish in the pond! You can see the fish on their merch as well. read more

We stopped in on a whim after the place we had wanted to go for lunch was closed. One of the patrons had told us that if we sat down, they'd bring us a menu (this is not correct - you have to go and order at the counter). Not a big deal since we weren't told that by a staff member. We ordered our food and were given a number to have at the table. The food was delivered fairly quickly. The soda machine was out of both Dr. Pepper and Coke, but they did have Cherry Coke. Overall, we all enjoyed our food. The biggest issue was that my SIL and I both got the fried shrimp and we only got one cocktail sauce as the kitchen needed to make more. We shared the one sauce and the waitress had to come back and apologize at least two more times that it wasn't made yet. By the time we received it, our shrimp were barely warm. As this was the start of summer, I would have expected the kitchen staff to be a bit more prepared. The shrimp themselves were breaded well and had a really good flavor (had I not used any sauce in the beginning, I would have been fine eating them plain). The fries are skinny style and were really good. Everyone who came and waited on our table was very friendly and apologetic when we didn't receive things quickly. read more

We stopped by while staying a weekend in Buxton. The 2 gentlemen working were both very welcoming, friendly and professional. We ordered Eggs Your Way for breakfast. Our food came out very quickly. Eggs were cooked perfectly, bacon was crispy, biscuit was fluffy, and the home fries were delicious as well. The staff checked on us several times to be sure we were pleased with our food. Dining room was fun. Lots of interesting and funny quotes to read while waiting. The place has a beachy, surfer vibe which was perfect for our beach vacation. The ice cream selection looked great. May come back for that later. read more

Fattys Eatery - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

Service is great! Breakfast is served and they have a varied menu. All items are cooked to order. read more

See all

Quick lunch stop coming off the beach fishing. Carolina Pulled Pork sandwich and Striped Fish sandwich were both delicious. Great service, will definitely be back! read more

"Decent, inexpensive lunch food near Hatteras lighthouse" We stopped by this place for lunch on a weekday after visiting the Cape Hatteras lighthouse-- it's super close and convenient. You order at a counter, get a number, and they bring the food to you, and then you pay after you're finished. The place was VERY roomy, and had an outdoor seating area. We didn't try the ice cream, but we did have sandwiches. Staff were friendly and helpful. It's not true "table service"-- you get your own drinks and such-- but they were nice. Food: Signature dog-- my son opted for this crazy dish, that comes with mac & cheese, an egg, fries, and more on top of a hot dog. It was a giant hot dog-- he wasn't quite sure how to eat it! But he managed-- said it was "a real mix of flavors" but he seemed to enjoy it. Came with a side of plain Lays chips, and cost $7. Philly cheese steak-- Certainly not a philly cheesesteak you'd write home about, but the meat was good and served nice and hot. The mushrooms looked like they came from a can, and there wasn't a ton of peppers and such on it, but I enjoyed the sandwich overall. Also came with plain Lays chips. Cost $9. Note they do have Cheerwine both in bottles and in their fountain. For what it was-- an alternative place to grab an inexpensive lunch than a fast food place-- it was decent. Between 3-4 stars, but I'll round up to be nice. I'd not rush back, but I wouldn't be upset if I found myself there again. read more

Everything was great. We stopped in for lunch on the way back from Avon. We are on Hatteras for VACA but love in Florida. This place is has some seriously good food at great prices. I had the mahi bites - a giant serving for $10?!?! Yes, they were fresh and tasted really good. That plate at home(another touristy location) would be half as big and cost $25. The article from Ben's service was great, we will be returning this week and on future trips. Thanks for a great lunch at a reasonable price! read more

Delicious food. Great hospitality from the owner. Quick service. Oh, did I mention delicious food? Nice atmosphere. read more

Fattys Eatery - Philliy Cheeses teak and Potato Wedges - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

See all

Y'all. Best stop I could have made. I was traveling home from NCCAT by myself and not much was open because it was mid-to end March. I'm so glad nothing was open and I found this! The food was on point, came out fast, service was friendly and I was so happy for my trip home. read more

Fattys Eatery - Shrimp and Grits - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

See all

We came on Saturday for a later lunch. It took over 50min for our food and when we asked about it, was given attitude. At one point when I tried to help with cleaning off the table we were going to sit at, I was again met with attitude. Food was ok, disorganized, not a lot of seating. Won't be back. read more

