Love the pizzas! Service is great and ambience is wonderful. I usually order DRAG IT THRU THE GARDEN!!! Full of veggies and cheese. read more

See all

Visiting from Dallas and was told this was one of the best. For 58 dollars I should have just got a CiCi pizza. It was over done and basically nothing on it. If you are Visiting from a North Eastern state that has REAL Pizza - don't waste your time..... Our pizzas looked nothing like the photos..... read more

Love this pizza great flavor and great service, affordable price and lunch specials, my husband and I we order the medium sized and was perfect for both of us read more

Extreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - McAllen, Texas

Wow! This pizza is amazing! You can taste the crust, not some pilsbury dough. Hot and fresh ingredients...there ghost pepper cheese on pizza-epic game changer. Now the atmosphere is small but packed with a bar and seating areas for a date night-spectacular!! read more

Not Bad, and Not any different than any other pizza chain...I specifically did a yelp search for best pizza in the area...(apparently there isn't any that live up to my expectations, or any other pizza lover like myself), But I could very well have ordered from Dominoes, Papa Johns or even Pizza Hut and would not have known the difference. The cheesecake slice was only $4, and that's about all it was worth in its size. So much for wanting to split it with the person I ordered with! read more

73 years old & finally discover the best pizza in mcallen, maybe the valley but i haven't tried them all. This place is fast & friendly & i had very little wait. i almost wish it took a little longer so i could enjoy 5X5 draft beer. next time i staying! read more

I think we found our pizza place. With high pizza standards, we're often disappointed exploring the pie options in town. Extreme Pizza hit the mark. The crust was a bit tough/chewy, but overall excellent flavor and assembly. You can order online for a 20 minute pickup. Delivery is also an option. They even let you do 1/2 & 1/2 without an upcharge which was really cool. Select a signature pizza and adjust toppings as needed, or create your own. I was very happy with the 'Screamin Tomato.' Don't forget your free chocolate chip cookie with Yelp check-in! read more

Extreme Pizza - 50:50 Screaming Tomato/Everest - Pizza Near Me - McAllen, Texas

Ordered from them 3xs with 3 different pizzas and each time I did they would call me and tell me they was out of some part of the pizza that was needed to complete the order. One time it was toasted garlic. When I asked what happened to the garlic, they just said "supply chain issues." Skip this place, overpriced and low quality pizza in general. read more

Their subs never disappoint! Always fresh and very filling! The toasted bread blends perfectly with the meats and cheese. Definitely one of their better dishes! read more

I got delivery thru Grub Hub and I loved the pizza! It was the Yardwork and had all my favorite toppings. Best pizza I have had in the area!! read more

The pizza and salad were both delicious! The toppings were so plentiful and fresh! They also have plenty of tv's if you enjoy watching while you eat... read more

Extreme Pizza - Yummmm!!! - Pizza Near Me - McAllen, Texas

Really enjoyed our lunch today! As first timers, the staff helped us choose from a very long, delicious menu. We were not disappointed in our choices. My husband had the Everest and I had a slice of pizza that was Draggin' Thru the Garden...both were delicious! Staff was courteous and everything was clean. Fun atmosphere, too. We'll be back! read more

All I can say is Wow!!! I was craving pizza and away from home. Extreme popped up in gluten free. I got the Yard Sale and it was fantastic. I had a bit of heat without adding pepper chips, which I really like. I will make a point to return for my pizza fix! read more

We ordered a 12 inch fully vegan drag it thru the garden pizza with vegan cheese which was good. At $25, the price was a little pricey but I'm happy to see vegan options at pizza place. read more

Extreme Pizza - 12" Vegan Gluten Free Crust Drag it Thru the Garden Pizza with vegan cheese - Pizza Near Me - McAllen, Texas

Wanted to try something different, and it definitely met expectations and more! Was super good will definitely be coming back soon!

I previously had rated y'all 5 stars reading back my only complaint was the dough was a little soggy on the pizza, Well we had two calzones today large and small BOTH were soggy!!! I live 3 mins away. Also my calzone tastes burned I called back and the person I spoke to was kind enough to give me a credit for next time explained its out in the oven twice to make sure it's cooked all the way. Well I think y'all just need to take calzones off the menu. The onion was no where near caramelized like the menu stated. The artichoke pieces were huge and not enough mushrooms. This order totally lacked love and for $23 we shoulda got more bang for our buck. read more

Extreme Pizza - We ordered the 18 inch I believe. Huge lol!!! They didn't skimp on the toppings like a lot of other places. - Pizza Near Me - McAllen, Texas

The pizza itself isn't that great if you look at the nasty aftertaste the crust leaves in your mouth. Seriously it just tastes like yeast and is very off putting. The toppings are good and they put a generous amount of cheese on the pizza, however this doesn't cover up that awful after taste. read more

Small but clean and reminded me of west coast bar. Pizza was delicious. Chicken parm sub was not what I expected in a good way. Chicken was tender and juicy and bread was soft but toasty. I can def see us watching a game drinking and eating. My new favorite spot. read more

Extreme Pizza - Started my review a little late. - Pizza Near Me - McAllen, Texas

Great pizza and great service. I recommend trying there pizzas!!! Great topping and great sauce. I would recommend the railroad specialty pizza read more

The staff was very friendly. The pizzas were amazing about time this town gets a real creative pizza place. I suggest you give it a try you will be pleasantly surprised read more

Extreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - McAllen, Texas

See all

Not to bad for pizza. This was the only pizza place that was open for eat in service. We ordered wings and a pizza. I ordered boneless and they came out bone in. I sent them back and my pizza came and then later on my wings came. Not a bad place for pizza, but it's probably not gonna be a very consistent business if they can't get the order right! read more

Calzone was perfectly cheesy and chewy. Nonnas little apple cinnamon dessert pizza was excellent. The meatball sub was just a slight bit over baked but tasty enough that I ate all of it. If you are looking for a great meal, this is the place. Next time I am getting one of the vert interesting sounding pizzas. read more

Delicious Pizza Excellent music Super Fast Service We ordered the lunch special...Wow!!! Fresh and Hot! read more

Extreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - McAllen, Texas

From now on I'm gonna order through telephone if I'm gonna order delivery. Good pizza good food close by. Grub hub completely fucked up my order. I will not blame extreme pizza. Now I know next time it's just better to order directly from the restaurant. Like this place A LOT read more

Best pizza in McAllen!!! Definitely have to get the supreme!! Which I believed is called pi read more

Extreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - McAllen, Texas

First time eating this pizza, we were pretty excited we have 2 teens so pizza is a favorite. The idea that you can split a pizza into 2 different types is pretty cool. I Can say that they were really quick order was ready in 15 Not sure if it was because is was the end of the night but oh man this was not even little Caesar's level. It was in need of cheese, sauce, and the crust was hard to bite through almost stale which isn't possible since it was fresh. Chewy yet hard dough. We didn't like it, $45 down the drain. Wings were soft and chewy/gummy. Peter Piper & even little ceasers is better hot and fresh. read more

This was awesome! We wanted to try a place close to home and we were very pleased. Tons of different pizzas... meat pizzas, veggie pizzas, build your own.. anything you want. We will be back.... Too many things we want to try. Great prices too. read more

This is our favorite place to get pizza. Great crust (my girl likes ordering it extra crispy)and lots of cheese (cheesy) They also have a great variety of beer to enjoy. Also the wings are delicious along with the Subs. My children like ordering the Pizzawich as a combo it includes chips and a drink for $8.50 read more

See all

Very good. Our first time here and we will definitely be back. Fresh toppings and lots of them. read more

Extreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - McAllen, Texas

If you are looking for a great pizza, this is the place regardless if you are looking for a simple pepperoni pizza or one of their custom pizzas. It is the only pizza place that all of my kids love and now they refuse to eat any other pizza. read more

This pizza looked nothing like the commercial. My pizza was a pick up order for 2 18 inch pepperoni a mini specialty cheese and a gluten free 12 inch. All of them were lacking toppings. There wasn't any sauce or cheese on any of the pizzas. Major waste of money. Wasn't even edible. read more

This is my go to pizza place. I have tried almost all specialty pizzas on the menu, but my personal favorite is Mont Blanc with chicken. You can actually taste the cheese and the richness of the ingredients. Way better than dominos, Pizza Hut, or whatever mainstream pizza restaurants out here. Definitely a must try. read more

Asked for a vegan pizza and instead I received a pizza with dairy cheese. We also waited 20 minutes when they had promised 10. Very disappointed. read more

Given the name of this restaurant, I was expecting to find a pizza hybrid, and being a pizza snob, I avoided it. Big surprise! I stopped in one day out of curiosity and was impressed with the delicious aroma. Ordered a veggie pizza that came loaded with healthy veggies. Quick service, too. I've been back multiple times. It's not my usual preference -- NY style pizza -- but they do make a variety of delicious pizzas. read more

Ordered online at 5:10 and I'm still waiting at 6:30 it is slow and every time I ask about it I'm responded with cuss words

The pizza here is truly great. Made well and doesn't hurt my stomach like man brand pizza places. Unfortunately I am not so impressed with the staff. Had multiple instances where they just weren't very helpful. Once I called and asked if they had a Margarita pizza and the person on the line says no. I hang up and check their website and they have one just not called margarita... UH OK. I also would suggest not getting a pizza delivered to your address unless you have the EXACT amount in cash. Delivery guy doesn't have change. read more

it's alright, wouldn't recommend. not horrible food but it's nothing special. they offer vegetarian and unique pizza options.

Pandora's Bix was an explosion if flavor. Even if you aren't a vegetarian, you'll love this pizza. My boyfriend had the Kickin' Chicken & it was like putting a delicious asian salad on pizza dough. Enrique gave excellent customer service & was patient with me, being it was my 1st time here. read more

Extreme Pizza - Pandora's Box has been opened & it's never tasted to good. The 1st bite was an explosion of flavors in my mouth. - Pizza Near Me - McAllen, Texas

Really good pizza, calzones and salads! Everything tasted so fresh in terms of salad. The cheese was really good quality, pull away goodness. The sauce was light and not over powering with salt or sweet. Definitely worth a try! read more

Better than I expected!! First time here and decided on pizza (Pandora's box) on wheat crust. Crust was really good. Crispy on bottom and soft and chewy on top. They are not stingy with toppings either. Wife got pizza (paia pie) and added goat cheese & jalapeños. Wife said it's the best pizza she's ever had. We will definitely be back. Can't wait to try the thin and crispy crust and their different crazy variety menu items. read more