Everything was closed on Sunday except for this place , and surprisingly grateful everything we ate here was good and the service was nice . We had shrimp po boy, shrimp burger the fish and chips and the shrimp and chips. read more

We've gone for ice cream twice in the evenings, very few places that serve ice cream in this area. The two guys helping us were very nice and welcoming - we truly enjoyed the service, and the ice cream selection was great! read more

Glad to try this place we've been seeing for several years, but we usually come in the off season when they are closed. Had a great breakfast! Bacon was on the thicker side, which we loved! Ordered cheese on my scrambled eggs which they left off, but hubby's had the cheese and I would def recommend it. They were just so busy when we were there and all the workers were doing their best so I didn't want to send mine back. Home fries are real potatoes, diced and we added grilled onions. Toast was thicker bread, which I also liked. Biscuits are a premade type, but gravy was good. Would def eat here again. Only complaint is I ordered the tougher parfait based on a picture in another review with strawberries and blueberries and mine came with apples and bananas and I don't like either of those, but I should've asked when I ordered. I did not get a picture of that. read more

See all

Uhmm, I was afraid walking into this place. I just felt eyes and felt 'out of place". Y'all know what I mean and are not saying. Okay, soooo the food was meh. When it was done, I guess they had run out of to-go bags. The guy dumped out supplies from a to-go bag and placed my order in it. DIGUSTING!! AND it's a COVID pandemic happening. I said my prayers, ate my home fries, and threw everything else away. Yuck! read more

See all

This is a must stop for our family every trip. Breakfast in the morning, ice cream in the evening. You gotta go with the flow, be flexible, and patient. The food is great, the staff is friendly. It's not 5 star dining. It's not meant to be. Grab a seat, read the wall, throw carbs in your face, and enjoy the beach. read more

Bottom Line: Very casual eatery with friendly staff serving comfort food. Fatty's Eatery is a super casual place so you can throw your clothes over your bathing suit and you'll be welcome. The staff is very friendly and they seem to be very collaborative too. The decor is very beachy - the floors are gritty with sand and the walls have amusing murals on them. (I particularly like the shark with eyebrows and it's tongue hanging out of its mouth.) I like that the food is good ol' fashioned American chow that is nourishing. I also appreciate that they have both a Pepsi soda fountain and a Coca-Cola soda fountain! We stopped in for breakfast sandwiches before climbing the Cape Hatteras Lighthouse and they were tasty and reasonably priced. read more

Fattys Eatery - Fattys at breakfast time. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

Stopped at Fatty's eatery after a very long drive from NJ and they were open, we had a delicious dinner and great service

Oh, this might not be a fair review but is a good one. We were running late for lunch, and it was raining. We headed here totally on a whim, and only realized after had ordered that they soon would be closing. But they never said it... they were chipper, helpful, and rushed... it felt like they were a little short-staffed, probably a product of COVID-related difficulties getting folks back and that it was after the summer season. In any case, their attitude carried the day. Super friendly service, good and quick take-out meal. I'll be back next time we are in town. read more

Food was not good and restaurant was very dirty. I wish we would have drove right by. The kids working didn't seem to know how to run a restaurant. They gave me a hard time for needing silverware. Our party of 5 was given 2 forks and a knife after our food arrived, but we had to ask twice. The arcade room had dead bugs all over the place. Go somewhere else! read more

I make it a point to come here every time in in Hatteras, simply for the shrimp n grits. These are the best shrimp n grits I've had anywhere! The sauce is awesome, and the price is very good as well. I've traveled all the way to Charleston, SC before to try shrimp n grits that were hyped up along tv, and they were terrible lol. Everything my wife had tried at Fatty's is very good as well. It's definitely a must try! read more

Fattys Eatery - Shrimp n Grits - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

Very tasty and lots of unique food choices, nothing fancy but good. Staff was friendly and for our party of seven not real long to get served. A little pricey but I expect that on vacation. We would go again. read more

Fattys Eatery - Mac and cheese hot dog - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

Service was good and food was pretty good. I got the fried shrimp. I just noticed that it's creole style. I did not read that on the menu at the time. It was alright but it was so spicy I could barely taste the shrimp. My daughter got chicken tenders for kids and it seemed like they used the same spice on her chicken! You guys need to know kids do not like spicy foods. The fries were really good. We also got some ice cream which was great. Prices were good. Tone down the spices though on the food and you would get a 5! read more

"Small breakfast joint along with ice cream shop.. good food..." We were walking on Cape Hatteras beach. It had rained previous night so the morning was quite chill. After walking we saw this and went there. Ordered French toast-coffee-pan cakes. They have so many FB meme hanging on the wall makes it interesting and the moment never gets bored. Server was lovely. They had colorful benches outside Lovely time. read more

See all

After going in to order a breakfast sandwich, only to discover that they were out of bacon, sausage, ham, eggs, and cheese, I ordered a shrimp Poboy. It took them over a half an hour to prepare it. 15 minutes into the process, I asked if it was too late to cancel the order. I was told that the shrimp were already in the fryer. When I complained 20 minutes later that the sandwiches, we're still not ready, I was told the shrimp and just been put into the fryer. Stay away from Fattys. read more

Yummy food and such a cute little place. Loved reading all the memes in the wall! Service was good too. read more

Fattys Eatery - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

See all

Excellent burgers, dogs, sandwiches. The fish sandwich was very fresh with great flavor. Staff was excellent. Great food and service at great prices. A must for lunch when you're in Buxton. read more

Great food and service for our group of 14. The prices are great and the staff is very friendly.

The breakfast sandwiches and burritos were absolutely delicious. I wish they offer espresso! read more

Good, simple fare with fun murals on the walls. My crab cake sandwich with optional lettuce, tomatoes and onions was really good. My husband's BLT was awesome. Our friends enjoyed their fried fish sandwich and Creole shrimp po' boy. Perfect spot for lunch before or after climbing the lighthouse. read more

See all

My husband and I stopped by for dinner. Gives a very beachy, laid back vibe. There are some arcade games in the back and picnic tables outside. Service was great, Ben and Gabe (sp?) were super friendly. The chef (who may have also been the owner) came out to check and make sure we had everything we needed as well. The shrimp was seasoned really well and the french fries are in the top 3 that I have ever had. We did not have any ice cream but they had tons of flavors. 10/10 would recommend!!!! read more

We love this place!! So many flavors to choose from and the workers are extremely kind! read more

See all

If you're looking for something good, keep looking. This place was underwhelming and kind of gross. The staff was super friendly and helpful, thus the two stars. Otherwise, it would have gotten one star. Husband order the shrimp po-boy and it could not have been more disappointing. A few shrimp tossed on a big, dry bread roll with some lettuce and tomatoes (definitely don't order this!), with very little sauce in the side. Daughter ordered chicken fingers w/ fries. They absolutely must have tossed it in the fryer frozen because the chicken was somewhat crispy on the outside and not very done inside - super gross. My Philly cheese-steak was passable - nothing wrong with it, but it lacked any flavor and was super greasy. We stopped here for the yelp reviews and ratings, but I honestly can't figure out what people see in this place. Maybe it's better for breakfast? read more

Fattys Eatery - Shrimp Po-Boy...nothing to write home about. :/ - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Buxton, North Carolina

Order at the counter, fast service, great food! Breakfast was great (I had the waffles) I didn't have a chance to grab lunch while I was in town, but their menu looked pretty good. I will definitely check out their lunch the next time we are in Buxton. Too bad they aren't open for dinner as well! read more

Arrived for an early lunch here after visiting the Cape Hatteras lighthouse. They serve breakfast until 11:30, which they are very strict about apparently. Food was good. The staff told me that they were out of biscuits so they didn't have what I wanted (biscuits and gravy) so I ordered the Fisherman's Batter Bar. It came with sausage and gravy, hash browns, eggs, and bacon, with a choice of either a Belgium waffle or French Toast. Again they didn't have my first choice, Belgium waffle, so I accepted the French Toast. Despite this, I was still happy with my meal. My husband wanted to order lunch, but it was it 11:10, so they would not take his lunch order. The three girls at the register acted clueless so the service left much to be desired. Not the best restaurant experience but the food was worth the money we paid, portions and prices were very good. Will definitely return, but earlier in the morning so they have what I want! read more